Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Metaphysics

Metaphysics (1.1.11-1.1.15)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg025.perseus-eng2:1.1.11-1.1.15
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.1.11', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 1 Subsection 11'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.1.15', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 1 Subsection 15'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

and this is because the former know the cause, whereas the latter do not. For the experienced know the fact, but not the wherefore; but the artists know the wherefore and the cause. For the same reason we consider that the master craftsmen in every profession are more estimable and know more and are wiser than the artisans,

981b
1
because they know the reasons of the things which are done; but we think that the artisans, like certain inanimate objects, do things, but without knowing what they are doing (as, for instance, fire burns);

only whereas inanimate objects perform all their actions in virtue of a certain natural quality, artisans perform theirs through habit. Thus the master craftsmen are superior in wisdom, not because they can do things, but because they possess a theory and know the causes.

In general the sign of knowledge or ignorance is the ability to teach, and for this reason we hold that art rather than experience is scientific knowledge; for the artists can teach, but the others cannot.

Further, we do not consider any of the senses to be Wisdom. They are indeed our chief sources of knowledge about particulars, but they do not tell us the reason for anything, as for example why fire is hot, but only that it is hot.

It is therefore probable that at first the inventor of any art which went further than the ordinary sensations was admired by his fellow-men, not merely because some of his inventions were useful, but as being a wise and superior person.

And as more and more arts were discovered, some relating to the necessities and some to the pastimes of life, the inventors of the latter were always considered wiser than those of the former,

20
because their branches of knowledge did not aim at utility.

Tokens

and 1 w 3
this 1 w 7
is 2 w 9
because 1 w 16
the 1 w 19
former 1 w 25
know 1 w 29
the 2 w 32
cause 2 w 37
whereas 1 w 45
the 3 w 48
latter 1 w 54
do 1 w 56
not 1 w 59
For 1 w 63
the 4 w 66
experienced 1 w 77
know 2 w 81
the 5 w 84
fact 1 w 88
but 1 w 92
not 2 w 95
the 6 w 98
wherefore 1 w 107
but 2 w 111
the 7 w 114
artists 1 w 121
know 3 w 125
the 8 w 128
wherefore 2 w 137
and 2 w 140
the 9 w 143
cause 3 w 148
For 2 w 152
the 10 w 155
same 1 w 159
reason 1 w 165
we 1 w 167
consider 1 w 175
that 1 w 179
the 11 w 182
master 1 w 188
craftsmen 1 w 197
in 1 w 199
every 1 w 204
profession 1 w 214
are 1 w 217
more 1 w 221
estimable 1 w 230
and 3 w 233
know 4 w 237
more 2 w 241
and 4 w 244
are 2 w 247
wiser 1 w 252
than 1 w 256
the 12 w 259
artisans 1 w 267
because 2 w 275
they 1 w 279
know 5 w 283
the 14 w 286
reasons 1 w 293
of 2 w 295
the 15 w 298
things 1 w 304
which 1 w 309
are 3 w 312
done 1 w 316
but 3 w 320
we 2 w 322
think 1 w 327
that 2 w 331
the 16 w 334
artisans 2 w 342
like 1 w 347
certain 1 w 354
inanimate 1 w 363
objects 1 w 370
do 3 w 373
things 2 w 379
but 4 w 383
without 1 w 390
knowing 1 w 397
what 1 w 401
they 2 w 405
are 4 w 408
doing 1 w 413
as 5 w 416
for 4 w 420
instance 1 w 428
fire 1 w 433
burns 1 w 438
only 1 w 444
whereas 2 w 451
inanimate 2 w 460
objects 2 w 467
perform 1 w 474
all 1 w 477
their 1 w 482
actions 1 w 489
in 11 w 491
virtue 1 w 497
of 3 w 499
a 41 w 500
certain 2 w 507
natural 1 w 514
quality 1 w 521
artisans 3 w 530
perform 2 w 537
theirs 1 w 543
through 1 w 550
habit 1 w 555
Thus 1 w 560
the 20 w 563
master 2 w 569
craftsmen 2 w 578
are 5 w 581
superior 1 w 589
in 13 w 591
wisdom 1 w 597
not 3 w 601
because 3 w 608
they 3 w 612
can 1 w 615
do 6 w 617
things 3 w 623
but 5 w 627
because 4 w 634
they 4 w 638
possess 1 w 645
a 55 w 646
theory 1 w 652
and 5 w 655
know 7 w 659
the 24 w 662
causes 1 w 668
In 1 w 671
general 1 w 678
the 25 w 681
sign 1 w 685
of 4 w 687
knowledge 1 w 696
or 13 w 698
ignorance 1 w 707
is 9 w 709
the 26 w 712
ability 1 w 719
to 1 w 721
teach 1 w 726
and 6 w 730
for 7 w 733
this 2 w 737
reason 3 w 743
we 3 w 745
hold 1 w 749
that 3 w 753
art 5 w 756
rather 1 w 762
than 2 w 766
experience 2 w 776
is 11 w 778
scientific 1 w 788
knowledge 2 w 797
for 8 w 801
the 28 w 804
artists 2 w 811
can 2 w 814
teach 2 w 819
but 6 w 823
the 29 w 826
others 1 w 832
cannot 1 w 838
Further 1 w 846
we 4 w 849
do 7 w 851
not 5 w 854
consider 2 w 862
any 1 w 865
of 5 w 867
the 32 w 870
senses 1 w 876
to 2 w 878
be 5 w 880
Wisdom 1 w 886
They 1 w 891
are 6 w 894
indeed 1 w 900
our 1 w 903
chief 1 w 908
sources 1 w 915
of 6 w 917
knowledge 3 w 926
about 1 w 931
particulars 1 w 942
but 7 w 946
they 5 w 950
do 9 w 952
not 6 w 955
tell 1 w 959
us 9 w 961
the 34 w 964
reason 4 w 970
for 9 w 973
anything 1 w 981
as 10 w 984
for 10 w 987
example 1 w 994
why 1 w 997
fire 2 w 1001
is 14 w 1003
hot 1 w 1006
but 8 w 1010
only 2 w 1014
that 4 w 1018
it 5 w 1020
is 15 w 1022
hot 2 w 1025
It 1 w 1028
is 16 w 1030
therefore 1 w 1039
probable 1 w 1047
that 5 w 1051
at 12 w 1053
first 1 w 1058
the 36 w 1061
inventor 1 w 1069
of 7 w 1071
any 3 w 1074
art 8 w 1077
which 2 w 1082
went 1 w 1086
further 1 w 1093
than 3 w 1097
the 38 w 1100
ordinary 1 w 1108
sensations 1 w 1118
was 1 w 1121
admired 1 w 1128
by 1 w 1130
his 3 w 1133
fellow-men 1 w 1143
not 7 w 1147
merely 1 w 1153
because 5 w 1160
some 1 w 1164
of 8 w 1166
his 4 w 1169
inventions 1 w 1179
were 1 w 1183
useful 1 w 1189
but 9 w 1193
as 12 w 1195
being 1 w 1200
a 94 w 1201
wise 2 w 1205
and 7 w 1208
superior 2 w 1216
person 1 w 1222
And 1 w 1226
as 13 w 1228
more 3 w 1232
and 8 w 1235
more 4 w 1239
arts 1 w 1243
were 2 w 1247
discovered 1 w 1257
some 2 w 1262
relating 1 w 1270
to 4 w 1272
the 39 w 1275
necessities 1 w 1286
and 9 w 1289
some 3 w 1293
to 5 w 1295
the 40 w 1298
pastimes 1 w 1306
of 9 w 1308
life 1 w 1312
the 41 w 1316
inventors 1 w 1325
of 10 w 1327
the 42 w 1330
latter 2 w 1336
were 3 w 1340
always 1 w 1346
considered 1 w 1356
wiser 2 w 1361
than 4 w 1365
those 1 w 1370
of 11 w 1372
the 43 w 1375
former 2 w 1381
because 6 w 1389
their 3 w 1394
branches 1 w 1402
of 12 w 1404
knowledge 4 w 1413
did 1 w 1416
not 8 w 1419
aim 1 w 1422
at 16 w 1424
utility 1 w 1431