Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Remarks Addressed To an Illiterate Book-fancier

Remarks Addressed To an Illiterate Book-fancier (11-15)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg028.perseus-eng4:11-15
Refs {'start': {'reference': '11', 'human_reference': 'None 11'}, 'end': {'reference': '15', 'human_reference': 'None 15'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

I have also an old Lesbian story which is very much to the point. It is said that after Orpheus had been torn to pieces by the Thracian women, his head and his lyre were carried down the Hebrus into the sea; the head, it seems, floated down upon the lyre, singing Orpheuss dirge as it went, while the winds blew an accompaniment upon the strings. In this manner they reached the coast of Lesbos; the head was then taken up and buried on the site of the present temple of Bacchus, and the lyre was long preserved as a relic in the temple of Apollo.

Later on, however, Neanthus, son of the tyrant Pittacus, hearing how the lyre had charmed beasts and trees and stones, and how after Orpheuss destruction it had played of its own accord, conceived a violent fancy for the instrument, and by means of a considerable bribe prevailed upon the priest to give him the genuine lyre, and replace it with one of similar appearance. Not thinking it advisable to display his acquisition in the city im broad daylight, he waited till night, and then, putting it under his cloak, walked off into the outskirts; and there this youth, who had not a note of music in him, produced his instrument and began jangling on the strings, expecting such divine strains to issue therefrom as would subdue all souls, and. prove him the fortunate heir to Orpheuss power. He went on till a number of dogs collected at the sound and tore him limb from limb;_ thus far, at least, his fate resembled that of Orpheus, though his power of attraction extended only to hostile dogs. It was abundantly proved that the charm lay not in the lyre, but solely in those peculiar gifts of song and music that had been bestowed upon Orpheus by his mother; as to the lyre, it was just like other lyres.

v.3.p.272

But there: what need to go back to Orpheus and Neanthus? We have instances in our own days: I believe the man is still alive who paid 120 for the earthenware lamp of Epictetus the Stoic. I suppose he thought he had only to read by the light of that lamp, and the wisdom of Epictetus would be communicated to him in his dreams, and he himself assume the likeness of that venerable sage.

And it was only a day or two ago that another enthusiast paid down 250 for the staff dropped by the Cynic Proteus[*] when he leaped upon the pyre. He treasures this relic, and shows it off just as the people of Tegea do the hide of the Calydonian boar,[*] or the Thebans the bones of Geryon, or the Memphians Isis hair. Now the original owner of this precious staff was one who for ignorance and vulgarity would have borne away the palm from yourself.—My friend, you are in a bad way: a stick across the head is what you want.

They say that when Dionysius took to tragedy-writing he made such sad stuff of it that Philoxenus was more than once thrown into the quarries because he could not control his laughter. Finding that his efforts only made him ridiculous, Dionysius was at some pains to procure the tablets on which Aeschylashad been wont to write. He looked to draw divine inspiration from them: as it turned out, however, he now wrote considerably worse rubbish than before, Among the contents of the tablets I may quote:

'Twas Dionysius wife, Doridion.
Here is another:
Most serviceable woman! thou art gone!
Genuine tablet that, and the next:
Men that are fools are their own follys butt.
Taken with reference to yourself, by the way, nothing could
v.3.p.273
be more to the point than this last line; Dionysiuss tablets deserved gilding, if only for that.

I 1 w 1
have 1 w 5
also 1 w 9
an 1 w 11
old 1 w 14
Lesbian 1 w 21
story 1 w 26
which 1 w 31
is 1 w 33
very 1 w 37
much 1 w 41
to 2 w 43
the 1 w 46
point 1 w 51
It 1 w 54
is 2 w 56
said 1 w 60
that 1 w 64
after 1 w 69
Orpheus 1 w 76
had 1 w 79
been 1 w 83
torn 1 w 87
to 4 w 89
pieces 1 w 95
by 1 w 97
the 2 w 100
Thracian 1 w 108
women 1 w 113
his 1 w 117
head 1 w 121
and 1 w 124
his 2 w 127
lyre 1 w 131
were 1 w 135
carried 1 w 142
down 1 w 146
the 3 w 149
Hebrus 1 w 155
into 1 w 159
the 4 w 162
sea 1 w 165
the 5 w 169
head 2 w 173
it 1 w 176
seems 1 w 181
floated 1 w 189
down 2 w 193
upon 1 w 197
the 6 w 200
lyre 2 w 204
singing 1 w 212
Orpheus 2 w 219
s 17 w 221
dirge 1 w 226
as 1 w 228
it 2 w 230
went 1 w 234
while 1 w 240
the 7 w 243
winds 1 w 248
blew 1 w 252
an 5 w 254
accompaniment 1 w 267
upon 2 w 271
the 8 w 274
strings 1 w 281
In 1 w 284
this 1 w 288
manner 1 w 294
they 1 w 298
reached 1 w 305
the 10 w 308
coast 1 w 313
of 1 w 315
Lesbos 1 w 321
the 11 w 325
head 3 w 329
was 1 w 332
then 1 w 336
taken 1 w 341
up 3 w 343
and 2 w 346
buried 1 w 352
on 3 w 354
the 13 w 357
site 1 w 361
of 2 w 363
the 14 w 366
present 1 w 373
temple 1 w 379
of 3 w 381
Bacchus 1 w 388
and 3 w 392
the 15 w 395
lyre 3 w 399
was 2 w 402
long 1 w 406
preserved 1 w 415
as 5 w 417
a 32 w 418
relic 1 w 423
in 7 w 425
the 16 w 428
temple 2 w 434
of 4 w 436
Apollo 1 w 442
Later 1 w 448
on 5 w 450
however 1 w 458
Neanthus 1 w 467
son 1 w 471
of 5 w 473
the 17 w 476
tyrant 1 w 482
Pittacus 1 w 490
hearing 1 w 498
how 2 w 501
the 18 w 504
lyre 4 w 508
had 2 w 511
charmed 1 w 518
beasts 1 w 524
and 4 w 527
trees 1 w 532
and 5 w 535
stones 1 w 541
and 6 w 545
how 3 w 548
after 2 w 553
Orpheus 3 w 560
s 42 w 562
destruction 1 w 573
it 5 w 575
had 3 w 578
played 1 w 584
of 6 w 586
its 1 w 589
own 3 w 592
accord 1 w 598
conceived 1 w 608
a 48 w 609
violent 1 w 616
fancy 1 w 621
for 1 w 624
the 19 w 627
instrument 1 w 637
and 7 w 641
by 2 w 643
means 1 w 648
of 7 w 650
a 52 w 651
considerable 1 w 663
bribe 1 w 668
prevailed 1 w 677
upon 3 w 681
the 20 w 684
priest 1 w 690
to 7 w 692
give 1 w 696
him 1 w 699
the 21 w 702
genuine 1 w 709
lyre 5 w 713
and 8 w 717
replace 1 w 724
it 7 w 726
with 1 w 730
one 2 w 733
of 8 w 735
similar 1 w 742
appearance 1 w 752
Not 1 w 756
thinking 1 w 764
it 9 w 766
advisable 1 w 775
to 8 w 777
display 1 w 784
his 4 w 787
acquisition 1 w 798
in 13 w 800
the 22 w 803
city 1 w 807
im 4 w 809
broad 1 w 814
daylight 1 w 822
he 31 w 825
waited 1 w 831
till 1 w 835
night 1 w 840
and 9 w 844
then 2 w 848
putting 1 w 856
it 13 w 858
under 1 w 863
his 5 w 866
cloak 1 w 871
walked 1 w 878
off 1 w 881
into 2 w 885
the 24 w 888
outskirts 1 w 897
and 10 w 901
there 1 w 906
this 2 w 910
youth 1 w 915
who 1 w 919
had 4 w 922
not 1 w 925
a 73 w 926
note 1 w 930
of 10 w 932
music 1 w 937
in 16 w 939
him 2 w 942
produced 1 w 951
his 7 w 954
instrument 2 w 964
and 11 w 967
began 1 w 972
jangling 1 w 980
on 14 w 982
the 26 w 985
strings 2 w 992
expecting 1 w 1002
such 1 w 1006
divine 1 w 1012
strains 1 w 1019
to 10 w 1021
issue 1 w 1026
therefrom 1 w 1035
as 7 w 1037
would 1 w 1042
subdue 1 w 1048
all 1 w 1051
souls 1 w 1056
and 12 w 1060
prove 1 w 1066
him 3 w 1069
the 28 w 1072
fortunate 1 w 1081
heir 1 w 1085
to 11 w 1087
Orpheus 4 w 1094
s 73 w 1096
power 1 w 1101
He 2 w 1104
went 2 w 1108
on 15 w 1110
till 2 w 1114
a 82 w 1115
number 1 w 1121
of 11 w 1123
dogs 1 w 1127
collected 1 w 1136
at 5 w 1138
the 29 w 1141
sound 1 w 1146
and 13 w 1149
tore 1 w 1153
him 4 w 1156
limb 1 w 1160
from 2 w 1164
limb 2 w 1168
thus 2 w 1174
far 1 w 1177
at 6 w 1180
least 1 w 1185
his 8 w 1189
fate 1 w 1193
resembled 1 w 1202
that 2 w 1206
of 12 w 1208
Orpheus 5 w 1215
though 1 w 1222
his 9 w 1225
power 2 w 1230
of 13 w 1232
attraction 1 w 1242
extended 1 w 1250
only 1 w 1254
to 13 w 1256
hostile 1 w 1263
dogs 2 w 1267
It 2 w 1270
was 3 w 1273
abundantly 1 w 1283
proved 1 w 1289
that 3 w 1293
the 30 w 1296
charm 2 w 1301
lay 3 w 1304
not 3 w 1307
in 23 w 1309
the 31 w 1312
lyre 6 w 1316
but 1 w 1320
solely 1 w 1326
in 24 w 1328
those 1 w 1333
peculiar 1 w 1341
gifts 1 w 1346
of 14 w 1348
song 1 w 1352
and 14 w 1355
music 2 w 1360
that 4 w 1364
had 5 w 1367
been 2 w 1371
bestowed 1 w 1379
upon 4 w 1383
Orpheus 6 w 1390
by 3 w 1392
his 10 w 1395
mother 1 w 1401
as 10 w 1404
to 15 w 1406
the 33 w 1409
lyre 7 w 1413
it 14 w 1416
was 4 w 1419
just 1 w 1423
like 1 w 1427
other 2 w 1432
lyres 1 w 1437
But 1 w 1441
there 3 w 1446
what 1 w 1451
need 1 w 1455
to 16 w 1457
go 1 w 1459
back 1 w 1463
to 17 w 1465
Orpheus 7 w 1472
and 15 w 1475
Neanthus 2 w 1483
We 1 w 1486
have 2 w 1490
instances 1 w 1499
in 26 w 1501
our 1 w 1504
own 4 w 1507
days 1 w 1511
I 5 w 1513
believe 1 w 1520
the 36 w 1523
man 2 w 1526
is 17 w 1528
still 1 w 1533
alive 1 w 1538
who 2 w 1541
paid 1 w 1545
120 1 w 1548
for 3 w 1551
the 37 w 1554
earthenware 1 w 1565
lamp 1 w 1569
of 15 w 1571
Epictetus 1 w 1580
the 39 w 1583
Stoic 1 w 1588
I 6 w 1590
suppose 1 w 1597
he 54 w 1599
thought 1 w 1606
he 55 w 1608
had 6 w 1611
only 2 w 1615
to 19 w 1617
read 1 w 1621
by 4 w 1623
the 40 w 1626
light 2 w 1631
of 16 w 1633
that 5 w 1637
lamp 2 w 1641
and 16 w 1645
the 41 w 1648
wisdom 1 w 1654
of 17 w 1656
Epictetus 2 w 1665
would 2 w 1670
be 9 w 1672
communicated 1 w 1684
to 20 w 1686
him 5 w 1689
in 27 w 1691
his 11 w 1694
dreams 1 w 1700
and 17 w 1704
he 58 w 1706
himself 1 w 1713
assume 1 w 1719
the 42 w 1722
likeness 1 w 1730
of 18 w 1732
that 6 w 1736
venerable 1 w 1745
sage 1 w 1749
And 1 w 1753
it 15 w 1755
was 5 w 1758
only 3 w 1762
a 130 w 1763
day 3 w 1766
or 8 w 1768
two 1 w 1771
ago 1 w 1774
that 7 w 1778
another 1 w 1785
enthusiast 1 w 1795
paid 2 w 1799
down 3 w 1803
250 1 w 1806
for 4 w 1809
the 44 w 1812
staff 1 w 1817
dropped 1 w 1824
by 5 w 1826
the 45 w 1829
Cynic 1 w 1834
Proteus 1 w 1841
See 1 w 1844
Peregrine 1 w 1853
in 29 w 1855
Notes 1 w 1860
when 1 w 1865
he 64 w 1867
leaped 1 w 1873
upon 5 w 1877
the 46 w 1880
pyre 1 w 1884
He 3 w 1887
treasures 1 w 1896
this 3 w 1900
relic 2 w 1905
and 18 w 1909
shows 1 w 1914
it 16 w 1916
off 2 w 1919
just 2 w 1923
as 16 w 1925
the 47 w 1928
people 1 w 1934
of 20 w 1936
Tegea 1 w 1941
do 7 w 1943
the 48 w 1946
hide 1 w 1950
of 21 w 1952
the 49 w 1955
Calydonian 1 w 1965
boar 1 w 1969
See 2 w 1973
Oeneus 1 w 1979
in 30 w 1981
Notes 2 w 1986
or 10 w 1989
the 50 w 1992
Thebans 1 w 1999
the 51 w 2002
bones 1 w 2007
of 22 w 2009
Geryon 1 w 2015
or 11 w 2018
the 52 w 2021
Memphians 1 w 2030
Isis 1 w 2034
hair 1 w 2039
Now 1 w 2043
the 53 w 2046
original 1 w 2054
owner 1 w 2059
of 23 w 2061
this 4 w 2065
precious 1 w 2073
staff 2 w 2078
was 6 w 2081
one 4 w 2084
who 3 w 2087
for 5 w 2090
ignorance 1 w 2099
and 19 w 2102
vulgarity 1 w 2111
would 3 w 2116
have 3 w 2120
borne 1 w 2125
away 1 w 2129
the 54 w 2132
palm 1 w 2136
from 3 w 2140
yourself 1 w 2148
My 1 w 2152
friend 1 w 2158
you 3 w 2162
are 2 w 2165
in 32 w 2167
a 160 w 2168
bad 1 w 2171
way 2 w 2174
a 163 w 2176
stick 1 w 2181
across 1 w 2187
the 55 w 2190
head 4 w 2194
is 23 w 2196
what 2 w 2200
you 4 w 2203
want 1 w 2207
They 1 w 2212
say 1 w 2215
that 8 w 2219
when 2 w 2223
Dionysius 1 w 2232
took 1 w 2236
to 22 w 2238
tragedy-writing 1 w 2253
he 79 w 2255
made 1 w 2259
such 2 w 2263
sad 1 w 2266
stuff 1 w 2271
of 24 w 2273
it 19 w 2275
that 9 w 2279
Philoxenus 1 w 2289
was 7 w 2292
more 1 w 2296
than 1 w 2300
once 2 w 2304
thrown 1 w 2310
into 3 w 2314
the 56 w 2317
quarries 1 w 2325
because 1 w 2332
he 81 w 2334
could 1 w 2339
not 5 w 2342
control 1 w 2349
his 14 w 2352
laughter 1 w 2360
Finding 1 w 2368
that 10 w 2372
his 15 w 2375
efforts 1 w 2382
only 4 w 2386
made 2 w 2390
him 7 w 2393
ridiculous 1 w 2403
Dionysius 2 w 2413
was 8 w 2416
at 21 w 2418
some 1 w 2422
pains 1 w 2427
to 24 w 2429
procure 1 w 2436
the 57 w 2439
tablets 1 w 2446
on 32 w 2448
which 2 w 2453
Aeschylashad 1 w 2465
been 3 w 2469
wont 1 w 2473
to 25 w 2475
write 1 w 2480
He 4 w 2483
looked 1 w 2489
to 26 w 2491
draw 1 w 2495
divine 2 w 2501
inspiration 1 w 2512
from 4 w 2516
them 1 w 2520
as 21 w 2523
it 21 w 2525
turned 1 w 2531
out 3 w 2534
however 2 w 2542
he 84 w 2545
now 1 w 2548
wrote 1 w 2553
considerably 1 w 2565
worse 1 w 2570
rubbish 1 w 2577
than 2 w 2581
before 1 w 2587
Among 1 w 2593
the 59 w 2596
contents 1 w 2604
of 25 w 2606
the 60 w 2609
tablets 2 w 2616
I 8 w 2617
may 1 w 2620
quote 1 w 2625
Twas 1 w 2631
Dionysius 3 w 2640
wife 1 w 2645
Doridion 1 w 2654
Here 1 w 2659
is 27 w 2661
another 2 w 2668
Most 1 w 2673
serviceable 1 w 2684
woman 1 w 2689
thou 3 w 2694
art 2 w 2697
gone 1 w 2701
Genuine 1 w 2709
tablet 3 w 2715
that 11 w 2719
and 20 w 2723
the 62 w 2726
next 1 w 2730
Men 1 w 2734
that 12 w 2738
are 3 w 2741
fools 1 w 2746
are 4 w 2749
their 1 w 2754
own 8 w 2757
folly 1 w 2762
s 182 w 2764
butt 1 w 2768
Taken 1 w 2774
with 2 w 2778
reference 1 w 2787
to 27 w 2789
yourself 2 w 2797
by 6 w 2800
the 64 w 2803
way 3 w 2806
nothing 1 w 2814
could 2 w 2819
be 13 w 2821
more 2 w 2825
to 28 w 2827
the 65 w 2830
point 2 w 2835
than 3 w 2839
this 5 w 2843
last 1 w 2847
line 1 w 2851
Dionysius 4 w 2861
s 188 w 2863
tablets 3 w 2870
deserved 1 w 2878
gilding 1 w 2885
if 3 w 2888
only 5 w 2892
for 8 w 2895
that 13 w 2899