Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Gorgias

Gorgias (510)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg023.perseus-eng2:510
Refs {'start': {'reference': '510', 'human_reference': 'Section 510'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
510
510a
Call.

Let it be as you would have it, Socrates, in order that you may come to a conclusion of your argument.

Soc.

Then for this purpose also, of not doing wrong, it seems we must provide ourselves with a certain power or art.

Call.

To be sure.

Soc.

Now what can be the art of providing so that we suffer no wrong, or as little as possible? Consider if you take the same view of it as I do. For in my view it is this: one must either be a ruler, or even a despot, in ones city, or else an associate of the existing government.

510b
Call.

Do you note, Socrates, how ready I am to praise, when you say a good thing? This seems to me excellently spoken.

Soc.

Then see if this next statement of mine strikes you as a good one too. It seems to me that the closest possible friendship between man and man is that mentioned by the sages of old time as like to like. Do you not agree?

Call.

I do.

Soc.

So where you have a savage, uneducated ruler as despot, if there were some one in the city far better than he, I suppose the despot would be afraid of him

510c
and could never become a friend to him with all his heart?

Call.

That is so.

Soc.

Nor a friend to anyone who was much inferior to him either; for the despot would despise him and never show him the attention due to a friend.

Call.

That is true also.

Soc.

Then the only friend of any account that remains for such a person is a man of his own temper, who blames and praises the same things, and is thus willing to be governed by him and to be subject to his rule. He is a man who will have great power in that state;

510d
him none will wrong with impunity. Is it not so?

Call.

Yes.

Soc.

Hence if one of the young men in that city should reflect: In what way can I have great power, and no one may do me wrong?—this, it would seem, is the path he must take, to accustom himself from his earliest youth to be delighted and annoyed by the same things as his master, and contrive to be as like the other as possible. Is it not so?

Call.

Yes.

510e
Soc.

And so this man will have attained to a condition of suffering no wrong and having great poweras your party maintainin the city.

Call.

Certainly.

Soc.

And of doing no wrong likewise? Or is it quite the contrary, if he is to be like his unjust ruler, and have great influence with him? Well, for my part, I think his efforts will be all the opposite way, that is, towards enabling himself to do as much wrong as possible and to pay no penalty for the wrong he does; will they not?

Call.

Apparently.

Tokens

Call 1 w 4
Let 1 w 8
it 1 w 10
be 1 w 12
as 1 w 14
you 1 w 17
would 1 w 22
have 1 w 26
it 2 w 28
Socrates 1 w 37
in 1 w 40
order 1 w 45
that 1 w 49
you 2 w 52
may 1 w 55
come 1 w 59
to 1 w 61
a 7 w 62
conclusion 1 w 72
of 1 w 74
your 1 w 78
argument 1 w 86
Soc 2 w 90
Then 1 w 95
for 1 w 98
this 1 w 102
purpose 1 w 109
also 1 w 113
of 2 w 116
not 1 w 119
doing 1 w 124
wrong 1 w 129
it 3 w 132
seems 1 w 137
we 1 w 139
must 1 w 143
provide 1 w 150
ourselves 1 w 159
with 1 w 163
a 10 w 164
certain 1 w 171
power 1 w 176
or 3 w 178
art 1 w 181
Call 2 w 186
To 1 w 189
be 2 w 191
sure 1 w 195
Soc 3 w 199
Now 1 w 203
what 1 w 207
can 1 w 210
be 3 w 212
the 1 w 215
art 2 w 218
of 3 w 220
providing 1 w 229
so 2 w 231
that 2 w 235
we 3 w 237
suffer 1 w 243
no 2 w 245
wrong 2 w 250
or 4 w 253
as 2 w 255
little 1 w 261
as 3 w 263
possible 1 w 271
Consider 1 w 280
if 1 w 282
you 4 w 285
take 1 w 289
the 2 w 292
same 1 w 296
view 1 w 300
of 4 w 302
it 6 w 304
as 4 w 306
I 1 w 307
do 2 w 309
For 1 w 313
in 5 w 315
my 1 w 317
view 2 w 321
it 7 w 323
is 2 w 325
this 2 w 329
one 1 w 333
must 2 w 337
either 1 w 343
be 4 w 345
a 23 w 346
ruler 1 w 351
or 6 w 354
even 1 w 358
a 24 w 359
despot 1 w 365
in 6 w 368
one 2 w 371
s 26 w 373
city 1 w 377
or 7 w 380
else 1 w 384
an 2 w 386
associate 1 w 395
of 5 w 397
the 4 w 400
existing 1 w 408
government 1 w 418
Call 3 w 423
Do 1 w 426
you 5 w 429
note 1 w 433
Socrates 2 w 442
how 1 w 446
ready 1 w 451
I 2 w 452
am 2 w 454
to 2 w 456
praise 1 w 462
when 1 w 467
you 6 w 470
say 1 w 473
a 34 w 474
good 1 w 478
thing 1 w 483
This 1 w 488
seems 2 w 493
to 3 w 495
me 5 w 497
excellently 1 w 508
spoken 1 w 514
Soc 5 w 518
Then 2 w 523
see 3 w 526
if 2 w 528
this 3 w 532
next 1 w 536
statement 1 w 545
of 6 w 547
mine 1 w 551
strikes 1 w 558
you 7 w 561
as 6 w 563
a 37 w 564
good 2 w 568
one 3 w 571
too 1 w 574
It 1 w 577
seems 3 w 582
to 5 w 584
me 7 w 586
that 3 w 590
the 5 w 593
closest 1 w 600
possible 2 w 608
friendship 1 w 618
between 1 w 625
man 1 w 628
and 1 w 631
man 2 w 634
is 8 w 636
that 4 w 640
mentioned 1 w 649
by 1 w 651
the 6 w 654
sages 1 w 659
of 7 w 661
old 1 w 664
time 1 w 668
as 7 w 670
like 1 w 674
to 6 w 676
like 2 w 680
Do 2 w 683
you 8 w 686
not 3 w 689
agree 1 w 694
Call 4 w 699
I 4 w 701
do 3 w 703
Soc 6 w 707
So 7 w 710
where 1 w 715
you 9 w 718
have 2 w 722
a 48 w 723
savage 1 w 729
uneducated 1 w 740
ruler 2 w 745
as 8 w 747
despot 2 w 753
if 3 w 756
there 1 w 761
were 1 w 765
some 1 w 769
one 5 w 772
in 10 w 774
the 8 w 777
city 2 w 781
far 1 w 784
better 1 w 790
than 1 w 794
he 13 w 796
I 5 w 798
suppose 1 w 805
the 9 w 808
despot 3 w 814
would 2 w 819
be 7 w 821
afraid 1 w 827
of 8 w 829
him 1 w 832
and 2 w 835
could 1 w 840
never 1 w 845
become 1 w 851
a 58 w 852
friend 2 w 858
to 7 w 860
him 2 w 863
with 2 w 867
all 5 w 870
his 5 w 873
heart 1 w 878
Call 5 w 883
That 1 w 888
is 10 w 890
so 5 w 892
Soc 7 w 896
Nor 1 w 900
a 63 w 901
friend 3 w 907
to 8 w 909
anyone 1 w 915
who 1 w 918
was 1 w 921
much 1 w 925
inferior 1 w 933
to 9 w 935
him 3 w 938
either 2 w 944
for 2 w 948
the 11 w 951
despot 4 w 957
would 3 w 962
despise 1 w 969
him 4 w 972
and 3 w 975
never 2 w 980
show 1 w 984
him 5 w 987
the 12 w 990
attention 1 w 999
due 1 w 1002
to 10 w 1004
a 68 w 1005
friend 4 w 1011
Call 6 w 1016
That 2 w 1021
is 12 w 1023
true 1 w 1027
also 2 w 1031
Soc 8 w 1035
Then 3 w 1040
the 13 w 1043
only 1 w 1047
friend 5 w 1053
of 9 w 1055
any 2 w 1058
account 1 w 1065
that 5 w 1069
remains 1 w 1076
for 3 w 1079
such 1 w 1083
a 76 w 1084
person 1 w 1090
is 13 w 1092
a 77 w 1093
man 3 w 1096
of 10 w 1098
his 6 w 1101
own 1 w 1104
temper 1 w 1110
who 2 w 1114
blames 1 w 1120
and 4 w 1123
praises 1 w 1130
the 14 w 1133
same 2 w 1137
things 1 w 1143
and 5 w 1147
is 16 w 1149
thus 1 w 1153
willing 1 w 1160
to 11 w 1162
be 9 w 1164
governed 1 w 1172
by 2 w 1174
him 6 w 1177
and 6 w 1180
to 12 w 1182
be 10 w 1184
subject 1 w 1191
to 13 w 1193
his 7 w 1196
rule 3 w 1200
He 1 w 1203
is 18 w 1205
a 85 w 1206
man 4 w 1209
who 3 w 1212
will 2 w 1216
have 3 w 1220
great 1 w 1225
power 2 w 1230
in 15 w 1232
that 6 w 1236
state 2 w 1241
him 7 w 1245
none 1 w 1249
will 3 w 1253
wrong 3 w 1258
with 3 w 1262
impunity 1 w 1270
Is 1 w 1273
it 15 w 1275
not 4 w 1278
so 8 w 1280
Call 7 w 1285
Yes 1 w 1289
Soc 9 w 1293
Hence 1 w 1299
if 4 w 1301
one 8 w 1304
of 11 w 1306
the 15 w 1309
young 1 w 1314
men 5 w 1317
in 16 w 1319
that 7 w 1323
city 3 w 1327
should 1 w 1333
reflect 1 w 1340
In 1 w 1343
what 2 w 1347
way 1 w 1350
can 2 w 1353
I 8 w 1354
have 4 w 1358
great 2 w 1363
power 3 w 1368
and 7 w 1372
no 7 w 1374
one 9 w 1377
may 2 w 1380
do 4 w 1382
me 15 w 1384
wrong 4 w 1389
this 4 w 1395
it 17 w 1398
would 4 w 1403
seem 4 w 1407
is 20 w 1410
the 16 w 1413
path 1 w 1417
he 24 w 1419
must 3 w 1423
take 2 w 1427
to 14 w 1430
accustom 1 w 1438
himself 1 w 1445
from 1 w 1449
his 9 w 1452
earliest 1 w 1460
youth 1 w 1465
to 16 w 1467
be 11 w 1469
delighted 1 w 1478
and 8 w 1481
annoyed 1 w 1488
by 3 w 1490
the 17 w 1493
same 3 w 1497
things 2 w 1503
as 10 w 1505
his 10 w 1508
master 1 w 1514
and 9 w 1518
contrive 1 w 1526
to 17 w 1528
be 12 w 1530
as 12 w 1532
like 3 w 1536
the 18 w 1539
other 1 w 1544
as 13 w 1546
possible 3 w 1554
Is 2 w 1557
it 18 w 1559
not 5 w 1562
so 9 w 1564
Call 8 w 1569
Yes 2 w 1573
Soc 10 w 1577
And 1 w 1581
so 10 w 1583
this 5 w 1587
man 5 w 1590
will 4 w 1594
have 5 w 1598
attained 1 w 1606
to 18 w 1608
a 117 w 1609
condition 1 w 1618
of 12 w 1620
suffering 1 w 1629
no 10 w 1631
wrong 5 w 1636
and 10 w 1639
having 1 w 1645
great 3 w 1650
power 4 w 1655
as 14 w 1658
your 2 w 1662
party 1 w 1667
maintain 1 w 1675
in 23 w 1678
the 20 w 1681
city 4 w 1685
Call 9 w 1690
Certainly 1 w 1700
Soc 11 w 1704
And 2 w 1708
of 13 w 1710
doing 2 w 1715
no 11 w 1717
wrong 6 w 1722
likewise 1 w 1730
Or 1 w 1733
is 25 w 1735
it 21 w 1737
quite 1 w 1742
the 21 w 1745
contrary 1 w 1753
if 5 w 1756
he 30 w 1758
is 26 w 1760
to 19 w 1762
be 13 w 1764
like 5 w 1768
his 12 w 1771
unjust 1 w 1777
ruler 3 w 1782
and 11 w 1786
have 6 w 1790
great 4 w 1795
influence 1 w 1804
with 4 w 1808
him 9 w 1811
Well 1 w 1816
for 4 w 1820
my 2 w 1822
part 2 w 1826
I 10 w 1828
think 1 w 1833
his 13 w 1836
efforts 1 w 1843
will 5 w 1847
be 14 w 1849
all 11 w 1852
the 22 w 1855
opposite 1 w 1863
way 2 w 1866
that 8 w 1871
is 29 w 1873
towards 1 w 1881
enabling 1 w 1889
himself 2 w 1896
to 21 w 1898
do 6 w 1900
as 15 w 1902
much 2 w 1906
wrong 7 w 1911
as 16 w 1913
possible 4 w 1921
and 12 w 1924
to 22 w 1926
pay 1 w 1929
no 12 w 1931
penalty 1 w 1938
for 6 w 1941
the 23 w 1944
wrong 8 w 1949
he 33 w 1951
does 1 w 1955
will 6 w 1960
they 1 w 1964
not 6 w 1967
Call 10 w 1972
Apparently 1 w 1983