Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Tyrannicide

The Tyrannicide (12-13)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg051.perseus-eng4:12-13
Refs {'start': {'reference': '12', 'human_reference': 'Section 12'}, 'end': {'reference': '13', 'human_reference': 'Section 13'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Moreover, it is laid down in our laws (unless after all these years of servitude my memory plays me false) that blood-guiltiness is of two kinds. A man may slay another with his own hand, or, without slaying him, he may put death unavoidably in his way; in the latter case the penalty is the same as in the former; and rightly, it being the intention of the law that the cause should rank with the act itself; the manner in which death is brought about is not the question. You would not acquit a man who in this sense had slain another; you would punish him as a murderer: how then can you refuse to reward as a benefactor the man who, by parity of reasoning, has shown himself to be the liberator of his country?

Nor again can it be objected that all I did was to strike the blow, and that the resulting benefits were accidental, and formed no part of my design. What had I to fear, when once the stronger of our oppressors was slain? And why did I leave my sword in the wound, if not because I foresaw the very thing that would happen? Are you prepared to deny that the death so occasioned was that of a tyrant both in name and in fact, or that his death was an event for which the state would gladly pay an abundant reward? I think not. If then the tyrant is slain, how can you withhold the reward from him who occasioned his death? What scrupulousness is thisto concern yourself with the manner of his end, while you are enjoying the freedom that results from it? Democracy is restored: what more can you demand from him who restored it? You refer us to the terms of the law: well, the law looks only at the end; of the means it says nothing; it has no concern with them. Has not

v.2.p.179
the reward of tyfannicide been paid before now to him who merely expelled a tyrant? And rightly so: for he too has made free men of slaves. But I have done more: banishment may be followed by restitution: but here the family of tyrants is utterly annihilated and destroyed; the evil thing is exterminated, root and branch.

Tokens

Moreover 1 w 8
it 1 w 11
is 1 w 13
laid 1 w 17
down 1 w 21
in 1 w 23
our 1 w 26
laws 1 w 30
unless 1 w 37
after 1 w 42
all 1 w 45
these 1 w 50
years 1 w 55
of 1 w 57
servitude 1 w 66
my 1 w 68
memory 1 w 74
plays 1 w 79
me 2 w 81
false 1 w 86
that 1 w 91
blood-guiltiness 1 w 107
is 2 w 109
of 2 w 111
two 1 w 114
kinds 1 w 119
A 1 w 121
man 1 w 124
may 1 w 127
slay 1 w 131
another 1 w 138
with 1 w 142
his 1 w 145
own 2 w 148
hand 1 w 152
or 3 w 155
without 1 w 163
slaying 1 w 170
him 1 w 173
he 3 w 176
may 2 w 179
put 1 w 182
death 1 w 187
unavoidably 1 w 198
in 5 w 200
his 2 w 203
way 1 w 206
in 6 w 209
the 3 w 212
latter 1 w 218
case 1 w 222
the 4 w 225
penalty 1 w 232
is 5 w 234
the 5 w 237
same 1 w 241
as 2 w 243
in 7 w 245
the 6 w 248
former 1 w 254
and 2 w 258
rightly 1 w 265
it 5 w 268
being 1 w 273
the 7 w 276
intention 1 w 285
of 3 w 287
the 8 w 290
law 2 w 293
that 2 w 297
the 9 w 300
cause 1 w 305
should 1 w 311
rank 1 w 315
with 3 w 319
the 10 w 322
act 1 w 325
itself 1 w 331
the 11 w 335
manner 1 w 341
in 10 w 343
which 1 w 348
death 2 w 353
is 6 w 355
brought 1 w 362
about 1 w 367
is 7 w 369
not 2 w 372
the 12 w 375
question 1 w 383
You 1 w 387
would 1 w 392
not 3 w 395
acquit 1 w 401
a 35 w 402
man 3 w 405
who 1 w 408
in 11 w 410
this 1 w 414
sense 1 w 419
had 1 w 422
slain 1 w 427
another 2 w 434
you 1 w 438
would 2 w 443
punish 1 w 449
him 2 w 452
as 3 w 454
a 41 w 455
murderer 1 w 463
how 1 w 467
then 1 w 471
can 1 w 474
you 2 w 477
refuse 1 w 483
to 1 w 485
reward 1 w 491
as 4 w 493
a 45 w 494
benefactor 1 w 504
the 15 w 507
man 4 w 510
who 2 w 513
by 1 w 516
parity 1 w 522
of 4 w 524
reasoning 1 w 533
has 1 w 537
shown 1 w 542
himself 1 w 549
to 3 w 551
be 3 w 553
the 16 w 556
liberator 1 w 565
of 5 w 567
his 4 w 570
country 1 w 577
Nor 1 w 581
again 1 w 586
can 2 w 589
it 10 w 591
be 5 w 593
objected 1 w 601
that 3 w 605
all 2 w 608
I 1 w 609
did 1 w 612
was 1 w 615
to 5 w 617
strike 1 w 623
the 17 w 626
blow 1 w 630
and 3 w 634
that 4 w 638
the 18 w 641
resulting 1 w 650
benefits 1 w 658
were 1 w 662
accidental 1 w 672
and 4 w 676
formed 1 w 682
no 5 w 684
part 1 w 688
of 6 w 690
my 2 w 692
design 1 w 698
What 1 w 703
had 2 w 706
I 2 w 707
to 6 w 709
fear 1 w 713
when 1 w 718
once 1 w 722
the 19 w 725
stronger 1 w 733
of 7 w 735
our 2 w 738
oppressors 1 w 748
was 2 w 751
slain 2 w 756
And 1 w 760
why 1 w 763
did 2 w 766
I 3 w 767
leave 1 w 772
my 3 w 774
sword 1 w 779
in 17 w 781
the 20 w 784
wound 1 w 789
if 1 w 792
not 5 w 795
because 1 w 802
I 4 w 803
foresaw 1 w 810
the 21 w 813
very 1 w 817
thing 1 w 822
that 5 w 826
would 3 w 831
happen 1 w 837
Are 1 w 841
you 3 w 844
prepared 1 w 852
to 7 w 854
deny 1 w 858
that 6 w 862
the 22 w 865
death 3 w 870
so 3 w 872
occasioned 1 w 882
was 3 w 885
that 7 w 889
of 8 w 891
a 80 w 892
tyrant 1 w 898
both 1 w 902
in 19 w 904
name 1 w 908
and 5 w 911
in 20 w 913
fact 2 w 917
or 12 w 920
that 8 w 924
his 5 w 927
death 4 w 932
was 4 w 935
an 16 w 937
event 1 w 942
for 4 w 945
which 2 w 950
the 23 w 953
state 1 w 958
would 4 w 963
gladly 1 w 969
pay 1 w 972
an 17 w 974
abundant 1 w 982
reward 2 w 988
I 5 w 990
think 1 w 995
not 6 w 998
If 1 w 1001
then 2 w 1005
the 25 w 1008
tyrant 2 w 1014
is 12 w 1016
slain 3 w 1021
how 3 w 1025
can 3 w 1028
you 4 w 1031
withhold 1 w 1039
the 26 w 1042
reward 3 w 1048
from 1 w 1052
him 4 w 1055
who 3 w 1058
occasioned 2 w 1068
his 6 w 1071
death 5 w 1076
What 2 w 1081
scrupulousness 1 w 1095
is 14 w 1097
this 2 w 1101
to 8 w 1104
concern 1 w 1111
yourself 1 w 1119
with 5 w 1123
the 27 w 1126
manner 2 w 1132
of 9 w 1134
his 8 w 1137
end 1 w 1140
while 1 w 1146
you 6 w 1149
are 2 w 1152
enjoying 1 w 1160
the 28 w 1163
freedom 1 w 1170
that 9 w 1174
results 1 w 1181
from 2 w 1185
it 14 w 1187
Democracy 1 w 1197
is 17 w 1199
restored 1 w 1207
what 1 w 1212
more 1 w 1216
can 4 w 1219
you 7 w 1222
demand 1 w 1228
from 3 w 1232
him 5 w 1235
who 4 w 1238
restored 2 w 1246
it 15 w 1248
You 2 w 1252
refer 1 w 1257
us 5 w 1259
to 11 w 1261
the 29 w 1264
terms 1 w 1269
of 10 w 1271
the 30 w 1274
law 3 w 1277
well 1 w 1282
the 31 w 1286
law 4 w 1289
looks 1 w 1294
only 1 w 1298
at 21 w 1300
the 32 w 1303
end 2 w 1306
of 11 w 1309
the 33 w 1312
means 1 w 1317
it 16 w 1319
says 1 w 1323
nothing 1 w 1330
it 17 w 1333
has 2 w 1336
no 9 w 1338
concern 2 w 1345
with 6 w 1349
them 1 w 1353
Has 1 w 1357
not 8 w 1360
the 35 w 1363
reward 4 w 1369
of 12 w 1371
tyfannicide 1 w 1382
been 1 w 1386
paid 1 w 1390
before 1 w 1396
now 1 w 1399
to 12 w 1401
him 6 w 1404
who 5 w 1407
merely 1 w 1413
expelled 1 w 1421
a 120 w 1422
tyrant 3 w 1428
And 2 w 1432
rightly 2 w 1439
so 4 w 1441
for 6 w 1445
he 38 w 1447
too 1 w 1450
has 3 w 1453
made 1 w 1457
free 2 w 1461
men 1 w 1464
of 13 w 1466
slaves 1 w 1472
But 1 w 1476
I 7 w 1477
have 1 w 1481
done 1 w 1485
more 2 w 1489
banishment 1 w 1500
may 3 w 1503
be 10 w 1505
followed 1 w 1513
by 2 w 1515
restitution 1 w 1526
but 1 w 1530
here 1 w 1534
the 36 w 1537
family 1 w 1543
of 14 w 1545
tyrants 1 w 1552
is 19 w 1554
utterly 1 w 1561
annihilated 1 w 1572
and 7 w 1575
destroyed 1 w 1584
the 37 w 1588
evil 1 w 1592
thing 3 w 1597
is 20 w 1599
exterminated 1 w 1611
root 1 w 1616
and 8 w 1619
branch 1 w 1625