Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Meno

Meno (95)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg024.perseus-eng2:95
Refs {'start': {'reference': '95', 'human_reference': 'Section 95'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
An.

Socrates, I consider you are too apt to speak ill of people. I, for one, if you will take my advice, would warn you to be careful: in most cities it is probably easier to do people harm than good, and particularly in this one;

95
95a
I think you know that yourself.[*]

Soc.

Meno, I think Anytus is angry, and I am not at all surprised: for he conceives, in the first place, that I am speaking ill of these gentlemen; and in the second place, he considers he is one of them himself. Yet, should the day come when he knows what speaking ill means, his anger will cease; at present he does not know.[*] Now you must answer me: are there not good and honorable men among your people also?

Men.

Certainly.

95b
Soc.

Well then, are they willing to put themselves forward as teachers of the young, and avow that they are teachers and that virtue is to be taught?

Men.

No, no, Socrates, I assure you: sometimes you may hear them refer to it as teachable, but sometimes as not.

Soc.

Then are we to call those persons teachers of this thing, when they do not even agree on that great question?

Men.

I should say not, Socrates.

Soc.

Well, and what of the sophists? Do you consider these, its only professors,

95c
to be teachers of virtue?

Men.

That is a point, Socrates, for which I admire Gorgias: you will never hear him promising this, and he ridicules the others when he hears them promise it. Skill in speaking is what he takes it to be their business to produce.

Soc.

Then you do not think the sophists are teachers of virtue?

Men.

I cannot say, Socrates. I am in the same plight as the rest of the world: sometimes I think that they are, sometimes that they are not.

Soc.

And are you aware that not only you and other political folk

95d
are in two minds as to whether virtue is to be taught, but Theognis the poet also says, you remember, the very same thing?

Men.

In which part of his poems?

Soc.

In those elegiac lines where he says

Eat and drink with these men; sit with them, and be pleasing unto them, who wield great power; for from the good wilt thou win thee lessons in the good; but mingle with the bad,
95e
and thou wilt lose even the sense that thou hast.
Theognis 33-36 BergkDo you observe how in these words he implies that virtue is to be taught?

Men.

He does, evidently.

Tokens

An 1 w 2
Socrates 1 w 11
I 1 w 13
consider 1 w 21
you 1 w 24
are 1 w 27
too 1 w 30
apt 1 w 33
to 2 w 35
speak 1 w 40
ill 1 w 43
of 1 w 45
people 1 w 51
I 2 w 53
for 1 w 57
one 1 w 60
if 1 w 63
you 2 w 66
will 1 w 70
take 1 w 74
my 1 w 76
advice 1 w 82
would 1 w 88
warn 1 w 92
you 3 w 95
to 3 w 97
be 1 w 99
careful 1 w 106
in 1 w 109
most 1 w 113
cities 1 w 119
it 2 w 121
is 1 w 123
probably 1 w 131
easier 1 w 137
to 4 w 139
do 1 w 141
people 2 w 147
harm 1 w 151
than 1 w 155
good 1 w 159
and 1 w 163
particularly 1 w 175
in 2 w 177
this 1 w 181
one 2 w 184
I 3 w 186
think 1 w 191
you 4 w 194
know 1 w 198
that 1 w 202
yourself 1 w 210
Anytus 1 w 217
goes 1 w 221
away 1 w 225
His 1 w 229
parting 1 w 236
words 1 w 241
show 1 w 245
that 2 w 249
in 5 w 252
Plato 1 w 257
s 15 w 259
view 1 w 263
he 1 w 266
regarded 1 w 274
Socrates 2 w 282
as 2 w 284
an 3 w 286
enemy 1 w 291
of 2 w 293
the 1 w 296
restored 1 w 304
democracy 1 w 313
which 1 w 318
he 3 w 321
hints 1 w 326
has 1 w 330
popular 1 w 337
juries 1 w 343
only 1 w 347
too 2 w 350
ready 1 w 355
to 8 w 357
condemn 1 w 364
such 1 w 368
an 4 w 370
awkward 1 w 377
critic 1 w 383
Soc 3 w 387
Meno 1 w 392
I 4 w 394
think 2 w 399
Anytus 2 w 405
is 4 w 407
angry 1 w 412
and 2 w 416
I 5 w 417
am 1 w 419
not 1 w 422
at 6 w 424
all 1 w 427
surprised 1 w 436
for 2 w 440
he 4 w 442
conceives 1 w 451
in 8 w 454
the 2 w 457
first 1 w 462
place 1 w 467
that 3 w 472
I 6 w 473
am 2 w 475
speaking 1 w 483
ill 3 w 486
of 3 w 488
these 1 w 493
gentlemen 1 w 502
and 3 w 506
in 10 w 508
the 4 w 511
second 1 w 517
place 2 w 522
he 8 w 525
considers 1 w 534
he 9 w 536
is 6 w 538
one 3 w 541
of 4 w 543
them 1 w 547
himself 1 w 554
Yet 1 w 558
should 1 w 565
the 6 w 568
day 1 w 571
come 1 w 575
when 1 w 579
he 13 w 581
knows 1 w 586
what 1 w 590
speaking 2 w 598
ill 4 w 601
means 1 w 606
his 2 w 610
anger 1 w 615
will 2 w 619
cease 1 w 624
at 9 w 627
present 1 w 634
he 14 w 636
does 1 w 640
not 2 w 643
know 3 w 647
This 1 w 652
is 9 w 654
probably 2 w 662
not 3 w 665
a 52 w 666
reference 1 w 675
to 9 w 677
a 53 w 678
prosecution 1 w 689
of 5 w 691
Anytus 3 w 697
himself 2 w 704
but 1 w 708
a 54 w 709
suggestion 1 w 719
that 4 w 723
what 2 w 727
he 15 w 729
needs 1 w 734
is 10 w 736
a 57 w 737
Socratic 1 w 745
discussion 1 w 755
on 13 w 757
speaking 3 w 765
ill 6 w 768
for 3 w 772
ill 7 w 775
may 1 w 778
mean 2 w 782
maliciously 1 w 793
untruthfully 1 w 806
ignorantly 1 w 817
etc 1 w 821
Now 1 w 825
you 6 w 828
must 1 w 832
answer 1 w 838
me 5 w 840
are 3 w 844
there 1 w 849
not 4 w 852
good 2 w 856
and 4 w 859
honorable 1 w 868
men 2 w 871
among 1 w 876
your 2 w 880
people 3 w 886
also 1 w 890
Men 2 w 894
Certainly 1 w 904
Soc 5 w 908
Well 1 w 913
then 1 w 917
are 4 w 921
they 1 w 925
willing 1 w 932
to 10 w 934
put 1 w 937
themselves 1 w 947
forward 1 w 954
as 5 w 956
teachers 1 w 964
of 6 w 966
the 11 w 969
young 1 w 974
and 5 w 978
avow 1 w 982
that 5 w 986
they 2 w 990
are 5 w 993
teachers 2 w 1001
and 6 w 1004
that 6 w 1008
virtue 1 w 1014
is 12 w 1016
to 11 w 1018
be 2 w 1020
taught 1 w 1026
Men 3 w 1030
No 2 w 1033
no 11 w 1036
Socrates 3 w 1045
I 7 w 1047
assure 1 w 1053
you 9 w 1056
sometimes 1 w 1066
you 10 w 1069
may 2 w 1072
hear 1 w 1076
them 3 w 1080
refer 2 w 1085
to 12 w 1087
it 4 w 1089
as 7 w 1091
teachable 1 w 1100
but 2 w 1104
sometimes 2 w 1113
as 8 w 1115
not 5 w 1118
Soc 7 w 1122
Then 1 w 1127
are 6 w 1130
we 2 w 1132
to 13 w 1134
call 1 w 1138
those 1 w 1143
persons 1 w 1150
teachers 3 w 1158
of 7 w 1160
this 2 w 1164
thing 1 w 1169
when 2 w 1174
they 3 w 1178
do 3 w 1180
not 6 w 1183
even 1 w 1187
agree 1 w 1192
on 17 w 1194
that 7 w 1198
great 1 w 1203
question 1 w 1211
Men 4 w 1215
I 8 w 1217
should 2 w 1223
say 1 w 1226
not 7 w 1229
Socrates 4 w 1238
Soc 9 w 1242
Well 2 w 1247
and 7 w 1251
what 3 w 1255
of 8 w 1257
the 15 w 1260
sophists 1 w 1268
Do 1 w 1271
you 11 w 1274
consider 3 w 1282
these 2 w 1287
its 1 w 1291
only 2 w 1295
professors 1 w 1305
to 14 w 1308
be 3 w 1310
teachers 4 w 1318
of 10 w 1320
virtue 2 w 1326
Men 5 w 1330
That 1 w 1335
is 15 w 1337
a 103 w 1338
point 1 w 1343
Socrates 5 w 1352
for 5 w 1356
which 2 w 1361
I 9 w 1362
admire 1 w 1368
Gorgias 1 w 1375
you 12 w 1379
will 4 w 1383
never 1 w 1388
hear 2 w 1392
him 3 w 1395
promising 1 w 1404
this 3 w 1408
and 8 w 1412
he 34 w 1414
ridicules 1 w 1423
the 17 w 1426
others 1 w 1432
when 3 w 1436
he 38 w 1438
hears 1 w 1443
them 4 w 1447
promise 1 w 1454
it 6 w 1456
Skill 1 w 1462
in 18 w 1464
speaking 4 w 1472
is 19 w 1474
what 4 w 1478
he 41 w 1480
takes 1 w 1485
it 7 w 1487
to 15 w 1489
be 4 w 1491
their 1 w 1496
business 1 w 1504
to 16 w 1506
produce 1 w 1513
Soc 11 w 1517
Then 2 w 1522
you 13 w 1525
do 4 w 1527
not 8 w 1530
think 3 w 1535
the 21 w 1538
sophists 2 w 1546
are 7 w 1549
teachers 5 w 1557
of 11 w 1559
virtue 3 w 1565
Men 6 w 1569
I 10 w 1571
cannot 1 w 1577
say 2 w 1580
Socrates 6 w 1589
I 11 w 1591
am 4 w 1593
in 22 w 1595
the 22 w 1598
same 1 w 1602
plight 1 w 1608
as 10 w 1610
the 23 w 1613
rest 2 w 1617
of 12 w 1619
the 24 w 1622
world 1 w 1627
sometimes 3 w 1637
I 12 w 1638
think 4 w 1643
that 8 w 1647
they 4 w 1651
are 8 w 1654
sometimes 4 w 1664
that 9 w 1668
they 5 w 1672
are 9 w 1675
not 10 w 1678
Soc 13 w 1682
And 1 w 1686
are 10 w 1689
you 14 w 1692
aware 1 w 1697
that 10 w 1701
not 11 w 1704
only 3 w 1708
you 15 w 1711
and 9 w 1714
other 2 w 1719
political 1 w 1728
folk 1 w 1732
are 12 w 1735
in 24 w 1737
two 1 w 1740
minds 1 w 1745
as 11 w 1747
to 17 w 1749
whether 1 w 1756
virtue 4 w 1762
is 21 w 1764
to 18 w 1766
be 5 w 1768
taught 2 w 1774
but 3 w 1778
Theognis 1 w 1786
the 29 w 1789
poet 1 w 1793
also 2 w 1797
says 1 w 1801
you 16 w 1805
remember 1 w 1813
the 30 w 1817
very 1 w 1821
same 2 w 1825
thing 2 w 1830
Men 7 w 1834
In 1 w 1837
which 3 w 1842
part 3 w 1846
of 13 w 1848
his 8 w 1851
poems 1 w 1856
Soc 14 w 1860
In 2 w 1863
those 2 w 1868
elegiac 1 w 1875
lines 1 w 1880
where 1 w 1885
he 58 w 1887
says 2 w 1891
Eat 1 w 1895
and 10 w 1898
drink 1 w 1903
with 1 w 1907
these 3 w 1912
men 3 w 1915
sit 1 w 1919
with 2 w 1923
them 5 w 1927
and 11 w 1931
be 7 w 1933
pleasing 1 w 1941
unto 1 w 1945
them 6 w 1949
who 1 w 1953
wield 1 w 1958
great 2 w 1963
power 1 w 1968
for 6 w 1972
from 1 w 1976
the 34 w 1979
good 3 w 1983
wilt 1 w 1987
thou 1 w 1991
win 1 w 1994
thee 1 w 1998
lessons 1 w 2005
in 31 w 2007
the 36 w 2010
good 4 w 2014
but 4 w 2018
mingle 1 w 2024
with 3 w 2028
the 37 w 2031
bad 1 w 2034
and 12 w 2038
thou 2 w 2042
wilt 2 w 2046
lose 1 w 2050
even 2 w 2054
the 38 w 2057
sense 1 w 2062
that 11 w 2066
thou 3 w 2070
hast 1 w 2074
Theognis 2 w 2083
33-36 1 w 2088
Bergk 1 w 2093
Do 2 w 2095
you 17 w 2098
observe 1 w 2105
how 2 w 2108
in 33 w 2110
these 4 w 2115
words 2 w 2120
he 69 w 2122
implies 1 w 2129
that 12 w 2133
virtue 5 w 2139
is 25 w 2141
to 20 w 2143
be 8 w 2145
taught 3 w 2151
Men 8 w 2155
He 1 w 2158
does 2 w 2162
evidently 1 w 2172