Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Mistaken Critic, or a Discourse on the Word

The Mistaken Critic, or a Discourse on the Word (11-12)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg049.perseus-eng2:11-12
Refs {'start': {'reference': '11', 'human_reference': 'Section 11'}, 'end': {'reference': '12', 'human_reference': 'Section 12'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

But no! not yet. First about that nefandous.’

Tell me, in the name of Aphrodite Pandemus and the Genetyllides[*] and Cybebe, in what respect did you think the word nefandous objectionable and fit to be laughed at? Oh, because it did not belong to the Greeks, but had somehow thrust its way in among them from their intercourse with Celts or Thracians or Scyths; wherefore youfor you know everything that pertains to the Atheniansexcluded it at once and banished it from the Greek world, and your laughter was because I committed a barbarism and used a foreign idiom and went beyond the Attic bounds!

Come now, what else is as well established on Athenian soil as that word?” people would say who are better informed than you about such matters. It would be easier for you to prove Erechtheus and Cecrops foreigners and invaders of Attica, than to show that nefandous is not at home and indigenous in Attica. There are many things which they designate in the same way as everybody else, but they, and they alone, designate as nefandous a day which is vile, abominable, inauspicious, useless, and like you.

There now! I have already taught you in passing what they mean by nefandous!

v.5.p.389

When official business is not transacted, introduction of lawsuits is not permissible, sacrifice of victims is not performed, and, in general, nothing is done that requires good omens, that day is nefandous.

Tokens

But 1 w 3
no 1 w 5
not 1 w 9
yet 1 w 12
First 1 w 18
about 1 w 23
that 1 w 27
nefandous 1 w 37
Tell 1 w 43
me 1 w 45
in 1 w 48
the 1 w 51
name 1 w 55
of 1 w 57
Aphrodite 1 w 66
Pandemus 1 w 74
and 3 w 77
the 2 w 80
Genetyllides 1 w 92
Genetyllis 1 w 102
was 1 w 105
originally 1 w 115
a 9 w 116
goddess 1 w 123
of 2 w 125
childbirth 1 w 135
Hesychius 1 w 145
says 1 w 149
that 2 w 153
she 1 w 156
resembled 1 w 165
Hecate 1 w 171
received 1 w 180
sacrifices 1 w 190
of 3 w 192
dogs 1 w 196
and 4 w 200
was 2 w 203
of 4 w 205
foreign 1 w 212
origin 2 w 218
But 2 w 222
in 4 w 224
Attica 1 w 230
where 1 w 236
she 2 w 239
was 3 w 242
worshipped 1 w 252
in 5 w 254
the 3 w 257
temple 1 w 263
of 5 w 265
another 1 w 272
similar 1 w 279
divinity 1 w 287
Colias 1 w 294
the 5 w 298
identities 1 w 308
of 6 w 310
the 6 w 313
two 1 w 316
were 1 w 320
apparently 1 w 330
so 1 w 332
thoroughly 1 w 342
merged 1 w 348
that 3 w 352
they 1 w 356
could 1 w 361
both 1 w 365
be 1 w 367
called 1 w 373
either 1 w 379
Genetyllides 2 w 391
or 6 w 393
Coliades 1 w 401
and 5 w 405
both 2 w 409
were 2 w 413
more 1 w 417
or 8 w 419
less 1 w 423
blended 1 w 430
with 1 w 434
Aphrodite 2 w 443
and 6 w 447
Cybebe 1 w 453
in 7 w 456
what 1 w 460
respect 1 w 467
did 1 w 470
you 1 w 473
think 1 w 478
the 9 w 481
word 1 w 485
nefandous 2 w 494
objectionable 1 w 507
and 8 w 510
fit 1 w 513
to 1 w 515
be 4 w 517
laughed 1 w 524
at 6 w 526
Oh 1 w 529
because 1 w 537
it 8 w 539
did 2 w 542
not 3 w 545
belong 1 w 551
to 2 w 553
the 10 w 556
Greeks 1 w 562
but 1 w 566
had 1 w 569
somehow 1 w 576
thrust 1 w 582
its 1 w 585
way 1 w 588
in 9 w 590
among 1 w 595
them 1 w 599
from 1 w 603
their 1 w 608
intercourse 1 w 619
with 2 w 623
Celts 1 w 628
or 10 w 630
Thracians 1 w 639
or 11 w 641
Scyths 1 w 647
wherefore 1 w 657
you 2 w 660
for 3 w 664
you 3 w 667
know 1 w 671
everything 1 w 681
that 4 w 685
pertains 1 w 693
to 3 w 695
the 13 w 698
Athenians 1 w 707
excluded 1 w 716
it 11 w 718
at 8 w 720
once 1 w 724
and 9 w 727
banished 1 w 735
it 12 w 737
from 2 w 741
the 15 w 744
Greek 2 w 749
world 1 w 754
and 10 w 758
your 1 w 762
laughter 1 w 770
was 4 w 773
because 2 w 780
I 1 w 781
committed 1 w 790
a 50 w 791
barbarism 1 w 800
and 11 w 803
used 1 w 807
a 54 w 808
foreign 2 w 815
idiom 1 w 820
and 12 w 823
went 1 w 827
beyond 1 w 833
the 16 w 836
Attic 2 w 841
bounds 1 w 847
Come 1 w 853
now 2 w 856
what 2 w 861
else 1 w 865
is 4 w 867
as 6 w 869
well 1 w 873
established 1 w 884
on 6 w 886
Athenian 2 w 894
soil 1 w 898
as 7 w 900
that 5 w 904
word 2 w 908
people 1 w 916
would 1 w 921
say 2 w 924
who 1 w 927
are 2 w 930
better 1 w 936
informed 1 w 944
than 1 w 948
you 5 w 951
about 2 w 956
such 1 w 960
matters 1 w 967
It 1 w 970
would 2 w 975
be 10 w 977
easier 1 w 983
for 6 w 986
you 6 w 989
to 4 w 991
prove 1 w 996
Erechtheus 1 w 1006
and 13 w 1009
Cecrops 1 w 1016
foreigners 1 w 1026
and 14 w 1029
invaders 1 w 1037
of 7 w 1039
Attica 2 w 1045
than 2 w 1050
to 5 w 1052
show 1 w 1056
that 6 w 1060
nefandous 3 w 1070
is 6 w 1073
not 4 w 1076
at 13 w 1078
home 1 w 1082
and 16 w 1085
indigenous 1 w 1095
in 16 w 1097
Attica 3 w 1103
There 1 w 1109
are 3 w 1112
many 1 w 1116
things 1 w 1122
which 1 w 1127
they 2 w 1131
designate 1 w 1140
in 18 w 1142
the 20 w 1145
same 1 w 1149
way 2 w 1152
as 9 w 1154
everybody 1 w 1163
else 2 w 1167
but 2 w 1171
they 3 w 1175
and 17 w 1179
they 4 w 1183
alone 1 w 1188
designate 2 w 1198
as 10 w 1200
nefandous 4 w 1209
a 89 w 1210
day 1 w 1213
which 2 w 1218
is 7 w 1220
vile 1 w 1224
abominable 1 w 1235
inauspicious 1 w 1248
useless 1 w 1256
and 19 w 1260
like 1 w 1264
you 7 w 1267
There 2 w 1273
now 3 w 1276
I 3 w 1278
have 1 w 1282
already 1 w 1289
taught 1 w 1295
you 8 w 1298
in 21 w 1300
passing 1 w 1307
what 3 w 1311
they 5 w 1315
mean 1 w 1319
by 1 w 1321
nefandous 5 w 1330
When 1 w 1335
official 1 w 1343
business 1 w 1351
is 8 w 1353
not 5 w 1356
transacted 1 w 1366
introduction 1 w 1379
of 9 w 1381
lawsuits 1 w 1389
is 9 w 1391
not 6 w 1394
permissible 1 w 1405
sacrifice 2 w 1415
of 10 w 1417
victims 1 w 1424
is 11 w 1426
not 7 w 1429
performed 1 w 1438
and 21 w 1442
in 25 w 1445
general 1 w 1452
nothing 1 w 1460
is 12 w 1462
done 1 w 1466
that 7 w 1470
requires 1 w 1478
good 1 w 1482
omens 1 w 1487
that 8 w 1492
day 2 w 1495
is 13 w 1497
nefandous 6 w 1506