Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / A True Story

A True Story (1.2-1.5)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg012.perseus-eng2:1.2-1.5
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.2', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 2'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.5', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 5'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

It would be appropriate recreation for them if they were to take up the sort of reading that, instead of affording just pure amusement based on wit and humour, also boasts a little food for thought that the Muses would not altogether spurn; and I think they will consider the present work something of the kind. They will find it enticing not only for the novelty of its subject, for the humour of its plan and because I tell all kinds of lies in a plausible and specious way, but also because everything in my story is a more or less comical parody of one or

v.1.p.251
another of the poets, historians and philosophers of old, who have written much that smacks of miracles and fables. I would cite them by name, were it not that you yourself will recognise them from your reading.

One of them is Ctesias, son of Ctesiochus, of Cnidos, who wrote a great deal about India and its characteristics that he had never seen himself nor heard from anyone else with a reputation for truthfulness. Iambulus also wrote much that was strange about the countries in the great sea: he made up a falsehood that is patent to everybody, but wrote a story that is not uninteresting for all that. [*] Many others, with the same intent, have written about imaginary travels and journeys of theirs, telling of huge beasts, cruel men and strange ways of living. Their guide and instructor in this sort of charlatanry is Homers Odysseus, who tells Alcinous and his court about winds in bondage, one-eyed men, carfnibals and savages; also about animals with many heads, and transformations of his comrades wrought with drugs. This stuff, and much more like it, is what our friend humbugged the illiterate Phaeacians with!

Well, on reading all these authors, I did not find much fault with them for their lying, as I saw that this was already a common practice even among men who profess philosophy.[*] I did wonder, though, that they thought that they could write untruths and not get caught at it. Therefore, as I myself, thanks to my vanity, was eager to hand something

v.1.p.253
down to posterity, that I might not be the only one excluded from the privileges of poetic licence, and as I had nothing true to tell, not having had any adventures of significance, I took to lying. But my lying is far more honest than theirs, for though I tell the truth in nothing else, I shall at least be truthful in saying that I ama liar. I think I can escape the censure of the world by my own admission that I am not telling a word of truth. Be it understood, then, that I am writing about things which I have neither seen nor had to do with nor learned from otherswhich, in fact, do not exist at all and, in the nature of things, cannot exist. [*] Therefore my readers should on no account believe in them.

Once upon a time, setting out from the Pillars of Hercules and heading for the western ocean with a fair wind, I went a-voyaging. The motive and purpose of my journey lay in my intellectual activity and desire for adventure, and in my wish to find out what the end of the ocean was, and who the people were that lived on the other side. On this account I put aboard a good store of provisions, stowed water enough, enlisted in the venture fifty of my acquaintances who were like-minded with myself, got together also a great quantity of arms, shipped the best sailing-master to be had at a big inducement, and put my boatshe was a pinnacein trim for a long and difficult voyage.

Tokens

It 1 w 2
would 1 w 7
be 1 w 9
appropriate 1 w 20
recreation 1 w 30
for 1 w 33
them 1 w 37
if 1 w 39
they 1 w 43
were 1 w 47
to 1 w 49
take 1 w 53
up 1 w 55
the 3 w 58
sort 1 w 62
of 1 w 64
reading 1 w 71
that 1 w 75
instead 1 w 83
of 2 w 85
affording 1 w 94
just 1 w 98
pure 1 w 102
amusement 1 w 111
based 1 w 116
on 2 w 118
wit 1 w 121
and 1 w 124
humour 1 w 130
also 1 w 135
boasts 1 w 141
a 14 w 142
little 1 w 148
food 1 w 152
for 3 w 155
thought 1 w 162
that 2 w 166
the 4 w 169
Muses 1 w 174
would 2 w 179
not 1 w 182
altogether 1 w 192
spurn 1 w 197
and 2 w 201
I 2 w 202
think 1 w 207
they 2 w 211
will 1 w 215
consider 1 w 223
the 7 w 226
present 1 w 233
work 1 w 237
something 1 w 246
of 3 w 248
the 8 w 251
kind 1 w 255
They 1 w 260
will 2 w 264
find 1 w 268
it 3 w 270
enticing 1 w 278
not 2 w 281
only 1 w 285
for 4 w 288
the 9 w 291
novelty 1 w 298
of 4 w 300
its 1 w 303
subject 1 w 310
for 5 w 314
the 10 w 317
humour 2 w 323
of 5 w 325
its 2 w 328
plan 1 w 332
and 3 w 335
because 1 w 342
I 3 w 343
tell 1 w 347
all 1 w 350
kinds 1 w 355
of 6 w 357
lies 1 w 361
in 10 w 363
a 22 w 364
plausible 1 w 373
and 4 w 376
specious 1 w 384
way 1 w 387
but 1 w 391
also 2 w 395
because 2 w 402
everything 1 w 412
in 12 w 414
my 1 w 416
story 1 w 421
is 1 w 423
a 28 w 424
more 1 w 428
or 10 w 430
less 1 w 434
comical 1 w 441
parody 1 w 447
of 7 w 449
one 1 w 452
or 11 w 454
another 1 w 461
of 8 w 463
the 12 w 466
poets 1 w 471
historians 1 w 482
and 5 w 485
philosophers 1 w 497
of 9 w 499
old 1 w 502
who 1 w 506
have 1 w 510
written 1 w 517
much 1 w 521
that 3 w 525
smacks 1 w 531
of 10 w 533
miracles 1 w 541
and 6 w 544
fables 1 w 550
I 4 w 552
would 3 w 557
cite 1 w 561
them 2 w 565
by 1 w 567
name 1 w 571
were 2 w 576
it 8 w 578
not 4 w 581
that 4 w 585
you 1 w 588
yourself 1 w 596
will 3 w 600
recognise 1 w 609
them 3 w 613
from 1 w 617
your 2 w 621
reading 2 w 628
One 1 w 632
of 11 w 634
them 4 w 638
is 4 w 640
Ctesias 1 w 647
son 1 w 651
of 12 w 653
Ctesiochus 1 w 663
of 13 w 666
Cnidos 1 w 672
who 2 w 676
wrote 1 w 681
a 44 w 682
great 1 w 687
deal 1 w 691
about 1 w 696
India 1 w 701
and 7 w 704
its 3 w 707
characteristics 1 w 722
that 5 w 726
he 18 w 728
had 1 w 731
never 1 w 736
seen 1 w 740
himself 1 w 747
nor 1 w 750
heard 1 w 755
from 2 w 759
anyone 1 w 765
else 1 w 769
with 1 w 773
a 56 w 774
reputation 1 w 784
for 6 w 787
truthfulness 1 w 799
Iambulus 1 w 808
also 3 w 812
wrote 2 w 817
much 2 w 821
that 6 w 825
was 1 w 828
strange 1 w 835
about 2 w 840
the 16 w 843
countries 1 w 852
in 14 w 854
the 17 w 857
great 2 w 862
sea 1 w 865
he 22 w 868
made 1 w 872
up 2 w 874
a 67 w 875
falsehood 1 w 884
that 7 w 888
is 6 w 890
patent 1 w 896
to 5 w 898
everybody 1 w 907
but 2 w 911
wrote 3 w 916
a 71 w 917
story 2 w 922
that 8 w 926
is 7 w 928
not 5 w 931
uninteresting 1 w 944
for 7 w 947
all 2 w 950
that 9 w 954
The 2 w 958
writings 1 w 966
of 14 w 968
Ctesias 2 w 975
and 8 w 978
Iambulus 2 w 986
are 1 w 989
lost 1 w 993
also 4 w 998
those 1 w 1003
of 15 w 1005
Antonius 1 w 1013
Diogenes 1 w 1021
whose 1 w 1027
story 3 w 1032
On 2 w 1035
the 18 w 1038
Wonders 1 w 1045
beyond 1 w 1051
Thule 1 w 1056
was 2 w 1060
according 1 w 1069
to 9 w 1071
Photius 1 w 1078
Bibb 1 w 1083
cod 1 w 1088
166 1 w 1092
111 1 w 1096
b 20 w 1097
the 19 w 1101
fountain-head 1 w 1114
of 16 w 1116
Lucian 1 w 1122
s 81 w 1124
tale 1 w 1128
Many 1 w 1133
others 1 w 1139
with 2 w 1144
the 21 w 1147
same 1 w 1151
intent 1 w 1157
have 2 w 1162
written 2 w 1169
about 3 w 1174
imaginary 1 w 1183
travels 1 w 1190
and 9 w 1193
journeys 1 w 1201
of 17 w 1203
theirs 1 w 1209
telling 1 w 1217
of 18 w 1219
huge 1 w 1223
beasts 1 w 1229
cruel 1 w 1235
men 2 w 1238
and 10 w 1241
strange 2 w 1248
ways 1 w 1252
of 19 w 1254
living 1 w 1260
Their 1 w 1266
guide 1 w 1271
and 11 w 1274
instructor 1 w 1284
in 25 w 1286
this 1 w 1290
sort 2 w 1294
of 20 w 1296
charlatanry 1 w 1307
is 9 w 1309
Homer 1 w 1314
s 95 w 1316
Odysseus 1 w 1324
who 4 w 1328
tells 1 w 1333
Alcinous 1 w 1341
and 12 w 1344
his 3 w 1347
court 1 w 1352
about 4 w 1357
winds 1 w 1362
in 28 w 1364
bondage 1 w 1371
one-eyed 1 w 1380
men 3 w 1383
carfnibals 1 w 1394
and 13 w 1397
savages 1 w 1404
also 5 w 1409
about 5 w 1414
animals 1 w 1421
with 3 w 1425
many 1 w 1429
heads 1 w 1434
and 14 w 1438
transformations 1 w 1453
of 21 w 1455
his 4 w 1458
comrades 1 w 1466
wrought 1 w 1473
with 4 w 1477
drugs 1 w 1482
This 1 w 1487
stuff 1 w 1492
and 15 w 1496
much 3 w 1500
more 2 w 1504
like 1 w 1508
it 16 w 1510
is 13 w 1513
what 1 w 1517
our 7 w 1520
friend 1 w 1526
humbugged 1 w 1535
the 23 w 1538
illiterate 1 w 1548
Phaeacians 1 w 1558
with 5 w 1562
Well 1 w 1567
on 15 w 1570
reading 3 w 1577
all 3 w 1580
these 1 w 1585
authors 1 w 1592
I 8 w 1594
did 1 w 1597
not 6 w 1600
find 2 w 1604
much 4 w 1608
fault 1 w 1613
with 6 w 1617
them 5 w 1621
for 9 w 1624
their 2 w 1629
lying 1 w 1634
as 8 w 1637
I 9 w 1638
saw 1 w 1641
that 10 w 1645
this 2 w 1649
was 3 w 1652
already 1 w 1659
a 136 w 1660
common 1 w 1666
practice 1 w 1674
even 1 w 1678
among 1 w 1683
men 4 w 1686
who 5 w 1689
profess 1 w 1696
philosophy 1 w 1706
A 3 w 1708
slap 1 w 1712
at 21 w 1714
Plato 1 w 1719
s 128 w 1721
Republic 1 w 1729
x 1 w 1731
614 1 w 1735
A 4 w 1736
seg 1 w 1739
as 10 w 1744
the 27 w 1747
scholiast 1 w 1756
says 1 w 1760
I 10 w 1762
did 2 w 1765
wonder 1 w 1771
though 2 w 1778
that 11 w 1783
they 3 w 1787
thought 2 w 1794
that 12 w 1798
they 4 w 1802
could 1 w 1807
write 1 w 1812
untruths 1 w 1820
and 16 w 1823
not 7 w 1826
get 2 w 1829
caught 1 w 1835
at 25 w 1837
it 21 w 1839
Therefore 1 w 1849
as 12 w 1852
I 11 w 1853
myself 1 w 1859
thanks 1 w 1866
to 12 w 1868
my 3 w 1870
vanity 1 w 1876
was 4 w 1880
eager 1 w 1885
to 13 w 1887
hand 1 w 1891
something 2 w 1900
down 1 w 1904
to 14 w 1906
posterity 1 w 1915
that 13 w 1920
I 12 w 1921
might 1 w 1926
not 8 w 1929
be 6 w 1931
the 30 w 1934
only 2 w 1938
one 4 w 1941
excluded 1 w 1949
from 3 w 1953
the 31 w 1956
privileges 1 w 1966
of 23 w 1968
poetic 1 w 1974
licence 1 w 1981
and 18 w 1985
as 14 w 1987
I 13 w 1988
had 2 w 1991
nothing 1 w 1998
true 1 w 2002
to 15 w 2004
tell 4 w 2008
not 10 w 2012
having 1 w 2018
had 3 w 2021
any 4 w 2024
adventures 1 w 2034
of 24 w 2036
significance 1 w 2048
I 14 w 2050
took 1 w 2054
to 17 w 2056
lying 2 w 2061
But 1 w 2065
my 4 w 2067
lying 3 w 2072
is 15 w 2074
far 1 w 2077
more 3 w 2081
honest 1 w 2087
than 2 w 2091
theirs 2 w 2097
for 11 w 2101
though 4 w 2107
I 15 w 2108
tell 5 w 2112
the 33 w 2115
truth 3 w 2120
in 37 w 2122
nothing 2 w 2129
else 2 w 2133
I 16 w 2135
shall 1 w 2140
at 27 w 2142
least 1 w 2147
be 7 w 2149
truthful 2 w 2157
in 39 w 2159
saying 1 w 2165
that 14 w 2169
I 17 w 2170
ama 1 w 2173
liar 1 w 2177
I 18 w 2179
think 2 w 2184
I 19 w 2185
can 2 w 2188
escape 1 w 2194
the 34 w 2197
censure 1 w 2204
of 25 w 2206
the 35 w 2209
world 1 w 2214
by 2 w 2216
my 5 w 2218
own 2 w 2221
admission 1 w 2230
that 15 w 2234
I 20 w 2235
am 8 w 2237
not 12 w 2240
telling 2 w 2247
a 180 w 2248
word 1 w 2252
of 26 w 2254
truth 5 w 2259
Be 1 w 2262
it 24 w 2264
understood 1 w 2274
then 1 w 2279
that 16 w 2284
I 21 w 2285
am 9 w 2287
writing 2 w 2294
about 6 w 2299
things 1 w 2305
which 1 w 2310
I 22 w 2311
have 3 w 2315
neither 1 w 2322
seen 2 w 2326
nor 2 w 2329
had 4 w 2332
to 19 w 2334
do 3 w 2336
with 7 w 2340
nor 3 w 2343
learned 1 w 2350
from 4 w 2354
others 2 w 2360
which 2 w 2366
in 45 w 2369
fact 1 w 2373
do 4 w 2376
not 13 w 2379
exist 1 w 2384
at 31 w 2386
all 5 w 2389
and 19 w 2392
in 46 w 2395
the 39 w 2398
nature 1 w 2404
of 27 w 2406
things 2 w 2412
cannot 1 w 2419
exist 2 w 2424
Compare 1 w 2432
the 40 w 2435
protestations 1 w 2448
of 28 w 2450
Ctesias 3 w 2457
and 20 w 2460
of 29 w 2462
Antonius 2 w 2470
Diogenes 2 w 2478
Phot 2 w 2483
cod 2 w 2487
72 1 w 2490
49-50 1 w 2496
166 2 w 2500
109 1 w 2504
b 33 w 2505
Therefore 2 w 2516
my 6 w 2518
readers 1 w 2525
should 1 w 2531
on 25 w 2533
no 20 w 2535
account 1 w 2542
believe 1 w 2549
in 48 w 2551
them 6 w 2555
Once 1 w 2560
upon 1 w 2564
a 199 w 2565
time 1 w 2569
setting 1 w 2577
out 7 w 2580
from 5 w 2584
the 42 w 2587
Pillars 1 w 2594
of 30 w 2596
Hercules 1 w 2604
and 21 w 2607
heading 1 w 2614
for 13 w 2617
the 43 w 2620
western 1 w 2627
ocean 1 w 2632
with 8 w 2636
a 204 w 2637
fair 1 w 2641
wind 2 w 2645
I 23 w 2647
went 1 w 2651
a-voyaging 1 w 2661
The 6 w 2665
motive 1 w 2671
and 22 w 2674
purpose 1 w 2681
of 31 w 2683
my 7 w 2685
journey 2 w 2692
lay 1 w 2695
in 53 w 2697
my 8 w 2699
intellectual 1 w 2711
activity 1 w 2719
and 23 w 2722
desire 1 w 2728
for 14 w 2731
adventure 2 w 2740
and 24 w 2744
in 55 w 2746
my 9 w 2748
wish 1 w 2752
to 21 w 2754
find 3 w 2758
out 8 w 2761
what 2 w 2765
the 44 w 2768
end 2 w 2771
of 32 w 2773
the 45 w 2776
ocean 2 w 2781
was 5 w 2784
and 25 w 2788
who 6 w 2791
the 46 w 2794
people 1 w 2800
were 3 w 2804
that 17 w 2808
lived 1 w 2813
on 27 w 2815
the 47 w 2818
other 4 w 2823
side 2 w 2827
On 4 w 2830
this 3 w 2834
account 2 w 2841
I 24 w 2842
put 2 w 2845
aboard 1 w 2851
a 223 w 2852
good 1 w 2856
store 1 w 2861
of 33 w 2863
provisions 1 w 2873
stowed 1 w 2880
water 1 w 2885
enough 1 w 2891
enlisted 1 w 2900
in 57 w 2902
the 49 w 2905
venture 3 w 2912
fifty 1 w 2917
of 34 w 2919
my 10 w 2921
acquaintances 1 w 2934
who 7 w 2937
were 4 w 2941
like-minded 1 w 2952
with 9 w 2956
myself 2 w 2962
got 1 w 2966
together 2 w 2974
also 6 w 2978
a 229 w 2979
great 3 w 2984
quantity 1 w 2992
of 35 w 2994
arms 1 w 2998
shipped 1 w 3006
the 51 w 3009
best 1 w 3013
sailing-master 1 w 3027
to 25 w 3029
be 10 w 3031
had 5 w 3034
at 38 w 3036
a 237 w 3037
big 1 w 3040
inducement 1 w 3050
and 26 w 3054
put 3 w 3057
my 12 w 3059
boat 1 w 3063
she 1 w 3067
was 6 w 3070
a 241 w 3071
pinnace 1 w 3078
in 63 w 3081
trim 1 w 3085
for 15 w 3088
a 243 w 3089
long 1 w 3093
and 27 w 3096
difficult 1 w 3105
voyage 1 w 3111