Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Nicomachean Ethics

Nicomachean Ethics (1.3.3-1.3.7)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg010.perseus-eng2:1.3.3-1.3.7
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.3.3', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 3 Subsection 3'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.3.7', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 3 Subsection 7'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.3'}]
Children []
prev
plain text • XML
next

And a similar uncertainty surrounds the conception of the Good, because it frequently occurs that good things have harmful consequences: people have before now been ruined by wealth, and in other cases courage has cost men their lives.

We must therefore be content if, in dealing with subjects

20
and starting from premises thus uncertain, we succeed in presenting a broad outline of the truth: when our subjects and our premises are merely generalities, it is enough if we arrive at generally valid conclusions. Accordingly we may ask the student also to accept the various views we put forward in the same spirit; for it is the mark of an educated mind to expect that amount of exactness in each kind which the nature of the particular subject admits. It is equally unreasonable to accept merely probable conclusions from a mathematician and to demand strict demonstration from an orator.

Again, each man judges correctly those matters with which he is acquainted; it is of these that he is a competent critic.

1095a
1
To criticize a particular subject, therefore, a man must have been trained in that subject: to be a good critic generally, he must have had an all-round education. Hence the young are not fit to be students of Political Science.[*] For they have no experience of life and conduct, and it is these that supply the premises and subject matter of this branch of philosophy.

And moreover they are led by their feelings; so that they will study the subject to no purpose or advantage, since the end of this science is not knowledge but action.

And it makes no difference whether they are young in years or immature in character: the defect is not a question of time, it is because their life and its various aims are guided by feeling; for to such persons their knowledge is of no use, any more than it is to persons of defective self-restraint.[*] But Moral Science may be of great value to those who guide their desires and actions by principle.

Tokens

And 1 w 3
a 1 w 4
similar 1 w 11
uncertainty 1 w 22
surrounds 1 w 31
the 1 w 34
conception 1 w 44
of 1 w 46
the 2 w 49
Good 1 w 53
because 1 w 61
it 1 w 63
frequently 1 w 73
occurs 1 w 79
that 1 w 83
good 1 w 87
things 1 w 93
have 1 w 97
harmful 1 w 104
consequences 1 w 116
people 1 w 123
have 2 w 127
before 1 w 133
now 1 w 136
been 1 w 140
ruined 1 w 146
by 1 w 148
wealth 1 w 154
and 1 w 158
in 4 w 160
other 1 w 165
cases 1 w 170
courage 1 w 177
has 1 w 180
cost 1 w 184
men 1 w 187
their 1 w 192
lives 1 w 197
We 1 w 200
must 1 w 204
therefore 1 w 213
be 4 w 215
content 1 w 222
if 1 w 224
in 5 w 227
dealing 1 w 234
with 1 w 238
subjects 1 w 246
and 2 w 249
starting 1 w 257
from 1 w 261
premises 1 w 269
thus 1 w 273
uncertain 2 w 282
we 2 w 285
succeed 1 w 292
in 9 w 294
presenting 1 w 304
a 18 w 305
broad 1 w 310
outline 1 w 317
of 2 w 319
the 6 w 322
truth 1 w 327
when 1 w 332
our 2 w 335
subjects 2 w 343
and 3 w 346
our 3 w 349
premises 2 w 357
are 1 w 360
merely 1 w 366
generalities 1 w 378
it 4 w 381
is 3 w 383
enough 1 w 389
if 2 w 391
we 3 w 393
arrive 1 w 399
at 2 w 401
generally 1 w 410
valid 1 w 415
conclusions 1 w 426
Accordingly 1 w 438
we 4 w 440
may 1 w 443
ask 1 w 446
the 7 w 449
student 1 w 456
also 1 w 460
to 1 w 462
accept 1 w 468
the 8 w 471
various 1 w 478
views 1 w 483
we 5 w 485
put 1 w 488
forward 1 w 495
in 13 w 497
the 9 w 500
same 1 w 504
spirit 1 w 510
for 4 w 514
it 6 w 516
is 4 w 518
the 10 w 521
mark 1 w 525
of 3 w 527
an 4 w 529
educated 1 w 537
mind 1 w 541
to 2 w 543
expect 1 w 549
that 2 w 553
amount 1 w 559
of 4 w 561
exactness 1 w 570
in 15 w 572
each 1 w 576
kind 1 w 580
which 1 w 585
the 11 w 588
nature 1 w 594
of 5 w 596
the 12 w 599
particular 1 w 609
subject 3 w 616
admits 1 w 622
It 1 w 625
is 5 w 627
equally 1 w 634
unreasonable 1 w 646
to 3 w 648
accept 2 w 654
merely 2 w 660
probable 1 w 668
conclusions 2 w 679
from 2 w 683
a 50 w 684
mathematician 1 w 697
and 4 w 700
to 4 w 702
demand 1 w 708
strict 1 w 714
demonstration 1 w 727
from 3 w 731
an 8 w 733
orator 1 w 739
Again 1 w 745
each 2 w 750
man 2 w 753
judges 1 w 759
correctly 1 w 768
those 1 w 773
matters 1 w 780
with 2 w 784
which 2 w 789
he 15 w 791
is 6 w 793
acquainted 1 w 803
it 9 w 806
is 7 w 808
of 6 w 810
these 1 w 815
that 3 w 819
he 17 w 821
is 8 w 823
a 66 w 824
competent 1 w 833
critic 1 w 839
To 1 w 842
criticize 1 w 851
a 67 w 852
particular 2 w 862
subject 4 w 869
therefore 2 w 879
a 70 w 881
man 3 w 884
must 2 w 888
have 3 w 892
been 2 w 896
trained 1 w 903
in 20 w 905
that 4 w 909
subject 5 w 916
to 6 w 919
be 6 w 921
a 75 w 922
good 2 w 926
critic 3 w 932
generally 2 w 941
he 19 w 944
must 3 w 948
have 4 w 952
had 1 w 955
an 11 w 957
all-round 1 w 966
education 1 w 975
Hence 1 w 981
the 16 w 984
young 1 w 989
are 2 w 992
not 1 w 995
fit 1 w 998
to 7 w 1000
be 7 w 1002
students 1 w 1010
of 7 w 1012
Political 1 w 1021
Science 1 w 1028
Quoted 1 w 1035
in 21 w 1037
Troilus 1 w 1044
and 6 w 1047
Cressida 1 w 1055
II 1 w 1058
ii 1 w 1061
165 1 w 1065
Young 1 w 1072
men 2 w 1075
whom 1 w 1080
Aristotle 1 w 1089
thought 1 w 1096
Unfit 1 w 1102
to 9 w 1104
hear 1 w 1108
moral 1 w 1113
philosophy 1 w 1123
For 1 w 1127
they 1 w 1131
have 5 w 1135
no 4 w 1137
experience 1 w 1147
of 8 w 1149
life 1 w 1153
and 7 w 1156
conduct 1 w 1163
and 8 w 1167
it 16 w 1169
is 10 w 1171
these 2 w 1176
that 5 w 1180
supply 1 w 1186
the 19 w 1189
premises 3 w 1197
and 9 w 1200
subject 6 w 1207
matter 2 w 1213
of 9 w 1215
this 1 w 1219
branch 1 w 1225
of 10 w 1227
philosophy 2 w 1237
And 2 w 1241
moreover 1 w 1249
they 2 w 1253
are 3 w 1256
led 1 w 1259
by 2 w 1261
their 2 w 1266
feelings 1 w 1274
so 5 w 1277
that 6 w 1281
they 3 w 1285
will 1 w 1289
study 1 w 1294
the 23 w 1297
subject 7 w 1304
to 10 w 1306
no 5 w 1308
purpose 1 w 1315
or 13 w 1317
advantage 1 w 1326
since 1 w 1332
the 24 w 1335
end 1 w 1338
of 11 w 1340
this 2 w 1344
science 1 w 1351
is 14 w 1353
not 2 w 1356
knowledge 1 w 1365
but 1 w 1368
action 1 w 1374
And 3 w 1378
it 17 w 1380
makes 1 w 1385
no 8 w 1387
difference 1 w 1397
whether 1 w 1404
they 4 w 1408
are 4 w 1411
young 2 w 1416
in 24 w 1418
years 1 w 1423
or 14 w 1425
immature 1 w 1433
in 25 w 1435
character 1 w 1444
the 27 w 1448
defect 1 w 1454
is 15 w 1456
not 3 w 1459
a 107 w 1460
question 1 w 1468
of 12 w 1470
time 1 w 1474
it 18 w 1477
is 16 w 1479
because 2 w 1486
their 3 w 1491
life 2 w 1495
and 10 w 1498
its 2 w 1501
various 2 w 1508
aims 1 w 1512
are 5 w 1515
guided 1 w 1521
by 3 w 1523
feeling 2 w 1530
for 6 w 1534
to 11 w 1536
such 1 w 1540
persons 1 w 1547
their 4 w 1552
knowledge 2 w 1561
is 17 w 1563
of 13 w 1565
no 11 w 1567
use 3 w 1570
any 1 w 1574
more 2 w 1578
than 1 w 1582
it 20 w 1584
is 18 w 1586
to 12 w 1588
persons 2 w 1595
of 14 w 1597
defective 1 w 1606
self-restraint 1 w 1620
The 1 w 1624
argument 1 w 1632
is 19 w 1634
that 7 w 1639
even 1 w 1643
if 6 w 1645
the 30 w 1648
young 3 w 1653
could 1 w 1658
gain 2 w 1662
a 119 w 1663
knowledge 3 w 1672
of 15 w 1674
Ethics 1 w 1680
which 3 w 1686
they 5 w 1690
cannot 1 w 1696
because 3 w 1704
it 21 w 1706
requires 1 w 1714
experience 2 w 1724
of 16 w 1726
life 3 w 1730
they 6 w 1736
would 1 w 1741
not 5 w 1744
use 5 w 1747
it 22 w 1749
as 5 w 1751
a 123 w 1752
guide 2 w 1757
to 13 w 1759
conduct 2 w 1766
because 4 w 1774
they 7 w 1778
are 6 w 1781
led 5 w 1784
by 4 w 1786
their 5 w 1791
passions 1 w 1799
and 11 w 1802
appetites 1 w 1811
and 12 w 1815
therefore 3 w 1824
the 36 w 1827
study 2 w 1832
is 20 w 1834
of 17 w 1836
no 15 w 1838
value 1 w 1843
for 8 w 1846
them 2 w 1850
since 2 w 1856
Ethics 2 w 1862
being 1 w 1868
a 131 w 1869
practical 1 w 1878
science 2 w 1885
is 21 w 1888
only 1 w 1892
pursued 1 w 1899
for 9 w 1902
the 38 w 1905
sake 1 w 1909
of 18 w 1911
its 3 w 1914
practical 2 w 1923
application 1 w 1934
But 1 w 1938
Moral 1 w 1943
Science 2 w 1950
may 2 w 1953
be 12 w 1955
of 19 w 1957
great 1 w 1962
value 2 w 1967
to 14 w 1969
those 2 w 1974
who 2 w 1977
guide 3 w 1982
their 6 w 1987
desires 1 w 1994
and 13 w 1997
actions 1 w 2004
by 5 w 2006
principle 1 w 2015