Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The True History

The True History (2.20-2.23)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg012.perseus-eng4:2.20-2.23
Refs {'start': {'reference': '2.20', 'human_reference': 'Book 2 Section 20'}, 'end': {'reference': '2.23', 'human_reference': 'Book 2 Section 23'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '2'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Before many days had passed, I accosted the poet Homer, when we were both disengaged, and asked him, among other things, where he came from; it was still a burning question with us, I explained. He said he was aware that some brought him from Chios, others from Smyrna, and others again from Colophon; the fact was, he was a Babylonian, generally known not as Homer, but as Tigranes; but when later in life he was given as a homer or hostage to the Greeks, that name clung to him. Another of my questions was about the so-called spurious lines; had he written them, or not? He said they were all genuine; so I now knew what to think of the critics Zenodotus and Aristarchus, and all their lucubrations. Having got a categorical answer on that point, I tried him next on his reason for starting the Iliad at the wrath of Achilles; he said he had no exquisite reason; it had just come into his head that way. Another thing I wanted to know was whether he had composed the Odyssey before the Iliad, as generally believed. He said

v.2.p.162
this was not so. As to his reported blindness, I did not need to ask; he had his sight, so there was an end of that. It became a habit of mine, whenever I saw him at leisure, to go up and ask him things, and he answered quite readilyespecially after his acquittal; a libel suit had been brought against him by Thersites, on the ground of the ridicule to which he is subjected in the poem; Homer had briefed Odysseus, and been acquitted.

It was during our sojourn that Pythagoras arrived; he had undergone seven transmigrations, lived the lives of that number of animals, and completed his psychic travels. It was the entire right half of him that was gold. He was at once given the franchise, but the question was still pending whether he was to be known as Pythagoras or Euphorbus, Empedocles also came, scorched all over and baked right through; but not all his entreaties could gain him admittance.

The progress of time brought round the Games of the Dead. The umpires were Achilles, holding that office for the fifth, and Theseus for the seventh time. A full report would take too long; but I will summarize the events. The wrestling went to Carus the Heraclid, who won the garland from Odysseus. The boxing resulted in a tie, the pair being the Egyptian Areus, whose grave is in Corinth, and Epeus. For mixed boxing and wrestling they have no prize. Who won the flat race, I have forgotten. In poetry, Homer really did much the best, but the award was for Hesiod. All prizes were plaited wreaths of peacock feathers.

Just after the Games were over, news came that the Damned had broken their fetters, overpowered their guard, and were on the point of invading the island, the ringleaders being Phalaris of Agrigentum, Busiris the Egyptian, Diomedes the Thracian, Sciron, and Pityocamptes. Rhadamanthus at once drew up the Heroes on the beach, giving the command to Theseus, Achilles, and Ajax Telamonius, now in his right senses. The battle was

v.2.p.163
fought, and won by the Heroes, thanks especially to Achilles. Socrates, who was in the right wing, distinguished himself still more than in his lifetime at Delium, standing firm and showing no sign of trepidation as the enemy came on; he was afterwards given as a reward of valour a large and beautiful park in the outskirts, to which he invited his friends for conversation, naming it the Post-mortem Academy.

Tokens

Before 1 w 6
many 1 w 10
days 1 w 14
had 1 w 17
passed 1 w 23
I 1 w 25
accosted 1 w 33
the 1 w 36
poet 1 w 40
Homer 1 w 45
when 1 w 50
we 1 w 52
were 1 w 56
both 1 w 60
disengaged 1 w 70
and 1 w 74
asked 1 w 79
him 1 w 82
among 1 w 88
other 1 w 93
things 1 w 99
where 1 w 105
he 5 w 107
came 1 w 111
from 1 w 115
it 1 w 118
was 1 w 121
still 1 w 126
a 12 w 127
burning 1 w 134
question 1 w 142
with 1 w 146
us 1 w 148
I 2 w 150
explained 1 w 159
He 1 w 162
said 1 w 166
he 6 w 168
was 2 w 171
aware 1 w 176
that 1 w 180
some 1 w 184
brought 1 w 191
him 2 w 194
from 2 w 198
Chios 1 w 203
others 1 w 210
from 3 w 214
Smyrna 1 w 220
and 2 w 224
others 2 w 230
again 1 w 235
from 4 w 239
Colophon 1 w 247
the 5 w 251
fact 1 w 255
was 3 w 258
he 10 w 261
was 4 w 264
a 26 w 265
Babylonian 1 w 275
generally 1 w 285
known 1 w 290
not 1 w 293
as 7 w 295
Homer 2 w 300
but 1 w 304
as 8 w 306
Tigranes 1 w 314
but 2 w 318
when 2 w 322
later 1 w 327
in 5 w 329
life 1 w 333
he 12 w 335
was 5 w 338
given 1 w 343
as 10 w 345
a 36 w 346
homer 1 w 351
or 2 w 353
hostage 1 w 360
to 1 w 362
the 6 w 365
Greeks 1 w 371
that 2 w 376
name 1 w 380
clung 1 w 385
to 2 w 387
him 3 w 390
Another 1 w 398
of 1 w 400
my 2 w 402
questions 1 w 411
was 6 w 414
about 1 w 419
the 8 w 422
so-called 1 w 431
spurious 1 w 439
lines 1 w 444
had 2 w 448
he 16 w 450
written 1 w 457
them 1 w 461
or 3 w 464
not 3 w 467
He 2 w 470
said 2 w 474
they 1 w 478
were 2 w 482
all 3 w 485
genuine 1 w 492
so 3 w 495
I 3 w 496
now 2 w 499
knew 1 w 503
what 1 w 507
to 3 w 509
think 1 w 514
of 2 w 516
the 11 w 519
critics 1 w 526
Zenodotus 1 w 535
and 3 w 538
Aristarchus 1 w 549
and 4 w 553
all 4 w 556
their 1 w 561
lucubrations 1 w 573
Having 1 w 580
got 1 w 583
a 53 w 584
categorical 1 w 595
answer 1 w 601
on 7 w 603
that 3 w 607
point 1 w 612
I 4 w 614
tried 1 w 619
him 4 w 622
next 1 w 626
on 8 w 628
his 1 w 631
reason 1 w 637
for 2 w 640
starting 1 w 648
the 13 w 651
Iliad 1 w 656
at 8 w 658
the 14 w 661
wrath 1 w 666
of 3 w 668
Achilles 1 w 676
he 23 w 679
said 3 w 683
he 24 w 685
had 3 w 688
no 7 w 690
exquisite 1 w 699
reason 2 w 705
it 6 w 708
had 4 w 711
just 1 w 715
come 1 w 719
into 1 w 723
his 2 w 726
head 1 w 730
that 4 w 734
way 1 w 737
Another 2 w 745
thing 2 w 750
I 6 w 751
wanted 1 w 757
to 5 w 759
know 2 w 763
was 7 w 766
whether 1 w 773
he 29 w 775
had 5 w 778
composed 1 w 786
the 17 w 789
Odyssey 1 w 796
before 1 w 802
the 18 w 805
Iliad 2 w 810
as 15 w 813
generally 2 w 822
believed 1 w 830
He 3 w 833
said 4 w 837
this 1 w 841
was 8 w 844
not 5 w 847
so 6 w 849
As 1 w 852
to 6 w 854
his 4 w 857
reported 1 w 865
blindness 1 w 874
I 8 w 876
did 1 w 879
not 6 w 882
need 1 w 886
to 7 w 888
ask 2 w 891
he 32 w 894
had 6 w 897
his 5 w 900
sight 1 w 905
so 7 w 908
there 1 w 913
was 9 w 916
an 10 w 918
end 1 w 921
of 4 w 923
that 5 w 927
It 1 w 930
became 1 w 936
a 84 w 937
habit 1 w 942
of 5 w 944
mine 1 w 948
whenever 1 w 957
I 10 w 958
saw 1 w 961
him 5 w 964
at 12 w 966
leisure 1 w 973
to 8 w 976
go 3 w 978
up 1 w 980
and 5 w 983
ask 3 w 986
him 6 w 989
things 2 w 995
and 6 w 999
he 35 w 1001
answered 1 w 1009
quite 1 w 1014
readily 1 w 1021
especially 1 w 1032
after 1 w 1037
his 6 w 1040
acquittal 1 w 1049
a 97 w 1051
libel 1 w 1056
suit 1 w 1060
had 7 w 1063
been 1 w 1067
brought 2 w 1074
against 1 w 1081
him 7 w 1084
by 2 w 1086
Thersites 1 w 1095
on 11 w 1098
the 20 w 1101
ground 1 w 1107
of 6 w 1109
the 21 w 1112
ridicule 1 w 1120
to 9 w 1122
which 1 w 1127
he 39 w 1129
is 11 w 1131
subjected 1 w 1140
in 18 w 1142
the 22 w 1145
poem 1 w 1149
Homer 3 w 1155
had 8 w 1158
briefed 1 w 1165
Odysseus 1 w 1173
and 7 w 1177
been 2 w 1181
acquitted 1 w 1190
It 2 w 1193
was 10 w 1196
during 1 w 1202
our 1 w 1205
sojourn 1 w 1212
that 6 w 1216
Pythagoras 1 w 1226
arrived 1 w 1233
he 41 w 1236
had 9 w 1239
undergone 1 w 1248
seven 1 w 1253
transmigrations 1 w 1268
lived 1 w 1274
the 23 w 1277
lives 1 w 1282
of 7 w 1284
that 7 w 1288
number 1 w 1294
of 8 w 1296
animals 1 w 1303
and 8 w 1307
completed 1 w 1316
his 7 w 1319
psychic 1 w 1326
travels 1 w 1333
It 3 w 1336
was 11 w 1339
the 24 w 1342
entire 1 w 1348
right 1 w 1353
half 1 w 1357
of 9 w 1359
him 8 w 1362
that 8 w 1366
was 12 w 1369
gold 1 w 1373
He 4 w 1376
was 13 w 1379
at 17 w 1381
once 1 w 1385
given 2 w 1390
the 25 w 1393
franchise 1 w 1402
but 3 w 1406
the 26 w 1409
question 3 w 1417
was 14 w 1420
still 2 w 1425
pending 1 w 1432
whether 2 w 1439
he 48 w 1441
was 15 w 1444
to 10 w 1446
be 8 w 1448
known 2 w 1453
as 27 w 1455
Pythagoras 2 w 1465
or 10 w 1467
Euphorbus 1 w 1476
Empedocles 1 w 1487
also 1 w 1491
came 3 w 1495
scorched 1 w 1504
all 7 w 1507
over 1 w 1511
and 9 w 1514
baked 1 w 1519
right 2 w 1524
through 1 w 1531
but 4 w 1535
not 7 w 1538
all 8 w 1541
his 9 w 1544
entreaties 1 w 1554
could 1 w 1559
gain 3 w 1563
him 9 w 1566
admittance 1 w 1576
The 2 w 1580
progress 1 w 1588
of 10 w 1590
time 1 w 1594
brought 3 w 1601
round 2 w 1606
the 28 w 1609
Games 1 w 1614
of 11 w 1616
the 29 w 1619
Dead 1 w 1623
The 3 w 1627
umpires 1 w 1634
were 4 w 1638
Achilles 2 w 1646
holding 1 w 1654
that 9 w 1658
office 1 w 1664
for 4 w 1667
the 30 w 1670
fifth 1 w 1675
and 10 w 1679
Theseus 1 w 1686
for 5 w 1689
the 31 w 1692
seventh 1 w 1699
time 2 w 1703
A 7 w 1705
full 1 w 1709
report 2 w 1715
would 1 w 1720
take 1 w 1724
too 1 w 1727
long 1 w 1731
but 5 w 1735
I 13 w 1736
will 1 w 1740
summarize 1 w 1749
the 32 w 1752
events 1 w 1758
The 5 w 1762
wrestling 1 w 1771
went 1 w 1775
to 12 w 1777
Carus 1 w 1782
the 33 w 1785
Heraclid 1 w 1793
who 1 w 1797
won 1 w 1800
the 34 w 1803
garland 1 w 1810
from 5 w 1814
Odysseus 2 w 1822
The 6 w 1826
boxing 1 w 1832
resulted 1 w 1840
in 25 w 1842
a 149 w 1843
tie 2 w 1846
the 35 w 1850
pair 1 w 1854
being 1 w 1859
the 36 w 1862
Egyptian 1 w 1870
Areus 1 w 1875
whose 1 w 1881
grave 1 w 1886
is 15 w 1888
in 27 w 1890
Corinth 1 w 1897
and 12 w 1901
Epeus 1 w 1906
For 1 w 1910
mixed 1 w 1915
boxing 2 w 1921
and 13 w 1924
wrestling 2 w 1933
they 2 w 1937
have 1 w 1941
no 14 w 1943
prize 1 w 1948
Who 1 w 1952
won 2 w 1955
the 38 w 1958
flat 1 w 1962
race 1 w 1966
I 14 w 1968
have 2 w 1972
forgotten 1 w 1981
In 1 w 1984
poetry 1 w 1990
Homer 4 w 1996
really 1 w 2002
did 2 w 2005
much 1 w 2009
the 39 w 2012
best 1 w 2016
but 6 w 2020
the 40 w 2023
award 1 w 2028
was 16 w 2031
for 7 w 2034
Hesiod 1 w 2040
All 1 w 2044
prizes 1 w 2050
were 5 w 2054
plaited 1 w 2061
wreaths 1 w 2068
of 13 w 2070
peacock 1 w 2077
feathers 1 w 2085
Just 1 w 2090
after 2 w 2095
the 42 w 2098
Games 2 w 2103
were 6 w 2107
over 2 w 2111
news 1 w 2116
came 4 w 2120
that 10 w 2124
the 43 w 2127
Damned 1 w 2133
had 10 w 2136
broken 1 w 2142
their 2 w 2147
fetters 1 w 2154
overpowered 1 w 2166
their 3 w 2171
guard 1 w 2176
and 14 w 2180
were 8 w 2184
on 19 w 2186
the 46 w 2189
point 2 w 2194
of 14 w 2196
invading 1 w 2204
the 47 w 2207
island 1 w 2213
the 48 w 2217
ringleaders 1 w 2228
being 2 w 2233
Phalaris 1 w 2241
of 15 w 2243
Agrigentum 1 w 2253
Busiris 1 w 2261
the 49 w 2264
Egyptian 2 w 2272
Diomedes 1 w 2281
the 50 w 2284
Thracian 1 w 2292
Sciron 1 w 2299
and 16 w 2303
Pityocamptes 1 w 2315
Rhadamanthus 1 w 2328
at 24 w 2330
once 2 w 2334
drew 1 w 2338
up 3 w 2340
the 51 w 2343
Heroes 1 w 2349
on 22 w 2351
the 52 w 2354
beach 1 w 2359
giving 1 w 2366
the 53 w 2369
command 1 w 2376
to 13 w 2378
Theseus 2 w 2385
Achilles 3 w 2394
and 18 w 2398
Ajax 1 w 2402
Telamonius 1 w 2412
now 5 w 2416
in 37 w 2418
his 10 w 2421
right 3 w 2426
senses 1 w 2432
The 8 w 2436
battle 1 w 2442
was 17 w 2445
fought 1 w 2451
and 19 w 2455
won 3 w 2458
by 3 w 2460
the 54 w 2463
Heroes 2 w 2469
thanks 1 w 2476
especially 2 w 2486
to 14 w 2488
Achilles 4 w 2496
Socrates 1 w 2505
who 3 w 2509
was 18 w 2512
in 38 w 2514
the 55 w 2517
right 4 w 2522
wing 1 w 2526
distinguished 1 w 2540
himself 1 w 2547
still 3 w 2552
more 1 w 2556
than 2 w 2560
in 41 w 2562
his 11 w 2565
lifetime 1 w 2573
at 27 w 2575
Delium 1 w 2581
standing 1 w 2590
firm 1 w 2594
and 21 w 2597
showing 1 w 2604
no 16 w 2606
sign 1 w 2610
of 16 w 2612
trepidation 1 w 2623
as 32 w 2625
the 56 w 2628
enemy 1 w 2633
came 5 w 2637
on 26 w 2639
he 87 w 2642
was 19 w 2645
afterwards 1 w 2655
given 3 w 2660
as 34 w 2662
a 212 w 2663
reward 1 w 2669
of 17 w 2671
valour 1 w 2677
a 215 w 2678
large 1 w 2683
and 22 w 2686
beautiful 1 w 2695
park 1 w 2699
in 44 w 2701
the 57 w 2704
outskirts 1 w 2713
to 15 w 2716
which 2 w 2721
he 89 w 2723
invited 1 w 2730
his 12 w 2733
friends 1 w 2740
for 8 w 2743
conversation 1 w 2755
naming 1 w 2762
it 17 w 2764
the 58 w 2767
Post-mortem 1 w 2778
Academy 1 w 2785