Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Zeus Rants

Zeus Rants (37-38)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg018.perseus-eng2:37-38
Refs {'start': {'reference': '37', 'human_reference': 'Section 37'}, 'end': {'reference': '38', 'human_reference': 'Section 38'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

DAMIS And when can they find time for me, when they have so many cares, you say, and manage all creation, which is unlimited in its extent? That is why they have not yet paid.you back for all your false oaths and everything elseI dont want to be forced to deal in abuse like you, contrary to our stipulations : and yet I dont see what better manifestation of their providence they could have made than to crush your life out miserably, miserable sinner that you are! But it is clear that they are away from home, across the Ocean, no doubt, visiting the guileless Ethiopians.[*] At any rate it is their custom to go and dine with them continually, even self-invited at times.

TIMOCLES What can I say in reply to all this impudence, Damis ?

DAMIS Tell me what I wanted you to tell me long ago, how you were induced to believe that the gods exercise providence.

TIMOCLES In the first place the order of nature convinced me, the sun always going the same road and the moon likewise and the seasons changing and plants growing and living creatures being born, and these latter so cleverly devised that they can support life and move and think and walk and build houses and cobble shoesand all the rest of it; these seem to me to be works of providence.

DAMIS That is just the question, Timocles, and you are trying to beg it, for it is not yet proved that each of

v.2.p.149
these things is accomplished by providence. While I myself would say that recurrent phenomena are as you describe them, I need not, however, at once admit a conviction that they recur by some sort of providence, for it is possible that they began at random[*] and now take place with uniformity and regularity. But you call necessity order and then, forsooth, get angry if anyone does not follow you when you catalogue and extol the characteristics of these phenomena and think it a proof that each of them is ordered by providence. So, in the words of the comic poet,
Thats but a sorry answer ; try again.

Tokens

DAMIS 1 w 5
And 1 w 8
when 1 w 12
can 1 w 15
they 1 w 19
find 1 w 23
time 1 w 27
for 1 w 30
me 2 w 32
when 2 w 37
they 2 w 41
have 1 w 45
so 1 w 47
many 1 w 51
cares 1 w 56
you 1 w 60
say 1 w 63
and 1 w 67
manage 1 w 73
all 1 w 76
creation 1 w 84
which 1 w 90
is 1 w 92
unlimited 1 w 101
in 2 w 103
its 1 w 106
extent 1 w 112
That 1 w 117
is 2 w 119
why 1 w 122
they 3 w 126
have 2 w 130
not 1 w 133
yet 1 w 136
paid 1 w 140
you 2 w 144
back 1 w 148
for 2 w 151
all 2 w 154
your 1 w 158
false 1 w 163
oaths 1 w 168
and 2 w 171
everything 1 w 181
else 1 w 185
I 2 w 187
don 1 w 190
t 15 w 192
want 1 w 196
to 1 w 198
be 1 w 200
forced 1 w 206
to 2 w 208
deal 1 w 212
in 4 w 214
abuse 1 w 219
like 1 w 223
you 4 w 226
contrary 1 w 235
to 3 w 237
our 2 w 240
stipulations 1 w 252
and 3 w 256
yet 2 w 259
I 3 w 260
don 2 w 263
t 24 w 265
see 1 w 268
what 1 w 272
better 1 w 278
manifestation 1 w 291
of 1 w 293
their 1 w 298
providence 1 w 308
they 4 w 312
could 1 w 317
have 3 w 321
made 1 w 325
than 1 w 329
to 4 w 331
crush 1 w 336
your 2 w 340
life 1 w 344
out 1 w 347
miserably 1 w 356
miserable 1 w 366
sinner 1 w 372
that 1 w 376
you 6 w 379
are 2 w 382
But 1 w 386
it 3 w 388
is 5 w 390
clear 1 w 395
that 2 w 399
they 5 w 403
are 3 w 406
away 1 w 410
from 1 w 414
home 1 w 418
across 1 w 425
the 7 w 428
Ocean 1 w 433
no 2 w 436
doubt 1 w 441
visiting 1 w 450
the 8 w 453
guileless 1 w 462
Ethiopians 1 w 472
Iliad 1 w 478
1 1 w 480
423 1 w 484
At 1 w 487
any 2 w 490
rate 1 w 494
it 5 w 496
is 7 w 498
their 2 w 503
custom 1 w 509
to 6 w 511
go 1 w 513
and 4 w 516
dine 1 w 520
with 1 w 524
them 1 w 528
continually 1 w 539
even 1 w 544
self-invited 1 w 556
at 10 w 558
times 1 w 563
TIMOCLES 1 w 572
What 1 w 576
can 2 w 579
I 6 w 580
say 2 w 583
in 10 w 585
reply 1 w 590
to 7 w 592
all 4 w 595
this 1 w 599
impudence 1 w 608
Damis 1 w 614
DAMIS 2 w 620
Tell 1 w 624
me 5 w 626
what 2 w 630
I 8 w 631
wanted 1 w 637
you 7 w 640
to 8 w 642
tell 1 w 646
me 6 w 648
long 1 w 652
ago 1 w 655
how 1 w 659
you 8 w 662
were 1 w 666
induced 1 w 673
to 9 w 675
believe 1 w 682
that 3 w 686
the 11 w 689
gods 1 w 693
exercise 1 w 701
providence 2 w 711
TIMOCLES 2 w 720
In 1 w 722
the 12 w 725
first 1 w 730
place 1 w 735
the 13 w 738
order 1 w 743
of 2 w 745
nature 1 w 751
convinced 1 w 760
me 7 w 762
the 14 w 766
sun 1 w 769
always 1 w 775
going 1 w 780
the 15 w 783
same 1 w 787
road 1 w 791
and 5 w 794
the 16 w 797
moon 1 w 801
likewise 1 w 809
and 6 w 812
the 17 w 815
seasons 1 w 822
changing 1 w 830
and 7 w 833
plants 1 w 839
growing 1 w 846
and 8 w 849
living 1 w 855
creatures 1 w 864
being 1 w 869
born 1 w 873
and 9 w 877
these 1 w 882
latter 1 w 888
so 3 w 890
cleverly 1 w 898
devised 1 w 905
that 4 w 909
they 6 w 913
can 3 w 916
support 1 w 923
life 2 w 927
and 10 w 930
move 1 w 934
and 11 w 937
think 1 w 942
and 12 w 945
walk 1 w 949
and 13 w 952
build 1 w 957
houses 1 w 963
and 14 w 966
cobble 1 w 972
shoes 1 w 977
and 15 w 981
all 5 w 984
the 20 w 987
rest 1 w 991
of 3 w 993
it 8 w 995
these 2 w 1001
seem 1 w 1005
to 10 w 1007
me 9 w 1009
to 11 w 1011
be 5 w 1013
works 1 w 1018
of 4 w 1020
providence 3 w 1030
DAMIS 3 w 1036
That 2 w 1040
is 13 w 1042
just 1 w 1046
the 22 w 1049
question 1 w 1057
Timocles 1 w 1066
and 16 w 1070
you 9 w 1073
are 4 w 1076
trying 1 w 1082
to 12 w 1084
beg 1 w 1087
it 9 w 1089
for 4 w 1093
it 10 w 1095
is 14 w 1097
not 2 w 1100
yet 3 w 1103
proved 1 w 1109
that 5 w 1113
each 1 w 1117
of 5 w 1119
these 3 w 1124
things 1 w 1130
is 15 w 1132
accomplished 1 w 1144
by 1 w 1146
providence 4 w 1156
While 1 w 1162
I 12 w 1163
myself 1 w 1169
would 1 w 1174
say 3 w 1177
that 6 w 1181
recurrent 1 w 1190
phenomena 1 w 1199
are 5 w 1202
as 2 w 1204
you 10 w 1207
describe 1 w 1215
them 2 w 1219
I 13 w 1221
need 1 w 1225
not 3 w 1228
however 1 w 1236
at 21 w 1239
once 1 w 1243
admit 1 w 1248
a 97 w 1249
conviction 1 w 1259
that 7 w 1263
they 7 w 1267
recur 2 w 1272
by 2 w 1274
some 1 w 1278
sort 1 w 1282
of 6 w 1284
providence 5 w 1294
for 5 w 1298
it 12 w 1300
is 17 w 1302
possible 1 w 1310
that 8 w 1314
they 8 w 1318
began 1 w 1323
at 24 w 1325
random 1 w 1331
In 2 w 1333
my 2 w 1335
opinion 1 w 1342
ἄλλως 1 w 1347
contrasts 1 w 1356
with 2 w 1360
ὁμοίως 1 w 1366
καὶ 1 w 1369
κατὰ 1 w 1373
ταὐτά 1 w 1378
not 4 w 1382
with 3 w 1386
ὑπό 1 w 1389
τινος 1 w 1394
προμηθείας 1 w 1404
The 1 w 1408
idea 1 w 1412
is 18 w 1414
more 1 w 1418
fully 1 w 1423
and 18 w 1426
clearly 1 w 1433
presented 1 w 1442
in 22 w 1444
Lucretius 1 w 1453
1 2 w 1454
1024-1028 1 w 1464
and 19 w 1468
now 1 w 1471
take 1 w 1475
place 2 w 1480
with 4 w 1484
uniformity 1 w 1494
and 20 w 1497
regularity 1 w 1507
But 2 w 1511
you 11 w 1514
call 1 w 1518
necessity 1 w 1527
order 2 w 1533
and 21 w 1537
then 1 w 1541
forsooth 1 w 1550
get 1 w 1554
angry 1 w 1559
if 5 w 1561
anyone 1 w 1567
does 1 w 1571
not 5 w 1574
follow 1 w 1580
you 12 w 1583
when 3 w 1587
you 13 w 1590
catalogue 1 w 1599
and 22 w 1602
extol 1 w 1607
the 28 w 1610
characteristics 1 w 1625
of 7 w 1627
these 4 w 1632
phenomena 2 w 1641
and 23 w 1644
think 2 w 1649
it 19 w 1651
a 123 w 1652
proof 1 w 1657
that 9 w 1661
each 2 w 1665
of 9 w 1667
them 3 w 1671
is 20 w 1673
ordered 1 w 1680
by 3 w 1682
providence 6 w 1692
So 1 w 1695
in 24 w 1698
the 31 w 1701
words 1 w 1706
of 10 w 1708
the 32 w 1711
comic 1 w 1716
poet 1 w 1720
That 3 w 1725
s 89 w 1727
but 1 w 1730
a 127 w 1731
sorry 1 w 1736
answer 1 w 1742
try 2 w 1746
again 1 w 1751