Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Way To Write History

The Way To Write History (36-40)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg053.perseus-eng4:36-40
Refs {'start': {'reference': '36', 'human_reference': 'None 36'}, 'end': {'reference': '40', 'human_reference': 'None 40'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

I do not suppose you will object that the man with insight has no need of system and instruction upon the things he is ignorant of; in that case he might have played the harp or flute untaught, and in fact have been omniscient. But, as things are at present, he cannot perform in these ways untaught, though with some assistance he will learn very easily, and soon be able to get along by himself.

You now know what sort of a pupil I (like the trainer) insist upon, He must not be weak either at understanding or at making himself understood, but a man of penetration, a capable administratorpotentially, that is,—with a soldierly spirit (which does not however exclude the civil spirit), and some military experience; at the least he must have been in camp, seen troops drilled or manceuvred, know a little about weapons and military engines, the differences between line and column, cavalry and infantry tactics (with the reasons for them), frontal and flank attacks; in a word, none of your armchair strategists relying wholly on hearsay.

But first and foremost, let him be a man of independent spirit, with nothing to fear or hope from anybody; else he will be a corrupt judge open to undue influences. If Philips eye is knocked out at Olynthus by Aster the Amphipolite archer, it is not his business to exclaim, but just to show him as he is;

v.2.p.128
he is not to think whether Alexander will be annoyed by a circumstantial account of the cruel murder of Clitus at table. If a Cleon has the ear of the assembly, and a monopoly of the tribune, he will not shrink on that account from describing him as a pestilent madman; all Athens will not stop him from dwelling on the Sicilian disaster, the capture of Demosthenes, the death of Nicias, the thirst, the foul water, and the shooting down of the drinkers. He will consider very rightly that no man of sense will blame him for recounting the effects of misfortune or folly in their entirety; he is not the author, but only the reporter of them. If a fleet is destroyed, it is not he who sinks it; if there is a rout, he is not in pursuitunless perhaps he ought to have prayed for better things, and omitted to do so. Of course, if silence or contradiction would have put matters right, Thucydides might with a stroke of the pen have knocked down the counterwall on Epipolae, sent Hermocratess trireme to the bottom, let daylight through the accursed Gylippus before he had done blocking the roads with wall and trench, and, finally, have cast the Syracusans into their own quarries and sent the Athenians cruising round Sicily and Italy with Alcibiadess first high hopes still on board. Alas, not Fate itself may undo the work of Fate.

The historians one task is to tell the thing as it happened.

This he cannot do, if he is Artaxerxess physician[*], trembling before him, or hoping to get a purple cloak, a golden chain, a horse of the Nisaean breed, in payment for his laudations. A fair historian, a Xenophon, a Thucydides, will not accept that position. He may nurse some private dislikes, but he will attach far more importance to the public good, and set the truth high above his hate; he may have his favourites, but he will not spare their errors. For history, I say again, has this and this only for its own; if a man will start upon it, he must

v.2.p.129
sacrifice to no God but Truth; he must neglect all else; his sole rule and unerring guide is thisto think not of those who are listening to him now, but of the yet unborn who shall seek his converse.

Any one who is intent only upon the immediate effect may reasonably be classed among the flatterers; and History has long ago realized that flattery is as little congenial to her as the arts of personal adornment to an athletes training. An anecdote of Alexander is to the point. Ah, Onesicritus,’ said he, how I should like to come to life again for a little while, and see how your stuff strikes people by that time; at present they have good enough reason to praise and welcome it; that is their way of angling for a share of my favour.’ On the same principle some people actually accept Homers history of Achilles, full of exaggerations as it is; the one great guarantee which they recognize of his truth is the fact that his subject was not living; that leaves him no motive for lying.

I 1 w 1
do 1 w 3
not 1 w 6
suppose 1 w 13
you 1 w 16
will 1 w 20
object 1 w 26
that 1 w 30
the 1 w 33
man 1 w 36
with 1 w 40
insight 1 w 47
has 1 w 50
no 2 w 52
need 1 w 56
of 1 w 58
system 1 w 64
and 1 w 67
instruction 1 w 78
upon 1 w 82
the 2 w 85
things 1 w 91
he 3 w 93
is 1 w 95
ignorant 1 w 103
of 2 w 105
in 4 w 108
that 2 w 112
case 1 w 116
he 4 w 118
might 1 w 123
have 1 w 127
played 1 w 133
the 3 w 136
harp 1 w 140
or 2 w 142
flute 1 w 147
untaught 1 w 155
and 2 w 159
in 5 w 161
fact 1 w 165
have 2 w 169
been 1 w 173
omniscient 1 w 183
But 1 w 187
as 3 w 190
things 2 w 196
are 1 w 199
at 3 w 201
present 1 w 208
he 6 w 211
cannot 1 w 217
perform 1 w 224
in 7 w 226
these 1 w 231
ways 1 w 235
untaught 2 w 243
though 1 w 250
with 2 w 254
some 1 w 258
assistance 1 w 268
he 8 w 270
will 2 w 274
learn 1 w 279
very 1 w 283
easily 1 w 289
and 3 w 293
soon 1 w 297
be 2 w 299
able 1 w 303
to 1 w 305
get 1 w 308
along 1 w 313
by 1 w 315
himself 1 w 322
You 1 w 326
now 1 w 329
know 1 w 333
what 1 w 337
sort 1 w 341
of 3 w 343
a 29 w 344
pupil 1 w 349
I 2 w 350
like 1 w 355
the 5 w 358
trainer 1 w 365
insist 1 w 372
upon 2 w 376
He 1 w 379
must 1 w 383
not 3 w 386
be 3 w 388
weak 1 w 392
either 1 w 398
at 5 w 400
understanding 1 w 413
or 5 w 415
at 6 w 417
making 1 w 423
himself 2 w 430
understood 1 w 440
but 1 w 444
a 36 w 445
man 2 w 448
of 4 w 450
penetration 1 w 461
a 39 w 463
capable 1 w 470
administrator 1 w 483
potentially 1 w 495
that 3 w 500
is 6 w 502
with 3 w 508
a 46 w 509
soldierly 1 w 518
spirit 1 w 524
which 1 w 530
does 1 w 534
not 4 w 537
however 1 w 544
exclude 1 w 551
the 7 w 554
civil 1 w 559
spirit 2 w 565
and 5 w 570
some 2 w 574
military 1 w 582
experience 1 w 592
at 10 w 595
the 8 w 598
least 1 w 603
he 13 w 605
must 2 w 609
have 3 w 613
been 2 w 617
in 13 w 619
camp 1 w 623
seen 1 w 628
troops 1 w 634
drilled 1 w 641
or 7 w 643
manceuvred 1 w 653
know 2 w 658
a 54 w 659
little 1 w 665
about 1 w 670
weapons 1 w 677
and 6 w 680
military 2 w 688
engines 1 w 695
the 9 w 699
differences 1 w 710
between 1 w 717
line 1 w 721
and 7 w 724
column 1 w 730
cavalry 1 w 738
and 8 w 741
infantry 1 w 749
tactics 1 w 756
with 4 w 761
the 10 w 764
reasons 1 w 771
for 2 w 774
them 1 w 778
frontal 1 w 787
and 9 w 790
flank 1 w 795
attacks 1 w 802
in 17 w 805
a 71 w 806
word 1 w 810
none 1 w 815
of 5 w 817
your 1 w 821
armchair 1 w 829
strategists 1 w 840
relying 1 w 847
wholly 1 w 853
on 11 w 855
hearsay 1 w 862
But 2 w 866
first 1 w 871
and 10 w 874
foremost 1 w 882
let 1 w 886
him 3 w 889
be 6 w 891
a 78 w 892
man 4 w 895
of 6 w 897
independent 1 w 908
spirit 3 w 914
with 5 w 919
nothing 1 w 926
to 4 w 928
fear 1 w 932
or 11 w 934
hope 1 w 938
from 1 w 942
anybody 1 w 949
else 1 w 954
he 18 w 956
will 3 w 960
be 7 w 962
a 82 w 963
corrupt 1 w 970
judge 1 w 975
open 1 w 979
to 5 w 981
undue 1 w 986
influences 1 w 996
If 1 w 999
Philip 1 w 1005
s 58 w 1007
eye 1 w 1010
is 8 w 1012
knocked 1 w 1019
out 2 w 1022
at 13 w 1024
Olynthus 1 w 1032
by 2 w 1034
Aster 1 w 1039
the 12 w 1042
Amphipolite 1 w 1053
archer 1 w 1059
it 14 w 1062
is 9 w 1064
not 6 w 1067
his 1 w 1070
business 1 w 1078
to 6 w 1080
exclaim 1 w 1087
but 2 w 1091
just 1 w 1095
to 7 w 1097
show 1 w 1101
him 4 w 1104
as 8 w 1106
he 21 w 1108
is 11 w 1110
he 22 w 1113
is 12 w 1115
not 7 w 1118
to 8 w 1120
think 1 w 1125
whether 1 w 1132
Alexander 1 w 1141
will 4 w 1145
be 8 w 1147
annoyed 1 w 1154
by 3 w 1156
a 89 w 1157
circumstantial 1 w 1171
account 1 w 1178
of 7 w 1180
the 14 w 1183
cruel 1 w 1188
murder 1 w 1194
of 8 w 1196
Clitus 1 w 1202
at 14 w 1204
table 1 w 1209
If 2 w 1212
a 95 w 1213
Cleon 1 w 1218
has 2 w 1221
the 15 w 1224
ear 4 w 1227
of 9 w 1229
the 16 w 1232
assembly 1 w 1240
and 12 w 1244
a 100 w 1245
monopoly 1 w 1253
of 10 w 1255
the 17 w 1258
tribune 1 w 1265
he 29 w 1268
will 5 w 1272
not 8 w 1275
shrink 1 w 1281
on 14 w 1283
that 4 w 1287
account 2 w 1294
from 2 w 1298
describing 1 w 1308
him 5 w 1311
as 11 w 1313
a 104 w 1314
pestilent 1 w 1323
madman 1 w 1329
all 2 w 1333
Athens 1 w 1339
will 6 w 1343
not 9 w 1346
stop 1 w 1350
him 6 w 1353
from 3 w 1357
dwelling 1 w 1365
on 15 w 1367
the 19 w 1370
Sicilian 1 w 1378
disaster 1 w 1386
the 20 w 1390
capture 1 w 1397
of 11 w 1399
Demosthenes 1 w 1410
the 22 w 1414
death 1 w 1419
of 12 w 1421
Nicias 1 w 1427
the 23 w 1431
thirst 1 w 1437
the 24 w 1441
foul 1 w 1445
water 1 w 1450
and 13 w 1454
the 25 w 1457
shooting 1 w 1465
down 1 w 1469
of 13 w 1471
the 26 w 1474
drinkers 1 w 1482
He 2 w 1485
will 7 w 1489
consider 1 w 1497
very 2 w 1501
rightly 1 w 1508
that 5 w 1512
no 19 w 1514
man 6 w 1517
of 14 w 1519
sense 1 w 1524
will 8 w 1528
blame 1 w 1533
him 7 w 1536
for 4 w 1539
recounting 1 w 1549
the 27 w 1552
effects 1 w 1559
of 15 w 1561
misfortune 1 w 1571
or 15 w 1573
folly 1 w 1578
in 30 w 1580
their 1 w 1585
entirety 1 w 1593
he 41 w 1596
is 15 w 1598
not 10 w 1601
the 29 w 1604
author 1 w 1610
but 3 w 1614
only 1 w 1618
the 30 w 1621
reporter 1 w 1629
of 16 w 1631
them 2 w 1635
If 3 w 1638
a 119 w 1639
fleet 1 w 1644
is 16 w 1646
destroyed 1 w 1655
it 16 w 1658
is 17 w 1660
not 11 w 1663
he 45 w 1665
who 2 w 1668
sinks 1 w 1673
it 17 w 1675
if 2 w 1678
there 1 w 1683
is 18 w 1685
a 120 w 1686
rout 1 w 1690
he 47 w 1693
is 19 w 1695
not 12 w 1698
in 32 w 1700
pursuit 1 w 1707
unless 1 w 1714
perhaps 1 w 1721
he 48 w 1723
ought 1 w 1728
to 10 w 1730
have 4 w 1734
prayed 1 w 1740
for 6 w 1743
better 1 w 1749
things 3 w 1755
and 14 w 1759
omitted 1 w 1766
to 11 w 1768
do 4 w 1770
so 7 w 1772
Of 1 w 1775
course 1 w 1781
if 3 w 1784
silence 1 w 1791
or 19 w 1793
contradiction 1 w 1806
would 1 w 1811
have 5 w 1815
put 1 w 1818
matters 1 w 1825
right 2 w 1830
Thucydides 1 w 1841
might 2 w 1846
with 6 w 1850
a 128 w 1851
stroke 1 w 1857
of 17 w 1859
the 33 w 1862
pen 4 w 1865
have 6 w 1869
knocked 2 w 1876
down 2 w 1880
the 34 w 1883
counterwall 1 w 1894
on 20 w 1896
Epipolae 1 w 1904
sent 2 w 1909
Hermocrates 1 w 1920
s 117 w 1922
trireme 1 w 1929
to 12 w 1931
the 35 w 1934
bottom 1 w 1940
let 2 w 1944
daylight 1 w 1952
through 1 w 1959
the 36 w 1962
accursed 1 w 1970
Gylippus 1 w 1978
before 1 w 1984
he 53 w 1986
had 1 w 1989
done 1 w 1993
blocking 1 w 2001
the 37 w 2004
roads 1 w 2009
with 7 w 2013
wall 2 w 2017
and 15 w 2020
trench 1 w 2026
and 16 w 2030
finally 1 w 2038
have 7 w 2043
cast 1 w 2047
the 38 w 2050
Syracusans 1 w 2060
into 1 w 2064
their 2 w 2069
own 3 w 2072
quarries 1 w 2080
and 17 w 2083
sent 3 w 2087
the 40 w 2090
Athenians 1 w 2099
cruising 1 w 2107
round 1 w 2112
Sicily 1 w 2118
and 18 w 2121
Italy 1 w 2126
with 8 w 2130
Alcibiades 1 w 2140
s 129 w 2142
first 2 w 2147
high 1 w 2151
hopes 1 w 2156
still 1 w 2161
on 22 w 2163
board 1 w 2168
Alas 1 w 2173
not 13 w 2177
Fate 1 w 2181
itself 1 w 2187
may 1 w 2190
undo 1 w 2194
the 42 w 2197
work 1 w 2201
of 18 w 2203
Fate 2 w 2207
The 1 w 2211
historian 1 w 2220
s 136 w 2222
one 3 w 2225
task 1 w 2229
is 22 w 2231
to 16 w 2233
tell 1 w 2237
the 43 w 2240
thing 5 w 2245
as 17 w 2247
it 24 w 2249
happened 1 w 2257
This 1 w 2262
he 62 w 2264
cannot 2 w 2270
do 8 w 2272
if 4 w 2275
he 63 w 2277
is 24 w 2279
Artaxerxes 1 w 2289
s 143 w 2291
physician 1 w 2300
See 1 w 2303
Ctesias 1 w 2310
in 39 w 2312
Notes 1 w 2317
trembling 1 w 2328
before 2 w 2334
him 8 w 2337
or 24 w 2340
hoping 1 w 2346
to 17 w 2348
get 2 w 2351
a 164 w 2352
purple 1 w 2358
cloak 1 w 2363
a 166 w 2365
golden 1 w 2371
chain 1 w 2376
a 168 w 2378
horse 1 w 2383
of 19 w 2385
the 44 w 2388
Nisaean 1 w 2395
breed 1 w 2400
in 43 w 2403
payment 1 w 2410
for 9 w 2413
his 4 w 2416
laudations 1 w 2426
A 9 w 2428
fair 1 w 2432
historian 2 w 2441
a 176 w 2443
Xenophon 1 w 2451
a 177 w 2453
Thucydides 2 w 2463
will 9 w 2468
not 15 w 2471
accept 1 w 2477
that 6 w 2481
position 1 w 2489
He 4 w 2492
may 2 w 2495
nurse 1 w 2500
some 3 w 2504
private 1 w 2511
dislikes 1 w 2519
but 4 w 2523
he 65 w 2525
will 10 w 2529
attach 1 w 2535
far 1 w 2538
more 1 w 2542
importance 1 w 2552
to 19 w 2554
the 45 w 2557
public 1 w 2563
good 1 w 2567
and 19 w 2571
set 1 w 2574
the 46 w 2577
truth 1 w 2582
high 2 w 2586
above 1 w 2591
his 6 w 2594
hate 1 w 2598
he 68 w 2601
may 3 w 2604
have 8 w 2608
his 7 w 2611
favourites 1 w 2621
but 5 w 2625
he 69 w 2627
will 11 w 2631
not 16 w 2634
spare 1 w 2639
their 3 w 2644
errors 1 w 2650
For 1 w 2654
history 1 w 2661
I 7 w 2663
say 2 w 2666
again 1 w 2671
has 3 w 2675
this 1 w 2679
and 20 w 2682
this 2 w 2686
only 2 w 2690
for 10 w 2693
its 2 w 2696
own 4 w 2699
if 5 w 2702
a 198 w 2703
man 7 w 2706
will 12 w 2710
start 1 w 2715
upon 3 w 2719
it 28 w 2721
he 71 w 2724
must 3 w 2728
sacrifice 1 w 2737
to 21 w 2739
no 29 w 2741
God 1 w 2744
but 6 w 2747
Truth 1 w 2752
he 72 w 2755
must 4 w 2759
neglect 1 w 2766
all 6 w 2769
else 2 w 2773
his 11 w 2777
sole 1 w 2781
rule 1 w 2785
and 21 w 2788
unerring 1 w 2796
guide 1 w 2801
is 35 w 2803
this 3 w 2807
to 22 w 2810
think 2 w 2815
not 17 w 2818
of 20 w 2820
those 1 w 2825
who 3 w 2828
are 3 w 2831
listening 1 w 2840
to 23 w 2842
him 9 w 2845
now 4 w 2848
but 7 w 2852
of 21 w 2854
the 48 w 2857
yet 1 w 2860
unborn 1 w 2866
who 4 w 2869
shall 1 w 2874
seek 1 w 2878
his 13 w 2881
converse 1 w 2889
Any 1 w 2893
one 4 w 2896
who 5 w 2899
is 39 w 2901
intent 1 w 2907
only 3 w 2911
upon 4 w 2915
the 49 w 2918
immediate 1 w 2927
effect 2 w 2933
may 4 w 2936
reasonably 1 w 2946
be 12 w 2948
classed 1 w 2955
among 1 w 2960
the 50 w 2963
flatterers 1 w 2973
and 22 w 2977
History 1 w 2984
has 4 w 2987
long 2 w 2991
ago 1 w 2994
realized 1 w 3002
that 7 w 3006
flattery 1 w 3014
is 41 w 3016
as 23 w 3018
little 2 w 3024
congenial 1 w 3033
to 25 w 3035
her 5 w 3038
as 24 w 3040
the 51 w 3043
arts 1 w 3047
of 22 w 3049
personal 1 w 3057
adornment 1 w 3066
to 26 w 3068
an 47 w 3070
athlete 1 w 3077
s 198 w 3079
training 1 w 3087
An 2 w 3090
anecdote 1 w 3098
of 23 w 3100
Alexander 2 w 3109
is 42 w 3111
to 27 w 3113
the 52 w 3116
point 1 w 3121
Ah 1 w 3125
Onesicritus 1 w 3137
said 1 w 3143
he 79 w 3145
how 3 w 3149
I 8 w 3150
should 1 w 3156
like 3 w 3160
to 28 w 3162
come 1 w 3166
to 29 w 3168
life 1 w 3172
again 2 w 3177
for 11 w 3180
a 233 w 3181
little 3 w 3187
while 1 w 3192
and 24 w 3196
see 3 w 3199
how 4 w 3202
your 2 w 3206
stuff 1 w 3211
strikes 1 w 3218
people 1 w 3224
by 4 w 3226
that 8 w 3230
time 1 w 3234
at 34 w 3237
present 2 w 3244
they 1 w 3248
have 9 w 3252
good 2 w 3256
enough 1 w 3262
reason 3 w 3268
to 30 w 3270
praise 1 w 3276
and 25 w 3279
welcome 1 w 3286
it 32 w 3288
that 9 w 3293
is 44 w 3295
their 4 w 3300
way 2 w 3303
of 24 w 3305
angling 1 w 3312
for 12 w 3315
a 244 w 3316
share 1 w 3321
of 25 w 3323
my 1 w 3325
favour 2 w 3331
On 2 w 3335
the 55 w 3338
same 1 w 3342
principle 1 w 3351
some 4 w 3355
people 2 w 3361
actually 1 w 3369
accept 2 w 3375
Homer 1 w 3380
s 215 w 3382
history 2 w 3389
of 26 w 3391
Achilles 1 w 3399
full 1 w 3404
of 27 w 3406
exaggerations 1 w 3419
as 26 w 3421
it 33 w 3423
is 46 w 3425
the 56 w 3429
one 5 w 3432
great 1 w 3437
guarantee 1 w 3446
which 2 w 3451
they 2 w 3455
recognize 1 w 3464
of 28 w 3466
his 15 w 3469
truth 2 w 3474
is 48 w 3476
the 58 w 3479
fact 2 w 3483
that 10 w 3487
his 16 w 3490
subject 1 w 3497
was 1 w 3500
not 18 w 3503
living 1 w 3509
that 11 w 3514
leaves 1 w 3520
him 10 w 3523
no 34 w 3525
motive 1 w 3531
for 13 w 3534
lying 2 w 3539