Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Gorgias

Gorgias (498)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg023.perseus-eng2:498
Refs {'start': {'reference': '498', 'human_reference': 'Section 498'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
498
498a
Soc.

And again, a man of sense in a state of pain or enjoyment?

Call.

Yes.

Soc.

And which sort are more apt to feel enjoyment or pain, the wise or the foolish?

Call.

I should think there is not much difference.

Soc.

Well, that will suffice. In war have you ever seen a coward?

Call.

Of course I have.

Soc.

Well now, when the enemy withdrew, which seemed to you to enjoy it more, the cowards or the brave?

498b
Call.

Both did, I thought; or if not that, about equally.

Soc.

No matter. Anyhow, the cowards do enjoy it?

Call.

Very much.

Soc.

And the fools, it would seem.

Call.

Yes.

Soc.

And when the foe advances, do the cowards alone feel pain, or the brave as well?

Call.

Both.

Soc.

Alike?

Call.

More, perhaps, the cowards.

Soc.

And when the foe withdraws, do they not enjoy it more?

Call.

Perhaps.

Soc.

So the foolish and the wise, and the cowardly and the brave,

498c
feel pain and enjoyment about equally, according to you, but the cowardly more than the brave?

Call.

I agree.

Soc.

But further, are the wise and brave good, and the cowards and fools bad?

Call.

Yes.

Soc.

Then the good and the bad feel enjoyment and pain about equally?

Call.

I agree.

Soc.

Then are the good and the bad about equally good and bad? Or are the bad in some yet greater measure good and bad?

498d
Call.

Why, upon my word, I cannot tell what you mean.

Soc.

You are aware, are you not, that you hold that the good are good by the presence of good things, and that the bad are so by the presence of bad things? And that the pleasures are the good things, and the pains bad things?

Call.

Yes, I am.

Soc.

Hence in those who have enjoyment the good thingsthe pleasuresare present, so long as they enjoy?

Call.

Of course.

Soc.

Then, good things being present, those who enjoy are good?

Call.

Yes.

Soc.

Well now, in those who feel pain are not bad things present, namely pains?

Call.

They are.

498e

Soc.

And it is by the presence of bad things, you say, that the bad are bad? Or do you no longer say so?

Call.

I do say so.

Soc.

Then whoever enjoys is good, and whoever is pained, bad?

Call.

Certainly.

Soc.

You mean, those more so who feel these things more, and those less who feel less, and those about equally who feel about equally?

Call.

Yes.

Soc.

Now you say that the wise and the foolish, the cowardly and the brave, feel enjoyment and pain about equally, or the cowards even more?

Call.

I do.

Tokens

Soc 1 w 3
And 1 w 7
again 1 w 12
a 3 w 14
man 1 w 17
of 1 w 19
sense 1 w 24
in 2 w 26
a 5 w 27
state 1 w 32
of 2 w 34
pain 1 w 38
or 1 w 40
enjoyment 1 w 49
Call 1 w 54
Yes 1 w 58
Soc 2 w 62
And 2 w 66
which 1 w 71
sort 1 w 75
are 1 w 78
more 1 w 82
apt 1 w 85
to 1 w 87
feel 1 w 91
enjoyment 2 w 100
or 4 w 102
pain 2 w 106
the 1 w 110
wise 1 w 114
or 5 w 116
the 2 w 119
foolish 1 w 126
Call 2 w 131
I 1 w 133
should 1 w 139
think 1 w 144
there 1 w 149
is 3 w 151
not 1 w 154
much 1 w 158
difference 1 w 168
Soc 3 w 172
Well 1 w 177
that 1 w 182
will 1 w 186
suffice 1 w 193
In 1 w 196
war 1 w 199
have 1 w 203
you 1 w 206
ever 1 w 210
seen 1 w 214
a 16 w 215
coward 1 w 221
Call 3 w 226
Of 1 w 229
course 1 w 235
I 3 w 236
have 2 w 240
Soc 4 w 244
Well 2 w 249
now 1 w 252
when 1 w 257
the 4 w 260
enemy 1 w 265
withdrew 1 w 273
which 2 w 279
seemed 1 w 285
to 2 w 287
you 2 w 290
to 3 w 292
enjoy 3 w 297
it 2 w 299
more 2 w 303
the 5 w 307
cowards 1 w 314
or 7 w 316
the 6 w 319
brave 1 w 324
Call 4 w 329
Both 1 w 334
did 1 w 337
I 4 w 339
thought 1 w 346
or 8 w 349
if 2 w 351
not 2 w 354
that 2 w 358
about 1 w 364
equally 1 w 371
Soc 5 w 375
No 1 w 378
matter 1 w 384
Anyhow 1 w 391
the 7 w 395
cowards 2 w 402
do 1 w 404
enjoy 4 w 409
it 3 w 411
Call 5 w 416
Very 1 w 421
much 2 w 425
Soc 6 w 429
And 3 w 433
the 8 w 436
fools 1 w 441
it 4 w 444
would 1 w 449
seem 2 w 453
Call 6 w 458
Yes 2 w 462
Soc 7 w 466
And 4 w 470
when 2 w 474
the 9 w 477
foe 1 w 480
advances 1 w 488
do 2 w 491
the 10 w 494
cowards 3 w 501
alone 1 w 506
feel 2 w 510
pain 3 w 514
or 9 w 517
the 11 w 520
brave 2 w 525
as 1 w 527
well 1 w 531
Call 7 w 536
Both 2 w 541
Soc 8 w 545
Alike 1 w 551
Call 8 w 556
More 1 w 561
perhaps 1 w 569
the 12 w 573
cowards 4 w 580
Soc 9 w 584
And 5 w 588
when 3 w 592
the 13 w 595
foe 2 w 598
withdraws 1 w 607
do 3 w 610
they 1 w 614
not 3 w 617
enjoy 5 w 622
it 6 w 624
more 3 w 628
Call 9 w 633
Perhaps 1 w 641
Soc 10 w 645
So 11 w 648
the 15 w 651
foolish 2 w 658
and 1 w 661
the 16 w 664
wise 2 w 668
and 2 w 672
the 17 w 675
cowardly 1 w 683
and 3 w 686
the 18 w 689
brave 3 w 694
feel 3 w 699
pain 4 w 703
and 4 w 706
enjoyment 3 w 715
about 2 w 720
equally 2 w 727
according 1 w 737
to 4 w 739
you 3 w 742
but 1 w 746
the 19 w 749
cowardly 2 w 757
more 4 w 761
than 1 w 765
the 20 w 768
brave 4 w 773
Call 10 w 778
I 5 w 780
agree 1 w 785
Soc 11 w 789
But 1 w 793
further 1 w 800
are 2 w 804
the 22 w 807
wise 3 w 811
and 5 w 814
brave 5 w 819
good 1 w 823
and 6 w 827
the 23 w 830
cowards 5 w 837
and 7 w 840
fools 2 w 845
bad 1 w 848
Call 11 w 853
Yes 3 w 857
Soc 12 w 861
Then 1 w 866
the 24 w 869
good 2 w 873
and 8 w 876
the 25 w 879
bad 2 w 882
feel 4 w 886
enjoyment 4 w 895
and 9 w 898
pain 5 w 902
about 3 w 907
equally 3 w 914
Call 12 w 919
I 6 w 921
agree 2 w 926
Soc 13 w 930
Then 2 w 935
are 3 w 938
the 26 w 941
good 3 w 945
and 10 w 948
the 27 w 951
bad 3 w 954
about 4 w 959
equally 4 w 966
good 4 w 970
and 11 w 973
bad 4 w 976
Or 1 w 979
are 4 w 982
the 28 w 985
bad 5 w 988
in 10 w 990
some 1 w 994
yet 1 w 997
greater 1 w 1004
measure 1 w 1011
good 5 w 1015
and 12 w 1018
bad 6 w 1021
Call 13 w 1026
Why 1 w 1030
upon 1 w 1035
my 2 w 1037
word 1 w 1041
I 7 w 1043
cannot 1 w 1049
tell 1 w 1053
what 1 w 1057
you 4 w 1060
mean 1 w 1064
Soc 14 w 1068
You 1 w 1072
are 5 w 1075
aware 1 w 1080
are 7 w 1084
you 5 w 1087
not 5 w 1090
that 3 w 1095
you 6 w 1098
hold 1 w 1102
that 4 w 1106
the 29 w 1109
good 6 w 1113
are 8 w 1116
good 7 w 1120
by 1 w 1122
the 30 w 1125
presence 1 w 1133
of 3 w 1135
good 8 w 1139
things 1 w 1145
and 13 w 1149
that 5 w 1153
the 31 w 1156
bad 7 w 1159
are 9 w 1162
so 3 w 1164
by 2 w 1166
the 32 w 1169
presence 2 w 1177
of 4 w 1179
bad 8 w 1182
things 2 w 1188
And 6 w 1192
that 6 w 1196
the 33 w 1199
pleasures 1 w 1208
are 10 w 1211
the 34 w 1214
good 9 w 1218
things 3 w 1224
and 14 w 1228
the 35 w 1231
pains 1 w 1236
bad 9 w 1239
things 4 w 1245
Call 14 w 1250
Yes 4 w 1254
I 8 w 1256
am 1 w 1258
Soc 15 w 1262
Hence 1 w 1268
in 16 w 1270
those 1 w 1275
who 1 w 1278
have 3 w 1282
enjoyment 5 w 1291
the 36 w 1294
good 10 w 1298
things 5 w 1304
the 37 w 1308
pleasures 2 w 1317
are 11 w 1321
present 1 w 1328
so 4 w 1331
long 1 w 1335
as 5 w 1337
they 2 w 1341
enjoy 9 w 1346
Call 15 w 1351
Of 2 w 1354
course 2 w 1360
Soc 16 w 1364
Then 3 w 1369
good 11 w 1374
things 6 w 1380
being 1 w 1385
present 2 w 1392
those 2 w 1398
who 2 w 1401
enjoy 10 w 1406
are 12 w 1409
good 12 w 1413
Call 16 w 1418
Yes 5 w 1422
Soc 17 w 1426
Well 3 w 1431
now 2 w 1434
in 20 w 1437
those 3 w 1442
who 3 w 1445
feel 5 w 1449
pain 7 w 1453
are 13 w 1456
not 6 w 1459
bad 10 w 1462
things 7 w 1468
present 3 w 1475
namely 1 w 1482
pains 2 w 1487
Call 17 w 1492
They 1 w 1497
are 14 w 1500
Soc 18 w 1504
And 7 w 1508
it 7 w 1510
is 7 w 1512
by 3 w 1514
the 39 w 1517
presence 3 w 1525
of 5 w 1527
bad 11 w 1530
things 8 w 1536
you 7 w 1540
say 1 w 1543
that 7 w 1548
the 40 w 1551
bad 12 w 1554
are 15 w 1557
bad 13 w 1560
Or 2 w 1563
do 4 w 1565
you 8 w 1568
no 9 w 1570
longer 1 w 1576
say 2 w 1579
so 5 w 1581
Call 18 w 1586
I 9 w 1588
do 5 w 1590
say 3 w 1593
so 6 w 1595
Soc 19 w 1599
Then 4 w 1604
whoever 1 w 1611
enjoys 1 w 1617
is 8 w 1619
good 13 w 1623
and 15 w 1627
whoever 2 w 1634
is 9 w 1636
pained 1 w 1642
bad 14 w 1646
Call 19 w 1651
Certainly 1 w 1661
Soc 20 w 1665
You 2 w 1669
mean 2 w 1673
those 4 w 1679
more 5 w 1683
so 7 w 1685
who 6 w 1688
feel 6 w 1692
these 1 w 1697
things 9 w 1703
more 6 w 1707
and 16 w 1711
those 5 w 1716
less 1 w 1720
who 7 w 1723
feel 7 w 1727
less 2 w 1731
and 17 w 1735
those 6 w 1740
about 5 w 1745
equally 5 w 1752
who 8 w 1755
feel 8 w 1759
about 6 w 1764
equally 6 w 1771
Call 20 w 1776
Yes 6 w 1780
Soc 21 w 1784
Now 1 w 1788
you 9 w 1791
say 4 w 1794
that 8 w 1798
the 42 w 1801
wise 4 w 1805
and 18 w 1808
the 43 w 1811
foolish 3 w 1818
the 44 w 1822
cowardly 3 w 1830
and 19 w 1833
the 45 w 1836
brave 6 w 1841
feel 9 w 1846
enjoyment 6 w 1855
and 20 w 1858
pain 10 w 1862
about 7 w 1867
equally 7 w 1874
or 17 w 1877
the 46 w 1880
cowards 6 w 1887
even 1 w 1891
more 7 w 1895
Call 21 w 1900
I 10 w 1902
do 6 w 1904