Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Metaphysics

Metaphysics (1.2.14-1.3.2)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg025.perseus-eng2:1.2.14-1.3.2
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.2.14', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 2 Subsection 14'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.3.2', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 3 Subsection 2'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.2'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Now there are two ways only in which it can be divine. A science is divine if it is peculiarly the possession of God, or if it is concerned with divine matters. And this science alone fulfils both these conditions; for (a) all believe that God is one of the causes and a kind of principle, and (b) God is the sole or chief possessor of this sort of knowledge. Accordingly, although all other sciences are more necessary than this, none is more excellent.

The acquisition of this knowledge, however, must in a sense result in something which is the reverse of the outlook with which we first approached the inquiry. All begin, as we have said, by wondering that things should be as they are, e.g. with regard to marionettes, or the solstices, or the incommensurability[*] of the diagonal of a square; because it seems wonderful to everyone who has not yet perceived the cause that a thing should not be measurable by the smallest unit.

But we must end with the contrary and (according to the proverb)[*] the better view, as men do even in these cases when they understand them;

20
for a geometrician would wonder at nothing so much as if the diagonal were to become measurable.

Thus we have stated what is the nature of the science which we are seeking, and what is the object which our search and our whole investigation must attain.

It is clear that we must obtain knowledge of the primary causes, because it is when we think that we understand its primary cause that we claim to know each particular thing. Now there are four recognized kinds of cause. Of these we hold that one is the essence or essential nature of the thing (since the reason why of a thing is ultimately reducible to its formula, and the ultimate reason why is a cause and principle); another is the matter or substrate; the third is the source of motion; and the fourth is the cause which is opposite to this, namely the purpose or good;

for this is the end of every generative or motive process. We have investigated these sufficiently in the Physics[*];

983b
1
however, let us avail ourselves of the evidence of those who have before us approached the investigation of reality and philosophized about Truth. For clearly they too recognize certain principles and causes, and so it will be of some assistance to our present inquiry if we study their teaching; because we shall either discover some other kind of cause, or have more confidence in those which we have just described.

Tokens

Now 1 w 3
there 1 w 8
are 1 w 11
two 1 w 14
ways 1 w 18
only 1 w 22
in 1 w 24
which 1 w 29
it 1 w 31
can 1 w 34
be 1 w 36
divine 1 w 42
A 1 w 44
science 1 w 51
is 1 w 53
divine 2 w 59
if 1 w 61
it 2 w 63
is 2 w 65
peculiarly 1 w 75
the 2 w 78
possession 1 w 88
of 1 w 90
God 1 w 93
or 1 w 96
if 2 w 98
it 3 w 100
is 3 w 102
concerned 1 w 111
with 1 w 115
divine 3 w 121
matters 1 w 128
And 1 w 132
this 1 w 136
science 2 w 143
alone 1 w 148
fulfils 1 w 155
both 1 w 159
these 1 w 164
conditions 1 w 174
for 1 w 178
a 7 w 180
all 1 w 184
believe 1 w 191
that 1 w 195
God 2 w 198
is 5 w 200
one 2 w 203
of 2 w 205
the 4 w 208
causes 1 w 214
and 1 w 217
a 12 w 218
kind 1 w 222
of 3 w 224
principle 1 w 233
and 2 w 237
b 4 w 239
God 3 w 243
is 6 w 245
the 5 w 248
sole 1 w 252
or 3 w 254
chief 1 w 259
possessor 1 w 268
of 4 w 270
this 2 w 274
sort 1 w 278
of 5 w 280
knowledge 1 w 289
Accordingly 1 w 301
although 1 w 310
all 2 w 313
other 1 w 318
sciences 1 w 326
are 2 w 329
more 1 w 333
necessary 1 w 342
than 1 w 346
this 3 w 350
none 1 w 355
is 9 w 357
more 2 w 361
excellent 1 w 370
The 1 w 374
acquisition 1 w 385
of 6 w 387
this 4 w 391
knowledge 2 w 400
however 1 w 408
must 1 w 413
in 8 w 415
a 20 w 416
sense 1 w 421
result 1 w 427
in 9 w 429
something 1 w 438
which 2 w 443
is 12 w 445
the 7 w 448
reverse 1 w 455
of 7 w 457
the 8 w 460
outlook 1 w 467
with 2 w 471
which 3 w 476
we 2 w 478
first 1 w 483
approached 1 w 493
the 9 w 496
inquiry 1 w 503
All 1 w 507
begin 1 w 512
as 1 w 515
we 3 w 517
have 1 w 521
said 1 w 525
by 1 w 528
wondering 1 w 537
that 2 w 541
things 1 w 547
should 1 w 553
be 4 w 555
as 2 w 557
they 1 w 561
are 3 w 564
e 70 w 566
g 9 w 568
with 3 w 573
regard 1 w 579
to 1 w 581
marionettes 1 w 592
or 9 w 595
the 11 w 598
solstices 1 w 607
or 10 w 610
the 12 w 613
incommensurability 1 w 631
i 62 w 632
e 78 w 634
the 13 w 638
fact 1 w 642
that 3 w 646
the 14 w 649
diagonal 1 w 657
of 8 w 659
a 36 w 660
square 1 w 666
cannot 1 w 672
be 5 w 674
rationally 1 w 684
expressed 1 w 693
in 16 w 695
terms 1 w 700
of 9 w 702
the 15 w 705
side 1 w 709
of 10 w 712
the 16 w 715
diagonal 2 w 723
of 11 w 725
a 43 w 726
square 2 w 732
because 1 w 740
it 10 w 742
seems 1 w 747
wonderful 1 w 756
to 2 w 758
everyone 1 w 766
who 1 w 769
has 1 w 772
not 2 w 775
yet 1 w 778
perceived 1 w 787
the 17 w 790
cause 3 w 795
that 4 w 799
a 49 w 800
thing 3 w 805
should 2 w 811
not 3 w 814
be 7 w 816
measurable 1 w 826
by 2 w 828
the 18 w 831
smallest 1 w 839
unit 1 w 843
But 1 w 847
we 4 w 849
must 2 w 853
end 1 w 856
with 4 w 860
the 19 w 863
contrary 1 w 871
and 3 w 874
according 1 w 884
to 3 w 886
the 20 w 889
proverb 1 w 896
i 74 w 898
e 115 w 900
δευτέρον 1 w 909
ἀμεινόνων 1 w 918
second 1 w 925
thoughts 1 w 933
are 6 w 936
better 1 w 942
Leutsch 1 w 951
and 4 w 954
Schneidwin 1 w 964
1 1 w 965
62 1 w 968
the 21 w 972
better 2 w 978
view 1 w 982
as 5 w 985
men 2 w 988
do 1 w 990
even 1 w 994
in 20 w 996
these 2 w 1001
cases 1 w 1006
when 1 w 1010
they 2 w 1014
understand 1 w 1024
them 1 w 1028
for 2 w 1032
a 61 w 1033
geometrician 1 w 1045
would 1 w 1050
wonder 3 w 1056
at 7 w 1058
nothing 1 w 1065
so 6 w 1067
much 1 w 1071
as 7 w 1073
if 3 w 1075
the 25 w 1078
diagonal 3 w 1086
were 1 w 1090
to 4 w 1092
become 1 w 1098
measurable 2 w 1108
Thus 1 w 1113
we 6 w 1115
have 2 w 1119
stated 1 w 1125
what 1 w 1129
is 13 w 1131
the 26 w 1134
nature 1 w 1140
of 12 w 1142
the 27 w 1145
science 4 w 1152
which 4 w 1157
we 7 w 1159
are 7 w 1162
seeking 1 w 1169
and 6 w 1173
what 2 w 1177
is 14 w 1179
the 28 w 1182
object 1 w 1188
which 5 w 1193
our 1 w 1196
search 1 w 1202
and 7 w 1205
our 2 w 1208
whole 1 w 1213
investigation 1 w 1226
must 3 w 1230
attain 1 w 1236
It 1 w 1239
is 15 w 1241
clear 1 w 1246
that 5 w 1250
we 8 w 1252
must 4 w 1256
obtain 1 w 1262
knowledge 3 w 1271
of 13 w 1273
the 29 w 1276
primary 1 w 1283
causes 2 w 1289
because 2 w 1297
it 13 w 1299
is 16 w 1301
when 2 w 1305
we 9 w 1307
think 1 w 1312
that 6 w 1316
we 10 w 1318
understand 2 w 1328
its 1 w 1331
primary 2 w 1338
cause 6 w 1343
that 7 w 1347
we 11 w 1349
claim 1 w 1354
to 5 w 1356
know 4 w 1360
each 1 w 1364
particular 1 w 1374
thing 5 w 1379
Now 2 w 1383
there 2 w 1388
are 8 w 1391
four 1 w 1395
recognized 1 w 1405
kinds 1 w 1410
of 14 w 1412
cause 7 w 1417
Of 1 w 1420
these 3 w 1425
we 12 w 1427
hold 1 w 1431
that 8 w 1435
one 6 w 1438
is 17 w 1440
the 32 w 1443
essence 1 w 1450
or 13 w 1452
essential 1 w 1461
nature 2 w 1467
of 15 w 1469
the 33 w 1472
thing 6 w 1477
since 1 w 1483
the 34 w 1486
reason 1 w 1492
why 1 w 1495
of 16 w 1497
a 102 w 1498
thing 7 w 1503
is 18 w 1505
ultimately 1 w 1515
reducible 1 w 1524
to 6 w 1526
its 2 w 1529
formula 1 w 1536
and 9 w 1540
the 35 w 1543
ultimate 2 w 1551
reason 2 w 1557
why 2 w 1560
is 19 w 1562
a 108 w 1563
cause 8 w 1568
and 10 w 1571
principle 2 w 1580
another 1 w 1589
is 20 w 1591
the 37 w 1594
matter 2 w 1600
or 15 w 1602
substrate 1 w 1611
the 38 w 1615
third 1 w 1620
is 21 w 1622
the 39 w 1625
source 1 w 1631
of 17 w 1633
motion 1 w 1639
and 11 w 1643
the 40 w 1646
fourth 1 w 1652
is 22 w 1654
the 41 w 1657
cause 9 w 1662
which 6 w 1667
is 23 w 1669
opposite 1 w 1677
to 7 w 1679
this 5 w 1683
namely 1 w 1690
the 42 w 1693
purpose 1 w 1700
or 16 w 1702
good 1 w 1706
for 4 w 1710
this 6 w 1714
is 26 w 1716
the 43 w 1719
end 2 w 1722
of 18 w 1724
every 2 w 1729
generative 1 w 1739
or 18 w 1741
motive 1 w 1747
process 1 w 1754
We 1 w 1757
have 3 w 1761
investigated 1 w 1773
these 4 w 1778
sufficiently 1 w 1790
in 34 w 1792
the 45 w 1795
Physics 1 w 1802
Phys 2 w 1806
2 2 w 1808
3 1 w 1810
Phys 3 w 1815
2 3 w 1817
7 1 w 1819
however 2 w 1827
let 1 w 1831
us 15 w 1833
avail 1 w 1838
ourselves 1 w 1847
of 19 w 1849
the 46 w 1852
evidence 1 w 1860
of 20 w 1862
those 1 w 1867
who 3 w 1870
have 4 w 1874
before 1 w 1880
us 16 w 1882
approached 2 w 1892
the 47 w 1895
investigation 2 w 1908
of 21 w 1910
reality 1 w 1917
and 12 w 1920
philosophized 1 w 1933
about 1 w 1938
Truth 1 w 1943
For 1 w 1947
clearly 1 w 1954
they 3 w 1958
too 1 w 1961
recognize 2 w 1970
certain 1 w 1977
principles 1 w 1987
and 13 w 1990
causes 3 w 1996
and 14 w 2000
so 11 w 2002
it 18 w 2004
will 1 w 2008
be 13 w 2010
of 22 w 2012
some 2 w 2016
assistance 1 w 2026
to 9 w 2028
our 7 w 2031
present 1 w 2038
inquiry 2 w 2045
if 4 w 2047
we 14 w 2049
study 1 w 2054
their 1 w 2059
teaching 1 w 2067
because 3 w 2075
we 15 w 2077
shall 1 w 2082
either 1 w 2088
discover 1 w 2096
some 3 w 2100
other 3 w 2105
kind 3 w 2109
of 23 w 2111
cause 12 w 2116
or 21 w 2119
have 5 w 2123
more 3 w 2127
confidence 1 w 2137
in 41 w 2139
those 2 w 2144
which 7 w 2149
we 16 w 2151
have 6 w 2155
just 1 w 2159
described 1 w 2168