Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / The Hall

The Hall (19-20)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0062.tlg009.perseus-eng4:19-20
Refs {'start': {'reference': '19', 'human_reference': 'Section 19'}, 'end': {'reference': '20', 'human_reference': 'Section 20'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Compare the story of the Sirens with that of the Gorgons, if you would know how insignificant is the power of words in comparison with that of visible objects. The enchantments of the former were at the best a matter of time; they did but flatter the ear with pleasing songs; if the mariner landed, he remained long on their hands, and it has even happened to them to be disregarded altogether. But the beauty of the Gorgons, irresistible in might, won its way to the inmost soul, and wrought amazement and dumbness in the beholder; admiration (so the legend goes) turned him to stone. All that my opponent has just said about the peacock illustrates my point: that bird charms not the ear, but the eye. Take a swan, take a nightingale, and set her singing: now put a silent peacock at her side, and I will tell you which bird has the attention of the company. The songstress may go hang now; so invincible a thing is the pleasure of the eyes. Shall I call evidence?

A sage, then, shall be my witness, how far mightier are the things of the eye than those of the ear. Usher, call me Herodotus, son of Lyxes, of Halicarnassus.—Ah, since he has been so obliging as to hear the summons, let him step into the box. You will excuse the Ionic dialect; it is his way.’

Gentlemen of the jury, the Theory hath spoken sooth. Give good heed to that he saith, how sight is a better thing

v.4.p.20
than hearing; for a man shall sooner trust bis eyes than bis ears.

'You hear him, gentlemen? He gives the preference to sight, and rightly. For words have wings; they are no sooner out of the mouth than they take flight and are lost: but the delight of the eyes is ever present, ever draws the beholder to itself.

Tokens

Compare 1 w 7
the 1 w 10
story 1 w 15
of 1 w 17
the 2 w 20
Sirens 1 w 26
with 1 w 30
that 1 w 34
of 2 w 36
the 3 w 39
Gorgons 1 w 46
if 1 w 49
you 1 w 52
would 1 w 57
know 1 w 61
how 1 w 64
insignificant 1 w 77
is 1 w 79
the 4 w 82
power 1 w 87
of 3 w 89
words 1 w 94
in 2 w 96
comparison 1 w 106
with 2 w 110
that 2 w 114
of 4 w 116
visible 1 w 123
objects 1 w 130
The 1 w 134
enchantments 1 w 146
of 5 w 148
the 5 w 151
former 1 w 157
were 1 w 161
at 3 w 163
the 6 w 166
best 1 w 170
a 8 w 171
matter 1 w 177
of 6 w 179
time 1 w 183
they 1 w 188
did 1 w 191
but 1 w 194
flatter 1 w 201
the 8 w 204
ear 1 w 207
with 3 w 211
pleasing 1 w 219
songs 1 w 224
if 3 w 227
the 9 w 230
mariner 1 w 237
landed 1 w 243
he 11 w 246
remained 1 w 254
long 1 w 258
on 5 w 260
their 1 w 265
hands 1 w 270
and 3 w 274
it 4 w 276
has 1 w 279
even 1 w 283
happened 1 w 291
to 2 w 293
them 1 w 297
to 3 w 299
be 2 w 301
disregarded 1 w 312
altogether 1 w 322
But 1 w 326
the 13 w 329
beauty 1 w 335
of 7 w 337
the 14 w 340
Gorgons 2 w 347
irresistible 1 w 360
in 6 w 362
might 1 w 367
won 1 w 371
its 1 w 374
way 1 w 377
to 5 w 379
the 15 w 382
inmost 1 w 388
soul 1 w 392
and 4 w 396
wrought 1 w 403
amazement 1 w 412
and 5 w 415
dumbness 1 w 423
in 8 w 425
the 16 w 428
beholder 1 w 436
admiration 1 w 447
so 4 w 450
the 17 w 453
legend 1 w 459
goes 1 w 463
turned 1 w 470
him 1 w 473
to 6 w 475
stone 1 w 480
All 1 w 484
that 3 w 488
my 1 w 490
opponent 1 w 498
has 2 w 501
just 1 w 505
said 1 w 509
about 1 w 514
the 18 w 517
peacock 1 w 524
illustrates 1 w 535
my 2 w 537
point 1 w 542
that 4 w 547
bird 1 w 551
charms 1 w 557
not 1 w 560
the 19 w 563
ear 2 w 566
but 2 w 570
the 20 w 573
eye 1 w 576
Take 1 w 581
a 40 w 582
swan 1 w 586
take 1 w 591
a 43 w 592
nightingale 1 w 603
and 6 w 607
set 1 w 610
her 2 w 613
singing 1 w 620
now 2 w 624
put 1 w 627
a 46 w 628
silent 1 w 634
peacock 2 w 641
at 10 w 643
her 3 w 646
side 1 w 650
and 7 w 654
I 1 w 655
will 1 w 659
tell 1 w 663
you 2 w 666
which 1 w 671
bird 2 w 675
has 3 w 678
the 21 w 681
attention 1 w 690
of 8 w 692
the 22 w 695
company 1 w 702
The 2 w 706
songstress 1 w 716
may 1 w 719
go 4 w 721
hang 1 w 725
now 3 w 728
so 6 w 731
invincible 1 w 741
a 55 w 742
thing 1 w 747
is 6 w 749
the 23 w 752
pleasure 1 w 760
of 9 w 762
the 24 w 765
eyes 1 w 769
Shall 1 w 775
I 2 w 776
call 1 w 780
evidence 1 w 788
A 2 w 790
sage 1 w 794
then 1 w 799
shall 1 w 805
be 5 w 807
my 3 w 809
witness 1 w 816
how 2 w 820
far 1 w 823
mightier 1 w 831
are 2 w 834
the 26 w 837
things 1 w 843
of 10 w 845
the 27 w 848
eye 3 w 851
than 1 w 855
those 1 w 860
of 11 w 862
the 28 w 865
ear 3 w 868
Usher 1 w 874
call 2 w 879
me 5 w 881
Herodotus 1 w 890
son 4 w 894
of 12 w 896
Lyxes 1 w 901
of 13 w 904
Halicarnassus 1 w 917
Ah 1 w 921
since 1 w 927
he 35 w 929
has 4 w 932
been 1 w 936
so 8 w 938
obliging 1 w 946
as 8 w 948
to 8 w 950
hear 1 w 954
the 29 w 957
summons 1 w 964
let 1 w 968
him 2 w 971
step 1 w 975
into 1 w 979
the 30 w 982
box 1 w 985
You 1 w 989
will 2 w 993
excuse 1 w 999
the 31 w 1002
Ionic 1 w 1007
dialect 1 w 1014
it 7 w 1017
is 7 w 1019
his 1 w 1022
way 2 w 1025
Gentlemen 1 w 1036
of 14 w 1038
the 32 w 1041
jury 1 w 1045
the 33 w 1049
Theory 1 w 1055
hath 1 w 1059
spoken 1 w 1065
sooth 1 w 1070
Give 1 w 1075
good 1 w 1079
heed 1 w 1083
to 10 w 1085
that 5 w 1089
he 44 w 1091
saith 1 w 1096
how 3 w 1100
sight 1 w 1105
is 9 w 1107
a 77 w 1108
better 1 w 1114
thing 3 w 1119
than 2 w 1123
hearing 1 w 1130
for 2 w 1134
a 80 w 1135
man 1 w 1138
shall 2 w 1143
sooner 1 w 1149
trust 1 w 1154
bis 1 w 1157
eyes 2 w 1161
than 3 w 1165
bis 2 w 1168
ears 1 w 1172
You 2 w 1177
hear 3 w 1181
him 3 w 1184
gentlemen 1 w 1194
He 2 w 1197
gives 1 w 1202
the 34 w 1205
preference 1 w 1215
to 11 w 1217
sight 2 w 1222
and 8 w 1226
rightly 1 w 1233
For 1 w 1237
words 2 w 1242
have 1 w 1246
wings 1 w 1251
they 2 w 1256
are 3 w 1259
no 5 w 1261
sooner 2 w 1267
out 2 w 1270
of 15 w 1272
the 36 w 1275
mouth 1 w 1280
than 4 w 1284
they 3 w 1288
take 2 w 1292
flight 1 w 1298
and 9 w 1301
are 4 w 1304
lost 1 w 1308
but 3 w 1312
the 38 w 1315
delight 1 w 1322
of 16 w 1324
the 39 w 1327
eyes 3 w 1331
is 12 w 1333
ever 1 w 1337
present 1 w 1344
ever 2 w 1349
draws 1 w 1354
the 40 w 1357
beholder 2 w 1365
to 12 w 1367
itself 1 w 1373