Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Eudemian Ethics

Eudemian Ethics (1.2.3-1.3.2)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg009.perseus-eng2:1.2.3-1.3.2
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.2.3', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 2 Subsection 3'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.3.2', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 3 Subsection 2'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}, {'reference': '1.2'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

and this is similarly the case with many other things; consequently also to live finely is not the same as the things without which living finely is impossible.

And in the latter class of things some that are indispensable conditions of health and life are not peculiar to special people but common to practically all menboth some states and some actionsfor instance, without breathing or being awake or participating in movement we could not possess any good or any evil at all; whereas others are more peculiar to special types of natural constitution

20
for instance, eating meat and taking walking exercise after dinner are not closely related to health in the same way as the conditions mentioned. And these facts must not be overlooked,[*]

for these are the causes of the disputes about the real nature of happiness and about the means of procuring it; for some people regard the things that are indispensable conditions of being happy as actual parts of happiness.

Now to examine all the opinions that any people hold about happiness is a superfluous task[*] For children and the sick and insane have many opinions which no sensible man would discuss, for these persons need not argument but the former time in which to grow up and alter and the latter medical or official chastisement (treatment with drugs being chastisement just as much as flogging is).

And similarly it is also superfluous to examine the opinions of the multitude[*] either;

1215a
1
for they talk at random about almost everything, and especially about happiness. We ought to examine only the opinions of the wise[*]; for it is out of place to apply reasoning to those who do not need reasoning at all, but experience.

Tokens

and 1 w 3
this 1 w 7
is 2 w 9
similarly 1 w 18
the 1 w 21
case 1 w 25
with 1 w 29
many 1 w 33
other 1 w 38
things 1 w 44
consequently 1 w 57
also 1 w 61
to 1 w 63
live 1 w 67
finely 1 w 73
is 3 w 75
not 1 w 78
the 3 w 81
same 1 w 85
as 2 w 87
the 4 w 90
things 2 w 96
without 1 w 103
which 1 w 108
living 1 w 114
finely 2 w 120
is 4 w 122
impossible 1 w 132
And 1 w 136
in 6 w 138
the 5 w 141
latter 1 w 147
class 1 w 152
of 1 w 154
things 3 w 160
some 1 w 164
that 1 w 168
are 1 w 171
indispensable 1 w 184
conditions 1 w 194
of 2 w 196
health 1 w 202
and 2 w 205
life 1 w 209
are 2 w 212
not 2 w 215
peculiar 1 w 223
to 2 w 225
special 1 w 232
people 1 w 238
but 1 w 241
common 1 w 247
to 3 w 249
practically 1 w 260
all 2 w 263
men 1 w 266
both 1 w 271
some 2 w 275
states 1 w 281
and 3 w 284
some 3 w 288
actions 1 w 295
for 1 w 299
instance 1 w 307
without 2 w 315
breathing 1 w 324
or 2 w 326
being 1 w 331
awake 1 w 336
or 3 w 338
participating 1 w 351
in 13 w 353
movement 1 w 361
we 1 w 363
could 1 w 368
not 3 w 371
possess 1 w 378
any 2 w 381
good 1 w 385
or 4 w 387
any 3 w 390
evil 1 w 394
at 6 w 396
all 3 w 399
whereas 1 w 407
others 1 w 413
are 3 w 416
more 1 w 420
peculiar 2 w 428
to 4 w 430
special 2 w 437
types 1 w 442
of 3 w 444
natural 1 w 451
constitution 1 w 463
for 2 w 467
instance 2 w 475
eating 1 w 482
meat 1 w 486
and 4 w 489
taking 1 w 495
walking 1 w 502
exercise 1 w 510
after 1 w 515
dinner 1 w 521
are 4 w 524
not 4 w 527
closely 1 w 534
related 1 w 541
to 5 w 543
health 2 w 549
in 19 w 551
the 7 w 554
same 2 w 558
way 1 w 561
as 5 w 563
the 8 w 566
conditions 2 w 576
mentioned 1 w 585
And 2 w 589
these 1 w 594
facts 1 w 599
must 1 w 603
not 5 w 606
be 2 w 608
overlooked 1 w 618
In 1 w 621
the 10 w 624
Mss 1 w 627
this 2 w 632
clause 1 w 638
comes 1 w 643
before 1 w 649
the 11 w 652
preceding 1 w 661
one 2 w 664
for 4 w 668
instance 3 w 676
eating 2 w 683
meat 2 w 687
mentioned 2 w 699
for 5 w 703
these 2 w 708
are 5 w 711
the 13 w 714
causes 1 w 720
of 4 w 722
the 14 w 725
disputes 1 w 733
about 1 w 738
the 15 w 741
real 1 w 745
nature 1 w 751
of 5 w 753
happiness 1 w 762
and 5 w 765
about 2 w 770
the 16 w 773
means 1 w 778
of 6 w 780
procuring 1 w 789
it 7 w 791
for 6 w 795
some 4 w 799
people 2 w 805
regard 1 w 811
the 17 w 814
things 4 w 820
that 2 w 824
are 6 w 827
indispensable 2 w 840
conditions 3 w 850
of 7 w 852
being 2 w 857
happy 1 w 862
as 6 w 864
actual 1 w 870
parts 1 w 875
of 8 w 877
happiness 2 w 886
Now 1 w 890
to 6 w 892
examine 1 w 899
all 4 w 902
the 18 w 905
opinions 1 w 913
that 3 w 917
any 4 w 920
people 3 w 926
hold 1 w 930
about 3 w 935
happiness 3 w 944
is 10 w 946
a 83 w 947
superfluous 1 w 958
task 1 w 962
Cf 1 w 964
Aristot 1 w 972
Nic 1 w 976
Eth 1 w 980
1095a 1 w 986
28-30 1 w 991
b 14 w 993
19ff 1 w 997
For 1 w 1001
children 1 w 1009
and 6 w 1012
the 19 w 1015
sick 1 w 1019
and 7 w 1022
insane 1 w 1028
have 1 w 1032
many 2 w 1036
opinions 2 w 1044
which 2 w 1049
no 6 w 1051
sensible 1 w 1059
man 3 w 1062
would 1 w 1067
discuss 1 w 1074
for 7 w 1078
these 3 w 1083
persons 1 w 1090
need 1 w 1094
not 6 w 1097
argument 1 w 1105
but 2 w 1108
the 21 w 1111
former 1 w 1117
time 1 w 1121
in 34 w 1123
which 3 w 1128
to 8 w 1130
grow 1 w 1134
up 2 w 1136
and 8 w 1139
alter 1 w 1144
and 9 w 1147
the 22 w 1150
latter 2 w 1156
medical 1 w 1163
or 14 w 1165
official 1 w 1173
chastisement 1 w 1185
treatment 1 w 1195
with 4 w 1199
drugs 1 w 1204
being 3 w 1209
chastisement 2 w 1221
just 1 w 1225
as 10 w 1227
much 1 w 1231
as 11 w 1233
flogging 1 w 1241
is 15 w 1243
And 3 w 1248
similarly 2 w 1257
it 10 w 1259
is 16 w 1261
also 2 w 1265
superfluous 2 w 1276
to 9 w 1278
examine 2 w 1285
the 23 w 1288
opinions 3 w 1296
of 10 w 1298
the 24 w 1301
multitude 1 w 1310
Cf 2 w 1312
Aristot 2 w 1320
Nic 2 w 1324
Eth 2 w 1328
1095b 1 w 1334
19 2 w 1336
either 1 w 1343
for 9 w 1347
they 1 w 1351
talk 1 w 1355
at 18 w 1357
random 1 w 1363
about 4 w 1368
almost 1 w 1374
everything 1 w 1384
and 11 w 1388
especially 1 w 1398
about 5 w 1403
happiness 4 w 1412
We 1 w 1415
ought 1 w 1420
to 11 w 1422
examine 3 w 1429
only 1 w 1433
the 27 w 1436
opinions 4 w 1444
of 11 w 1446
the 28 w 1449
wise 1 w 1453
The 1 w 1456
words 1 w 1461
translated 1 w 1471
happiness 5 w 1480
and 12 w 1483
the 29 w 1486
opinions 5 w 1494
of 12 w 1496
the 30 w 1499
wise 2 w 1503
are 7 w 1506
conjectural 1 w 1517
insertions 1 w 1527
in 46 w 1529
the 31 w 1532
Greek 1 w 1537
for 10 w 1542
it 13 w 1544
is 20 w 1546
out 8 w 1549
of 13 w 1551
place 1 w 1556
to 12 w 1558
apply 1 w 1563
reasoning 1 w 1572
to 13 w 1574
those 1 w 1579
who 1 w 1582
do 2 w 1584
not 7 w 1587
need 2 w 1591
reasoning 2 w 1600
at 20 w 1602
all 6 w 1605
but 3 w 1609
experience 1 w 1619