Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Gorgias

Gorgias (486)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg023.perseus-eng2:486
Refs {'start': {'reference': '486', 'human_reference': 'Section 486'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Call.

Indeed I am prompted to address you in the same sort of words as he did his brother: You neglect, Socrates, what you ought to mind; you distort with a kind of boyish travesty a soul of such noble nature;

486
486a
and neither will you bring to the counsels of justice any rightly spoken word, nor will you accept any as probable or convincing, nor advise any gallant plan for your fellow. And yet, my dear Socratesnow do not be annoyed with me, for I am going to say this from goodwill to youdoes it not seem to you disgraceful to be in the state I consider you are in, along with the rest of those who are ever pushing further into philosophy? For as it is, if somebody should seize hold of you or anyone else at all of your sort, and drag you off to prison, asserting that you were guilty of a wrong you had never done, you know you would be at a loss what to do with yourself, and would be all dizzy
486b
and agape without a word to say; and when you came up in court, though your accuser might be ever so paltry a rascal, you would have to die if he chose to claim death as your penalty. And yet what wisdom is there, Socrates, in an art that found a man of goodly parts and made him worse, unable either to succor himself, or to deliver himself or anyone else from the greatest dangers, but like
486c
to be stripped by his enemies of all his substance, and to live in his city as an absolute outcast? Such a person, if one may use a rather low expression, can be given a box on the ear with impunity. No, take my advice, my good sir, and cease refuting; some practical proficiency induce,something that will give you credit for sense: to others leave these pretty toys,call them vaporings or fooleries as you will,—
486d
which will bring you to inhabit empty halls; and emulate, not men who probe these trifles, but who have means and repute and other good things in plenty.

Soc.

If my soul had happened to be made of gold, Callicles, do you not think I should have been delighted to find one of those stones with which they test gold, and the best one; which, if I applied it, and it confirmed to me that my soul had been properly tended, would give me full assurance that I am in a satisfactory state and

486e
have no need of other testing?

Call.

What is the point of that question, Socrates?

Soc.

I will tell you. I am just thinking what a lucky stroke I have had in striking up with you.

Call.

How so?

Tokens

Call 1 w 4
Indeed 1 w 11
I 2 w 12
am 1 w 14
prompted 1 w 22
to 1 w 24
address 1 w 31
you 1 w 34
in 1 w 36
the 1 w 39
same 1 w 43
sort 1 w 47
of 1 w 49
words 1 w 54
as 1 w 56
he 2 w 58
did 1 w 61
his 1 w 64
brother 1 w 71
You 1 w 75
neglect 1 w 82
Socrates 1 w 91
what 1 w 96
you 2 w 99
ought 1 w 104
to 2 w 106
mind 1 w 110
you 3 w 114
distort 1 w 121
with 1 w 125
a 8 w 126
kind 1 w 130
of 2 w 132
boyish 1 w 138
travesty 1 w 146
a 10 w 147
soul 1 w 151
of 3 w 153
such 1 w 157
noble 1 w 162
nature 1 w 168
and 1 w 172
neither 1 w 179
will 1 w 183
you 4 w 186
bring 1 w 191
to 4 w 193
the 4 w 196
counsels 1 w 204
of 4 w 206
justice 1 w 213
any 1 w 216
rightly 1 w 223
spoken 1 w 229
word 2 w 233
nor 1 w 237
will 2 w 241
you 5 w 244
accept 1 w 250
any 2 w 253
as 2 w 255
probable 1 w 263
or 6 w 265
convincing 1 w 275
nor 2 w 279
advise 1 w 285
any 3 w 288
gallant 1 w 295
plan 1 w 299
for 1 w 302
your 1 w 306
fellow 1 w 312
And 1 w 316
yet 1 w 319
my 1 w 322
dear 1 w 326
Socrates 2 w 334
now 1 w 338
do 1 w 340
not 1 w 343
be 1 w 345
annoyed 1 w 352
with 2 w 356
me 2 w 358
for 2 w 362
I 3 w 363
am 3 w 365
going 1 w 370
to 5 w 372
say 1 w 375
this 1 w 379
from 1 w 383
goodwill 1 w 391
to 6 w 393
you 7 w 396
does 1 w 401
it 4 w 403
not 2 w 406
seem 1 w 410
to 7 w 412
you 8 w 415
disgraceful 1 w 426
to 8 w 428
be 2 w 430
in 8 w 432
the 5 w 435
state 1 w 440
I 4 w 441
consider 1 w 449
you 9 w 452
are 1 w 455
in 9 w 457
along 1 w 463
with 3 w 467
the 6 w 470
rest 1 w 474
of 5 w 476
those 1 w 481
who 1 w 484
are 2 w 487
ever 1 w 491
pushing 1 w 498
further 1 w 505
into 1 w 509
philosophy 1 w 519
For 1 w 523
as 3 w 525
it 6 w 527
is 7 w 529
if 1 w 532
somebody 1 w 540
should 1 w 546
seize 1 w 551
hold 1 w 555
of 6 w 557
you 10 w 560
or 11 w 562
anyone 1 w 568
else 1 w 572
at 6 w 574
all 3 w 577
of 7 w 579
your 2 w 583
sort 2 w 587
and 2 w 591
drag 1 w 595
you 12 w 598
off 1 w 601
to 10 w 603
prison 1 w 609
asserting 1 w 619
that 1 w 623
you 13 w 626
were 1 w 630
guilty 1 w 636
of 9 w 638
a 41 w 639
wrong 1 w 644
you 14 w 647
had 1 w 650
never 1 w 655
done 1 w 659
you 15 w 663
know 1 w 667
you 16 w 670
would 1 w 675
be 3 w 677
at 8 w 679
a 44 w 680
loss 1 w 684
what 2 w 688
to 11 w 690
do 4 w 692
with 4 w 696
yourself 1 w 704
and 3 w 708
would 2 w 713
be 4 w 715
all 4 w 718
dizzy 1 w 723
and 4 w 726
agape 1 w 731
without 1 w 738
a 51 w 739
word 3 w 743
to 12 w 745
say 2 w 748
and 5 w 752
when 1 w 756
you 18 w 759
came 1 w 763
up 1 w 765
in 13 w 767
court 1 w 772
though 1 w 779
your 4 w 783
accuser 1 w 790
might 1 w 795
be 5 w 797
ever 3 w 801
so 7 w 803
paltry 1 w 809
a 57 w 810
rascal 1 w 816
you 20 w 820
would 3 w 825
have 1 w 829
to 13 w 831
die 1 w 834
if 2 w 836
he 10 w 838
chose 1 w 843
to 14 w 845
claim 1 w 850
death 1 w 855
as 6 w 857
your 5 w 861
penalty 1 w 868
And 2 w 872
yet 2 w 875
what 3 w 879
wisdom 1 w 885
is 10 w 887
there 1 w 892
Socrates 3 w 901
in 14 w 904
an 13 w 906
art 1 w 909
that 2 w 913
found 1 w 918
a 70 w 919
man 1 w 922
of 10 w 924
goodly 1 w 930
parts 1 w 935
and 6 w 938
made 1 w 942
him 1 w 945
worse 1 w 950
unable 1 w 957
either 2 w 963
to 15 w 965
succor 1 w 971
himself 1 w 978
or 16 w 981
to 16 w 983
deliver 1 w 990
himself 2 w 997
or 17 w 999
anyone 2 w 1005
else 2 w 1009
from 2 w 1013
the 10 w 1016
greatest 1 w 1024
dangers 1 w 1031
but 1 w 1035
like 1 w 1039
to 17 w 1041
be 6 w 1043
stripped 1 w 1051
by 1 w 1053
his 3 w 1056
enemies 1 w 1063
of 11 w 1065
all 5 w 1068
his 4 w 1071
substance 1 w 1080
and 7 w 1084
to 18 w 1086
live 2 w 1090
in 15 w 1092
his 5 w 1095
city 1 w 1099
as 7 w 1101
an 20 w 1103
absolute 1 w 1111
outcast 1 w 1118
Such 1 w 1123
a 86 w 1124
person 1 w 1130
if 3 w 1133
one 4 w 1136
may 1 w 1139
use 2 w 1142
a 88 w 1143
rather 1 w 1149
low 2 w 1152
expression 1 w 1162
can 1 w 1166
be 7 w 1168
given 1 w 1173
a 91 w 1174
box 1 w 1177
on 12 w 1179
the 12 w 1182
ear 2 w 1185
with 6 w 1189
impunity 1 w 1197
No 1 w 1200
take 1 w 1205
my 2 w 1207
advice 1 w 1213
my 3 w 1216
good 3 w 1220
sir 1 w 1223
and 8 w 1227
cease 1 w 1232
refuting 1 w 1240
some 2 w 1245
practical 1 w 1254
proficiency 1 w 1265
induce 1 w 1271
something 1 w 1282
that 3 w 1286
will 4 w 1290
give 2 w 1294
you 22 w 1297
credit 1 w 1303
for 3 w 1306
sense 1 w 1311
to 19 w 1314
others 1 w 1320
leave 1 w 1325
these 1 w 1330
pretty 1 w 1336
toys 1 w 1340
call 1 w 1346
them 1 w 1350
vaporings 1 w 1359
or 20 w 1361
fooleries 1 w 1370
as 10 w 1372
you 23 w 1375
will 5 w 1379
which 1 w 1386
will 6 w 1390
bring 2 w 1395
you 24 w 1398
to 21 w 1400
inhabit 1 w 1407
empty 1 w 1412
halls 1 w 1417
and 9 w 1421
emulate 1 w 1428
not 3 w 1432
men 1 w 1435
who 2 w 1438
probe 1 w 1443
these 2 w 1448
trifles 1 w 1455
but 2 w 1459
who 3 w 1462
have 2 w 1466
means 1 w 1471
and 10 w 1474
repute 1 w 1480
and 11 w 1483
other 3 w 1488
good 4 w 1492
things 1 w 1498
in 23 w 1500
plenty 1 w 1506
Soc 4 w 1510
If 1 w 1513
my 4 w 1515
soul 2 w 1519
had 2 w 1522
happened 1 w 1530
to 22 w 1532
be 9 w 1534
made 2 w 1538
of 13 w 1540
gold 1 w 1544
Callicles 1 w 1554
do 6 w 1557
you 25 w 1560
not 4 w 1563
think 1 w 1568
I 6 w 1569
should 2 w 1575
have 3 w 1579
been 1 w 1583
delighted 1 w 1592
to 23 w 1594
find 1 w 1598
one 5 w 1601
of 14 w 1603
those 2 w 1608
stones 1 w 1614
with 7 w 1618
which 2 w 1623
they 1 w 1627
test 2 w 1631
gold 2 w 1635
and 12 w 1639
the 19 w 1642
best 1 w 1646
one 7 w 1649
which 3 w 1655
if 5 w 1658
I 7 w 1659
applied 1 w 1666
it 16 w 1668
and 13 w 1672
it 17 w 1674
confirmed 1 w 1683
to 25 w 1685
me 10 w 1687
that 4 w 1691
my 5 w 1693
soul 3 w 1697
had 3 w 1700
been 2 w 1704
properly 1 w 1712
tended 1 w 1718
would 4 w 1724
give 3 w 1728
me 11 w 1730
full 1 w 1734
assurance 1 w 1743
that 5 w 1747
I 8 w 1748
am 5 w 1750
in 26 w 1752
a 126 w 1753
satisfactory 1 w 1765
state 2 w 1770
and 14 w 1773
have 4 w 1777
no 11 w 1779
need 1 w 1783
of 15 w 1785
other 4 w 1790
testing 1 w 1797
Call 3 w 1802
What 1 w 1807
is 15 w 1809
the 21 w 1812
point 1 w 1817
of 16 w 1819
that 6 w 1823
question 1 w 1831
Socrates 4 w 1840
Soc 6 w 1844
I 9 w 1846
will 7 w 1850
tell 1 w 1854
you 26 w 1857
I 10 w 1859
am 6 w 1861
just 2 w 1865
thinking 1 w 1873
what 4 w 1877
a 138 w 1878
lucky 1 w 1883
stroke 1 w 1889
I 11 w 1890
have 5 w 1894
had 4 w 1897
in 31 w 1899
striking 1 w 1907
up 2 w 1909
with 8 w 1913
you 27 w 1916
Call 4 w 1921
How 1 w 1925
so 14 w 1927