Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Parmenides

Parmenides (150)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg009.perseus-eng2:150
Refs {'start': {'reference': '150', 'human_reference': 'Section 150'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Ceph.
These two ideas, greatness and smallness, exist, do they not?
For if they did not exist, they could not be opposites of one another and could not come into being in things.
That is obvious.
150
150a
Then if smallness comes into being in the one, it would be either in a part or in the whole of it.
Necessarily.
What if it be in the whole of one?
Will it not either be on an equality with the one, extending throughout the whole of it, or else contain it?
Clearly.
And if smallness be on an equality with the one, will it not be equal to the one, and if it contain the one, greater than the one?
Of course.
But can smallness be equal to anything or greater than anything, performing the functions of greatness or equality and not its own functions?
150b
No, it cannot.
Then smallness cannot exist in the whole of the one, but, if at all, only in a part of it.
Yes.
And neither can it exist in a whole part, for then it will behave just as it did in relation to the whole; it will be equal to or greater than the part in which it happens to exist.
Inevitably.
Then smallness will never exist in anything, either in a part or in a whole, nor will anything be small except absolute smallness.
So it appears.
Nor will greatness exist in the one.
150c
For in that case, something other than absolute greatness and differing from it, namely that in which greatness exists, would be greater, and that although there is no smallness in it, which greatness must exceed, if it be great. But this is impossible, since smallness exists nowhere.
True.
But absolute greatness is not greater than anything but absolute smallness, and absolute smallness is not smaller than anything but absolute greatness.
No.
Then other things are neither greater nor smaller than the one, if they have neither greatness nor smallness,
150d
nor have even these two the power of exceeding or being exceeded in relation to the one, but only in relation to each other, nor can the one be greater or less than these two or than other things, since it has neither greatness nor smallness.
Evidently not.
Then if the one is neither greater nor smaller than the others, it can neither exceed them nor be exceeded by them?
Certainly not.
Then that which neither exceeds nor is exceeded must be on an equality, and being on an equality, must be equal.
Of course.
150e
And the one will be in the same relation to itself also; if it have in itself neither greatness nor smallness, it cannot be exceeded by itself or exceed itself; it would be on an equality with and equal to itself.
Certainly.
The one is, then, equal to itself and to the others.
Evidently.

Tokens

Ceph 1 w 4
These 1 w 10
two 1 w 13
ideas 1 w 18
greatness 1 w 28
and 1 w 31
smallness 1 w 40
exist 1 w 46
do 1 w 49
they 1 w 53
not 1 w 56
For 1 w 60
if 1 w 62
they 2 w 66
did 1 w 69
not 2 w 72
exist 2 w 77
they 3 w 82
could 1 w 87
not 3 w 90
be 1 w 92
opposites 1 w 101
of 1 w 103
one 1 w 106
another 1 w 113
and 2 w 116
could 2 w 121
not 5 w 124
come 1 w 128
into 1 w 132
being 1 w 137
in 3 w 139
things 1 w 145
That 1 w 150
is 3 w 152
obvious 1 w 159
Then 1 w 164
if 2 w 166
smallness 2 w 175
comes 1 w 180
into 2 w 184
being 2 w 189
in 7 w 191
the 5 w 194
one 2 w 197
it 2 w 200
would 1 w 205
be 4 w 207
either 1 w 213
in 8 w 215
a 9 w 216
part 1 w 220
or 2 w 222
in 9 w 224
the 7 w 227
whole 1 w 232
of 2 w 234
it 4 w 236
Necessarily 1 w 248
What 1 w 253
if 3 w 255
it 5 w 257
be 5 w 259
in 10 w 261
the 8 w 264
whole 2 w 269
of 3 w 271
one 3 w 274
Will 1 w 279
it 6 w 281
not 6 w 284
either 2 w 290
be 6 w 292
on 4 w 294
an 4 w 296
equality 1 w 304
with 1 w 308
the 10 w 311
one 4 w 314
extending 1 w 324
throughout 1 w 334
the 11 w 337
whole 3 w 342
of 4 w 344
it 10 w 346
or 3 w 349
else 1 w 353
contain 1 w 360
it 11 w 362
Clearly 1 w 370
And 1 w 374
if 4 w 376
smallness 3 w 385
be 7 w 387
on 7 w 389
an 5 w 391
equality 2 w 399
with 2 w 403
the 12 w 406
one 5 w 409
will 1 w 414
it 14 w 416
not 7 w 419
be 8 w 421
equal 3 w 426
to 3 w 428
the 13 w 431
one 6 w 434
and 3 w 438
if 5 w 440
it 15 w 442
contain 2 w 449
the 14 w 452
one 7 w 455
greater 1 w 463
than 1 w 467
the 15 w 470
one 8 w 473
Of 1 w 476
course 1 w 482
But 1 w 486
can 1 w 489
smallness 4 w 498
be 9 w 500
equal 4 w 505
to 4 w 507
anything 1 w 515
or 4 w 517
greater 2 w 524
than 2 w 528
anything 2 w 536
performing 1 w 547
the 16 w 550
functions 1 w 559
of 5 w 561
greatness 2 w 570
or 6 w 572
equality 3 w 580
and 4 w 583
not 8 w 586
its 1 w 589
own 1 w 592
functions 2 w 601
No 1 w 604
it 18 w 607
cannot 1 w 613
Then 2 w 618
smallness 5 w 627
cannot 2 w 633
exist 3 w 638
in 17 w 640
the 17 w 643
whole 4 w 648
of 6 w 650
the 18 w 653
one 9 w 656
but 1 w 660
if 6 w 663
at 7 w 665
all 6 w 668
only 1 w 673
in 18 w 675
a 40 w 676
part 2 w 680
of 7 w 682
it 19 w 684
Yes 1 w 688
And 2 w 692
neither 1 w 699
can 4 w 702
it 21 w 704
exist 4 w 709
in 19 w 711
a 43 w 712
whole 5 w 717
part 3 w 721
for 2 w 725
then 1 w 729
it 22 w 731
will 2 w 735
behave 1 w 741
just 1 w 745
as 2 w 747
it 23 w 749
did 2 w 752
in 20 w 754
relation 1 w 762
to 5 w 764
the 21 w 767
whole 6 w 772
it 24 w 775
will 3 w 779
be 11 w 781
equal 6 w 786
to 6 w 788
or 8 w 790
greater 3 w 797
than 3 w 801
the 22 w 804
part 4 w 808
in 21 w 810
which 1 w 815
it 25 w 817
happens 1 w 824
to 7 w 826
exist 5 w 831
Inevitably 1 w 842
Then 3 w 847
smallness 6 w 856
will 4 w 860
never 1 w 865
exist 6 w 870
in 22 w 872
anything 3 w 880
either 4 w 887
in 24 w 889
a 56 w 890
part 5 w 894
or 9 w 896
in 25 w 898
a 58 w 899
whole 7 w 904
nor 1 w 908
will 5 w 912
anything 4 w 920
be 12 w 922
small 7 w 927
except 1 w 933
absolute 1 w 941
smallness 7 w 950
So 1 w 953
it 28 w 955
appears 1 w 962
Nor 1 w 966
will 6 w 970
greatness 3 w 979
exist 7 w 984
in 27 w 986
the 24 w 989
one 10 w 992
For 2 w 996
in 28 w 998
that 1 w 1002
case 1 w 1006
something 1 w 1016
other 2 w 1021
than 4 w 1025
absolute 2 w 1033
greatness 4 w 1042
and 5 w 1045
differing 1 w 1054
from 1 w 1058
it 29 w 1060
namely 1 w 1067
that 2 w 1071
in 31 w 1073
which 2 w 1078
greatness 5 w 1087
exists 1 w 1093
would 2 w 1099
be 13 w 1101
greater 4 w 1108
and 6 w 1112
that 3 w 1116
although 1 w 1124
there 1 w 1129
is 10 w 1131
no 12 w 1133
smallness 8 w 1142
in 32 w 1144
it 30 w 1146
which 3 w 1152
greatness 6 w 1161
must 1 w 1165
exceed 1 w 1171
if 8 w 1174
it 31 w 1176
be 14 w 1178
great 11 w 1183
But 2 w 1187
this 1 w 1191
is 12 w 1193
impossible 1 w 1203
since 1 w 1209
smallness 9 w 1218
exists 2 w 1224
nowhere 1 w 1231
True 1 w 1236
But 3 w 1240
absolute 3 w 1248
greatness 7 w 1257
is 14 w 1259
not 11 w 1262
greater 5 w 1269
than 5 w 1273
anything 5 w 1281
but 2 w 1284
absolute 4 w 1292
smallness 10 w 1301
and 7 w 1305
absolute 5 w 1313
smallness 11 w 1322
is 15 w 1324
not 12 w 1327
smaller 1 w 1334
than 6 w 1338
anything 6 w 1346
but 3 w 1349
absolute 6 w 1357
greatness 8 w 1366
No 3 w 1369
Then 4 w 1374
other 3 w 1379
things 2 w 1385
are 1 w 1388
neither 2 w 1395
greater 6 w 1402
nor 2 w 1405
smaller 2 w 1412
than 7 w 1416
the 29 w 1419
one 11 w 1422
if 9 w 1425
they 4 w 1429
have 2 w 1433
neither 3 w 1440
greatness 9 w 1449
nor 3 w 1452
smallness 12 w 1461
nor 4 w 1465
have 3 w 1469
even 1 w 1473
these 1 w 1478
two 2 w 1481
the 33 w 1484
power 1 w 1489
of 8 w 1491
exceeding 1 w 1500
or 16 w 1502
being 3 w 1507
exceeded 1 w 1515
in 39 w 1517
relation 2 w 1525
to 8 w 1527
the 34 w 1530
one 12 w 1533
but 4 w 1537
only 2 w 1541
in 40 w 1543
relation 3 w 1551
to 9 w 1553
each 1 w 1557
other 4 w 1562
nor 5 w 1566
can 5 w 1569
the 36 w 1572
one 13 w 1575
be 16 w 1577
greater 7 w 1584
or 18 w 1586
less 1 w 1590
than 8 w 1594
these 2 w 1599
two 3 w 1602
or 19 w 1604
than 9 w 1608
other 5 w 1613
things 3 w 1619
since 2 w 1625
it 34 w 1627
has 1 w 1630
neither 4 w 1637
greatness 10 w 1646
nor 6 w 1649
smallness 13 w 1658
Evidently 1 w 1668
not 13 w 1671
Then 5 w 1676
if 10 w 1678
the 40 w 1681
one 14 w 1684
is 16 w 1686
neither 5 w 1693
greater 8 w 1700
nor 7 w 1703
smaller 3 w 1710
than 10 w 1714
the 42 w 1717
others 1 w 1723
it 37 w 1726
can 6 w 1729
neither 6 w 1736
exceed 4 w 1742
them 1 w 1746
nor 8 w 1749
be 17 w 1751
exceeded 2 w 1759
by 1 w 1761
them 2 w 1765
Certainly 1 w 1775
not 14 w 1778
Then 6 w 1783
that 4 w 1787
which 4 w 1792
neither 7 w 1799
exceeds 1 w 1806
nor 9 w 1809
is 17 w 1811
exceeded 3 w 1819
must 2 w 1823
be 18 w 1825
on 26 w 1827
an 33 w 1829
equality 4 w 1837
and 8 w 1841
being 4 w 1846
on 27 w 1848
an 35 w 1850
equality 5 w 1858
must 3 w 1863
be 20 w 1865
equal 9 w 1870
Of 2 w 1873
course 2 w 1879
And 3 w 1883
the 48 w 1886
one 15 w 1889
will 7 w 1893
be 21 w 1895
in 45 w 1897
the 49 w 1900
same 1 w 1904
relation 4 w 1912
to 10 w 1914
itself 1 w 1920
also 1 w 1924
if 11 w 1927
it 43 w 1929
have 4 w 1933
in 46 w 1935
itself 2 w 1941
neither 8 w 1948
greatness 11 w 1957
nor 10 w 1960
smallness 14 w 1969
it 46 w 1972
cannot 3 w 1978
be 22 w 1980
exceeded 4 w 1988
by 2 w 1990
itself 3 w 1996
or 25 w 1998
exceed 9 w 2004
itself 4 w 2010
it 49 w 2013
would 3 w 2018
be 23 w 2020
on 30 w 2022
an 37 w 2024
equality 6 w 2032
with 3 w 2036
and 9 w 2039
equal 11 w 2044
to 11 w 2046
itself 5 w 2052
Certainly 2 w 2062
The 8 w 2066
one 16 w 2069
is 18 w 2071
then 2 w 2076
equal 12 w 2082
to 12 w 2084
itself 6 w 2090
and 10 w 2093
to 13 w 2095
the 52 w 2098
others 2 w 2104
Evidently 2 w 2114