Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Cratylus

Cratylus (414)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg005.perseus-eng2:414
Refs {'start': {'reference': '414', 'human_reference': 'Section 414'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Socrates. Of course it is clear that not the current opposed to every current is courage, but only that opposed to the current which is contrary to justice;
414
414a
for otherwise courage would not be praised. The words ἄρρεν (male) and ἀνήρ (man) refer, like ἀνδρεία, to the upward (ἄνω) current or flow. The word γυνή (woman) seems to me to be much the same as γονή (birth). I think θῆλυ (female) is derived from θηλή (teat); and is not θηλή, Hermogenes, so called because it makes things flourish (τεθηλέναι), like plants wet with showers?

Hermogenes. Very likely, Socrates.

Socrates. And again, the word θάλλειν (flourish) seems to me to figure the rapid and sudden growth of the young.
414b
Something of that sort the namegiver has reproduced in the name, which he compounded of θεῖν (run) and ἅλλεσθαι (jump). You do not seem to notice how I rush along outside of the race-course, when I get on smooth ground. But we still have plenty of subjects left which seem to be serious.

Hermogenes. True.

Socrates. One of which is to see what the word τέχνη (art, science) means.

Hermogenes. Certainly.

Socrates. Does not this denote possession of mind, if you remove the tau and insert omicron between the chi and the nu
414c
and the nu and the eta (making ἐχονόη)?

Hermogenes. It does it very poorly, Socrates.

Socrates. My friend, you do not bear in mind that the original words have before now been completely buried by those who wished to dress them up, for they have added and subtracted letters for the sake of euphony and have distorted the words in every way for ornamentation or merely in the lapse of time. Do you not, for instance, think it absurd that the letter rho is inserted in the word κάαπτρον (mirror)?
414d
I think that sort of thing is the work of people who care nothing for truth, but only for the shape of their mouths; so they keep adding to the original words until finally no human being can understand what in the world the word means. So the sphinx, for instance, is called sphinx, instead of phix, and there are many other examples.

Hermogenes. Yes, that is true, Socrates.

Socrates. And if we are permitted to insert and remove any letters we please in words, it will be perfectly easy to fit any name to anything.
414e

Hermogenes. True.

Socrates. Yes, quite true. But I think you, as a wise director, must observe the rule of moderation and probability.

Hermogenes. I should like to do so.

Tokens

Socrates 1 w 8
Of 1 w 11
course 1 w 17
it 1 w 19
is 1 w 21
clear 1 w 26
that 1 w 30
not 1 w 33
the 1 w 36
current 1 w 43
opposed 1 w 50
to 1 w 52
every 1 w 57
current 2 w 64
is 2 w 66
courage 1 w 73
but 1 w 77
only 1 w 81
that 2 w 85
opposed 2 w 92
to 2 w 94
the 2 w 97
current 3 w 104
which 1 w 109
is 3 w 111
contrary 1 w 119
to 3 w 121
justice 1 w 128
for 1 w 132
otherwise 1 w 141
courage 2 w 148
would 1 w 153
not 2 w 156
be 1 w 158
praised 1 w 165
The 1 w 169
words 1 w 174
ἄρρεν 1 w 179
male 1 w 184
and 1 w 188
ἀνήρ 1 w 192
man 1 w 196
refer 1 w 202
like 1 w 207
ἀνδρεία 1 w 214
to 4 w 217
the 4 w 220
upward 1 w 226
ἄνω 1 w 230
current 4 w 238
or 3 w 240
flow 1 w 244
The 2 w 248
word 2 w 252
γυνή 1 w 256
woman 1 w 262
seems 1 w 268
to 5 w 270
me 1 w 272
to 6 w 274
be 2 w 276
much 1 w 280
the 5 w 283
same 1 w 287
as 1 w 289
γονή 1 w 293
birth 1 w 299
I 1 w 302
think 1 w 307
θῆλυ 1 w 311
female 1 w 318
is 6 w 321
derived 1 w 328
from 1 w 332
θηλή 1 w 336
teat 1 w 341
and 2 w 346
is 7 w 348
not 3 w 351
θηλή 2 w 355
Hermogenes 1 w 366
so 1 w 369
called 1 w 375
because 1 w 382
it 2 w 384
makes 1 w 389
things 1 w 395
flourish 1 w 403
τεθηλέναι 1 w 413
like 2 w 419
plants 1 w 425
wet 1 w 428
with 1 w 432
showers 1 w 439
Hermogenes 2 w 450
Very 1 w 455
likely 1 w 461
Socrates 2 w 470
Socrates 3 w 479
And 1 w 483
again 1 w 488
the 6 w 492
word 3 w 496
θάλλειν 1 w 503
flourish 2 w 512
seems 2 w 518
to 7 w 520
me 3 w 522
to 8 w 524
figure 1 w 530
the 7 w 533
rapid 1 w 538
and 3 w 541
sudden 1 w 547
growth 1 w 553
of 1 w 555
the 8 w 558
young 1 w 563
Something 1 w 573
of 2 w 575
that 3 w 579
sort 1 w 583
the 9 w 586
namegiver 1 w 595
has 1 w 598
reproduced 1 w 608
in 5 w 610
the 10 w 613
name 2 w 617
which 2 w 623
he 13 w 625
compounded 1 w 635
of 3 w 637
θεῖν 1 w 641
run 1 w 645
and 4 w 649
ἅλλεσθαι 1 w 657
jump 1 w 662
You 1 w 667
do 1 w 669
not 4 w 672
seem 3 w 676
to 9 w 678
notice 1 w 684
how 2 w 687
I 2 w 688
rush 1 w 692
along 1 w 697
outside 1 w 704
of 4 w 706
the 11 w 709
race-course 1 w 720
when 1 w 725
I 3 w 726
get 1 w 729
on 4 w 731
smooth 1 w 737
ground 1 w 743
But 1 w 747
we 3 w 749
still 1 w 754
have 1 w 758
plenty 1 w 764
of 5 w 766
subjects 1 w 774
left 1 w 778
which 3 w 783
seem 4 w 787
to 10 w 789
be 4 w 791
serious 1 w 798
Hermogenes 3 w 809
True 1 w 814
Socrates 4 w 823
One 1 w 827
of 6 w 829
which 4 w 834
is 10 w 836
to 11 w 838
see 5 w 841
what 1 w 845
the 12 w 848
word 4 w 852
τέχνη 1 w 857
art 1 w 861
science 1 w 869
means 1 w 875
Hermogenes 4 w 886
Certainly 1 w 896
Socrates 5 w 905
Does 1 w 910
not 6 w 913
this 1 w 917
denote 1 w 923
possession 1 w 933
of 7 w 935
mind 1 w 939
if 1 w 942
you 2 w 945
remove 1 w 951
the 13 w 954
tau 1 w 957
and 5 w 960
insert 1 w 966
omicron 1 w 973
between 1 w 980
the 14 w 983
chi 1 w 986
and 6 w 989
the 15 w 992
nu 1 w 994
and 7 w 997
the 16 w 1000
nu 2 w 1002
and 8 w 1005
the 17 w 1008
eta 1 w 1011
making 1 w 1018
ἐχονόη 1 w 1024
Hermogenes 5 w 1036
It 1 w 1039
does 1 w 1043
it 4 w 1045
very 2 w 1049
poorly 1 w 1055
Socrates 6 w 1064
Socrates 7 w 1073
My 1 w 1076
friend 1 w 1082
you 3 w 1086
do 3 w 1088
not 8 w 1091
bear 1 w 1095
in 10 w 1097
mind 2 w 1101
that 4 w 1105
the 18 w 1108
original 1 w 1116
words 2 w 1121
have 2 w 1125
before 1 w 1131
now 1 w 1134
been 1 w 1138
completely 1 w 1148
buried 1 w 1154
by 1 w 1156
those 1 w 1161
who 1 w 1164
wished 1 w 1170
to 12 w 1172
dress 1 w 1177
them 1 w 1181
up 2 w 1183
for 3 w 1187
they 1 w 1191
have 3 w 1195
added 1 w 1200
and 9 w 1203
subtracted 1 w 1213
letters 1 w 1220
for 4 w 1223
the 21 w 1226
sake 1 w 1230
of 8 w 1232
euphony 1 w 1239
and 10 w 1242
have 4 w 1246
distorted 1 w 1255
the 22 w 1258
words 3 w 1263
in 13 w 1265
every 2 w 1270
way 1 w 1273
for 5 w 1276
ornamentation 1 w 1289
or 18 w 1291
merely 1 w 1297
in 14 w 1299
the 23 w 1302
lapse 1 w 1307
of 9 w 1309
time 1 w 1313
Do 2 w 1316
you 4 w 1319
not 9 w 1322
for 6 w 1326
instance 1 w 1334
think 2 w 1340
it 5 w 1342
absurd 1 w 1348
that 5 w 1352
the 24 w 1355
letter 2 w 1361
rho 1 w 1364
is 14 w 1366
inserted 1 w 1374
in 18 w 1376
the 25 w 1379
word 7 w 1383
κάαπτρον 1 w 1391
mirror 1 w 1398
I 5 w 1401
think 3 w 1406
that 6 w 1410
sort 2 w 1414
of 10 w 1416
thing 3 w 1421
is 15 w 1423
the 26 w 1426
work 1 w 1430
of 11 w 1432
people 1 w 1438
who 2 w 1441
care 1 w 1445
nothing 1 w 1452
for 7 w 1455
truth 1 w 1460
but 2 w 1464
only 2 w 1468
for 8 w 1471
the 27 w 1474
shape 1 w 1479
of 12 w 1481
their 1 w 1486
mouths 1 w 1492
so 4 w 1495
they 2 w 1499
keep 1 w 1503
adding 1 w 1509
to 14 w 1511
the 30 w 1514
original 2 w 1522
words 4 w 1527
until 1 w 1532
finally 1 w 1539
no 12 w 1541
human 1 w 1546
being 1 w 1551
can 1 w 1554
understand 1 w 1564
what 2 w 1568
in 26 w 1570
the 31 w 1573
world 1 w 1578
the 32 w 1581
word 9 w 1585
means 2 w 1590
So 9 w 1593
the 33 w 1596
sphinx 1 w 1602
for 9 w 1606
instance 2 w 1614
is 16 w 1617
called 2 w 1623
sphinx 2 w 1629
instead 1 w 1637
of 13 w 1639
phix 1 w 1643
and 12 w 1647
there 1 w 1652
are 2 w 1655
many 1 w 1659
other 2 w 1664
examples 1 w 1672
Hermogenes 6 w 1683
Yes 1 w 1687
that 7 w 1692
is 17 w 1694
true 1 w 1698
Socrates 8 w 1707
Socrates 9 w 1716
And 2 w 1720
if 2 w 1722
we 5 w 1724
are 3 w 1727
permitted 1 w 1736
to 15 w 1738
insert 3 w 1744
and 13 w 1747
remove 2 w 1753
any 2 w 1756
letters 2 w 1763
we 6 w 1765
please 1 w 1771
in 32 w 1773
words 5 w 1778
it 7 w 1781
will 1 w 1785
be 10 w 1787
perfectly 1 w 1796
easy 1 w 1800
to 16 w 1802
fit 1 w 1805
any 3 w 1808
name 4 w 1812
to 17 w 1814
anything 1 w 1822
Hermogenes 7 w 1833
True 2 w 1838
Socrates 10 w 1847
Yes 2 w 1851
quite 1 w 1857
true 2 w 1861
But 2 w 1865
I 6 w 1866
think 4 w 1871
you 5 w 1874
as 5 w 1877
a 101 w 1878
wise 2 w 1882
director 1 w 1890
must 1 w 1895
observe 1 w 1902
the 36 w 1905
rule 1 w 1909
of 14 w 1911
moderation 1 w 1921
and 14 w 1924
probability 1 w 1935
Hermogenes 8 w 1946
I 7 w 1948
should 1 w 1954
like 4 w 1958
to 19 w 1960
do 4 w 1962
so 5 w 1964