Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Metaphysics

Metaphysics (1.3.13-1.3.17)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg025.perseus-eng2:1.3.13-1.3.17
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.3.13', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 3 Subsection 13'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.3.17', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 3 Subsection 17'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.3'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

984b
1
None of those who maintained that the universe is a unity achieved any conception of this type of cause, except perhaps Parmenides[*]; and him only in so far as he admits, in a sense, not one cause only but two.[*]

But those who recognize more than one entity, e.g. hot and cold, or fire and earth, are better able to give a systematic explanation, because they avail themselves of fire as being of a kinetic nature, and of water, earth, etc., as being the opposite.[*]

After these thinkers and the discovery of these causes, since they were insufficient to account for the generation of the actual world, men were again compelled (as we have said) by truth itself to investigate the next first principle.

For presumably it is unnatural that either fire or earth or any other such element should cause existing things to be or become well and beautifully disposed; or indeed that those thinkers should hold such a view. Nor again was it satisfactory to commit so important a matter to spontaneity and chance.

Hence when someone[*] said that there is Mind in nature, just as in animals, and that this is the cause of all order and arrangement, he seemed like a sane man in contrast with the haphazard statements of his predecessors.[*]

We know definitely that Anaxagoras adopted this view; but Hermotimus[*]

20
of Clazomenae is credited with having stated it earlier. Those thinkers, then, who held this view assumed a principle in things which is the cause of beauty, and the sort of cause by which motion is communicated to things.

Tokens

None 1 w 4
of 1 w 6
those 1 w 11
who 1 w 14
maintained 1 w 24
that 1 w 28
the 1 w 31
universe 1 w 39
is 1 w 41
a 4 w 42
unity 1 w 47
achieved 1 w 55
any 1 w 58
conception 1 w 68
of 2 w 70
this 1 w 74
type 1 w 78
of 3 w 80
cause 1 w 85
except 1 w 92
perhaps 1 w 99
Parmenides 1 w 109
Founder 1 w 116
of 4 w 118
the 2 w 121
above 1 w 126
fl 1 w 129
about 1 w 135
475 1 w 138
and 1 w 143
him 1 w 146
only 1 w 150
in 3 w 152
so 1 w 154
far 1 w 157
as 1 w 159
he 3 w 161
admits 1 w 167
in 4 w 170
a 16 w 171
sense 1 w 176
not 1 w 180
one 2 w 183
cause 2 w 188
only 2 w 192
but 1 w 195
two 1 w 198
i 14 w 200
e 25 w 202
in 5 w 205
the 3 w 208
Δόξα 1 w 212
Parmenides 2 w 223
Fr 1 w 225
8 1 w 227
Diels 1 w 233
R 1 w 236
P 3 w 238
121 1 w 242
But 1 w 246
those 2 w 251
who 2 w 254
recognize 1 w 263
more 1 w 267
than 1 w 271
one 3 w 274
entity 1 w 280
e 36 w 282
g 2 w 284
hot 1 w 288
and 2 w 291
cold 1 w 295
or 2 w 298
fire 1 w 302
and 3 w 305
earth 1 w 310
are 1 w 314
better 1 w 320
able 1 w 324
to 1 w 326
give 1 w 330
a 25 w 331
systematic 1 w 341
explanation 1 w 352
because 1 w 360
they 1 w 364
avail 1 w 369
themselves 1 w 379
of 5 w 381
fire 2 w 385
as 2 w 387
being 1 w 392
of 6 w 394
a 33 w 395
kinetic 1 w 402
nature 1 w 408
and 4 w 412
of 7 w 414
water 1 w 419
earth 2 w 425
etc 1 w 429
as 3 w 433
being 2 w 438
the 6 w 441
opposite 1 w 449
Aristotle 1 w 459
is 4 w 461
probably 1 w 469
thinking 1 w 477
of 8 w 479
Empedocles 1 w 489
Cf 1 w 492
Aristot 2 w 500
Met 1 w 504
4 2 w 506
8 2 w 508
After 1 w 514
these 1 w 519
thinkers 1 w 527
and 5 w 530
the 8 w 533
discovery 1 w 542
of 9 w 544
these 2 w 549
causes 1 w 555
since 1 w 561
they 2 w 565
were 1 w 569
insufficient 1 w 581
to 4 w 583
account 1 w 590
for 1 w 593
the 11 w 596
generation 1 w 606
of 10 w 608
the 12 w 611
actual 1 w 617
world 1 w 622
men 3 w 626
were 2 w 630
again 1 w 635
compelled 1 w 644
as 4 w 647
we 3 w 649
have 1 w 653
said 1 w 657
by 1 w 660
truth 1 w 665
itself 1 w 671
to 5 w 673
investigate 1 w 684
the 13 w 687
next 1 w 691
first 1 w 696
principle 1 w 705
For 1 w 709
presumably 1 w 719
it 6 w 721
is 7 w 723
unnatural 1 w 732
that 2 w 736
either 1 w 742
fire 3 w 746
or 6 w 748
earth 3 w 753
or 7 w 755
any 2 w 758
other 1 w 763
such 1 w 767
element 1 w 774
should 1 w 780
cause 5 w 785
existing 1 w 793
things 1 w 799
to 6 w 801
be 5 w 803
or 8 w 805
become 1 w 811
well 1 w 815
and 6 w 818
beautifully 1 w 829
disposed 1 w 837
or 9 w 840
indeed 1 w 846
that 3 w 850
those 3 w 855
thinkers 2 w 863
should 2 w 869
hold 1 w 873
such 2 w 877
a 62 w 878
view 1 w 882
Nor 1 w 886
again 2 w 891
was 1 w 894
it 8 w 896
satisfactory 1 w 908
to 8 w 910
commit 1 w 916
so 2 w 918
important 1 w 927
a 69 w 928
matter 1 w 934
to 9 w 936
spontaneity 1 w 947
and 7 w 950
chance 1 w 956
Hence 1 w 962
when 1 w 966
someone 1 w 973
Anaxagoras 1 w 983
said 2 w 988
that 4 w 992
there 1 w 997
is 11 w 999
Mind 1 w 1003
in 23 w 1005
nature 2 w 1011
just 1 w 1016
as 7 w 1018
in 24 w 1020
animals 1 w 1027
and 8 w 1031
that 5 w 1035
this 2 w 1039
is 13 w 1041
the 17 w 1044
cause 6 w 1049
of 11 w 1051
all 1 w 1054
order 1 w 1059
and 9 w 1062
arrangement 1 w 1073
he 20 w 1076
seemed 1 w 1082
like 1 w 1086
a 90 w 1087
sane 1 w 1091
man 1 w 1094
in 25 w 1096
contrast 1 w 1104
with 1 w 1108
the 18 w 1111
haphazard 1 w 1120
statements 1 w 1130
of 12 w 1132
his 3 w 1135
predecessors 1 w 1147
Cf 2 w 1150
Plat 1 w 1155
Phaedo 1 w 1162
97b-98b 1 w 1169
We 1 w 1172
know 1 w 1176
definitely 1 w 1186
that 6 w 1190
Anaxagoras 2 w 1200
adopted 1 w 1207
this 3 w 1211
view 2 w 1215
but 2 w 1219
Hermotimus 1 w 1229
A 6 w 1230
semi-mythical 1 w 1243
person 1 w 1249
supposed 1 w 1257
to 10 w 1259
have 2 w 1263
been 1 w 1267
a 107 w 1268
preincarnation 1 w 1282
of 13 w 1284
Pythagoras 1 w 1294
of 14 w 1297
Clazomenae 1 w 1307
is 16 w 1309
credited 1 w 1317
with 2 w 1321
having 1 w 1327
stated 1 w 1333
it 15 w 1335
earlier 1 w 1342
Those 1 w 1348
thinkers 3 w 1356
then 1 w 1361
who 3 w 1365
held 1 w 1369
this 4 w 1373
view 3 w 1377
assumed 1 w 1384
a 118 w 1385
principle 2 w 1394
in 31 w 1396
things 2 w 1402
which 1 w 1407
is 18 w 1409
the 20 w 1412
cause 7 w 1417
of 15 w 1419
beauty 1 w 1425
and 10 w 1429
the 21 w 1432
sort 1 w 1436
of 16 w 1438
cause 8 w 1443
by 2 w 1445
which 2 w 1450
motion 1 w 1456
is 19 w 1458
communicated 1 w 1470
to 11 w 1472
things 3 w 1478