Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Theaetetus

Theaetetus (150)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg006.perseus-eng2:150
Refs {'start': {'reference': '150', 'human_reference': 'None 150'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
150
150a

SOC. No; but because there is a wrongful and unscientific way of bringing men and women together, which is called pandering, the midwives, since they are women of dignity and worth, avoid matchmaking, through fear of falling under the charge of pandering. And yet the true midwife is the only proper match-maker.

THEAET. It seems so.

SOC. So great, then, is the importance of midwives; but their function is less important than mine. For women do not, like my patients, bring forth
150b
at one time real children and at another mere images which it is difficult to distinguish from the real. For if they did, the greatest and noblest part of the work of the midwives would be in distinguishing between the real and the false. Do you not think so?

THEAET. Yes, I do.

SOC. All that is true of their art of midwifery is true also of mine, but mine differs from theirs in being practised upon men, not women, and in tending their souls in labor, not their bodies. But the greatest thing about my art is this,
150c
that it can test in every way whether the mind of the young man is bringing forth a mere image, an imposture, or a real and genuine offspring. For I have this in common with the midwives: I am sterile in point of wisdom, and the reproach which has often been brought against me, that I question others but make no reply myself about anything, because I have no wisdom in me, is a true reproach; and the reason of it is this: the god compels me to act as midwife, but has never allowed me to bring forth. I am, then, not at all a wise person myself,
150d
nor have I any wise invention, the offspring born of my own soul; but those who associate with me, although at first some of them seem very ignorant, yet, as our acquaintance advances, all of them to whom the god is gracious make wonderful progress, not only in their own opinion, but in that of others as well. And it is clear that they do this, not because they have ever learned anything from me, but because they have found in themselves many fair things and have brought them forth. But the delivery is due to the god and me. And the proof of it is this: many before now,
150e
being ignorant of this fact and thinking that they were themselves the cause of their success, but despising me, have gone away from me sooner than they ought, whether of their own accord or because others persuaded them to do so. Then, after they have gone away, they have miscarried thenceforth on account of evil companionship, and the offspring which they had brought forth through my assistance they have reared so badly that they have lost it; they have considered impostures and images of more importance than the truth, and at last it was evident to themselves, as well as to others, that they were ignorant.

SOC 1 w 3
No 1 w 6
but 1 w 10
because 1 w 17
there 1 w 22
is 1 w 24
a 2 w 25
wrongful 1 w 33
and 1 w 36
unscientific 1 w 48
way 1 w 51
of 1 w 53
bringing 1 w 61
men 1 w 64
and 2 w 67
women 1 w 72
together 1 w 80
which 1 w 86
is 2 w 88
called 1 w 94
pandering 1 w 103
the 3 w 107
midwives 1 w 115
since 1 w 121
they 1 w 125
are 1 w 128
women 2 w 133
of 2 w 135
dignity 1 w 142
and 4 w 145
worth 1 w 150
avoid 1 w 156
matchmaking 1 w 167
through 1 w 175
fear 1 w 179
of 3 w 181
falling 1 w 188
under 1 w 193
the 5 w 196
charge 1 w 202
of 4 w 204
pandering 2 w 213
And 1 w 217
yet 1 w 220
the 6 w 223
true 1 w 227
midwife 1 w 234
is 3 w 236
the 7 w 239
only 1 w 243
proper 1 w 249
match-maker 1 w 260
THEAET 1 w 267
It 1 w 270
seems 1 w 275
so 1 w 277
SOC 2 w 281
So 1 w 284
great 1 w 289
then 1 w 294
is 4 w 297
the 9 w 300
importance 1 w 310
of 5 w 312
midwives 2 w 320
but 2 w 324
their 1 w 329
function 1 w 337
is 5 w 339
less 1 w 343
important 1 w 352
than 1 w 356
mine 1 w 360
For 1 w 364
women 3 w 369
do 1 w 371
not 1 w 374
like 1 w 379
my 1 w 381
patients 1 w 389
bring 2 w 395
forth 1 w 400
at 5 w 402
one 1 w 405
time 1 w 409
real 1 w 413
children 1 w 421
and 6 w 424
at 6 w 426
another 1 w 433
mere 1 w 437
images 1 w 443
which 2 w 448
it 2 w 450
is 6 w 452
difficult 1 w 461
to 2 w 463
distinguish 1 w 474
from 1 w 478
the 12 w 481
real 2 w 485
For 2 w 489
if 4 w 491
they 2 w 495
did 1 w 498
the 14 w 502
greatest 1 w 510
and 7 w 513
noblest 1 w 520
part 1 w 524
of 6 w 526
the 15 w 529
work 1 w 533
of 7 w 535
the 16 w 538
midwives 3 w 546
would 1 w 551
be 2 w 553
in 11 w 555
distinguishing 1 w 569
between 1 w 576
the 17 w 579
real 3 w 583
and 8 w 586
the 18 w 589
false 1 w 594
Do 1 w 597
you 1 w 600
not 3 w 603
think 1 w 608
so 2 w 610
THEAET 2 w 617
Yes 1 w 621
I 2 w 623
do 2 w 625
SOC 3 w 629
All 1 w 633
that 1 w 637
is 11 w 639
true 2 w 643
of 8 w 645
their 2 w 650
art 2 w 653
of 9 w 655
midwifery 1 w 664
is 12 w 666
true 3 w 670
also 1 w 674
of 10 w 676
mine 2 w 680
but 3 w 684
mine 3 w 688
differs 1 w 695
from 2 w 699
theirs 1 w 705
in 17 w 707
being 1 w 712
practised 1 w 721
upon 1 w 725
men 5 w 728
not 4 w 732
women 4 w 737
and 9 w 741
in 19 w 743
tending 1 w 750
their 4 w 755
souls 1 w 760
in 21 w 762
labor 1 w 767
not 5 w 771
their 5 w 776
bodies 1 w 782
But 1 w 786
the 23 w 789
greatest 2 w 797
thing 1 w 802
about 1 w 807
my 2 w 809
art 3 w 812
is 14 w 814
this 1 w 818
that 2 w 823
it 3 w 825
can 1 w 828
test 3 w 832
in 23 w 834
every 1 w 839
way 2 w 842
whether 1 w 849
the 25 w 852
mind 1 w 856
of 11 w 858
the 26 w 861
young 1 w 866
man 1 w 869
is 16 w 871
bringing 2 w 879
forth 2 w 884
a 50 w 885
mere 2 w 889
image 2 w 894
an 16 w 897
imposture 1 w 906
or 10 w 909
a 53 w 910
real 4 w 914
and 10 w 917
genuine 1 w 924
offspring 1 w 933
For 3 w 937
I 3 w 938
have 1 w 942
this 2 w 946
in 29 w 948
common 1 w 954
with 1 w 958
the 27 w 961
midwives 4 w 969
I 4 w 971
am 1 w 973
sterile 1 w 980
in 30 w 982
point 1 w 987
of 13 w 989
wisdom 1 w 995
and 11 w 999
the 28 w 1002
reproach 1 w 1010
which 3 w 1015
has 1 w 1018
often 1 w 1023
been 1 w 1027
brought 1 w 1034
against 1 w 1041
me 10 w 1043
that 3 w 1048
I 5 w 1049
question 1 w 1057
others 1 w 1063
but 4 w 1066
make 2 w 1070
no 7 w 1072
reply 1 w 1077
myself 1 w 1083
about 2 w 1088
anything 1 w 1096
because 2 w 1104
I 6 w 1105
have 2 w 1109
no 8 w 1111
wisdom 2 w 1117
in 34 w 1119
me 11 w 1121
is 20 w 1124
a 69 w 1125
true 4 w 1129
reproach 2 w 1137
and 12 w 1141
the 30 w 1144
reason 1 w 1150
of 15 w 1152
it 5 w 1154
is 21 w 1156
this 3 w 1160
the 31 w 1164
god 1 w 1167
compels 1 w 1174
me 12 w 1176
to 3 w 1178
act 2 w 1181
as 3 w 1183
midwife 3 w 1190
but 5 w 1194
has 2 w 1197
never 1 w 1202
allowed 1 w 1209
me 13 w 1211
to 4 w 1213
bring 4 w 1218
forth 3 w 1223
I 7 w 1225
am 2 w 1227
then 2 w 1232
not 6 w 1236
at 12 w 1238
all 4 w 1241
a 80 w 1242
wise 1 w 1246
person 1 w 1252
myself 2 w 1258
nor 1 w 1262
have 3 w 1266
I 8 w 1267
any 2 w 1270
wise 2 w 1274
invention 1 w 1283
the 33 w 1287
offspring 2 w 1296
born 1 w 1300
of 17 w 1302
my 5 w 1304
own 1 w 1307
soul 2 w 1311
but 6 w 1315
those 1 w 1320
who 1 w 1323
associate 1 w 1332
with 2 w 1336
me 14 w 1338
although 1 w 1347
at 14 w 1349
first 1 w 1354
some 1 w 1358
of 18 w 1360
them 1 w 1364
seem 2 w 1368
very 2 w 1372
ignorant 1 w 1380
yet 2 w 1384
as 6 w 1387
our 1 w 1390
acquaintance 1 w 1402
advances 1 w 1410
all 5 w 1414
of 19 w 1416
them 2 w 1420
to 5 w 1422
whom 1 w 1426
the 36 w 1429
god 2 w 1432
is 25 w 1434
gracious 1 w 1442
make 3 w 1446
wonderful 1 w 1455
progress 1 w 1463
not 7 w 1467
only 2 w 1471
in 39 w 1473
their 6 w 1478
own 2 w 1481
opinion 1 w 1488
but 7 w 1492
in 41 w 1494
that 4 w 1498
of 20 w 1500
others 2 w 1506
as 7 w 1508
well 1 w 1512
And 2 w 1516
it 7 w 1518
is 26 w 1520
clear 1 w 1525
that 5 w 1529
they 3 w 1533
do 5 w 1535
this 4 w 1539
not 8 w 1543
because 3 w 1550
they 4 w 1554
have 4 w 1558
ever 3 w 1562
learned 1 w 1569
anything 2 w 1577
from 3 w 1581
me 16 w 1583
but 8 w 1587
because 4 w 1594
they 5 w 1598
have 5 w 1602
found 1 w 1607
in 43 w 1609
themselves 1 w 1619
many 1 w 1623
fair 1 w 1627
things 1 w 1633
and 13 w 1636
have 6 w 1640
brought 2 w 1647
them 4 w 1651
forth 4 w 1656
But 2 w 1660
the 44 w 1663
delivery 1 w 1671
is 28 w 1673
due 1 w 1676
to 6 w 1678
the 45 w 1681
god 3 w 1684
and 14 w 1687
me 17 w 1689
And 3 w 1693
the 46 w 1696
proof 1 w 1701
of 22 w 1703
it 8 w 1705
is 29 w 1707
this 5 w 1711
many 2 w 1716
before 1 w 1722
now 1 w 1725
being 2 w 1731
ignorant 2 w 1739
of 23 w 1741
this 6 w 1745
fact 1 w 1749
and 15 w 1752
thinking 1 w 1760
that 6 w 1764
they 6 w 1768
were 1 w 1772
themselves 2 w 1782
the 49 w 1785
cause 5 w 1790
of 24 w 1792
their 7 w 1797
success 1 w 1804
but 9 w 1808
despising 1 w 1817
me 18 w 1819
have 7 w 1824
gone 1 w 1828
away 1 w 1832
from 4 w 1836
me 19 w 1838
sooner 1 w 1844
than 2 w 1848
they 7 w 1852
ought 3 w 1857
whether 2 w 1865
of 25 w 1867
their 8 w 1872
own 3 w 1875
accord 1 w 1881
or 20 w 1883
because 5 w 1890
others 3 w 1896
persuaded 1 w 1905
them 6 w 1909
to 7 w 1911
do 6 w 1913
so 11 w 1915
Then 1 w 1920
after 1 w 1926
they 8 w 1930
have 8 w 1934
gone 2 w 1938
away 2 w 1942
they 9 w 1947
have 9 w 1951
miscarried 1 w 1961
thenceforth 1 w 1972
on 17 w 1974
account 1 w 1981
of 26 w 1983
evil 1 w 1987
companionship 1 w 2000
and 16 w 2004
the 59 w 2007
offspring 3 w 2016
which 4 w 2021
they 10 w 2025
had 1 w 2028
brought 3 w 2035
forth 6 w 2040
through 2 w 2047
my 6 w 2049
assistance 1 w 2059
they 11 w 2063
have 10 w 2067
reared 1 w 2073
so 12 w 2075
badly 1 w 2080
that 7 w 2084
they 12 w 2088
have 11 w 2092
lost 1 w 2096
it 9 w 2098
they 13 w 2103
have 12 w 2107
considered 1 w 2117
impostures 1 w 2127
and 17 w 2130
images 2 w 2136
of 28 w 2138
more 1 w 2142
importance 2 w 2152
than 3 w 2156
the 64 w 2159
truth 1 w 2164
and 18 w 2168
at 19 w 2170
last 1 w 2174
it 10 w 2176
was 1 w 2179
evident 1 w 2186
to 8 w 2188
themselves 3 w 2198
as 11 w 2201
well 2 w 2205
as 12 w 2207
to 9 w 2209
others 4 w 2215
that 8 w 2220
they 14 w 2224
were 2 w 2228
ignorant 3 w 2236