Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Euthydemus

Euthydemus (302)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg021.perseus-eng2:302
Refs {'start': {'reference': '302', 'human_reference': 'Section 302'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
Soc.

Then tell me,
he asked,
do you count those things yours which you control and are free to use as you please?
302
302a
For instance, an ox or a sheep,would you count these as yours, if you were free to sell or bestow them, or sacrifice them to any god you chose? And things which you could not treat thus are not yours?
Hereupon, since I knew that some brilliant result was sure to bob up from the mere turn of the questions, and as I also wanted to hear it as quickly as possible, I said: It is precisely as you say; only such things are mine.
Well now,
he went on:
you call those things animals which have life?
302b
Yes, I said.
And you admit that only those animals are yours which you are at liberty to deal with in those various ways that I mentioned just now?
I admit that.
Thenafter a very ironical pause, as though he were pondering some great matterhe proceeded:
Tell me, Socrates, have you an ancestral Zeus[*]?
Here I suspected the discussion was approaching the point at which it eventually ended, and so I tried what desperate wriggle I could to escape from the net in which I now felt myself entangled. My answer was: I have not, Dionysodorus.
What a miserable fellow you must be,
302c
he said,
and no Athenian at all, if you have neither ancestral gods, nor shrines, nor anything else that denotes a gentleman!
Enough, Dionysodorus; speak fair words, and dont browbeat your pupil! For I have altars and shrines, domestic and ancestral, and everything else of the sort that other Athenians have.
Then have not other Athenians,
he asked,
their ancestral Zeus?
None of the Ionians, I replied, give him this title, neither we nor those who have left this city to settle abroad: they have an ancestral Apollo,
302d
because of Ions parentage.[*] Among us the name ancestral is not given to Zeus, but that of houseward and tribal, and we have a tribal Athena.
That will do,
said Dionysodorus;
you have, it seems, Apollo and Zeus and Athena.
Certainly, I said.
Then these must be your gods?
he said.
My ancestors, I said, and lords.
Well, at least, you have them,
he said:
or have you not admitted they are yours?
I have admitted it, I replied: what else could I do?
And are not these gods animals?
he asked:
you know you have admitted
302e
that whatever has life is an animal. Or have these gods no life?
They have, I replied.
Then are they not animals?
Yes, animals, I said.
And those animals,
he went on,
you have admitted to be yours, which you are free to bestow and sell and sacrifice to any god you please.
I have admitted it, I replied; there is no escape for me, Euthydemus.

Tokens

Soc 1 w 3
Then 1 w 8
tell 1 w 12
me 1 w 14
he 2 w 17
asked 1 w 22
do 1 w 25
you 1 w 28
count 1 w 33
those 1 w 38
things 1 w 44
yours 1 w 49
which 1 w 54
you 3 w 57
control 1 w 64
and 1 w 67
are 1 w 70
free 1 w 74
to 1 w 76
use 1 w 79
as 2 w 81
you 4 w 84
please 1 w 90
For 1 w 94
instance 1 w 102
an 3 w 105
ox 1 w 107
or 2 w 109
a 8 w 110
sheep 1 w 115
would 1 w 121
you 5 w 124
count 2 w 129
these 1 w 134
as 4 w 136
yours 2 w 141
if 1 w 144
you 7 w 147
were 1 w 151
free 2 w 155
to 2 w 157
sell 1 w 161
or 3 w 163
bestow 1 w 169
them 1 w 173
or 4 w 176
sacrifice 1 w 185
them 2 w 189
to 4 w 191
any 1 w 194
god 1 w 197
you 8 w 200
chose 1 w 205
And 1 w 209
things 2 w 215
which 2 w 220
you 9 w 223
could 1 w 228
not 1 w 231
treat 1 w 236
thus 1 w 240
are 2 w 243
not 2 w 246
yours 3 w 251
Hereupon 1 w 260
since 1 w 266
I 1 w 267
knew 1 w 271
that 1 w 275
some 1 w 279
brilliant 1 w 288
result 1 w 294
was 1 w 297
sure 1 w 301
to 5 w 303
bob 1 w 306
up 2 w 308
from 1 w 312
the 4 w 315
mere 1 w 319
turn 1 w 323
of 1 w 325
the 5 w 328
questions 1 w 337
and 2 w 341
as 6 w 343
I 2 w 344
also 1 w 348
wanted 1 w 354
to 6 w 356
hear 1 w 360
it 1 w 362
as 7 w 364
quickly 1 w 371
as 8 w 373
possible 1 w 381
I 3 w 383
said 1 w 387
It 1 w 390
is 1 w 392
precisely 1 w 401
as 9 w 403
you 11 w 406
say 1 w 409
only 1 w 414
such 1 w 418
things 3 w 424
are 3 w 427
mine 1 w 431
Well 1 w 436
now 1 w 439
he 10 w 442
went 1 w 446
on 5 w 448
you 12 w 452
call 1 w 456
those 2 w 461
things 4 w 467
animals 1 w 474
which 3 w 479
have 1 w 483
life 1 w 487
Yes 1 w 491
I 5 w 493
said 2 w 497
And 2 w 501
you 13 w 504
admit 1 w 509
that 2 w 513
only 2 w 517
those 3 w 522
animals 2 w 529
are 4 w 532
yours 4 w 537
which 4 w 542
you 15 w 545
are 5 w 548
at 4 w 550
liberty 1 w 557
to 7 w 559
deal 1 w 563
with 1 w 567
in 8 w 569
those 4 w 574
various 1 w 581
ways 1 w 585
that 3 w 589
I 6 w 590
mentioned 1 w 599
just 1 w 603
now 2 w 606
I 7 w 608
admit 2 w 613
that 4 w 617
Then 2 w 622
after 1 w 628
a 47 w 629
very 1 w 633
ironical 1 w 641
pause 1 w 646
as 10 w 649
though 1 w 655
he 12 w 657
were 2 w 661
pondering 1 w 670
some 2 w 674
great 1 w 679
matter 1 w 685
he 13 w 688
proceeded 1 w 697
Tell 1 w 702
me 6 w 704
Socrates 1 w 713
have 2 w 718
you 16 w 721
an 10 w 723
ancestral 1 w 732
Zeus 1 w 736
Zeus 2 w 740
was 2 w 743
the 6 w 746
ancestral 2 w 755
or 5 w 757
tutelary 1 w 765
god 2 w 768
of 2 w 770
the 7 w 773
Dorians 1 w 780
Here 2 w 785
I 8 w 786
suspected 1 w 795
the 8 w 798
discussion 1 w 808
was 3 w 811
approaching 1 w 822
the 9 w 825
point 1 w 830
at 10 w 832
which 5 w 837
it 5 w 839
eventually 1 w 849
ended 1 w 854
and 3 w 858
so 4 w 860
I 9 w 861
tried 1 w 866
what 1 w 870
desperate 1 w 879
wriggle 1 w 886
I 10 w 887
could 2 w 892
to 8 w 894
escape 1 w 900
from 2 w 904
the 10 w 907
net 1 w 910
in 12 w 912
which 6 w 917
I 11 w 918
now 3 w 921
felt 1 w 925
myself 1 w 931
entangled 1 w 940
My 1 w 943
answer 1 w 949
was 4 w 952
I 12 w 954
have 3 w 958
not 3 w 961
Dionysodorus 1 w 974
What 1 w 979
a 77 w 980
miserable 1 w 989
fellow 1 w 995
you 17 w 998
must 1 w 1002
be 3 w 1004
he 19 w 1007
said 3 w 1011
and 4 w 1015
no 7 w 1017
Athenian 1 w 1025
at 14 w 1027
all 3 w 1030
if 4 w 1033
you 18 w 1036
have 4 w 1040
neither 1 w 1047
ancestral 3 w 1056
gods 1 w 1060
nor 1 w 1064
shrines 1 w 1071
nor 2 w 1075
anything 1 w 1083
else 1 w 1087
that 5 w 1091
denotes 1 w 1098
a 89 w 1099
gentleman 1 w 1108
Enough 1 w 1115
Dionysodorus 2 w 1128
speak 1 w 1134
fair 1 w 1138
words 1 w 1143
and 5 w 1147
don 1 w 1150
t 93 w 1152
browbeat 1 w 1160
your 5 w 1164
pupil 1 w 1169
For 2 w 1173
I 13 w 1174
have 5 w 1178
altars 1 w 1184
and 6 w 1187
shrines 2 w 1194
domestic 1 w 1203
and 7 w 1206
ancestral 4 w 1215
and 8 w 1219
everything 1 w 1229
else 2 w 1233
of 3 w 1235
the 13 w 1238
sort 1 w 1242
that 6 w 1246
other 1 w 1251
Athenians 1 w 1260
have 6 w 1264
Then 3 w 1269
have 7 w 1273
not 5 w 1276
other 2 w 1281
Athenians 2 w 1290
he 28 w 1293
asked 2 w 1298
their 1 w 1304
ancestral 5 w 1313
Zeus 3 w 1317
None 1 w 1322
of 4 w 1324
the 19 w 1327
Ionians 1 w 1334
I 15 w 1336
replied 1 w 1343
give 1 w 1348
him 1 w 1351
this 1 w 1355
title 1 w 1360
neither 2 w 1368
we 5 w 1370
nor 3 w 1373
those 5 w 1378
who 1 w 1381
have 8 w 1385
left 1 w 1389
this 2 w 1393
city 1 w 1397
to 9 w 1399
settle 1 w 1405
abroad 1 w 1411
they 1 w 1416
have 9 w 1420
an 31 w 1422
ancestral 6 w 1431
Apollo 1 w 1437
because 1 w 1445
of 5 w 1447
Ion 2 w 1450
s 108 w 1452
parentage 1 w 1461
Cf 1 w 1464
Eur 1 w 1468
Ion 3 w 1472
64-75 1 w 1477
Apollo 2 w 1484
begot 1 w 1489
Ion 4 w 1492
upon 2 w 1496
Creusa 1 w 1502
daughter 1 w 1511
of 6 w 1513
Erechtheus 1 w 1523
Among 1 w 1529
us 17 w 1531
the 23 w 1534
name 1 w 1538
ancestral 7 w 1547
is 7 w 1549
not 6 w 1552
given 1 w 1557
to 10 w 1559
Zeus 4 w 1563
but 1 w 1567
that 7 w 1571
of 7 w 1573
houseward 1 w 1582
and 9 w 1585
tribal 1 w 1591
and 10 w 1595
we 6 w 1597
have 10 w 1601
a 133 w 1602
tribal 2 w 1608
Athena 1 w 1614
That 1 w 1619
will 1 w 1623
do 6 w 1625
said 4 w 1630
Dionysodorus 3 w 1642
you 20 w 1646
have 11 w 1650
it 10 w 1653
seems 1 w 1658
Apollo 3 w 1665
and 11 w 1668
Zeus 5 w 1672
and 12 w 1675
Athena 2 w 1681
Certainly 1 w 1691
I 19 w 1693
said 5 w 1697
Then 4 w 1702
these 2 w 1707
must 2 w 1711
be 7 w 1713
your 6 w 1717
gods 2 w 1721
he 39 w 1724
said 6 w 1728
My 2 w 1731
ancestors 1 w 1740
I 20 w 1742
said 7 w 1746
and 13 w 1750
lords 1 w 1755
Well 2 w 1760
at 20 w 1763
least 1 w 1768
you 22 w 1772
have 12 w 1776
them 3 w 1780
he 41 w 1783
said 8 w 1787
or 18 w 1790
have 13 w 1794
you 23 w 1797
not 7 w 1800
admitted 1 w 1808
they 2 w 1812
are 7 w 1815
yours 5 w 1820
I 21 w 1822
have 14 w 1826
admitted 2 w 1834
it 13 w 1836
I 22 w 1838
replied 2 w 1845
what 2 w 1850
else 3 w 1854
could 3 w 1859
I 23 w 1860
do 8 w 1862
And 3 w 1866
are 8 w 1869
not 8 w 1872
these 3 w 1877
gods 3 w 1881
animals 3 w 1888
he 44 w 1891
asked 3 w 1896
you 25 w 1900
know 1 w 1904
you 26 w 1907
have 15 w 1911
admitted 3 w 1919
that 8 w 1923
whatever 1 w 1931
has 1 w 1934
life 2 w 1938
is 8 w 1940
an 41 w 1942
animal 4 w 1948
Or 1 w 1951
have 16 w 1955
these 4 w 1960
gods 4 w 1964
no 18 w 1966
life 3 w 1970
They 1 w 1975
have 17 w 1979
I 24 w 1981
replied 3 w 1988
Then 5 w 1993
are 9 w 1996
they 3 w 2000
not 9 w 2003
animals 4 w 2010
Yes 2 w 2014
animals 5 w 2022
I 25 w 2024
said 9 w 2028
And 4 w 2032
those 6 w 2037
animals 6 w 2044
he 49 w 2047
went 2 w 2051
on 22 w 2053
you 27 w 2057
have 18 w 2061
admitted 4 w 2069
to 12 w 2071
be 8 w 2073
yours 6 w 2078
which 7 w 2084
you 29 w 2087
are 10 w 2090
free 3 w 2094
to 13 w 2096
bestow 2 w 2102
and 14 w 2105
sell 2 w 2109
and 15 w 2112
sacrifice 2 w 2121
to 15 w 2123
any 3 w 2126
god 7 w 2129
you 30 w 2132
please 2 w 2138
I 26 w 2140
have 19 w 2144
admitted 5 w 2152
it 17 w 2154
I 27 w 2156
replied 4 w 2163
there 1 w 2169
is 9 w 2171
no 20 w 2173
escape 2 w 2179
for 1 w 2182
me 9 w 2184
Euthydemus 1 w 2195