Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Philebus

Philebus (67)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg010.perseus-eng2:67
Refs {'start': {'reference': '67', 'human_reference': 'Section 67'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
67
67a

Pro. Yes, that is what you said.

Soc. And next it was most sufficiently proved that each of these two was insufficient.

Pro. Very true.

Soc. In this argument, then, both mind and pleasure were set aside; neither of them is the absolute good, since they are devoid of self-sufficiency, adequacy, and perfection?

Pro. Quite right.

Soc. And on the appearance of a third competitor, better than either of these, mind is now found to be ten thousand times more akin than pleasure to the victor.

Pro. Certainly.

Soc. Then, according to the judgement which has now been given by our discussion, the power of pleasure would be fifth.

Pro. So it seems.

67b

Soc. But not first, even if all the cattle and horses and other beasts in the world, in their pursuit of enjoyment, so assert. Trusting in them, as augurs trust in birds, the many judge that pleasures are the greatest blessings in life, and they imagine that the lusts of beasts are better witnesses than are the aspirations and thoughts inspired by the philosophic muse.

Pro. Socrates, we all now declare that what you have said is perfectly true.

Soc. Then you will let me go?

Pro. There is still a little left, Socrates. I am sure you will not give up before we do, and I will remind you of what remains.

Tokens

Pro 1 w 3
Yes 1 w 7
that 1 w 12
is 1 w 14
what 1 w 18
you 1 w 21
said 1 w 25
Soc 1 w 29
And 1 w 33
next 1 w 37
it 1 w 39
was 1 w 42
most 1 w 46
sufficiently 1 w 58
proved 1 w 64
that 2 w 68
each 1 w 72
of 1 w 74
these 1 w 79
two 1 w 82
was 2 w 85
insufficient 1 w 97
Pro 2 w 101
Very 1 w 106
true 1 w 110
Soc 2 w 114
In 1 w 117
this 1 w 121
argument 1 w 129
then 1 w 134
both 1 w 139
mind 1 w 143
and 1 w 146
pleasure 1 w 154
were 1 w 158
set 1 w 161
aside 1 w 166
neither 1 w 174
of 2 w 176
them 1 w 180
is 3 w 182
the 5 w 185
absolute 1 w 193
good 1 w 197
since 1 w 203
they 1 w 207
are 1 w 210
devoid 1 w 216
of 3 w 218
self-sufficiency 1 w 234
adequacy 1 w 243
and 2 w 247
perfection 1 w 257
Pro 3 w 261
Quite 1 w 267
right 1 w 272
Soc 3 w 276
And 2 w 280
on 2 w 282
the 7 w 285
appearance 1 w 295
of 4 w 297
a 20 w 298
third 1 w 303
competitor 1 w 313
better 1 w 320
than 1 w 324
either 2 w 330
of 5 w 332
these 2 w 337
mind 2 w 342
is 4 w 344
now 1 w 347
found 1 w 352
to 2 w 354
be 2 w 356
ten 1 w 359
thousand 1 w 367
times 1 w 372
more 1 w 376
akin 1 w 380
than 2 w 384
pleasure 2 w 392
to 3 w 394
the 10 w 397
victor 1 w 403
Pro 4 w 407
Certainly 1 w 417
Soc 4 w 421
Then 1 w 426
according 1 w 436
to 5 w 438
the 11 w 441
judgement 1 w 450
which 1 w 455
has 1 w 458
now 2 w 461
been 1 w 465
given 1 w 470
by 1 w 472
our 1 w 475
discussion 1 w 485
the 12 w 489
power 1 w 494
of 6 w 496
pleasure 3 w 504
would 1 w 509
be 4 w 511
fifth 1 w 516
Pro 5 w 520
So 5 w 523
it 6 w 525
seems 1 w 530
Soc 5 w 534
But 1 w 538
not 1 w 541
first 1 w 546
even 1 w 551
if 2 w 553
all 1 w 556
the 13 w 559
cattle 1 w 565
and 4 w 568
horses 1 w 574
and 5 w 577
other 1 w 582
beasts 1 w 588
in 8 w 590
the 15 w 593
world 1 w 598
in 9 w 601
their 1 w 606
pursuit 1 w 613
of 7 w 615
enjoyment 1 w 624
so 2 w 627
assert 1 w 633
Trusting 1 w 642
in 11 w 644
them 2 w 648
as 10 w 651
augurs 1 w 657
trust 1 w 662
in 12 w 664
birds 1 w 669
the 18 w 673
many 1 w 677
judge 2 w 682
that 3 w 686
pleasures 1 w 695
are 2 w 698
the 19 w 701
greatest 1 w 709
blessings 1 w 718
in 14 w 720
life 1 w 724
and 6 w 728
they 2 w 732
imagine 1 w 739
that 4 w 743
the 21 w 746
lusts 1 w 751
of 8 w 753
beasts 2 w 759
are 3 w 762
better 2 w 768
witnesses 1 w 777
than 3 w 781
are 4 w 784
the 22 w 787
aspirations 1 w 798
and 7 w 801
thoughts 1 w 809
inspired 1 w 817
by 2 w 819
the 23 w 822
philosophic 1 w 833
muse 1 w 837
Pro 6 w 841
Socrates 1 w 850
we 3 w 853
all 2 w 856
now 3 w 859
declare 1 w 866
that 5 w 870
what 2 w 874
you 2 w 877
have 1 w 881
said 2 w 885
is 6 w 887
perfectly 1 w 896
true 2 w 900
Soc 7 w 904
Then 2 w 909
you 3 w 912
will 1 w 916
let 1 w 919
me 5 w 921
go 2 w 923
Pro 7 w 927
There 1 w 933
is 7 w 935
still 1 w 940
a 60 w 941
little 1 w 947
left 1 w 951
Socrates 2 w 960
I 2 w 962
am 1 w 964
sure 5 w 968
you 4 w 971
will 2 w 975
not 2 w 978
give 2 w 982
up 1 w 984
before 1 w 990
we 4 w 992
do 1 w 994
and 8 w 998
I 3 w 999
will 3 w 1003
remind 1 w 1009
you 5 w 1012
of 9 w 1014
what 3 w 1018
remains 1 w 1025