Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On Funerals

On Funerals (1-5)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg036.perseus-eng2:1-5
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1', 'human_reference': 'Section 1'}, 'end': {'reference': '5', 'human_reference': 'Section 5'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Truly, it is well worth while to observe what most people do and say at funerals, and on the other hand what their would-be comforters say ; to observe also how unbearable the mourners consider what is happening, not only for themselves but for those whom they mourn. Yet, I swear by Pluto and Persephone, they have not one whit of definite knowledge as to whether this experience is unpleasant and worth grieving about, or on the contrary delightful and better for those who undergo it. No, they simply commit their grief into the charge of custom and habit. When someone dies, then, this is what they dobut stay! First I wish to tell you what beliefs they hold about death itself, for then it will become clear why they engage in these superfluous practices.

The general herd, whom philosophers call the laity, trust Homer and Hesiod and the other mythmakers in these matters, and take their poetry for a law unto themselves. So they suppose that there is a place deep under the earth called Hades, which is large and roomy and murky and sunless; I dont know how they imagine it to be lighted up so that everything in it can be seen. The king of the

v.4.p.115
abyss is a brother of Zeus named Pluto, who has been honoured with that appellative, so I was told by one well versed in such matters, because of his wealth of corpses.[*] This Pluto, they say, has organized his state and the world below as follows. He himself has been allotted the sovereignty of the dead, whom he receives, takes in charge, and retains in close custody, permitting nobody whatsoever to go back up above, except, in all time, a very few for most important reasons.

His country is surrounded by great rivers, fearful even in name; for they are called Wailing,” Burning Fire,’ and the like. But the principal feature is Lake Acheron, which lies in front and first receives visitors; it cannot be crossed or passed without the ferryman, for it is too deep to ford afoot and too broad to swim acrossindeed, even dead birds cannot fly across it![*]

Hard by the descent and the portal, which is of adamant, stands the kings nephew, Aeacus, who is commander of the guard; and beside him is a three-headed dog, very long-fanged, who gives a friendly, peaceable glance to those who come in, but howls at those who try to run away and frightens them with his great mouth.

After passing the lake on going in, one comes next to a

v.4.p.117
great meadow overgrown with asphodel, and to a spring that is inimical to memory; in fact, they call it Oblivion for that reason. All this, by the way, was told to the ancients by people who came back from there, Alcestis and Protesilaus of Thessaly, Theseus, son of Aegeus, and Homer's Odysseus, highly respectable and trustworthy witnesses, who, I suppose, did not drink of the spring, or else they would not have remembered it all.

Truly 1 w 5
it 1 w 8
is 1 w 10
well 1 w 14
worth 1 w 19
while 1 w 24
to 1 w 26
observe 1 w 33
what 1 w 37
most 1 w 41
people 1 w 47
do 1 w 49
and 1 w 52
say 1 w 55
at 2 w 57
funerals 1 w 65
and 2 w 69
on 1 w 71
the 1 w 74
other 1 w 79
hand 1 w 83
what 2 w 87
their 1 w 92
would-be 1 w 100
comforters 1 w 110
say 2 w 113
to 2 w 116
observe 2 w 123
also 1 w 127
how 1 w 130
unbearable 1 w 140
the 4 w 143
mourners 1 w 151
consider 1 w 159
what 3 w 163
is 2 w 165
happening 1 w 174
not 1 w 178
only 1 w 182
for 2 w 185
themselves 1 w 195
but 1 w 198
for 3 w 201
those 1 w 206
whom 1 w 210
they 1 w 214
mourn 2 w 219
Yet 1 w 223
I 1 w 225
swear 1 w 230
by 1 w 232
Pluto 1 w 237
and 4 w 240
Persephone 1 w 250
they 2 w 255
have 1 w 259
not 2 w 262
one 2 w 265
whit 1 w 269
of 1 w 271
definite 1 w 279
knowledge 1 w 288
as 1 w 290
to 4 w 292
whether 1 w 299
this 1 w 303
experience 1 w 313
is 4 w 315
unpleasant 1 w 325
and 5 w 328
worth 2 w 333
grieving 1 w 341
about 1 w 346
or 6 w 349
on 6 w 351
the 9 w 354
contrary 1 w 362
delightful 1 w 372
and 6 w 375
better 1 w 381
for 4 w 384
those 2 w 389
who 2 w 392
undergo 1 w 399
it 4 w 401
No 1 w 404
they 3 w 409
simply 1 w 415
commit 1 w 421
their 2 w 426
grief 1 w 431
into 1 w 435
the 12 w 438
charge 1 w 444
of 2 w 446
custom 1 w 452
and 7 w 455
habit 1 w 460
When 1 w 465
someone 1 w 472
dies 1 w 476
then 1 w 481
this 2 w 486
is 6 w 488
what 4 w 492
they 4 w 496
do 2 w 498
but 2 w 502
stay 1 w 506
First 1 w 512
I 2 w 513
wish 1 w 517
to 7 w 519
tell 1 w 523
you 1 w 526
what 5 w 530
beliefs 1 w 537
they 5 w 541
hold 1 w 545
about 2 w 550
death 1 w 555
itself 1 w 561
for 5 w 565
then 2 w 569
it 8 w 571
will 1 w 575
become 1 w 581
clear 1 w 586
why 1 w 589
they 6 w 593
engage 1 w 599
in 5 w 601
these 1 w 606
superfluous 1 w 617
practices 1 w 626
The 1 w 630
general 1 w 637
herd 1 w 641
whom 2 w 646
philosophers 1 w 658
call 1 w 662
the 19 w 665
laity 1 w 670
trust 1 w 676
Homer 1 w 681
and 8 w 684
Hesiod 1 w 690
and 9 w 693
the 20 w 696
other 2 w 701
mythmakers 1 w 711
in 6 w 713
these 2 w 718
matters 1 w 725
and 10 w 729
take 1 w 733
their 3 w 738
poetry 1 w 744
for 6 w 747
a 45 w 748
law 1 w 751
unto 1 w 755
themselves 2 w 765
So 1 w 768
they 7 w 772
suppose 1 w 779
that 1 w 783
there 1 w 788
is 8 w 790
a 48 w 791
place 1 w 796
deep 1 w 800
under 2 w 805
the 27 w 808
earth 1 w 813
called 1 w 819
Hades 1 w 824
which 1 w 830
is 9 w 832
large 1 w 837
and 11 w 840
roomy 1 w 845
and 12 w 848
murky 1 w 853
and 13 w 856
sunless 1 w 863
I 3 w 865
don 1 w 868
t 86 w 870
know 2 w 874
how 2 w 877
they 8 w 881
imagine 1 w 888
it 10 w 890
to 9 w 892
be 6 w 894
lighted 1 w 901
up 3 w 903
so 4 w 905
that 2 w 909
everything 1 w 919
in 9 w 921
it 11 w 923
can 1 w 926
be 7 w 928
seen 1 w 932
The 2 w 936
king 1 w 940
of 3 w 942
the 29 w 945
abyss 1 w 950
is 10 w 952
a 61 w 953
brother 1 w 960
of 4 w 962
Zeus 1 w 966
named 1 w 971
Pluto 2 w 976
who 4 w 980
has 1 w 983
been 1 w 987
honoured 1 w 995
with 1 w 999
that 3 w 1003
appellative 1 w 1014
so 5 w 1017
I 4 w 1018
was 1 w 1021
told 1 w 1025
by 3 w 1027
one 4 w 1030
well 2 w 1034
versed 1 w 1040
in 11 w 1042
such 1 w 1046
matters 2 w 1053
because 1 w 1061
of 5 w 1063
his 3 w 1066
wealth 1 w 1072
of 6 w 1074
corpses 1 w 1081
The 3 w 1085
Greeks 1 w 1091
derived 1 w 1098
the 31 w 1101
name 2 w 1105
Ploutdn 1 w 1112
Pluto 3 w 1118
from 1 w 1123
ploutein 1 w 1131
to 13 w 1134
be 10 w 1136
rich 1 w 1140
and 14 w 1145
generally 1 w 1154
held 1 w 1158
that 4 w 1162
it 13 w 1164
was 2 w 1167
given 1 w 1172
to 14 w 1174
Hades 2 w 1179
because 2 w 1186
he 40 w 1188
owned 1 w 1193
and 15 w 1196
dispensed 1 w 1205
the 32 w 1208
riches 1 w 1214
that 5 w 1218
are 1 w 1221
in 13 w 1223
the 33 w 1226
earth 2 w 1231
So 2 w 1234
Lucian 1 w 1240
in 14 w 1242
the 34 w 1245
Timon 1 w 1250
21 1 w 1253
Here 1 w 1259
however 1 w 1267
we 6 w 1270
have 2 w 1274
in 15 w 1276
substance 1 w 1285
the 35 w 1288
view 1 w 1292
of 7 w 1294
Cornutus 1 w 1302
5 1 w 1304
He 3 w 1309
was 3 w 1312
called 2 w 1318
Pluto 4 w 1323
because 3 w 1330
of 8 w 1333
all 5 w 1336
that 6 w 1340
is 13 w 1342
perishable 1 w 1352
there 2 w 1358
is 15 w 1360
nothing 1 w 1367
which 2 w 1372
does 1 w 1376
not 4 w 1379
at 17 w 1381
last 1 w 1385
go 2 w 1387
down 1 w 1391
to 16 w 1393
him 1 w 1396
and 16 w 1399
become 2 w 1405
his 4 w 1408
property 1 w 1416
This 1 w 1422
Pluto 5 w 1427
they 9 w 1432
say 3 w 1435
has 2 w 1439
organized 1 w 1448
his 6 w 1451
state 1 w 1456
and 17 w 1459
the 38 w 1462
world 1 w 1467
below 1 w 1472
as 9 w 1474
follows 1 w 1481
He 4 w 1484
himself 1 w 1491
has 3 w 1494
been 2 w 1498
allotted 1 w 1506
the 39 w 1509
sovereignty 1 w 1520
of 9 w 1522
the 40 w 1525
dead 1 w 1529
whom 3 w 1534
he 51 w 1536
receives 1 w 1544
takes 1 w 1550
in 17 w 1552
charge 2 w 1558
and 18 w 1562
retains 1 w 1569
in 19 w 1571
close 1 w 1576
custody 1 w 1583
permitting 1 w 1594
nobody 1 w 1600
whatsoever 1 w 1610
to 19 w 1612
go 3 w 1614
back 1 w 1618
up 4 w 1620
above 1 w 1625
except 1 w 1632
in 21 w 1635
all 7 w 1638
time 1 w 1642
a 111 w 1644
very 2 w 1648
few 1 w 1651
for 7 w 1654
most 2 w 1658
important 1 w 1667
reasons 1 w 1674
His 1 w 1678
country 1 w 1685
is 20 w 1687
surrounded 1 w 1697
by 4 w 1699
great 1 w 1704
rivers 1 w 1710
fearful 1 w 1718
even 1 w 1722
in 22 w 1724
name 3 w 1728
for 8 w 1732
they 10 w 1736
are 2 w 1739
called 3 w 1745
Wailing 1 w 1753
Burning 1 w 1763
Fire 1 w 1767
and 19 w 1772
the 42 w 1775
like 1 w 1779
But 1 w 1783
the 43 w 1786
principal 1 w 1795
feature 1 w 1802
is 21 w 1804
Lake 1 w 1808
Acheron 1 w 1815
which 3 w 1821
lies 1 w 1825
in 26 w 1827
front 1 w 1832
and 20 w 1835
first 1 w 1840
receives 2 w 1848
visitors 1 w 1856
it 16 w 1859
cannot 1 w 1865
be 16 w 1867
crossed 1 w 1874
or 18 w 1876
passed 1 w 1882
without 1 w 1889
the 44 w 1892
ferryman 1 w 1900
for 9 w 1904
it 18 w 1906
is 23 w 1908
too 1 w 1911
deep 2 w 1915
to 22 w 1917
ford 1 w 1921
afoot 1 w 1926
and 21 w 1929
too 2 w 1932
broad 1 w 1937
to 24 w 1939
swim 1 w 1943
across 1 w 1949
indeed 1 w 1956
even 2 w 1961
dead 2 w 1965
birds 1 w 1970
cannot 2 w 1976
fly 1 w 1979
across 2 w 1985
it 19 w 1987
Many 1 w 1992
places 1 w 1998
on 16 w 2000
earth 3 w 2005
men 1 w 2009
thought 1 w 2016
exhaled 1 w 2024
vapours 1 w 2031
so 9 w 2033
deadly 1 w 2039
that 7 w 2043
birds 2 w 2048
attempting 1 w 2059
to 25 w 2061
cross 4 w 2066
them 3 w 2070
fell 1 w 2075
dead 4 w 2079
the 46 w 2083
most 3 w 2087
famous 1 w 2093
of 10 w 2095
these 3 w 2100
Plutonia 1 w 2109
was 4 w 2113
the 48 w 2116
lake 1 w 2120
near 1 w 2124
Cumae 1 w 2129
called 4 w 2136
Aopyos 1 w 2143
par 1 w 2146
excellence 1 w 2156
whence 1 w 2163
Avernus 1 w 2170
Iflive 1 w 2177
birds 3 w 2182
could 1 w 2187
not 7 w 2190
fly 2 w 2193
across 3 w 2199
Avernus 2 w 2206
surely 1 w 2213
the 49 w 2216
ghost 1 w 2221
of 11 w 2223
a 153 w 2224
bird 4 w 2228
could 2 w 2233
not 8 w 2236
fly 3 w 2239
across 4 w 2245
Acheron 2 w 2252
Hard 1 w 2257
by 5 w 2259
the 50 w 2262
descent 1 w 2269
and 22 w 2272
the 51 w 2275
portal 1 w 2281
which 4 w 2287
is 24 w 2289
of 12 w 2291
adamant 1 w 2298
stands 1 w 2305
the 52 w 2308
king 2 w 2312
s 153 w 2314
nephew 1 w 2320
Aeacus 1 w 2327
who 6 w 2331
is 25 w 2333
commander 1 w 2342
of 13 w 2344
the 53 w 2347
guard 1 w 2352
and 25 w 2356
beside 1 w 2362
him 3 w 2365
is 26 w 2367
a 166 w 2368
three-headed 1 w 2380
dog 1 w 2383
very 3 w 2388
long-fanged 1 w 2399
who 7 w 2403
gives 1 w 2408
a 169 w 2409
friendly 1 w 2417
peaceable 1 w 2427
glance 1 w 2433
to 27 w 2435
those 3 w 2440
who 8 w 2443
come 3 w 2447
in 30 w 2449
but 3 w 2453
howls 1 w 2458
at 24 w 2460
those 4 w 2465
who 9 w 2468
try 3 w 2471
to 28 w 2473
run 1 w 2476
away 1 w 2480
and 26 w 2483
frightens 1 w 2492
them 4 w 2496
with 3 w 2500
his 7 w 2503
great 2 w 2508
mouth 1 w 2513
After 1 w 2519
passing 1 w 2526
the 55 w 2529
lake 2 w 2533
on 20 w 2535
going 1 w 2540
in 33 w 2542
one 5 w 2546
comes 1 w 2551
next 1 w 2555
to 29 w 2557
a 180 w 2558
great 3 w 2563
meadow 1 w 2569
overgrown 1 w 2578
with 4 w 2582
asphodel 1 w 2590
and 27 w 2594
to 30 w 2596
a 185 w 2597
spring 1 w 2603
that 8 w 2607
is 28 w 2609
inimical 1 w 2617
to 31 w 2619
memory 1 w 2625
in 36 w 2628
fact 1 w 2632
they 11 w 2637
call 6 w 2641
it 22 w 2643
Oblivion 1 w 2652
for 11 w 2656
that 9 w 2660
reason 2 w 2666
All 1 w 2670
this 3 w 2674
by 6 w 2677
the 57 w 2680
way 2 w 2683
was 5 w 2687
told 2 w 2691
to 33 w 2693
the 58 w 2696
ancients 1 w 2704
by 7 w 2706
people 2 w 2712
who 10 w 2715
came 1 w 2719
back 2 w 2723
from 2 w 2727
there 3 w 2732
Alcestis 1 w 2741
and 28 w 2744
Protesilaus 1 w 2755
of 14 w 2757
Thessaly 1 w 2765
Theseus 1 w 2773
son 3 w 2777
of 15 w 2779
Aegeus 1 w 2785
and 29 w 2789
Homer 2 w 2794
s 184 w 2796
Odysseus 1 w 2804
highly 1 w 2811
respectable 1 w 2822
and 30 w 2825
trustworthy 1 w 2836
witnesses 1 w 2845
who 11 w 2849
I 6 w 2851
suppose 2 w 2858
did 1 w 2862
not 9 w 2865
drink 1 w 2870
of 16 w 2872
the 60 w 2875
spring 2 w 2881
or 25 w 2884
else 1 w 2888
they 12 w 2892
would 2 w 2897
not 10 w 2900
have 3 w 2904
remembered 1 w 2914
it 24 w 2916
all 11 w 2919