Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Parmenides

Parmenides (159)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg009.perseus-eng2:159
Refs {'start': {'reference': '159', 'human_reference': 'Section 159'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Ceph.
And inasmuch as they are so affected as to be both limited and limitless, they are affected by affections which are the opposites of one another.
159
159a
Yes.
But opposites are as unlike as possible.
To be sure.
Then with regard to either one of their two affections they are like themselves and each other, but with regard to both of them together they are utterly opposed and unlike.
Yes, that must be true.
Therefore the others are both like and unlike themselves and one another.
So they are.
And they are the same as one another and also other than one another, they are both in motion and at rest, and since we have proved these cases, we can easily show that the things
159b
which are other than one experience all the opposite affections.
You are right.
Then what if we now drop these matters as evident and again consider whether, if one is, the things other than one are as we have said, and there is no alternative.
Certainly.
Let us then begin at the beginning and ask, if one is, what must happen to the things which are other than one.
By all means.
Must not the one be separate from the others, and the others from the one?
Why is that?
Because there is nothing else besides these,
159c
which is other than one and other than the others. For when we have said one and the others we have included all things.
Yes, all things.
Then there is nothing other than these, in which both the one and the others may be.
No.
Then the one and the others can never be in the same.
Apparently not.
Then they are separate?
Yes.
And surely we say that what is truly one has no parts.
How can it have parts?
Then the one cannot be in the others as a whole, nor can parts of it, if it is separate from the others and has no parts.
Of course not.
159d
Then the others cannot partake of the one in any way; they can neither partake of any part of it nor of the whole.
No, apparently not.
The others are, then, not one in any sense, nor have they in themselves any unity.
No.
But neither are the others many; for if they were many, each of them would be one part of the whole; but actually the things that are other than one are not many nor a whole nor parts, since they do not participate in the one in any way.
Right.
Neither are the others two or three, nor are two or three in them, if they are entirely deprived of unity.
159e
True.
Nor are the others either themselves like and unlike the one, nor are likeness and unlikeness in them; for if they were like and unlike or had likeness and unlikeness in them, the things which are other than the one would have in them two elements opposite to one another.
That is clear.
But it is impossible for that to partake of two things which does not even partake of one.
Impossible.

Tokens

Ceph 1 w 4
And 1 w 8
inasmuch 1 w 16
as 2 w 18
they 1 w 22
are 1 w 25
so 1 w 27
affected 1 w 35
as 3 w 37
to 1 w 39
be 1 w 41
both 1 w 45
limited 1 w 52
and 1 w 55
limitless 1 w 64
they 2 w 69
are 2 w 72
affected 2 w 80
by 1 w 82
affections 1 w 92
which 1 w 97
are 3 w 100
the 3 w 103
opposites 1 w 112
of 1 w 114
one 1 w 117
another 1 w 124
Yes 1 w 128
But 1 w 132
opposites 2 w 141
are 4 w 144
as 4 w 146
unlike 1 w 152
as 5 w 154
possible 1 w 162
To 1 w 165
be 2 w 167
sure 1 w 171
Then 1 w 176
with 1 w 180
regard 1 w 186
to 2 w 188
either 1 w 194
one 2 w 197
of 2 w 199
their 1 w 204
two 1 w 207
affections 2 w 217
they 3 w 221
are 5 w 224
like 2 w 228
themselves 1 w 238
and 2 w 241
each 1 w 245
other 2 w 250
but 1 w 254
with 2 w 258
regard 2 w 264
to 3 w 266
both 2 w 270
of 3 w 272
them 2 w 276
together 1 w 284
they 4 w 288
are 6 w 291
utterly 1 w 298
opposed 1 w 305
and 3 w 308
unlike 2 w 314
Yes 2 w 318
that 1 w 323
must 1 w 327
be 3 w 329
true 1 w 333
Therefore 1 w 343
the 13 w 346
others 1 w 352
are 7 w 355
both 3 w 359
like 4 w 363
and 4 w 366
unlike 3 w 372
themselves 2 w 382
and 5 w 385
one 3 w 388
another 2 w 395
So 1 w 398
they 5 w 402
are 8 w 405
And 2 w 409
they 6 w 413
are 9 w 416
the 19 w 419
same 1 w 423
as 6 w 425
one 4 w 428
another 3 w 435
and 6 w 438
also 1 w 442
other 6 w 447
than 1 w 451
one 5 w 454
another 4 w 461
they 7 w 466
are 10 w 469
both 4 w 473
in 2 w 475
motion 1 w 481
and 7 w 484
at 2 w 486
rest 1 w 490
and 8 w 494
since 1 w 499
we 1 w 501
have 1 w 505
proved 1 w 511
these 1 w 516
cases 1 w 521
we 2 w 524
can 1 w 527
easily 1 w 533
show 1 w 537
that 2 w 541
the 25 w 544
things 1 w 550
which 2 w 555
are 11 w 558
other 8 w 563
than 2 w 567
one 6 w 570
experience 1 w 580
all 1 w 583
the 27 w 586
opposite 3 w 594
affections 3 w 604
You 1 w 608
are 12 w 611
right 1 w 616
Then 2 w 621
what 1 w 625
if 1 w 627
we 3 w 629
now 1 w 632
drop 1 w 636
these 2 w 641
matters 1 w 648
as 9 w 650
evident 1 w 657
and 9 w 660
again 1 w 665
consider 1 w 673
whether 1 w 680
if 2 w 683
one 7 w 686
is 1 w 688
the 30 w 692
things 2 w 698
other 9 w 703
than 3 w 707
one 8 w 710
are 13 w 713
as 10 w 715
we 4 w 717
have 2 w 721
said 1 w 725
and 10 w 729
there 1 w 734
is 2 w 736
no 6 w 738
alternative 1 w 749
Certainly 1 w 759
Let 1 w 763
us 2 w 765
then 1 w 769
begin 1 w 774
at 7 w 776
the 34 w 779
beginning 1 w 788
and 11 w 791
ask 1 w 794
if 3 w 797
one 9 w 800
is 3 w 802
what 2 w 807
must 2 w 811
happen 1 w 817
to 5 w 819
the 35 w 822
things 3 w 828
which 3 w 833
are 14 w 836
other 10 w 841
than 4 w 845
one 10 w 848
By 1 w 851
all 2 w 854
means 1 w 859
Must 1 w 864
not 5 w 867
the 37 w 870
one 11 w 873
be 6 w 875
separate 1 w 883
from 1 w 887
the 38 w 890
others 2 w 896
and 12 w 900
the 40 w 903
others 3 w 909
from 2 w 913
the 42 w 916
one 12 w 919
Why 1 w 923
is 4 w 925
that 3 w 929
Because 1 w 937
there 2 w 942
is 5 w 944
nothing 1 w 951
else 1 w 955
besides 1 w 962
these 3 w 967
which 4 w 973
is 6 w 975
other 13 w 980
than 5 w 984
one 13 w 987
and 13 w 990
other 14 w 995
than 6 w 999
the 47 w 1002
others 4 w 1008
For 1 w 1012
when 1 w 1016
we 5 w 1018
have 3 w 1022
said 2 w 1026
one 14 w 1029
and 14 w 1032
the 49 w 1035
others 5 w 1041
we 6 w 1043
have 4 w 1047
included 1 w 1055
all 3 w 1058
things 4 w 1064
Yes 3 w 1068
all 4 w 1072
things 5 w 1078
Then 3 w 1083
there 3 w 1088
is 7 w 1090
nothing 2 w 1097
other 17 w 1102
than 7 w 1106
these 4 w 1111
in 17 w 1114
which 5 w 1119
both 5 w 1123
the 54 w 1126
one 15 w 1129
and 15 w 1132
the 55 w 1135
others 6 w 1141
may 1 w 1144
be 8 w 1146
No 1 w 1149
Then 4 w 1154
the 57 w 1157
one 16 w 1160
and 16 w 1163
the 58 w 1166
others 7 w 1172
can 2 w 1175
never 1 w 1180
be 9 w 1182
in 18 w 1184
the 60 w 1187
same 2 w 1191
Apparently 1 w 1202
not 8 w 1205
Then 5 w 1210
they 8 w 1214
are 16 w 1217
separate 2 w 1225
Yes 4 w 1229
And 3 w 1233
surely 1 w 1239
we 7 w 1241
say 1 w 1244
that 4 w 1248
what 3 w 1252
is 8 w 1254
truly 1 w 1259
one 17 w 1262
has 1 w 1265
no 11 w 1267
parts 1 w 1272
How 1 w 1276
can 3 w 1279
it 9 w 1281
have 5 w 1285
parts 2 w 1290
Then 6 w 1295
the 62 w 1298
one 18 w 1301
cannot 1 w 1307
be 10 w 1309
in 19 w 1311
the 63 w 1314
others 8 w 1320
as 13 w 1322
a 109 w 1323
whole 1 w 1328
nor 1 w 1332
can 5 w 1335
parts 3 w 1340
of 4 w 1342
it 10 w 1344
if 4 w 1347
it 11 w 1349
is 9 w 1351
separate 3 w 1359
from 3 w 1363
the 65 w 1366
others 9 w 1372
and 17 w 1375
has 2 w 1378
no 14 w 1380
parts 4 w 1385
Of 1 w 1388
course 1 w 1394
not 10 w 1397
Then 7 w 1402
the 67 w 1405
others 10 w 1411
cannot 2 w 1417
partake 1 w 1424
of 5 w 1426
the 69 w 1429
one 19 w 1432
in 20 w 1434
any 1 w 1437
way 1 w 1440
they 9 w 1445
can 7 w 1448
neither 1 w 1455
partake 2 w 1462
of 6 w 1464
any 2 w 1467
part 7 w 1471
of 7 w 1473
it 13 w 1475
nor 2 w 1478
of 8 w 1480
the 72 w 1483
whole 2 w 1488
No 2 w 1491
apparently 1 w 1502
not 12 w 1505
The 9 w 1509
others 11 w 1515
are 18 w 1518
then 2 w 1523
not 13 w 1527
one 20 w 1530
in 21 w 1532
any 3 w 1535
sense 1 w 1540
nor 3 w 1544
have 6 w 1548
they 10 w 1552
in 22 w 1554
themselves 3 w 1564
any 4 w 1567
unity 1 w 1572
No 3 w 1575
But 2 w 1579
neither 2 w 1586
are 19 w 1589
the 78 w 1592
others 12 w 1598
many 1 w 1602
for 2 w 1606
if 5 w 1608
they 11 w 1612
were 1 w 1616
many 2 w 1620
each 2 w 1625
of 9 w 1627
them 5 w 1631
would 1 w 1636
be 11 w 1638
one 21 w 1641
part 8 w 1645
of 10 w 1647
the 82 w 1650
whole 3 w 1655
but 2 w 1659
actually 1 w 1667
the 83 w 1670
things 6 w 1676
that 5 w 1680
are 20 w 1683
other 25 w 1688
than 8 w 1692
one 22 w 1695
are 21 w 1698
not 14 w 1701
many 3 w 1705
nor 4 w 1708
a 145 w 1709
whole 4 w 1714
nor 5 w 1717
parts 5 w 1722
since 2 w 1728
they 12 w 1732
do 1 w 1734
not 15 w 1737
participate 1 w 1748
in 25 w 1750
the 86 w 1753
one 23 w 1756
in 26 w 1758
any 8 w 1761
way 2 w 1764
Right 1 w 1770
Neither 1 w 1778
are 22 w 1781
the 88 w 1784
others 13 w 1790
two 2 w 1793
or 9 w 1795
three 1 w 1800
nor 6 w 1804
are 23 w 1807
two 3 w 1810
or 11 w 1812
three 2 w 1817
in 27 w 1819
them 6 w 1823
if 6 w 1826
they 13 w 1830
are 24 w 1833
entirely 1 w 1841
deprived 1 w 1849
of 11 w 1851
unity 2 w 1856
True 1 w 1861
Nor 1 w 1865
are 25 w 1868
the 92 w 1871
others 14 w 1877
either 5 w 1883
themselves 4 w 1893
like 6 w 1897
and 18 w 1900
unlike 4 w 1906
the 96 w 1909
one 24 w 1912
nor 7 w 1916
are 26 w 1919
likeness 1 w 1927
and 19 w 1930
unlikeness 1 w 1940
in 28 w 1942
them 8 w 1946
for 3 w 1950
if 7 w 1952
they 14 w 1956
were 2 w 1960
like 10 w 1964
and 20 w 1967
unlike 6 w 1973
or 15 w 1975
had 1 w 1978
likeness 3 w 1986
and 21 w 1989
unlikeness 2 w 1999
in 29 w 2001
them 9 w 2005
the 100 w 2009
things 7 w 2015
which 6 w 2020
are 27 w 2023
other 28 w 2028
than 9 w 2032
the 102 w 2035
one 25 w 2038
would 2 w 2043
have 7 w 2047
in 31 w 2049
them 10 w 2053
two 4 w 2056
elements 1 w 2064
opposite 4 w 2072
to 6 w 2074
one 26 w 2077
another 5 w 2084
That 1 w 2089
is 10 w 2091
clear 1 w 2096
But 3 w 2100
it 20 w 2102
is 11 w 2104
impossible 1 w 2114
for 4 w 2117
that 6 w 2121
to 7 w 2123
partake 3 w 2130
of 12 w 2132
two 5 w 2135
things 8 w 2141
which 7 w 2146
does 1 w 2150
not 17 w 2153
even 1 w 2157
partake 4 w 2164
of 13 w 2166
one 27 w 2169
Impossible 1 w 2180