Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / A Slip of the Tongue in Salutation

A Slip of the Tongue in Salutation (1-5)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg058.perseus-eng4:1-5
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1', 'human_reference': 'None 1'}, 'end': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'None 5'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

If a poor mortal has some difficulty in guarding against that spirit of mischief which dwells aloft, he has still more in clearing himself of the absurd consequences when that spirit trips him up. Iam in both predicaments at once; coming to make you my morning salutation, which should have taken the orthodox form of Rejoice, I bade you, in a very choice fit of absentmindedness, Be healthya good enough wish in its way, but a little untimely and unconnected with that early hour. I at

v.2.p.35
once went moist and red, not quite aware whether I was on my head or my heels; some of the company took me for a lunatic, no doubt, some thought I was in my second childhood, some that I had not quite got over my last nights winethough you yourself were the pink of good manners, not showing your consciousness of the slip by any ghost of a smile. It occurred to me to write to myself a little something in the way of comfort, and so modify the distress my blunder gave meprove to myself that it was not absolutely unpardonable for an old man to transgress etiquette so flagrantly before so many witnesses. As to apology, there could be no occasion for that, when ones slip had resulted in so well-omened a wish.

I began to write expecting my task to be very difficult, but found plenty of material as I went on. I will defer it, however, till I have cleared the way with a few necessary remarks on the three formsRejoice or Joy, Prosper or Prosperity, Hail or Health. Joy is a very ancient greeting; but it was not confined to the morning, or the first meeting. They did use it when they first saw one another:

Joy to thee, Lord of this Tirynthian land!
But again at the moment when the wine succeeded to the meal:
Achilles, Joy! We lack not fair repast
so says Odysseus discharging his embassy. And even at parting:
Joy be with you! And henceforth know me God,
No longer mortal man,
In fact the apostrophe was not limited to any particular season, as now to the morning alone; indeed they used it on gloomy, nay, on the most lamentable occasions; in Euripides, Polynices ends his life with the words,
Joy with you! for the darkness closes on me.
v.2.p.36
Nor was it necessarily significative of friendliness; it could express hatred and the determination to see no more of another. To wish much joy to, was a regular form for ceasing to care about.

The modern use of the word dates back to Philippides the dispatch-runner. Bringing the news of Marathon, he found the archons seated, in suspense regarding the issue of the battle

Joy, we win!’ he said, and died upon his message, breathing his last in the word Joy. The earliest letter beginning with it is that in which Cleon the Athenian demagogue, writing from Sphacteria, sends the good news of his victory and capture of Spartans at that place. However, later than that we find Nicias writing from Sicily and keeping to the older custom of coming to business at once with no such introduction.

Now the admirable Plato, no bad authority on such matters, would have us reject the salutation Joy altogether; it is a mean wish, wanting in seriousness, according to him; his substitute is Prosperity, which stands for a satisfactory condition both of body and soul; in a letter to Dionysius, he reproves him for commencing a hymn to Apollo with Joy, which he maintains is unworthy of the Pythian, and not fit even for men of any discretion, not to mention Gods.

Pythagoras the mystic has vouchsafed us no writings of his own; but we may infer from his disciples, Ocellus the Lucanian and Archytas, for instance, that he headed his letters neither with Joy nor Prosperity, but recommended beginning with Hail. At any rate all the Pythagoreans in writing to one another (when their tone is serious, that is) started with wishing Health, which they took to be the prime need of soul and body alike, and to include all human blessings, The Pentagram[*], that interlaced triple triangle which served them as a sort of password, they called by the name Health. They argued that

v.2.p.37
Health included Joy and Prosperity, but that neither of those two was coextensive with Health. Some of them gave to the Quaternion[*], which is their most solemn oath, and sums their perfect number, the name of Beginning of Health. Philolaus might be quoted.

If 1 w 2
a 1 w 3
poor 1 w 7
mortal 1 w 13
has 1 w 16
some 1 w 20
difficulty 1 w 30
in 1 w 32
guarding 1 w 40
against 1 w 47
that 1 w 51
spirit 1 w 57
of 1 w 59
mischief 1 w 67
which 1 w 72
dwells 1 w 78
aloft 1 w 83
he 1 w 86
has 2 w 89
still 1 w 94
more 1 w 98
in 4 w 100
clearing 1 w 108
himself 1 w 115
of 3 w 117
the 1 w 120
absurd 1 w 126
consequences 1 w 138
when 1 w 142
that 2 w 146
spirit 2 w 152
trips 1 w 157
him 2 w 160
up 1 w 162
Iam 1 w 166
in 6 w 168
both 1 w 172
predicaments 1 w 184
at 3 w 186
once 1 w 190
coming 1 w 197
to 1 w 199
make 1 w 203
you 1 w 206
my 1 w 208
morning 1 w 215
salutation 1 w 225
which 2 w 231
should 1 w 237
have 1 w 241
taken 1 w 246
the 2 w 249
orthodox 1 w 257
form 1 w 261
of 4 w 263
Rejoice 1 w 270
I 3 w 272
bade 1 w 276
you 2 w 279
in 9 w 282
a 22 w 283
very 1 w 287
choice 1 w 293
fit 1 w 296
of 5 w 298
absentmindedness 1 w 314
Be 1 w 317
healthy 1 w 324
a 25 w 326
good 1 w 330
enough 1 w 336
wish 1 w 340
in 11 w 342
its 1 w 345
way 1 w 348
but 1 w 352
a 27 w 353
little 1 w 359
untimely 1 w 367
and 1 w 370
unconnected 1 w 381
with 1 w 385
that 3 w 389
early 1 w 394
hour 1 w 398
I 4 w 400
at 6 w 402
once 2 w 406
went 1 w 410
moist 1 w 415
and 2 w 418
red 2 w 421
not 1 w 425
quite 1 w 430
aware 1 w 435
whether 1 w 442
I 5 w 443
was 1 w 446
on 6 w 448
my 2 w 450
head 1 w 454
or 7 w 456
my 3 w 458
heels 1 w 463
some 2 w 468
of 6 w 470
the 4 w 473
company 1 w 480
took 1 w 484
me 5 w 486
for 2 w 489
a 38 w 490
lunatic 1 w 497
no 3 w 500
doubt 1 w 505
some 3 w 510
thought 1 w 517
I 6 w 518
was 2 w 521
in 12 w 523
my 4 w 525
second 1 w 531
childhood 1 w 540
some 4 w 545
that 4 w 549
I 7 w 550
had 1 w 553
not 2 w 556
quite 2 w 561
got 1 w 564
over 1 w 568
my 5 w 570
last 1 w 574
night 1 w 579
s 32 w 581
wine 1 w 585
though 2 w 592
you 3 w 595
yourself 1 w 603
were 1 w 607
the 5 w 610
pink 1 w 614
of 7 w 616
good 2 w 620
manners 1 w 627
not 3 w 631
showing 1 w 638
your 2 w 642
consciousness 1 w 655
of 8 w 657
the 6 w 660
slip 1 w 664
by 1 w 666
any 2 w 669
ghost 1 w 674
of 9 w 676
a 46 w 677
smile 1 w 682
It 1 w 685
occurred 1 w 693
to 3 w 695
me 8 w 697
to 4 w 699
write 1 w 704
to 5 w 706
myself 1 w 712
a 47 w 713
little 2 w 719
something 1 w 728
in 17 w 730
the 7 w 733
way 2 w 736
of 10 w 738
comfort 1 w 745
and 3 w 749
so 6 w 751
modify 1 w 757
the 8 w 760
distress 1 w 768
my 7 w 770
blunder 1 w 777
gave 1 w 781
me 10 w 783
prove 1 w 789
to 6 w 791
myself 2 w 797
that 5 w 801
it 11 w 803
was 3 w 806
not 4 w 809
absolutely 1 w 819
unpardonable 1 w 831
for 4 w 834
an 7 w 836
old 1 w 839
man 2 w 842
to 7 w 844
transgress 1 w 854
etiquette 1 w 863
so 8 w 865
flagrantly 1 w 875
before 1 w 881
so 9 w 883
many 1 w 887
witnesses 1 w 896
As 1 w 899
to 8 w 901
apology 1 w 908
there 1 w 914
could 1 w 919
be 2 w 921
no 7 w 923
occasion 1 w 931
for 6 w 934
that 6 w 938
when 2 w 943
one 1 w 946
s 62 w 948
slip 2 w 952
had 2 w 955
resulted 1 w 963
in 18 w 965
so 10 w 967
well-omened 1 w 978
a 66 w 979
wish 2 w 983
I 9 w 985
began 1 w 990
to 9 w 992
write 2 w 997
expecting 1 w 1006
my 9 w 1008
task 1 w 1012
to 10 w 1014
be 4 w 1016
very 2 w 1020
difficult 2 w 1029
but 2 w 1033
found 1 w 1038
plenty 1 w 1044
of 11 w 1046
material 1 w 1054
as 9 w 1056
I 10 w 1057
went 2 w 1061
on 12 w 1063
I 11 w 1065
will 1 w 1069
defer 1 w 1074
it 14 w 1076
however 1 w 1084
till 2 w 1089
I 12 w 1090
have 2 w 1094
cleared 1 w 1101
the 10 w 1104
way 3 w 1107
with 2 w 1111
a 75 w 1112
few 1 w 1115
necessary 1 w 1124
remarks 1 w 1131
on 13 w 1133
the 11 w 1136
three 1 w 1141
forms 1 w 1146
Rejoice 2 w 1154
or 14 w 1156
Joy 1 w 1159
Prosper 1 w 1167
or 15 w 1169
Prosperity 1 w 1179
Hail 1 w 1184
or 16 w 1186
Health 1 w 1192
Joy 2 w 1196
is 6 w 1198
a 80 w 1199
very 3 w 1203
ancient 1 w 1210
greeting 1 w 1218
but 3 w 1222
it 17 w 1224
was 4 w 1227
not 5 w 1230
confined 1 w 1238
to 11 w 1240
the 12 w 1243
morning 2 w 1250
or 18 w 1253
the 13 w 1256
first 1 w 1261
meeting 1 w 1268
They 1 w 1273
did 1 w 1276
use 1 w 1279
it 18 w 1281
when 3 w 1285
they 1 w 1289
first 2 w 1294
saw 1 w 1297
one 2 w 1300
another 1 w 1307
Joy 3 w 1311
to 12 w 1313
thee 1 w 1317
Lord 1 w 1322
of 12 w 1324
this 1 w 1328
Tirynthian 1 w 1338
land 1 w 1342
But 1 w 1346
again 2 w 1351
at 12 w 1353
the 17 w 1356
moment 1 w 1362
when 4 w 1366
the 18 w 1369
wine 2 w 1373
succeeded 1 w 1382
to 13 w 1384
the 19 w 1387
meal 1 w 1391
Achilles 1 w 1400
Joy 4 w 1404
We 1 w 1407
lack 1 w 1411
not 7 w 1414
fair 1 w 1418
repast 1 w 1424
so 11 w 1427
says 1 w 1431
Odysseus 1 w 1439
discharging 1 w 1450
his 2 w 1453
embassy 1 w 1460
And 1 w 1464
even 1 w 1468
at 13 w 1470
parting 1 w 1477
Joy 5 w 1481
be 5 w 1483
with 3 w 1487
you 6 w 1490
And 2 w 1494
henceforth 1 w 1504
know 1 w 1508
me 15 w 1510
God 1 w 1513
No 1 w 1516
longer 1 w 1522
mortal 2 w 1528
man 4 w 1531
In 1 w 1534
fact 1 w 1538
the 20 w 1541
apostrophe 1 w 1551
was 5 w 1554
not 8 w 1557
limited 1 w 1564
to 14 w 1566
any 4 w 1569
particular 1 w 1579
season 1 w 1585
as 15 w 1588
now 2 w 1591
to 15 w 1593
the 21 w 1596
morning 3 w 1603
alone 1 w 1608
indeed 1 w 1615
they 2 w 1619
used 1 w 1623
it 21 w 1625
on 19 w 1627
gloomy 1 w 1633
nay 1 w 1637
on 20 w 1640
the 23 w 1643
most 1 w 1647
lamentable 1 w 1657
occasions 1 w 1666
in 30 w 1669
Euripides 1 w 1678
Polynices 1 w 1688
ends 1 w 1692
his 3 w 1695
life 1 w 1699
with 4 w 1703
the 24 w 1706
words 1 w 1711
Joy 6 w 1715
with 5 w 1719
you 7 w 1722
for 9 w 1726
the 25 w 1729
darkness 1 w 1737
closes 1 w 1743
on 22 w 1745
me 17 w 1747
Nor 1 w 1751
was 6 w 1754
it 24 w 1756
necessarily 1 w 1767
significative 1 w 1780
of 13 w 1782
friendliness 1 w 1794
it 25 w 1797
could 2 w 1802
express 1 w 1809
hatred 1 w 1815
and 5 w 1818
the 26 w 1821
determination 1 w 1834
to 16 w 1836
see 1 w 1839
no 14 w 1841
more 2 w 1845
of 14 w 1847
another 2 w 1854
To 1 w 1857
wish 3 w 1861
much 1 w 1865
joy 1 w 1868
to 17 w 1870
was 7 w 1874
a 123 w 1875
regular 1 w 1882
form 3 w 1886
for 11 w 1889
ceasing 1 w 1896
to 18 w 1898
care 1 w 1902
about 1 w 1907
The 2 w 1911
modern 1 w 1917
use 3 w 1920
of 15 w 1922
the 28 w 1925
word 2 w 1929
dates 1 w 1934
back 1 w 1938
to 19 w 1940
Philippides 1 w 1951
the 29 w 1954
dispatch-runner 1 w 1969
Bringing 1 w 1978
the 30 w 1981
news 1 w 1985
of 16 w 1987
Marathon 1 w 1995
he 44 w 1998
found 2 w 2003
the 31 w 2006
archons 1 w 2013
seated 1 w 2019
in 36 w 2022
suspense 1 w 2030
regarding 1 w 2039
the 32 w 2042
issue 1 w 2047
of 17 w 2049
the 33 w 2052
battle 1 w 2058
Joy 7 w 2062
we 7 w 2065
win 4 w 2068
he 48 w 2072
said 1 w 2076
and 6 w 2080
died 1 w 2084
upon 1 w 2088
his 4 w 2091
message 1 w 2098
breathing 1 w 2108
his 5 w 2111
last 2 w 2115
in 40 w 2117
the 34 w 2120
word 3 w 2124
Joy 8 w 2127
The 3 w 2131
earliest 1 w 2139
letter 1 w 2145
beginning 1 w 2154
with 6 w 2158
it 27 w 2160
is 16 w 2162
that 7 w 2166
in 43 w 2168
which 3 w 2173
Cleon 1 w 2178
the 35 w 2181
Athenian 1 w 2189
demagogue 1 w 2198
writing 1 w 2206
from 1 w 2210
Sphacteria 1 w 2220
sends 1 w 2226
the 37 w 2229
good 3 w 2233
news 2 w 2237
of 18 w 2239
his 6 w 2242
victory 1 w 2249
and 7 w 2252
capture 1 w 2259
of 19 w 2261
Spartans 1 w 2269
at 24 w 2271
that 8 w 2275
place 1 w 2280
However 1 w 2288
later 1 w 2294
than 1 w 2298
that 9 w 2302
we 9 w 2304
find 1 w 2308
Nicias 1 w 2314
writing 2 w 2321
from 2 w 2325
Sicily 1 w 2331
and 8 w 2334
keeping 1 w 2341
to 21 w 2343
the 38 w 2346
older 1 w 2351
custom 1 w 2357
of 20 w 2359
coming 2 w 2365
to 23 w 2367
business 1 w 2375
at 28 w 2377
once 3 w 2381
with 7 w 2385
no 16 w 2387
such 1 w 2391
introduction 1 w 2403
Now 1 w 2407
the 39 w 2410
admirable 1 w 2419
Plato 1 w 2424
no 17 w 2427
bad 2 w 2430
authority 1 w 2439
on 30 w 2441
such 2 w 2445
matters 1 w 2452
would 1 w 2458
have 3 w 2462
us 9 w 2464
reject 1 w 2470
the 40 w 2473
salutation 2 w 2483
Joy 9 w 2486
altogether 1 w 2496
it 32 w 2499
is 18 w 2501
a 171 w 2502
mean 1 w 2506
wish 4 w 2510
wanting 1 w 2518
in 52 w 2520
seriousness 1 w 2531
according 1 w 2541
to 26 w 2543
him 3 w 2546
his 7 w 2550
substitute 1 w 2560
is 21 w 2562
Prosperity 2 w 2572
which 4 w 2578
stands 1 w 2584
for 12 w 2587
a 176 w 2588
satisfactory 1 w 2600
condition 1 w 2609
both 2 w 2613
of 21 w 2615
body 1 w 2619
and 10 w 2622
soul 1 w 2626
in 54 w 2629
a 180 w 2630
letter 2 w 2636
to 28 w 2638
Dionysius 1 w 2647
he 58 w 2650
reproves 1 w 2658
him 4 w 2661
for 13 w 2664
commencing 1 w 2674
a 181 w 2675
hymn 1 w 2679
to 29 w 2681
Apollo 1 w 2687
with 8 w 2691
Joy 10 w 2694
which 5 w 2700
he 59 w 2702
maintains 1 w 2711
is 23 w 2713
unworthy 1 w 2721
of 22 w 2723
the 42 w 2726
Pythian 1 w 2733
and 11 w 2737
not 10 w 2740
fit 2 w 2743
even 2 w 2747
for 14 w 2750
men 6 w 2753
of 23 w 2755
any 5 w 2758
discretion 1 w 2768
not 11 w 2772
to 30 w 2774
mention 1 w 2781
Gods 1 w 2785
Pythagoras 1 w 2796
the 43 w 2799
mystic 1 w 2805
has 3 w 2808
vouchsafed 1 w 2818
us 12 w 2820
no 20 w 2822
writings 1 w 2830
of 24 w 2832
his 8 w 2835
own 1 w 2838
but 4 w 2842
we 10 w 2844
may 1 w 2847
infer 1 w 2852
from 3 w 2856
his 9 w 2859
disciples 1 w 2868
Ocellus 1 w 2876
the 44 w 2879
Lucanian 1 w 2887
and 12 w 2890
Archytas 1 w 2898
for 15 w 2902
instance 1 w 2910
that 10 w 2915
he 63 w 2917
headed 1 w 2923
his 10 w 2926
letters 1 w 2933
neither 1 w 2940
with 9 w 2944
Joy 11 w 2947
nor 1 w 2950
Prosperity 3 w 2960
but 5 w 2964
recommended 1 w 2975
beginning 2 w 2984
with 10 w 2988
Hail 2 w 2992
At 2 w 2995
any 6 w 2998
rate 1 w 3002
all 1 w 3005
the 46 w 3008
Pythagoreans 1 w 3020
in 63 w 3022
writing 4 w 3029
to 31 w 3031
one 4 w 3034
another 3 w 3041
when 5 w 3046
their 1 w 3051
tone 1 w 3055
is 29 w 3057
serious 2 w 3064
that 11 w 3069
is 30 w 3071
started 1 w 3079
with 11 w 3083
wishing 1 w 3090
Health 2 w 3096
which 6 w 3102
they 3 w 3106
took 2 w 3110
to 34 w 3112
be 8 w 3114
the 50 w 3117
prime 1 w 3122
need 1 w 3126
of 25 w 3128
soul 2 w 3132
and 13 w 3135
body 2 w 3139
alike 1 w 3144
and 14 w 3148
to 35 w 3150
include 1 w 3157
all 2 w 3160
human 1 w 3165
blessings 1 w 3174
The 4 w 3178
Pentagram 1 w 3187
See 1 w 3190
Pythagoras 2 w 3200
in 68 w 3202
Notes 1 w 3207
that 12 w 3213
interlaced 1 w 3223
triple 1 w 3229
triangle 1 w 3237
which 7 w 3242
served 1 w 3248
them 1 w 3252
as 26 w 3254
a 222 w 3255
sort 1 w 3259
of 26 w 3261
password 1 w 3269
they 4 w 3274
called 1 w 3280
by 2 w 3282
the 53 w 3285
name 1 w 3289
Health 3 w 3295
They 2 w 3300
argued 1 w 3306
that 13 w 3310
Health 4 w 3316
included 1 w 3324
Joy 12 w 3327
and 15 w 3330
Prosperity 4 w 3340
but 6 w 3344
that 14 w 3348
neither 2 w 3355
of 27 w 3357
those 1 w 3362
two 1 w 3365
was 8 w 3368
coextensive 1 w 3379
with 12 w 3383
Health 5 w 3389
Some 1 w 3394
of 28 w 3396
them 2 w 3400
gave 2 w 3404
to 36 w 3406
the 56 w 3409
Quaternion 1 w 3419
See 2 w 3422
Pythagoras 3 w 3432
in 71 w 3434
Notes 2 w 3439
which 8 w 3446
is 32 w 3448
their 2 w 3453
most 2 w 3457
solemn 1 w 3463
oath 1 w 3467
and 16 w 3471
sums 1 w 3475
their 3 w 3480
perfect 1 w 3487
number 1 w 3493
the 59 w 3497
name 2 w 3501
of 29 w 3503
Beginning 1 w 3512
of 30 w 3514
Health 6 w 3520
Philolaus 1 w 3530
might 1 w 3535
be 10 w 3537
quoted 1 w 3543