Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Metaphysics

Metaphysics (1.3.3-1.3.7)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg025.perseus-eng2:1.3.3-1.3.7
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.3.3', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 3 Subsection 3'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.3.7', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 3 Subsection 7'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.3'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Most of the earliest philosophers conceived only of material principles as underlying all things. That of which all things consist, from which they first come and into which on their destruction they are ultimately resolved, of which the essence persists although modified by its affectionsthis, they say, is an element and principle of existing things. Hence they believe that nothing is either generated or destroyed, since this kind of primary entity always persists. Similarly we do not say that Socrates comes into being absolutely when he becomes handsome or cultured, nor that he is destroyed when he loses these qualities; because the substrate, Socrates himself, persists.

In the same way nothing else is generated or destroyed; for there is some one entity (or more than one) which always persists and from which all other things are generated.

All are not agreed, however,

20
as to the number and character of these principles. Thales,[*] the founder of this school of philosophy,[*] says the permanent entity is water (which is why he also propounded that the earth floats on water). Presumably he derived this assumption from seeing that the nutriment of everything is moist, and that heat itself is generated from moisture and depends upon it for its existence (and that from which a thing is generated is always its first principle). He derived his assumption, then, from this; and also from the fact that the seeds of everything have a moist nature, whereas water is the first principle of the nature of moist things.

There are some[*] who think that the men of very ancient times, long before the present era, who first speculated about the gods, also held this same opinion about the primary entity. For they[*] represented Oceanus and Tethys to be the parents of creation, and the oath of the gods to be by water Styx,[*] as they call it. Now what is most ancient is most revered, and what is most revered is what we swear by.

984a
1
Whether this view of the primary entity is really ancient and time-honored may perhaps be considered uncertain; however, it is said that this was Thales opinion concerning the first cause. (I say nothing of Hippo,[*] because no one would presume to include him in this company, in view of the paltriness of his intelligence.)

Tokens

Most 1 w 4
of 1 w 6
the 1 w 9
earliest 1 w 17
philosophers 1 w 29
conceived 1 w 38
only 1 w 42
of 2 w 44
material 1 w 52
principles 1 w 62
as 1 w 64
underlying 1 w 74
all 1 w 77
things 1 w 83
That 1 w 88
of 3 w 90
which 1 w 95
all 2 w 98
things 2 w 104
consist 1 w 111
from 1 w 116
which 2 w 121
they 1 w 125
first 1 w 130
come 1 w 134
and 1 w 137
into 1 w 141
which 3 w 146
on 4 w 148
their 1 w 153
destruction 1 w 164
they 2 w 168
are 1 w 171
ultimately 1 w 181
resolved 1 w 189
of 4 w 192
which 4 w 197
the 5 w 200
essence 1 w 207
persists 1 w 215
although 1 w 223
modified 1 w 231
by 1 w 233
its 1 w 236
affections 1 w 246
this 1 w 251
they 3 w 256
say 1 w 259
is 4 w 262
an 2 w 264
element 1 w 271
and 2 w 274
principle 2 w 283
of 5 w 285
existing 1 w 293
things 3 w 299
Hence 1 w 305
they 4 w 309
believe 1 w 316
that 1 w 320
nothing 1 w 327
is 6 w 329
either 1 w 335
generated 1 w 344
or 1 w 346
destroyed 1 w 355
since 1 w 361
this 2 w 365
kind 1 w 369
of 6 w 371
primary 1 w 378
entity 1 w 384
always 1 w 390
persists 2 w 398
Similarly 1 w 408
we 1 w 410
do 1 w 412
not 2 w 415
say 2 w 418
that 2 w 422
Socrates 1 w 430
comes 1 w 435
into 2 w 439
being 1 w 444
absolutely 1 w 454
when 1 w 458
he 11 w 460
becomes 1 w 467
handsome 1 w 475
or 2 w 477
cultured 1 w 485
nor 1 w 489
that 3 w 493
he 12 w 495
is 9 w 497
destroyed 2 w 506
when 2 w 510
he 14 w 512
loses 1 w 517
these 1 w 522
qualities 1 w 531
because 1 w 539
the 10 w 542
substrate 1 w 551
Socrates 2 w 560
himself 1 w 567
persists 3 w 576
In 1 w 579
the 11 w 582
same 1 w 586
way 2 w 589
nothing 2 w 596
else 1 w 600
is 11 w 602
generated 2 w 611
or 4 w 613
destroyed 3 w 622
for 1 w 626
there 1 w 631
is 12 w 633
some 2 w 637
one 1 w 640
entity 2 w 646
or 6 w 649
more 1 w 653
than 1 w 657
one 2 w 660
which 5 w 666
always 2 w 672
persists 4 w 680
and 4 w 683
from 2 w 687
which 6 w 692
all 3 w 695
other 1 w 700
things 4 w 706
are 2 w 709
generated 3 w 718
All 1 w 722
are 3 w 725
not 4 w 728
agreed 1 w 734
however 1 w 742
as 2 w 745
to 3 w 747
the 14 w 750
number 1 w 756
and 5 w 759
character 1 w 768
of 7 w 770
these 2 w 775
principles 2 w 785
Thales 1 w 792
Thales 2 w 799
of 8 w 801
Miletus 1 w 808
fl 1 w 811
585 1 w 815
B 1 w 816
C 1 w 818
the 16 w 822
founder 1 w 829
of 9 w 831
this 3 w 835
school 1 w 841
of 10 w 843
philosophy 1 w 853
That 2 w 858
of 11 w 860
the 17 w 863
Ionian 1 w 869
monists 1 w 876
who 1 w 880
sought 1 w 886
a 52 w 887
single 1 w 893
material 2 w 901
principle 4 w 910
of 12 w 912
everything 1 w 922
says 1 w 927
the 18 w 930
permanent 1 w 939
entity 3 w 945
is 16 w 947
water 1 w 952
which 7 w 958
is 17 w 960
why 1 w 963
he 25 w 965
also 1 w 969
propounded 1 w 979
that 4 w 983
the 19 w 986
earth 1 w 991
floats 1 w 997
on 11 w 999
water 2 w 1004
Presumably 1 w 1016
he 27 w 1018
derived 1 w 1025
this 4 w 1029
assumption 1 w 1039
from 3 w 1043
seeing 1 w 1049
that 5 w 1053
the 20 w 1056
nutriment 1 w 1065
of 13 w 1067
everything 2 w 1077
is 19 w 1079
moist 1 w 1084
and 6 w 1088
that 6 w 1092
heat 1 w 1096
itself 1 w 1102
is 21 w 1104
generated 4 w 1113
from 4 w 1117
moisture 1 w 1125
and 7 w 1128
depends 1 w 1135
upon 1 w 1139
it 8 w 1141
for 2 w 1144
its 3 w 1147
existence 1 w 1156
and 8 w 1160
that 7 w 1164
from 5 w 1168
which 8 w 1173
a 73 w 1174
thing 9 w 1179
is 24 w 1181
generated 5 w 1190
is 25 w 1192
always 3 w 1198
its 4 w 1201
first 2 w 1206
principle 5 w 1215
He 2 w 1219
derived 2 w 1226
his 5 w 1229
assumption 2 w 1239
then 1 w 1244
from 6 w 1249
this 5 w 1253
and 9 w 1257
also 2 w 1261
from 7 w 1265
the 22 w 1268
fact 1 w 1272
that 8 w 1276
the 23 w 1279
seeds 1 w 1284
of 14 w 1286
everything 3 w 1296
have 1 w 1300
a 83 w 1301
moist 3 w 1306
nature 1 w 1312
whereas 1 w 1320
water 3 w 1325
is 29 w 1327
the 24 w 1330
first 3 w 1335
principle 6 w 1344
of 15 w 1346
the 25 w 1349
nature 2 w 1355
of 16 w 1357
moist 4 w 1362
things 5 w 1368
There 1 w 1374
are 4 w 1377
some 3 w 1381
Cf 1 w 1383
Plat 1 w 1388
Crat 1 w 1393
402b 1 w 1398
Plat 2 w 1403
Theaet 1 w 1410
152e 1 w 1415
Plat 3 w 1420
Theaet 2 w 1427
180c 1 w 1432
d 41 w 1434
who 2 w 1438
think 1 w 1443
that 9 w 1447
the 26 w 1450
men 3 w 1453
of 17 w 1455
very 4 w 1459
ancient 1 w 1466
times 1 w 1471
long 1 w 1476
before 1 w 1482
the 27 w 1485
present 1 w 1492
era 6 w 1495
who 3 w 1499
first 4 w 1504
speculated 1 w 1514
about 1 w 1519
the 28 w 1522
gods 1 w 1526
also 3 w 1531
held 1 w 1535
this 6 w 1539
same 2 w 1543
opinion 1 w 1550
about 2 w 1555
the 29 w 1558
primary 2 w 1565
entity 4 w 1571
For 1 w 1575
they 5 w 1579
cf 1 w 1581
Hom 1 w 1585
Il 1 w 1588
14 1 w 1591
201 1 w 1595
Hom 2 w 1599
Il 2 w 1602
14 2 w 1605
246 1 w 1609
represented 1 w 1621
Oceanus 1 w 1628
and 10 w 1631
Tethys 1 w 1637
to 4 w 1639
be 7 w 1641
the 31 w 1644
parents 1 w 1651
of 18 w 1653
creation 1 w 1661
and 11 w 1665
the 32 w 1668
oath 1 w 1672
of 19 w 1674
the 33 w 1677
gods 2 w 1681
to 5 w 1683
be 8 w 1685
by 2 w 1687
water 4 w 1692
Styx 1 w 1697
Cf 2 w 1700
Hom 3 w 1704
Il 3 w 1707
2 5 w 1709
755 1 w 1713
Hom 4 w 1717
Il 4 w 1720
14 3 w 1723
271 1 w 1727
Hom 5 w 1731
Il 5 w 1734
15 2 w 1737
37 1 w 1740
as 6 w 1743
they 6 w 1747
call 1 w 1751
it 12 w 1753
Now 1 w 1757
what 1 w 1761
is 32 w 1763
most 1 w 1767
ancient 2 w 1774
is 33 w 1776
most 2 w 1780
revered 1 w 1787
and 12 w 1791
what 2 w 1795
is 34 w 1797
most 3 w 1801
revered 2 w 1808
is 35 w 1810
what 3 w 1814
we 3 w 1816
swear 1 w 1821
by 3 w 1823
Whether 1 w 1831
this 7 w 1835
view 1 w 1839
of 20 w 1841
the 36 w 1844
primary 3 w 1851
entity 5 w 1857
is 37 w 1859
really 1 w 1865
ancient 3 w 1872
and 13 w 1875
time-honored 1 w 1887
may 1 w 1890
perhaps 1 w 1897
be 9 w 1899
considered 1 w 1909
uncertain 1 w 1918
however 2 w 1926
it 14 w 1929
is 38 w 1931
said 1 w 1935
that 10 w 1939
this 8 w 1943
was 1 w 1946
Thales 3 w 1952
opinion 2 w 1960
concerning 1 w 1970
the 37 w 1973
first 5 w 1978
cause 2 w 1983
I 8 w 1986
say 4 w 1989
nothing 3 w 1996
of 21 w 1998
Hippo 1 w 2003
Hippo 2 w 2009
of 22 w 2011
Samos 1 w 2016
a 133 w 2018
medical 1 w 2025
writer 1 w 2031
and 14 w 2034
eclectic 1 w 2042
philosopher 2 w 2053
who 4 w 2056
lived 1 w 2061
in 33 w 2063
the 38 w 2066
latter 1 w 2072
half 1 w 2076
of 23 w 2078
the 39 w 2081
fifth 1 w 2086
century 1 w 2093
B 2 w 2094
C 5 w 2096
Cf 3 w 2099
Aristot 1 w 2107
De 1 w 2110
Anima 1 w 2115
405b 1 w 2119
2 7 w 2120
because 2 w 2128
no 8 w 2130
one 3 w 2133
would 1 w 2138
presume 1 w 2145
to 7 w 2147
include 1 w 2154
him 2 w 2157
in 35 w 2159
this 9 w 2163
company 1 w 2170
in 36 w 2173
view 2 w 2177
of 24 w 2179
the 40 w 2182
paltriness 1 w 2192
of 25 w 2194
his 11 w 2197
intelligence 1 w 2209