Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Metaphysics

Metaphysics (1.2.9-1.2.13)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg025.perseus-eng2:1.2.9-1.2.13
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.2.9', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 2 Subsection 9'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.2.13', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 2 Subsection 13'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.2'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

It is through wonder that men now begin and originally began to philosophize; wondering in the first place at obvious perplexities, and then by gradual progression raising questions about the greater matters too, e.g. about the changes of the moon and of the sun, about the stars and about the origin of the universe.

Now he who wonders and is perplexed feels that he is ignorant (thus the myth-lover is in a sense a philosopher, since myths are composed of wonders);

20
therefore if it was to escape ignorance that men studied philosophy, it is obvious that they pursued science for the sake of knowledge, and not for any practical utility.

The actual course of events bears witness to this; for speculation of this kind began with a view to recreation and pastime, at a time when practically all the necessities of life were already supplied. Clearly then it is for no extrinsic advantage that we seek this knowledge; for just as we call a man independent who exists for himself and not for another, so we call this the only independent science, since it alone exists for itself.

For this reason its acquisition might justly be supposed to be beyond human power, since in many respects human nature is servile; in which case, as Simonides[*] says, God alone can have this privilege, and man should only seek the knowledge which is within his reach.

Indeed if the poets are right and the Deity is by nature jealous,

983a
1
it is probable that in this case He would be particularly jealous, and all those who excel in knowledge unfortunate. But it is impossible for the Deity to be jealous (indeed, as the proverb[*] says, poets tell many a lie), nor must we suppose that any other form of knowledge is more precious than this; for what is most divine is most precious.

Tokens

It 1 w 2
is 1 w 4
through 1 w 11
wonder 1 w 17
that 1 w 21
men 1 w 24
now 1 w 27
begin 1 w 32
and 1 w 35
originally 1 w 45
began 1 w 50
to 1 w 52
philosophize 1 w 64
wondering 1 w 74
in 4 w 76
the 1 w 79
first 1 w 84
place 1 w 89
at 2 w 91
obvious 1 w 98
perplexities 1 w 110
and 2 w 114
then 1 w 118
by 1 w 120
gradual 1 w 127
progression 1 w 138
raising 1 w 145
questions 1 w 154
about 1 w 159
the 3 w 162
greater 1 w 169
matters 1 w 176
too 1 w 179
e 19 w 181
g 10 w 183
about 2 w 189
the 4 w 192
changes 1 w 199
of 1 w 201
the 5 w 204
moon 1 w 208
and 3 w 211
of 2 w 213
the 6 w 216
sun 1 w 219
about 3 w 225
the 7 w 228
stars 1 w 233
and 4 w 236
about 4 w 241
the 8 w 244
origin 2 w 250
of 3 w 252
the 9 w 255
universe 1 w 263
Now 1 w 267
he 10 w 269
who 1 w 272
wonders 1 w 279
and 5 w 282
is 3 w 284
perplexed 1 w 293
feels 1 w 298
that 2 w 302
he 11 w 304
is 4 w 306
ignorant 1 w 314
thus 1 w 319
the 10 w 322
myth-lover 1 w 332
is 5 w 334
in 7 w 336
a 24 w 337
sense 1 w 342
a 25 w 343
philosopher 1 w 354
since 1 w 360
myths 1 w 365
are 1 w 368
composed 1 w 376
of 4 w 378
wonders 2 w 385
therefore 1 w 396
if 1 w 398
it 2 w 400
was 1 w 403
to 3 w 405
escape 1 w 411
ignorance 1 w 420
that 3 w 424
men 2 w 427
studied 1 w 434
philosophy 1 w 444
it 3 w 447
is 6 w 449
obvious 2 w 456
that 4 w 460
they 1 w 464
pursued 1 w 471
science 1 w 478
for 2 w 481
the 13 w 484
sake 1 w 488
of 5 w 490
knowledge 1 w 499
and 6 w 503
not 1 w 506
for 3 w 509
any 1 w 512
practical 1 w 521
utility 1 w 528
The 1 w 532
actual 1 w 538
course 1 w 544
of 6 w 546
events 1 w 552
bears 1 w 557
witness 1 w 564
to 4 w 566
this 1 w 570
for 4 w 574
speculation 1 w 585
of 7 w 587
this 2 w 591
kind 1 w 595
began 2 w 600
with 1 w 604
a 42 w 605
view 1 w 609
to 5 w 611
recreation 1 w 621
and 7 w 624
pastime 1 w 631
at 10 w 634
a 47 w 635
time 2 w 639
when 1 w 643
practically 1 w 654
all 3 w 657
the 14 w 660
necessities 1 w 671
of 8 w 673
life 1 w 677
were 1 w 681
already 1 w 688
supplied 1 w 696
Clearly 1 w 704
then 2 w 708
it 8 w 710
is 9 w 712
for 5 w 715
no 6 w 717
extrinsic 1 w 726
advantage 1 w 735
that 5 w 739
we 2 w 741
seek 1 w 745
this 3 w 749
knowledge 2 w 758
for 6 w 762
just 1 w 766
as 3 w 768
we 3 w 770
call 2 w 774
a 60 w 775
man 1 w 778
independent 1 w 789
who 2 w 792
exists 1 w 798
for 7 w 801
himself 1 w 808
and 8 w 811
not 2 w 814
for 8 w 817
another 1 w 824
so 4 w 827
we 4 w 829
call 3 w 833
this 4 w 837
the 17 w 840
only 1 w 844
independent 2 w 855
science 2 w 862
since 2 w 868
it 9 w 870
alone 1 w 875
exists 2 w 881
for 9 w 884
itself 1 w 890
For 1 w 894
this 5 w 898
reason 1 w 904
its 2 w 907
acquisition 1 w 918
might 1 w 923
justly 1 w 929
be 5 w 931
supposed 1 w 939
to 6 w 941
be 6 w 943
beyond 1 w 949
human 1 w 954
power 1 w 959
since 3 w 965
in 15 w 967
many 1 w 971
respects 1 w 979
human 2 w 984
nature 1 w 990
is 16 w 992
servile 1 w 999
in 16 w 1002
which 1 w 1007
case 1 w 1011
as 6 w 1014
Simonides 1 w 1023
Simon 2 w 1028
Fr 1 w 1031
3 1 w 1033
Hiller 1 w 1040
says 1 w 1046
God 1 w 1050
alone 2 w 1055
can 1 w 1058
have 1 w 1062
this 6 w 1066
privilege 1 w 1075
and 9 w 1079
man 5 w 1082
should 1 w 1088
only 2 w 1092
seek 2 w 1096
the 18 w 1099
knowledge 3 w 1108
which 2 w 1113
is 18 w 1115
within 1 w 1121
his 7 w 1124
reach 1 w 1129
Indeed 1 w 1136
if 3 w 1138
the 19 w 1141
poets 1 w 1146
are 2 w 1149
right 1 w 1154
and 10 w 1157
the 20 w 1160
Deity 1 w 1165
is 20 w 1167
by 2 w 1169
nature 2 w 1175
jealous 1 w 1182
it 15 w 1185
is 21 w 1187
probable 1 w 1195
that 6 w 1199
in 18 w 1201
this 7 w 1205
case 2 w 1209
He 1 w 1211
would 1 w 1216
be 8 w 1218
particularly 1 w 1230
jealous 2 w 1237
and 11 w 1241
all 6 w 1244
those 1 w 1249
who 3 w 1252
excel 1 w 1257
in 19 w 1259
knowledge 4 w 1268
unfortunate 1 w 1279
But 1 w 1283
it 16 w 1285
is 23 w 1287
impossible 1 w 1297
for 11 w 1300
the 21 w 1303
Deity 2 w 1308
to 7 w 1310
be 9 w 1312
jealous 3 w 1319
indeed 1 w 1326
as 8 w 1329
the 22 w 1332
proverb 1 w 1339
Cf 1 w 1341
Solon 1 w 1347
Fr 2 w 1350
26 1 w 1353
Hiller 2 w 1360
Leutsch 1 w 1369
and 12 w 1372
Schneidwin 1 w 1382
Paroemiographi 1 w 1397
1 1 w 1399
371 1 w 1403
says 2 w 1408
poets 2 w 1414
tell 1 w 1418
many 2 w 1422
a 101 w 1423
lie 2 w 1426
nor 3 w 1431
must 1 w 1435
we 6 w 1437
suppose 2 w 1444
that 7 w 1448
any 4 w 1451
other 2 w 1456
form 1 w 1460
of 9 w 1462
knowledge 5 w 1471
is 24 w 1473
more 1 w 1477
precious 1 w 1485
than 1 w 1489
this 8 w 1493
for 13 w 1497
what 1 w 1501
is 26 w 1503
most 1 w 1507
divine 1 w 1513
is 27 w 1515
most 2 w 1519
precious 2 w 1527