Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / How to write history

How to write history (31-33)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg053.perseus-eng3:31-33
Refs {'start': {'reference': '31', 'human_reference': 'Section 31'}, 'end': {'reference': '33', 'human_reference': 'Section 33'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

I have heard of one who even included the future in his history: the capture of Vologesus, the killing of Osroeshow he was going to be thrown to the lions and, to cap everything, the triumph we have longed for so much—, in such a prophetic state was he as he hastened to the end of his composition. Why he even founded a city in Mesopotamia, outstanding in size, and of unsurpassed beauty. He is still considering and taking thought, however, whether he should call it Nicaea, after the victory, or Concord or Peacetown. It is still undecided and we have no name for that beautiful city full of copious nonsense and historical drivel. He has promised to write of

v.6.p.47
future happenings in India and the circumnavigation of the outer seaand this is not just a promise; the introduction to his Indian History is already done, and the Third Legion, the Celts, and a small detachment of Moors have all crossed the River Indus with Cassius. What they are going to do and how they will receive the charge of the elephants, our wonderful historian will tell us before very long by letter from Muziris [*] or the Oxydraci.

This is the sort of nonsense they talk in floods through their lack of schooling. They neither see what is worth looking at nor, if they did see it, have they the ability to give it suitable expression. They invent and manufacture whatever comes to the tip of an unlucky tongue,” as they say, and pride themselves in the number of their books and in particular on the titles, which again are completely ridiculous: So-and-sos Parthian victories in so many books”; and again: Parthis I and II,” like Atthis of course. Someone else did it much more stylishlyI have read it myself—“The Parthonicica of Demetrius of Sagalassus . . . [*] not to make fun of them and pour scorn on histories so fine but with a practical end in view. For whoever avoids these faults and their like has already mastered a great part of what makes correct historical writing, or, rather, needs but little more, if logic is right when it says that to abolish one of two direct opposites is to establish the other instead.

Well now, someone will say, you have carefully cleared your ground and cut out all the thorns and

v.6.p.49
brambles, and all the debris has been carried away and all the rough places are now smooth, so now build something yourself to show you are good not only at overturning other peoples edifices but at thinking out something clever yourself which no one, not even Momus, [*] could censure.

Tokens

I 1 w 1
have 1 w 5
heard 1 w 10
of 1 w 12
one 1 w 15
who 1 w 18
even 1 w 22
included 1 w 30
the 1 w 33
future 1 w 39
in 2 w 41
his 1 w 44
history 1 w 51
the 2 w 55
capture 1 w 62
of 2 w 64
Vologesus 1 w 73
the 3 w 77
killing 1 w 84
of 3 w 86
Osroes 1 w 92
how 1 w 96
he 5 w 98
was 1 w 101
going 1 w 106
to 2 w 108
be 1 w 110
thrown 1 w 116
to 3 w 118
the 4 w 121
lions 1 w 126
and 1 w 129
to 4 w 132
cap 2 w 135
everything 1 w 145
the 5 w 149
triumph 1 w 156
we 1 w 158
have 2 w 162
longed 1 w 168
for 1 w 171
so 1 w 173
much 1 w 177
in 6 w 181
such 1 w 185
a 8 w 186
prophetic 1 w 195
state 1 w 200
was 2 w 203
he 9 w 205
as 3 w 207
he 10 w 209
hastened 1 w 217
to 5 w 219
the 6 w 222
end 1 w 225
of 4 w 227
his 3 w 230
composition 1 w 241
Why 1 w 245
he 12 w 247
even 2 w 251
founded 1 w 258
a 13 w 259
city 1 w 263
in 7 w 265
Mesopotamia 1 w 276
outstanding 1 w 288
in 9 w 290
size 1 w 294
and 3 w 298
of 5 w 300
unsurpassed 1 w 311
beauty 1 w 317
He 1 w 320
is 4 w 322
still 1 w 327
considering 1 w 338
and 4 w 341
taking 1 w 347
thought 1 w 354
however 1 w 362
whether 1 w 370
he 15 w 372
should 1 w 378
call 1 w 382
it 3 w 384
Nicaea 1 w 390
after 1 w 396
the 8 w 399
victory 1 w 406
or 4 w 409
Concord 1 w 416
or 6 w 418
Peacetown 1 w 427
It 1 w 430
is 5 w 432
still 2 w 437
undecided 1 w 446
and 5 w 449
we 3 w 451
have 3 w 455
no 1 w 457
name 1 w 461
for 2 w 464
that 1 w 468
beautiful 1 w 477
city 2 w 481
full 1 w 485
of 6 w 487
copious 1 w 494
nonsense 1 w 502
and 6 w 505
historical 1 w 515
drivel 1 w 521
He 2 w 524
has 2 w 527
promised 1 w 535
to 9 w 537
write 1 w 542
of 7 w 544
future 2 w 550
happenings 1 w 560
in 13 w 562
India 1 w 567
and 7 w 570
the 9 w 573
circumnavigation 1 w 589
of 8 w 591
the 10 w 594
outer 1 w 599
sea 1 w 602
and 8 w 606
this 1 w 610
is 9 w 612
not 1 w 615
just 1 w 619
a 42 w 620
promise 2 w 627
the 11 w 631
introduction 1 w 643
to 10 w 645
his 6 w 648
Indian 1 w 655
History 1 w 662
is 13 w 665
already 1 w 672
done 1 w 676
and 9 w 680
the 12 w 683
Third 1 w 688
Legion 1 w 694
the 13 w 698
Celts 1 w 703
and 10 w 707
a 48 w 708
small 1 w 713
detachment 1 w 723
of 9 w 725
Moors 1 w 730
have 4 w 734
all 3 w 737
crossed 1 w 744
the 14 w 747
River 1 w 752
Indus 1 w 757
with 1 w 761
Cassius 1 w 768
What 1 w 773
they 1 w 777
are 1 w 780
going 2 w 785
to 12 w 787
do 2 w 789
and 11 w 792
how 3 w 795
they 2 w 799
will 1 w 803
receive 1 w 810
the 17 w 813
charge 1 w 819
of 10 w 821
the 18 w 824
elephants 1 w 833
our 1 w 837
wonderful 1 w 846
historian 1 w 855
will 2 w 859
tell 1 w 863
us 6 w 865
before 1 w 871
very 2 w 875
long 2 w 879
by 1 w 881
letter 1 w 887
from 1 w 891
Muziris 1 w 898
Mangalore 1 w 907
Cranganore 1 w 918
or 15 w 922
the 19 w 925
Oxydraci 1 w 933
This 1 w 938
is 17 w 940
the 20 w 943
sort 1 w 947
of 11 w 949
nonsense 2 w 957
they 3 w 961
talk 1 w 965
in 16 w 967
floods 1 w 973
through 1 w 980
their 1 w 985
lack 1 w 989
of 12 w 991
schooling 1 w 1000
They 1 w 1005
neither 1 w 1012
see 1 w 1015
what 1 w 1019
is 18 w 1021
worth 1 w 1026
looking 1 w 1033
at 6 w 1035
nor 2 w 1038
if 2 w 1041
they 4 w 1045
did 1 w 1048
see 2 w 1051
it 8 w 1053
have 5 w 1058
they 5 w 1062
the 26 w 1065
ability 1 w 1072
to 14 w 1074
give 1 w 1078
it 10 w 1080
suitable 1 w 1088
expression 1 w 1098
They 2 w 1103
invent 1 w 1109
and 12 w 1112
manufacture 1 w 1123
whatever 1 w 1131
comes 1 w 1137
to 15 w 1139
the 27 w 1142
tip 1 w 1145
of 13 w 1147
an 20 w 1149
unlucky 1 w 1156
tongue 1 w 1162
as 8 w 1166
they 6 w 1170
say 1 w 1173
and 13 w 1177
pride 1 w 1182
themselves 1 w 1192
in 20 w 1194
the 30 w 1197
number 1 w 1203
of 14 w 1205
their 2 w 1210
books 1 w 1215
and 14 w 1218
in 21 w 1220
particular 1 w 1230
on 17 w 1232
the 32 w 1235
titles 1 w 1241
which 1 w 1247
again 1 w 1252
are 2 w 1255
completely 1 w 1265
ridiculous 1 w 1275
So-and-so 1 w 1286
s 79 w 1288
Parthian 1 w 1296
victories 1 w 1305
in 23 w 1307
so 5 w 1309
many 1 w 1313
books 2 w 1318
and 16 w 1323
again 2 w 1328
Parthis 1 w 1337
I 6 w 1338
and 17 w 1341
II 1 w 1343
like 1 w 1349
Atthis 1 w 1356
of 15 w 1359
course 1 w 1365
Someone 1 w 1373
else 1 w 1377
did 2 w 1380
it 13 w 1382
much 2 w 1386
more 1 w 1390
stylishly 1 w 1399
I 9 w 1401
have 6 w 1405
read 2 w 1409
it 14 w 1411
myself 1 w 1417
The 3 w 1422
Parthonicica 1 w 1434
of 16 w 1436
Demetrius 1 w 1445
of 17 w 1447
Sagalassus 1 w 1457
There 1 w 1466
is 22 w 1468
a 102 w 1469
gap 1 w 1472
in 25 w 1474
the 33 w 1477
MSS 1 w 1480
here 2 w 1484
not 2 w 1488
to 18 w 1490
make 1 w 1494
fun 1 w 1497
of 18 w 1499
them 2 w 1503
and 18 w 1506
pour 1 w 1510
scorn 1 w 1515
on 20 w 1517
histories 1 w 1526
so 6 w 1528
fine 1 w 1532
but 1 w 1535
with 2 w 1539
a 106 w 1540
practical 1 w 1549
end 2 w 1552
in 27 w 1554
view 1 w 1558
For 1 w 1562
whoever 1 w 1569
avoids 1 w 1575
these 1 w 1580
faults 1 w 1586
and 19 w 1589
their 3 w 1594
like 2 w 1598
has 3 w 1601
already 2 w 1608
mastered 1 w 1616
a 116 w 1617
great 1 w 1622
part 2 w 1626
of 19 w 1628
what 3 w 1632
makes 1 w 1637
correct 1 w 1644
historical 2 w 1654
writing 1 w 1661
or 26 w 1664
rather 1 w 1671
needs 1 w 1677
but 2 w 1680
little 1 w 1686
more 2 w 1690
if 3 w 1693
logic 1 w 1698
is 25 w 1700
right 1 w 1705
when 1 w 1709
it 18 w 1711
says 1 w 1715
that 2 w 1719
to 21 w 1721
abolish 1 w 1728
one 4 w 1731
of 20 w 1733
two 1 w 1736
direct 1 w 1742
opposites 1 w 1751
is 27 w 1753
to 22 w 1755
establish 1 w 1764
the 38 w 1767
other 1 w 1772
instead 1 w 1779
Well 1 w 1784
now 1 w 1787
someone 1 w 1795
will 3 w 1799
say 3 w 1802
you 1 w 1806
have 7 w 1810
carefully 1 w 1819
cleared 1 w 1826
your 1 w 1830
ground 1 w 1836
and 20 w 1839
cut 1 w 1842
out 3 w 1845
all 4 w 1848
the 40 w 1851
thorns 1 w 1857
and 21 w 1860
brambles 1 w 1868
and 22 w 1872
all 5 w 1875
the 41 w 1878
debris 1 w 1884
has 4 w 1887
been 1 w 1891
carried 1 w 1898
away 1 w 1902
and 23 w 1905
all 6 w 1908
the 42 w 1911
rough 2 w 1916
places 1 w 1922
are 5 w 1925
now 2 w 1928
smooth 1 w 1934
so 8 w 1937
now 3 w 1940
build 1 w 1945
something 1 w 1954
yourself 1 w 1962
to 23 w 1964
show 1 w 1968
you 4 w 1971
are 6 w 1974
good 1 w 1978
not 3 w 1981
only 1 w 1985
at 12 w 1987
overturning 1 w 1998
other 2 w 2003
peoples 1 w 2010
edifices 1 w 2019
but 3 w 2022
at 13 w 2024
thinking 1 w 2032
out 4 w 2035
something 2 w 2044
clever 1 w 2050
yourself 2 w 2058
which 2 w 2063
no 12 w 2065
one 6 w 2068
not 4 w 2072
even 3 w 2076
Momus 1 w 2081
Momus 2 w 2087
was 3 w 2090
a 150 w 2091
literary 1 w 2099
personification 1 w 2114
of 21 w 2116
fault-finding 1 w 2129
he 58 w 2132
appears 1 w 2139
in 37 w 2141
Lucian 1 w 2147
s 138 w 2149
Zeus 1 w 2153
Rants 1 w 2158
Loeb 1 w 2163
vol 1 w 2167
ii 1 w 2170
p 32 w 2172
119 1 w 2176
could 1 w 2182
censure 1 w 2189