Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Gorgias

Gorgias (524)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg023.perseus-eng2:524
Refs {'start': {'reference': '524', 'human_reference': 'Section 524'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Soc.

Now I, knowing all this before you, have appointed sons of my own to be judges; two from Asia, Minos and Rhadamanthus,

524
524a
and one from Europe, Aeacus. These, when their life is ended, shall give judgement in the meadow at the dividing of the road, whence are the two ways leading, one to the Isles of the Blest, and the other to Tartarus. And those who come from Asia shall Rhadamanthus try, and those from Europe, Aeacus; and to Minos I will give the privilege of the final decision, if the other two be in any doubt; that the judgement upon this journey of mankind may be supremely just.
This, Callicles, is what I have heard and believe to be true;
524b
and from these stories, on my reckoning, we must draw some such moral as this: death, as it seems to me, is actually nothing but the disconnection of two things, the soul and the body, from each other. And so when they are disconnected from one another, each of them keeps its own condition very much as it was when the man was alive, the body having its own nature, with its treatments and experiences all manifest upon it. For instance,
524c
if anyones body was large by nature or by feeding or by both when he was alive, his corpse will be large also when he is dead; and if he was fat, it will be fat too after his death, and so on for the rest; or again, if he used to follow the fashion of long hair, long-haired also will be his corpse. Again, if anyone had been a sturdy rogue, and bore traces of his stripes in scars on his body, either from the whip or from other wounds, while yet alive, then after death too his body has these marks visible upon it; or if anyones limbs were broken or distorted in life, these same effects are manifest in death.
524d
In a word, whatever sort of bodily appearance a man had acquired in life, that is manifest also after his death either wholly or in the main for some time. And so it seems to me that the same is the case with the soul too, Callicles: when a mans soul is stripped bare of the body, all its natural gifts, and the experiences added to that soul as the result of his various pursuits, are manifest in it. So when they have arrived
524e
in presence of their judge, they of Asia before Rhadamanthus, these Rhadamanthus sets before him and surveys the soul of each, not knowing whose it is; nay, often when he has laid hold of the Great King or some other prince or potentate, he perceives the utter unhealthiness of his soul, striped all over with the scourge, and a mass of wounds, the work of perjuries and injustice;

Tokens

Soc 1 w 3
Now 1 w 7
I 1 w 8
knowing 1 w 16
all 1 w 19
this 1 w 23
before 1 w 29
you 1 w 32
have 1 w 37
appointed 1 w 46
sons 1 w 50
of 1 w 52
my 1 w 54
own 1 w 57
to 1 w 59
be 2 w 61
judges 1 w 67
two 1 w 71
from 1 w 75
Asia 1 w 79
Minos 1 w 85
and 1 w 88
Rhadamanthus 1 w 100
and 2 w 104
one 1 w 107
from 2 w 111
Europe 1 w 117
Aeacus 1 w 124
These 1 w 130
when 1 w 135
their 1 w 140
life 1 w 144
is 2 w 146
ended 1 w 151
shall 1 w 157
give 1 w 161
judgement 1 w 170
in 4 w 172
the 2 w 175
meadow 1 w 181
at 1 w 183
the 3 w 186
dividing 1 w 194
of 2 w 196
the 4 w 199
road 1 w 203
whence 1 w 210
are 1 w 213
the 5 w 216
two 2 w 219
ways 1 w 223
leading 1 w 230
one 2 w 234
to 2 w 236
the 6 w 239
Isles 1 w 244
of 3 w 246
the 7 w 249
Blest 1 w 254
and 3 w 258
the 8 w 261
other 1 w 266
to 3 w 268
Tartarus 1 w 276
And 1 w 280
those 1 w 285
who 1 w 288
come 1 w 292
from 3 w 296
Asia 2 w 300
shall 2 w 305
Rhadamanthus 2 w 317
try 1 w 320
and 4 w 324
those 2 w 329
from 4 w 333
Europe 2 w 339
Aeacus 2 w 346
and 5 w 350
to 4 w 352
Minos 2 w 357
I 3 w 358
will 1 w 362
give 2 w 366
the 10 w 369
privilege 1 w 378
of 4 w 380
the 11 w 383
final 1 w 388
decision 1 w 396
if 2 w 399
the 12 w 402
other 2 w 407
two 3 w 410
be 3 w 412
in 9 w 414
any 1 w 417
doubt 1 w 422
that 1 w 427
the 14 w 430
judgement 2 w 439
upon 1 w 443
this 2 w 447
journey 1 w 454
of 5 w 456
mankind 1 w 463
may 1 w 466
be 4 w 468
supremely 1 w 477
just 1 w 481
This 1 w 486
Callicles 1 w 496
is 6 w 499
what 1 w 503
I 4 w 504
have 2 w 508
heard 1 w 513
and 6 w 516
believe 1 w 523
to 5 w 525
be 6 w 527
true 1 w 531
and 7 w 535
from 5 w 539
these 1 w 544
stories 1 w 551
on 6 w 554
my 2 w 556
reckoning 1 w 565
we 1 w 568
must 1 w 572
draw 1 w 576
some 1 w 580
such 1 w 584
moral 1 w 589
as 1 w 591
this 3 w 595
death 1 w 601
as 2 w 604
it 1 w 606
seems 1 w 611
to 7 w 613
me 7 w 615
is 8 w 618
actually 1 w 626
nothing 1 w 633
but 1 w 636
the 16 w 639
disconnection 1 w 652
of 6 w 654
two 4 w 657
things 1 w 663
the 17 w 667
soul 1 w 671
and 8 w 674
the 18 w 677
body 1 w 681
from 6 w 686
each 1 w 690
other 3 w 695
And 2 w 699
so 4 w 701
when 3 w 705
they 1 w 709
are 2 w 712
disconnected 1 w 724
from 7 w 728
one 3 w 731
another 1 w 738
each 2 w 743
of 7 w 745
them 1 w 749
keeps 1 w 754
its 1 w 757
own 2 w 760
condition 1 w 769
very 1 w 773
much 1 w 777
as 3 w 779
it 4 w 781
was 1 w 784
when 4 w 788
the 23 w 791
man 4 w 794
was 2 w 797
alive 1 w 802
the 24 w 806
body 2 w 810
having 1 w 816
its 2 w 819
own 3 w 822
nature 1 w 828
with 1 w 833
its 3 w 836
treatments 1 w 846
and 9 w 849
experiences 1 w 860
all 6 w 863
manifest 1 w 871
upon 2 w 875
it 8 w 877
For 1 w 881
instance 1 w 889
if 4 w 892
anyone 1 w 898
s 59 w 900
body 3 w 904
was 3 w 907
large 1 w 912
by 1 w 914
nature 2 w 920
or 5 w 922
by 2 w 924
feeding 1 w 931
or 6 w 933
by 3 w 935
both 1 w 939
when 5 w 943
he 32 w 945
was 4 w 948
alive 2 w 953
his 5 w 957
corpse 1 w 963
will 2 w 967
be 7 w 969
large 2 w 974
also 1 w 978
when 6 w 982
he 34 w 984
is 12 w 986
dead 1 w 990
and 10 w 994
if 5 w 996
he 35 w 998
was 5 w 1001
fat 1 w 1004
it 9 w 1007
will 3 w 1011
be 8 w 1013
fat 2 w 1016
too 1 w 1019
after 1 w 1024
his 6 w 1027
death 2 w 1032
and 11 w 1036
so 6 w 1038
on 16 w 1040
for 2 w 1043
the 25 w 1046
rest 1 w 1050
or 9 w 1053
again 1 w 1058
if 6 w 1061
he 37 w 1063
used 1 w 1067
to 9 w 1069
follow 1 w 1075
the 26 w 1078
fashion 1 w 1085
of 8 w 1087
long 1 w 1091
hair 1 w 1095
long-haired 1 w 1107
also 2 w 1111
will 4 w 1115
be 9 w 1117
his 7 w 1120
corpse 2 w 1126
Again 1 w 1132
if 7 w 1135
anyone 2 w 1141
had 3 w 1144
been 1 w 1148
a 89 w 1149
sturdy 1 w 1155
rogue 1 w 1160
and 12 w 1164
bore 1 w 1168
traces 1 w 1174
of 9 w 1176
his 8 w 1179
stripes 1 w 1186
in 19 w 1188
scars 1 w 1193
on 21 w 1195
his 9 w 1198
body 4 w 1202
either 1 w 1209
from 8 w 1213
the 28 w 1216
whip 1 w 1220
or 12 w 1222
from 9 w 1226
other 5 w 1231
wounds 1 w 1237
while 1 w 1243
yet 1 w 1246
alive 3 w 1251
then 1 w 1256
after 2 w 1261
death 3 w 1266
too 2 w 1269
his 10 w 1272
body 5 w 1276
has 1 w 1279
these 2 w 1284
marks 1 w 1289
visible 1 w 1296
upon 3 w 1300
it 11 w 1302
or 13 w 1305
if 8 w 1307
anyone 3 w 1313
s 89 w 1315
limbs 1 w 1320
were 1 w 1324
broken 1 w 1330
or 14 w 1332
distorted 1 w 1341
in 20 w 1343
life 2 w 1347
these 3 w 1353
same 1 w 1357
effects 1 w 1364
are 3 w 1367
manifest 2 w 1375
in 21 w 1377
death 4 w 1382
In 1 w 1385
a 103 w 1386
word 1 w 1390
whatever 1 w 1399
sort 1 w 1403
of 10 w 1405
bodily 1 w 1411
appearance 1 w 1421
a 108 w 1422
man 7 w 1425
had 4 w 1428
acquired 1 w 1436
in 22 w 1438
life 3 w 1442
that 2 w 1447
is 20 w 1449
manifest 3 w 1457
also 3 w 1461
after 3 w 1466
his 11 w 1469
death 5 w 1474
either 2 w 1480
wholly 1 w 1486
or 18 w 1488
in 23 w 1490
the 34 w 1493
main 1 w 1497
for 3 w 1500
some 2 w 1504
time 1 w 1508
And 3 w 1512
so 11 w 1514
it 13 w 1516
seems 2 w 1521
to 12 w 1523
me 12 w 1525
that 3 w 1529
the 35 w 1532
same 2 w 1536
is 22 w 1538
the 36 w 1541
case 1 w 1545
with 2 w 1549
the 37 w 1552
soul 2 w 1556
too 3 w 1559
Callicles 2 w 1569
when 7 w 1574
a 122 w 1575
man 9 w 1578
s 110 w 1580
soul 3 w 1584
is 23 w 1586
stripped 1 w 1594
bare 1 w 1598
of 11 w 1600
the 38 w 1603
body 6 w 1607
all 8 w 1611
its 4 w 1614
natural 1 w 1621
gifts 1 w 1626
and 13 w 1630
the 39 w 1633
experiences 2 w 1644
added 1 w 1649
to 14 w 1651
that 4 w 1655
soul 4 w 1659
as 12 w 1661
the 40 w 1664
result 1 w 1670
of 12 w 1672
his 12 w 1675
various 1 w 1682
pursuits 1 w 1690
are 5 w 1694
manifest 4 w 1702
in 25 w 1704
it 17 w 1706
So 2 w 1709
when 8 w 1713
they 2 w 1717
have 3 w 1721
arrived 1 w 1728
in 26 w 1730
presence 1 w 1738
of 13 w 1740
their 2 w 1745
judge 4 w 1750
they 3 w 1755
of 14 w 1757
Asia 3 w 1761
before 2 w 1767
Rhadamanthus 3 w 1779
these 4 w 1785
Rhadamanthus 4 w 1797
sets 1 w 1801
before 3 w 1807
him 1 w 1810
and 14 w 1813
surveys 1 w 1820
the 45 w 1823
soul 5 w 1827
of 15 w 1829
each 3 w 1833
not 3 w 1837
knowing 2 w 1844
whose 1 w 1849
it 18 w 1851
is 25 w 1853
nay 1 w 1857
often 1 w 1863
when 9 w 1867
he 61 w 1869
has 2 w 1872
laid 1 w 1876
hold 1 w 1880
of 17 w 1882
the 46 w 1885
Great 1 w 1890
King 1 w 1894
or 22 w 1896
some 3 w 1900
other 6 w 1905
prince 1 w 1911
or 23 w 1913
potentate 1 w 1922
he 64 w 1925
perceives 1 w 1934
the 48 w 1937
utter 1 w 1942
unhealthiness 1 w 1955
of 18 w 1957
his 13 w 1960
soul 6 w 1964
striped 1 w 1972
all 9 w 1975
over 1 w 1979
with 3 w 1983
the 49 w 1986
scourge 1 w 1993
and 15 w 1997
a 154 w 1998
mass 1 w 2002
of 19 w 2004
wounds 2 w 2010
the 50 w 2014
work 1 w 2018
of 20 w 2020
perjuries 1 w 2029
and 16 w 2032
injustice 1 w 2041