Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Metaphysics

Metaphysics (1.1.6-1.1.10)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg025.perseus-eng2:1.1.6-1.1.10
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.1.6', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 1 Subsection 6'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.1.10', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 1 Subsection 10'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

To have a judgement that when Callias was suffering from this or that disease this or that benefited him, and similarly with Socrates and various other individuals, is a matter of experience; but to judge that it benefits all persons of a certain type, considered as a class, who suffer from this or that disease (e.g. the phlegmatic or bilious when suffering from burning fever) is a matter of art.

It would seem that for practical purposes experience is in no way inferior to art; indeed we see men of experience succeeding more than those who have theory without experience.

The reason of this is a that experience is knowledge of particulars, but art of universals; and actions and the effects produced are all concerned with the particular. For it is not man that the physician cures, except incidentally, but Callias or Socrates or some other person similarly named, who is incidentally a man as well.

20
So if a man has theory without experience, and knows the universal, but does not know the particular contained in it, he will often fail in his treatment; for it is the particular that must be treated.

Nevertheless we consider that knowledge and proficiency belong to art rather than to experience, and we assume that artists are wiser than men of mere experience (which implies that in all cases wisdom depends rather upon knowledge);

Tokens

To 1 w 2
have 1 w 6
a 2 w 7
judgement 1 w 16
that 1 w 20
when 1 w 24
Callias 1 w 31
was 1 w 34
suffering 1 w 43
from 1 w 47
this 1 w 51
or 1 w 53
that 2 w 57
disease 1 w 64
this 2 w 68
or 2 w 70
that 3 w 74
benefited 1 w 83
him 1 w 86
and 1 w 90
similarly 1 w 99
with 1 w 103
Socrates 1 w 111
and 2 w 114
various 1 w 121
other 1 w 126
individuals 1 w 137
is 4 w 140
a 16 w 141
matter 1 w 147
of 1 w 149
experience 1 w 159
but 1 w 163
to 1 w 165
judge 2 w 170
that 4 w 174
it 3 w 176
benefits 1 w 184
all 2 w 187
persons 1 w 194
of 2 w 196
a 20 w 197
certain 1 w 204
type 1 w 208
considered 1 w 219
as 4 w 221
a 23 w 222
class 1 w 227
who 1 w 231
suffer 2 w 237
from 2 w 241
this 3 w 245
or 3 w 247
that 5 w 251
disease 2 w 258
e 29 w 260
g 4 w 262
the 2 w 266
phlegmatic 1 w 276
or 4 w 278
bilious 1 w 285
when 2 w 289
suffering 2 w 298
from 3 w 302
burning 1 w 309
fever 1 w 314
is 7 w 317
a 28 w 318
matter 2 w 324
of 3 w 326
art 1 w 329
It 1 w 332
would 1 w 337
seem 1 w 341
that 6 w 345
for 1 w 348
practical 1 w 357
purposes 1 w 365
experience 2 w 375
is 8 w 377
in 6 w 379
no 1 w 381
way 1 w 384
inferior 1 w 392
to 2 w 394
art 2 w 397
indeed 1 w 404
we 1 w 406
see 2 w 409
men 2 w 412
of 4 w 414
experience 3 w 424
succeeding 1 w 434
more 1 w 438
than 1 w 442
those 1 w 447
who 2 w 450
have 2 w 454
theory 1 w 460
without 1 w 467
experience 4 w 477
The 1 w 481
reason 1 w 487
of 5 w 489
this 4 w 493
is 10 w 495
a 39 w 496
that 7 w 500
experience 5 w 510
is 11 w 512
knowledge 1 w 521
of 6 w 523
particulars 1 w 534
but 2 w 538
art 4 w 541
of 7 w 543
universals 1 w 553
and 3 w 557
actions 1 w 564
and 4 w 567
the 4 w 570
effects 1 w 577
produced 1 w 585
are 1 w 588
all 3 w 591
concerned 1 w 600
with 3 w 604
the 5 w 607
particular 2 w 617
For 1 w 621
it 7 w 623
is 12 w 625
not 1 w 628
man 1 w 631
that 8 w 635
the 6 w 638
physician 1 w 647
cures 1 w 652
except 1 w 659
incidentally 1 w 671
but 3 w 675
Callias 2 w 682
or 10 w 684
Socrates 2 w 692
or 11 w 694
some 1 w 698
other 2 w 703
person 2 w 709
similarly 2 w 718
named 1 w 723
who 3 w 727
is 13 w 729
incidentally 2 w 741
a 62 w 742
man 2 w 745
as 9 w 747
well 1 w 751
So 3 w 754
if 1 w 756
a 65 w 757
man 3 w 760
has 1 w 763
theory 2 w 769
without 2 w 776
experience 6 w 786
and 5 w 790
knows 1 w 795
the 9 w 798
universal 2 w 807
but 4 w 811
does 1 w 815
not 2 w 818
know 3 w 822
the 10 w 825
particular 3 w 835
contained 1 w 844
in 13 w 846
it 9 w 848
he 14 w 851
will 1 w 855
often 1 w 860
fail 1 w 864
in 14 w 866
his 5 w 869
treatment 1 w 878
for 2 w 882
it 10 w 884
is 15 w 886
the 11 w 889
particular 4 w 899
that 9 w 903
must 1 w 907
be 3 w 909
treated 1 w 916
Nevertheless 1 w 929
we 3 w 931
consider 2 w 939
that 10 w 943
knowledge 2 w 952
and 6 w 955
proficiency 1 w 966
belong 1 w 972
to 3 w 974
art 8 w 977
rather 1 w 983
than 2 w 987
to 4 w 989
experience 7 w 999
and 7 w 1003
we 4 w 1005
assume 1 w 1011
that 11 w 1015
artists 1 w 1022
are 2 w 1025
wiser 1 w 1030
than 3 w 1034
men 4 w 1037
of 10 w 1039
mere 1 w 1043
experience 8 w 1053
which 1 w 1059
implies 1 w 1066
that 12 w 1070
in 15 w 1072
all 7 w 1075
cases 1 w 1080
wisdom 1 w 1086
depends 1 w 1093
rather 2 w 1099
upon 1 w 1103
knowledge 3 w 1112