Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Essays in Portraiture Defended

Essays in Portraiture Defended (26-29)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg040.perseus-eng2:26-29
Refs {'start': {'reference': '26', 'human_reference': 'Section 26'}, 'end': {'reference': '29', 'human_reference': 'Section 29'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Moreover, he not only compares human beings with gods, but likens the long hair of Euphorbus to

v.4.p.333
the Graces, and that too when it was soaked with blood! In short, this sort of thing is so frequent that there is no part of his poetry which is not well adorned with comparisons of gods. Therefore you must either expunge all that, or permit us to be equally venturesome. So exempt from all accountability is the use of comparisons and similes that Homer actually did not hesitate to derive praise for the goddesses from things of lower degree. For instance, he likened Heras eyes to those of kine. And someone else called Aphrodite violet-browed.[*] As for rosy-fingered,” who that has even the slightest acquaintance with Homers poetry does not know it?

As far as personal appearance is concerned, it signifies comparatively little if one is said to be like a god. But how many there are who have copied the very names of the gods, calling themselves Dionysius, Hephaestion, Zeno, Poseidonius, Hermes! And there was a Leto, the wife of Evagoras, king of Cyprus; yet the goddess did not take on about it, though she might have turned her into stone as she did Niobe. The Egyptians I forbear to mention, who, though the most superstitious people in the world, yet use the names of the gods to their hearts content; in fact, most of their names are derived from Heaven.

It is not incumbent upon you, then, to be thus timorous in respect of praise. If any offence at all has been perpetrated against divinity in that essay, you are not accountable for itunless you think that to listen makes one accountable; it is I whom

v.4.p.335
the gods will punish, after first punishing Homer and the other poets! But to this day they have not punished the best of the philosophers for saying that man was Gods image![*]

Although I might say much more to you, I shall stop for the sake of Polystratus here, so that he may be able to repeat from memory what has been said.

POLYSTRATUS I dont know if that is any longer possible for me, Lycinus. Even as it is, you have made a long speech, far beyond your allowance of water. But I shall try to remember it all the same; and, as you see, I am already making off to her with my ears stopped for fear that something else may pop in to confuse its outline, and then I may have the bad luck to be hissed by my hearers!

LYCINUS That is your concern, Polystratus, to act your part to the best advantage. As for me, now that I have once for all put the play into your hands, I shall withdraw for the present; but when they announce the votes of the judges, I shall be there in person to see what will be the outcome of the contest.

Tokens

Moreover 1 w 8
he 1 w 11
not 1 w 14
only 1 w 18
compares 1 w 26
human 1 w 31
beings 1 w 37
with 1 w 41
gods 1 w 45
but 1 w 49
likens 1 w 55
the 1 w 58
long 1 w 62
hair 1 w 66
of 1 w 68
Euphorbus 1 w 77
to 1 w 79
the 2 w 82
Graces 1 w 88
and 1 w 92
that 1 w 96
too 1 w 99
when 1 w 103
it 2 w 105
was 1 w 108
soaked 1 w 114
with 2 w 118
blood 1 w 123
In 1 w 126
short 1 w 131
this 1 w 136
sort 1 w 140
of 2 w 142
thing 1 w 147
is 2 w 149
so 3 w 151
frequent 1 w 159
that 2 w 163
there 1 w 168
is 3 w 170
no 2 w 172
part 1 w 176
of 3 w 178
his 2 w 181
poetry 1 w 187
which 1 w 192
is 5 w 194
not 2 w 197
well 1 w 201
adorned 1 w 208
with 3 w 212
comparisons 1 w 223
of 4 w 225
gods 2 w 229
Therefore 1 w 239
you 1 w 242
must 1 w 246
either 1 w 252
expunge 1 w 259
all 1 w 262
that 3 w 266
or 7 w 269
permit 1 w 275
us 3 w 277
to 3 w 279
be 2 w 281
equally 1 w 288
venturesome 1 w 299
So 1 w 302
exempt 1 w 308
from 1 w 312
all 3 w 315
accountability 1 w 329
is 7 w 331
the 5 w 334
use 1 w 337
of 5 w 339
comparisons 2 w 350
and 2 w 353
similes 1 w 360
that 4 w 364
Homer 1 w 369
actually 1 w 377
did 1 w 380
not 3 w 383
hesitate 1 w 391
to 4 w 393
derive 1 w 399
praise 1 w 405
for 2 w 408
the 6 w 411
goddesses 1 w 420
from 2 w 424
things 1 w 430
of 6 w 432
lower 1 w 437
degree 1 w 443
For 1 w 447
instance 1 w 455
he 11 w 458
likened 1 w 465
Hera 1 w 469
s 36 w 471
eyes 1 w 475
to 5 w 477
those 1 w 482
of 7 w 484
kine 1 w 488
And 1 w 492
someone 1 w 499
else 1 w 503
called 1 w 509
Aphrodite 1 w 518
violet-browed 1 w 531
The 2 w 535
Theban 1 w 542
poet 2 w 546
of 8 w 549
the 7 w 552
preceding 1 w 561
piece 1 w 566
p 15 w 568
271 1 w 572
i 36 w 575
e 75 w 577
Pindar 1 w 584
As 1 w 587
for 3 w 590
rosy-fingered 1 w 604
who 1 w 609
that 5 w 613
has 1 w 616
even 1 w 620
the 8 w 623
slightest 1 w 632
acquaintance 1 w 644
with 4 w 648
Homer 2 w 653
s 46 w 655
poetry 2 w 661
does 1 w 665
not 4 w 668
know 1 w 672
it 11 w 674
As 2 w 677
far 1 w 680
as 3 w 682
personal 1 w 690
appearance 1 w 700
is 10 w 702
concerned 1 w 711
it 12 w 714
signifies 1 w 723
comparatively 1 w 736
little 1 w 742
if 2 w 744
one 2 w 747
is 11 w 749
said 1 w 753
to 6 w 755
be 3 w 757
like 3 w 761
a 45 w 762
god 4 w 765
But 1 w 769
how 1 w 772
many 1 w 776
there 2 w 781
are 2 w 784
who 2 w 787
have 1 w 791
copied 1 w 797
the 10 w 800
very 1 w 804
names 1 w 809
of 9 w 811
the 11 w 814
gods 3 w 818
calling 1 w 826
themselves 1 w 836
Dionysius 1 w 845
Hephaestion 1 w 857
Zeno 1 w 862
Poseidonius 1 w 874
Hermes 1 w 881
And 2 w 885
there 3 w 890
was 2 w 893
a 53 w 894
Leto 1 w 898
the 14 w 902
wife 1 w 906
of 10 w 908
Evagoras 1 w 916
king 1 w 921
of 11 w 923
Cyprus 1 w 929
yet 1 w 933
the 15 w 936
goddess 2 w 943
did 2 w 946
not 5 w 949
take 1 w 953
on 12 w 955
about 1 w 960
it 14 w 962
though 1 w 969
she 1 w 972
might 1 w 977
have 2 w 981
turned 1 w 987
her 6 w 990
into 1 w 994
stone 1 w 999
as 6 w 1001
she 2 w 1004
did 3 w 1007
Niobe 1 w 1012
The 4 w 1016
Egyptians 1 w 1025
I 2 w 1026
forbear 1 w 1033
to 10 w 1035
mention 1 w 1042
who 3 w 1046
though 2 w 1053
the 16 w 1056
most 1 w 1060
superstitious 1 w 1073
people 1 w 1079
in 13 w 1081
the 17 w 1084
world 1 w 1089
yet 2 w 1093
use 2 w 1096
the 18 w 1099
names 2 w 1104
of 12 w 1106
the 19 w 1109
gods 4 w 1113
to 11 w 1115
their 1 w 1120
hearts 1 w 1126
content 1 w 1134
in 14 w 1137
fact 1 w 1141
most 2 w 1146
of 13 w 1148
their 2 w 1153
names 3 w 1158
are 3 w 1161
derived 1 w 1168
from 3 w 1172
Heaven 1 w 1178
It 1 w 1181
is 12 w 1183
not 6 w 1186
incumbent 1 w 1195
upon 1 w 1199
you 2 w 1202
then 1 w 1207
to 12 w 1210
be 7 w 1212
thus 1 w 1216
timorous 1 w 1224
in 16 w 1226
respect 1 w 1233
of 14 w 1235
praise 2 w 1241
If 1 w 1244
any 2 w 1247
offence 1 w 1254
at 8 w 1256
all 7 w 1259
has 2 w 1262
been 1 w 1266
perpetrated 1 w 1277
against 1 w 1284
divinity 1 w 1292
in 19 w 1294
that 6 w 1298
essay 1 w 1303
you 3 w 1307
are 4 w 1310
not 7 w 1313
accountable 1 w 1324
for 5 w 1327
it 17 w 1329
unless 1 w 1336
you 4 w 1339
think 1 w 1344
that 7 w 1348
to 13 w 1350
listen 1 w 1356
makes 1 w 1361
one 4 w 1364
accountable 2 w 1375
it 18 w 1378
is 15 w 1380
I 5 w 1381
whom 1 w 1385
the 23 w 1388
gods 5 w 1392
will 1 w 1396
punish 1 w 1402
after 1 w 1408
first 1 w 1413
punishing 1 w 1422
Homer 3 w 1427
and 3 w 1430
the 24 w 1433
other 1 w 1438
poets 1 w 1443
But 2 w 1447
to 14 w 1449
this 2 w 1453
day 1 w 1456
they 1 w 1460
have 3 w 1464
not 8 w 1467
punished 1 w 1475
the 27 w 1478
best 1 w 1482
of 16 w 1484
the 28 w 1487
philosophers 1 w 1499
for 6 w 1502
saying 1 w 1508
that 8 w 1512
man 3 w 1515
was 3 w 1518
God 1 w 1521
s 112 w 1523
image 1 w 1528
Hardly 1 w 1535
Plato 1 w 1540
though 3 w 1547
he 43 w 1549
has 3 w 1552
something 1 w 1561
similar 1 w 1568
in 24 w 1570
the 29 w 1573
Republic 1 w 1581
501 1 w 1585
But 3 w 1589
to 16 w 1591
him 1 w 1594
the 30 w 1597
universe 1 w 1605
is 20 w 1607
God 2 w 1610
s 118 w 1612
image 2 w 1617
see 1 w 1621
the 31 w 1624
end 1 w 1627
of 17 w 1629
the 32 w 1632
Timaeus 1 w 1639
Perhaps 1 w 1647
Lucian 1 w 1653
means 1 w 1658
Diogenes 1 w 1666
who 5 w 1670
said 2 w 1674
that 9 w 1678
good 1 w 1682
men 2 w 1685
were 1 w 1689
images 1 w 1695
of 18 w 1697
gods 6 w 1701
Diog 2 w 1706
Laert 1 w 1712
6 1 w 1714
51 1 w 1717
Although 1 w 1727
I 6 w 1728
might 2 w 1733
say 3 w 1736
much 1 w 1740
more 1 w 1744
to 17 w 1746
you 5 w 1749
I 7 w 1751
shall 1 w 1756
stop 1 w 1760
for 7 w 1763
the 33 w 1766
sake 1 w 1770
of 19 w 1772
Polystratus 1 w 1783
here 5 w 1787
so 11 w 1790
that 10 w 1794
he 50 w 1796
may 1 w 1799
be 10 w 1801
able 3 w 1805
to 19 w 1807
repeat 1 w 1813
from 4 w 1817
memory 1 w 1823
what 1 w 1827
has 4 w 1830
been 2 w 1834
said 3 w 1838
POLYSTRATUS 1 w 1850
I 8 w 1851
don 2 w 1854
t 171 w 1856
know 2 w 1860
if 4 w 1862
that 11 w 1866
is 21 w 1868
any 3 w 1871
longer 1 w 1877
possible 1 w 1885
for 8 w 1888
me 15 w 1890
Lycinus 1 w 1898
Even 1 w 1903
as 11 w 1905
it 19 w 1907
is 22 w 1909
you 6 w 1913
have 4 w 1917
made 1 w 1921
a 123 w 1922
long 3 w 1926
speech 1 w 1932
far 2 w 1936
beyond 1 w 1942
your 1 w 1946
allowance 1 w 1955
of 20 w 1957
water 1 w 1962
But 4 w 1966
I 9 w 1967
shall 2 w 1972
try 3 w 1975
to 20 w 1977
remember 1 w 1985
it 20 w 1987
all 11 w 1990
the 34 w 1993
same 1 w 1997
and 4 w 2001
as 12 w 2004
you 8 w 2007
see 2 w 2010
I 10 w 2012
am 5 w 2014
already 1 w 2021
making 1 w 2027
off 2 w 2030
to 21 w 2032
her 10 w 2035
with 5 w 2039
my 1 w 2041
ears 1 w 2045
stopped 1 w 2052
for 9 w 2055
fear 1 w 2059
that 12 w 2063
something 2 w 2072
else 2 w 2076
may 2 w 2079
pop 1 w 2082
in 28 w 2084
to 23 w 2086
confuse 1 w 2093
its 1 w 2096
outline 1 w 2103
and 5 w 2107
then 2 w 2111
I 11 w 2112
may 3 w 2115
have 5 w 2119
the 36 w 2122
bad 1 w 2125
luck 1 w 2129
to 24 w 2131
be 14 w 2133
hissed 1 w 2139
by 1 w 2141
my 2 w 2143
hearers 1 w 2150
LYCINUS 1 w 2158
That 1 w 2162
is 24 w 2164
your 2 w 2168
concern 2 w 2175
Polystratus 2 w 2187
to 25 w 2190
act 3 w 2193
your 3 w 2197
part 2 w 2201
to 26 w 2203
the 37 w 2206
best 2 w 2210
advantage 1 w 2219
As 3 w 2222
for 10 w 2225
me 19 w 2227
now 3 w 2231
that 13 w 2235
I 13 w 2236
have 6 w 2240
once 3 w 2244
for 11 w 2247
all 12 w 2250
put 1 w 2253
the 38 w 2256
play 1 w 2260
into 2 w 2264
your 4 w 2268
hands 1 w 2273
I 14 w 2275
shall 3 w 2280
withdraw 1 w 2288
for 12 w 2291
the 39 w 2294
present 1 w 2301
but 2 w 2305
when 2 w 2309
they 2 w 2313
announce 1 w 2321
the 41 w 2324
votes 1 w 2329
of 22 w 2331
the 42 w 2334
judges 1 w 2340
I 15 w 2342
shall 4 w 2347
be 16 w 2349
there 4 w 2354
in 31 w 2356
person 2 w 2362
to 28 w 2364
see 3 w 2367
what 2 w 2371
will 2 w 2375
be 17 w 2377
the 44 w 2380
outcome 1 w 2387
of 23 w 2389
the 45 w 2392
contest 1 w 2399