Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Gorgias

Gorgias (484)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg023.perseus-eng2:484
Refs {'start': {'reference': '484', 'human_reference': 'Section 484'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Call.

we mold the best and strongest amongst us, taking them from their infancy like young lions, and utterly enthral them by our spells

484
484a
and witchcraft, telling them the while that they must have but their equal share, and that this is what is fair and just. But, I fancy, when some man arises with a nature of sufficient force, he shakes off all that we have taught him, bursts his bonds, and breaks free; he tramples underfoot our codes and juggleries, our charms and laws, which are all against nature; our slave rises in revolt and shows himself our master, and there
484b
dawns the full light of natural justice. And it seems to me that Pindar adds his evidence to what I say, in the ode where he says
Law the sovereign of all,
Mortals and immortals,
Pind. Fr. 169 (Bergk)which, so he continues,—
Carries all with highest hand,
Justifying the utmost force: in proof I take
The deeds of Hercules, for unpurchased
Pind. Fr. 169 (Bergk)the words are something like thatI do not know the poem wellbut it tells how he drove off the cows
484c
as neither a purchase nor a gift from Geryones; taking it as a natural right that cows ar any other possessions of the inferior and weaker should all belong to the superior and stronger. Well, that is the truth of the matter; and you will grasp it if you will now put philosophy aside and pass to greater things. For philosophy, you know, Socrates, is a charming thing, if a man has to do with it moderately in his younger days; but if he continues to spend his time on it too long, it is ruin to any man. However well endowed one may be, if one philosophizes far on into life, one must needs find oneself
484d
ignorant of everything that ought to be familiar to the man who would be a thorough gentleman and make a good figure in the world. For such people are shown to be ignorant of the laws of their city, and of the terms which have to be used in negotiating agreements with their fellows in private or in public affairs, and of human pleasures and desires; and, in short, to be utterly inexperienced in mens characters. So when they enter upon any private or public business they make themselves ridiculous, just as on the other hand, I suppose, when public men
484e
engage in your studies and discussions, they are quite ridiculous.

Tokens

Call 1 w 4
we 1 w 7
mold 1 w 11
the 1 w 14
best 1 w 18
and 1 w 21
strongest 1 w 30
amongst 1 w 37
us 1 w 39
taking 1 w 46
them 1 w 50
from 1 w 54
their 1 w 59
infancy 1 w 66
like 1 w 70
young 1 w 75
lions 1 w 80
and 2 w 84
utterly 1 w 91
enthral 1 w 98
them 2 w 102
by 1 w 104
our 1 w 107
spells 1 w 113
and 3 w 116
witchcraft 1 w 126
telling 1 w 134
them 3 w 138
the 6 w 141
while 1 w 146
that 1 w 150
they 1 w 154
must 1 w 158
have 1 w 162
but 1 w 165
their 2 w 170
equal 1 w 175
share 1 w 180
and 4 w 184
that 2 w 188
this 1 w 192
is 2 w 194
what 1 w 198
is 3 w 200
fair 1 w 204
and 5 w 207
just 1 w 211
But 1 w 215
I 1 w 217
fancy 2 w 222
when 1 w 227
some 1 w 231
man 1 w 234
arises 1 w 240
with 1 w 244
a 22 w 245
nature 1 w 251
of 1 w 253
sufficient 1 w 263
force 1 w 268
he 10 w 271
shakes 1 w 277
off 1 w 280
all 2 w 283
that 3 w 287
we 2 w 289
have 2 w 293
taught 1 w 299
him 1 w 302
bursts 1 w 309
his 2 w 312
bonds 1 w 317
and 6 w 321
breaks 1 w 327
free 1 w 331
he 11 w 334
tramples 1 w 342
underfoot 1 w 351
our 2 w 354
codes 1 w 359
and 7 w 362
juggleries 1 w 372
our 3 w 376
charms 1 w 382
and 8 w 385
laws 1 w 389
which 1 w 395
are 2 w 398
all 3 w 401
against 1 w 408
nature 2 w 414
our 4 w 418
slave 1 w 423
rises 2 w 428
in 5 w 430
revolt 1 w 436
and 9 w 439
shows 1 w 444
himself 1 w 451
our 5 w 454
master 1 w 460
and 10 w 464
there 1 w 469
dawns 1 w 474
the 10 w 477
full 1 w 481
light 1 w 486
of 3 w 488
natural 1 w 495
justice 1 w 502
And 1 w 506
it 3 w 508
seems 1 w 513
to 1 w 515
me 2 w 517
that 4 w 521
Pindar 1 w 527
adds 1 w 531
his 3 w 534
evidence 1 w 542
to 2 w 544
what 2 w 548
I 2 w 549
say 1 w 552
in 7 w 555
the 11 w 558
ode 2 w 561
where 1 w 566
he 16 w 568
says 1 w 572
Law 1 w 576
the 12 w 579
sovereign 1 w 588
of 4 w 590
all 4 w 593
Mortals 1 w 601
and 11 w 604
immortals 1 w 613
Pind 2 w 618
Fr 1 w 621
169 1 w 625
Bergk 1 w 631
which 2 w 637
so 3 w 640
he 18 w 642
continues 1 w 651
Carries 1 w 660
all 5 w 663
with 2 w 667
highest 1 w 674
hand 1 w 678
Justifying 1 w 689
the 13 w 692
utmost 1 w 698
force 2 w 703
in 11 w 706
proof 1 w 711
I 3 w 712
take 1 w 716
The 1 w 719
deeds 1 w 724
of 6 w 726
Hercules 1 w 734
for 3 w 738
unpurchased 1 w 749
Pind 3 w 753
Fr 2 w 756
169 2 w 760
Bergk 2 w 766
the 14 w 771
words 1 w 776
are 3 w 779
something 1 w 788
like 2 w 792
that 5 w 796
I 4 w 798
do 1 w 800
not 1 w 803
know 1 w 807
the 15 w 810
poem 1 w 814
well 1 w 818
but 2 w 822
it 5 w 824
tells 1 w 829
how 2 w 832
he 24 w 834
drove 1 w 839
off 2 w 842
the 16 w 845
cows 1 w 849
as 3 w 851
neither 1 w 858
a 67 w 859
purchase 2 w 867
nor 1 w 870
a 69 w 871
gift 1 w 875
from 2 w 879
Geryones 1 w 887
taking 2 w 894
it 7 w 896
as 5 w 898
a 72 w 899
natural 2 w 906
right 1 w 911
that 6 w 915
cows 2 w 919
ar 8 w 921
any 1 w 924
other 1 w 929
possessions 1 w 940
of 8 w 942
the 19 w 945
inferior 1 w 953
and 13 w 956
weaker 1 w 962
should 1 w 968
all 6 w 971
belong 1 w 977
to 3 w 979
the 20 w 982
superior 1 w 990
and 14 w 993
stronger 1 w 1001
Well 1 w 1006
that 7 w 1011
is 8 w 1013
the 21 w 1016
truth 1 w 1021
of 9 w 1023
the 22 w 1026
matter 1 w 1032
and 15 w 1036
you 2 w 1039
will 1 w 1043
grasp 1 w 1048
it 8 w 1050
if 3 w 1052
you 3 w 1055
will 2 w 1059
now 2 w 1062
put 1 w 1065
philosophy 1 w 1075
aside 1 w 1080
and 16 w 1083
pass 1 w 1087
to 4 w 1089
greater 1 w 1096
things 1 w 1102
For 1 w 1106
philosophy 2 w 1116
you 4 w 1120
know 2 w 1124
Socrates 1 w 1133
is 9 w 1136
a 91 w 1137
charming 1 w 1145
thing 3 w 1150
if 4 w 1153
a 93 w 1154
man 2 w 1157
has 3 w 1160
to 5 w 1162
do 2 w 1164
with 3 w 1168
it 10 w 1170
moderately 1 w 1180
in 19 w 1182
his 4 w 1185
younger 1 w 1192
days 1 w 1196
but 3 w 1200
if 5 w 1202
he 32 w 1204
continues 2 w 1213
to 6 w 1215
spend 1 w 1220
his 5 w 1223
time 1 w 1227
on 11 w 1229
it 11 w 1231
too 1 w 1234
long 2 w 1238
it 12 w 1241
is 12 w 1243
ruin 1 w 1247
to 8 w 1249
any 2 w 1252
man 3 w 1255
However 1 w 1263
well 2 w 1267
endowed 1 w 1274
one 2 w 1277
may 1 w 1280
be 3 w 1282
if 6 w 1285
one 3 w 1288
philosophizes 1 w 1301
far 1 w 1304
on 15 w 1306
into 1 w 1310
life 1 w 1314
one 4 w 1318
must 2 w 1322
needs 1 w 1327
find 1 w 1331
oneself 1 w 1338
ignorant 1 w 1346
of 10 w 1348
everything 1 w 1358
that 8 w 1362
ought 1 w 1367
to 10 w 1369
be 4 w 1371
familiar 1 w 1379
to 11 w 1381
the 23 w 1384
man 4 w 1387
who 1 w 1390
would 1 w 1395
be 5 w 1397
a 107 w 1398
thorough 1 w 1406
gentleman 1 w 1415
and 17 w 1418
make 1 w 1422
a 111 w 1423
good 1 w 1427
figure 1 w 1433
in 25 w 1435
the 24 w 1438
world 1 w 1443
For 2 w 1447
such 1 w 1451
people 1 w 1457
are 4 w 1460
shown 1 w 1465
to 12 w 1467
be 6 w 1469
ignorant 2 w 1477
of 11 w 1479
the 25 w 1482
laws 2 w 1486
of 12 w 1488
their 3 w 1493
city 1 w 1497
and 18 w 1501
of 13 w 1503
the 27 w 1506
terms 1 w 1511
which 3 w 1516
have 3 w 1520
to 13 w 1522
be 7 w 1524
used 1 w 1528
in 26 w 1530
negotiating 1 w 1541
agreements 1 w 1551
with 4 w 1555
their 4 w 1560
fellows 1 w 1567
in 28 w 1569
private 1 w 1576
or 16 w 1578
in 29 w 1580
public 1 w 1586
affairs 1 w 1593
and 19 w 1597
of 14 w 1599
human 1 w 1604
pleasures 1 w 1613
and 20 w 1616
desires 1 w 1623
and 21 w 1627
in 30 w 1630
short 1 w 1635
to 14 w 1638
be 8 w 1640
utterly 2 w 1647
inexperienced 1 w 1660
in 32 w 1662
men 2 w 1665
s 112 w 1667
characters 1 w 1677
So 2 w 1680
when 2 w 1684
they 2 w 1688
enter 1 w 1693
upon 1 w 1697
any 3 w 1700
private 2 w 1707
or 18 w 1709
public 2 w 1715
business 1 w 1723
they 3 w 1727
make 2 w 1731
themselves 1 w 1741
ridiculous 1 w 1751
just 3 w 1756
as 11 w 1758
on 19 w 1760
the 32 w 1763
other 2 w 1768
hand 2 w 1772
I 5 w 1774
suppose 1 w 1781
when 3 w 1786
public 3 w 1792
men 3 w 1795
engage 1 w 1801
in 34 w 1803
your 1 w 1807
studies 1 w 1814
and 23 w 1817
discussions 1 w 1828
they 4 w 1833
are 5 w 1836
quite 1 w 1841
ridiculous 2 w 1851