Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Cratylus

Cratylus (404)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg005.perseus-eng2:404
Refs {'start': {'reference': '404', 'human_reference': 'Section 404'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Socrates. Then, too, he refuses to consort with men while they have bodies, but only accepts their society
404
404a
when the soul is pure of all the evils and desires of the body. Do you not think this shows him to be a philosopher and to understand perfectly that under these conditions he could restrain them by binding them with the desire of virtue, but that so long as they are infected with the unrest and madness of the body, not even his father Cronus could hold them to himself, though he bound them with his famous chains?

Hermogenes. There seems to be something in that, Socrates.
404b

Socrates. And the name Hades is not in the least derived from the invisible (ἀειδές), but far more probably from knowing (εἰδέναι) all noble things, and for that reason he was called Hades by the lawgiver.

Hermogenes. Very well; what shall we say of Demeter, Hera, Apollo, Athena, Hephaestus, Ares, and the other gods

Socrates. Demeter appears to have been called Demeter, because like a mother (μήτηρ) she gives the gift of food,
404c
and Hera is a lovely one (ἐρατή), as indeed, Zeus is said to have married her for love. But perhaps the lawgiver had natural phenomena in mind, and called her Hera (Ἥρα) as a disguise for ἀήρ (air), putting the beginning at the end. You would understand, if you were to repeat the name Hera over and over. And Pherephatta!—How many people fear this name, and also Apollo! I imagine it is because they do not know about correctness of names. You see they change the name to Phersephone and its aspect frightens them. But really the name indicates that the goddess is wise;
404d
for since things are in motion (φερόμενα), that which grasps (ἐφαπτόμενον) and touches (ἐπαφῶν) and is able to follow them is wisdom. Pherepapha, or something of that sort, would therefore be the correct name of the goddess, because she is wise and touches that which is in motion (ἐπαφὴ τοῦ φερομένου)—and this is the reason why Hades, who is wise, consorts with her, because she is wisebut people have altered her name, attaching more importance to euphony than to truth, and they call her Pherephatta. Likewise in the case of Apollo,
404e
as I say, many people are afraid because of the name of the god, thinking that it has some terrible meaning. Have you not noticed that?

Hermogenes. Certainly; what you say is true.

Socrates. But really the name is admirably appropriate to the power of the god.

Hermogenes. How is that?

Tokens

Socrates 1 w 8
Then 1 w 13
too 1 w 17
he 2 w 20
refuses 1 w 27
to 2 w 29
consort 1 w 36
with 1 w 40
men 1 w 43
while 1 w 48
they 1 w 52
have 1 w 56
bodies 1 w 62
but 1 w 66
only 1 w 70
accepts 1 w 77
their 1 w 82
society 1 w 89
when 1 w 93
the 3 w 96
soul 1 w 100
is 1 w 102
pure 1 w 106
of 1 w 108
all 1 w 111
the 4 w 114
evils 1 w 119
and 1 w 122
desires 1 w 129
of 2 w 131
the 5 w 134
body 1 w 138
Do 1 w 141
you 1 w 144
not 1 w 147
think 1 w 152
this 1 w 156
shows 1 w 161
him 1 w 164
to 3 w 166
be 1 w 168
a 6 w 169
philosopher 1 w 180
and 2 w 183
to 4 w 185
understand 1 w 195
perfectly 1 w 204
that 1 w 208
under 2 w 213
these 1 w 218
conditions 1 w 228
he 11 w 230
could 1 w 235
restrain 1 w 243
them 1 w 247
by 1 w 249
binding 1 w 256
them 2 w 260
with 2 w 264
the 9 w 267
desire 2 w 273
of 3 w 275
virtue 1 w 281
but 2 w 285
that 2 w 289
so 5 w 291
long 1 w 295
as 1 w 297
they 2 w 301
are 1 w 304
infected 1 w 312
with 3 w 316
the 11 w 319
unrest 1 w 325
and 4 w 328
madness 1 w 335
of 4 w 337
the 12 w 340
body 2 w 344
not 2 w 348
even 1 w 352
his 2 w 355
father 1 w 361
Cronus 1 w 367
could 2 w 372
hold 1 w 376
them 3 w 380
to 5 w 382
himself 1 w 389
though 1 w 396
he 20 w 398
bound 1 w 403
them 4 w 407
with 4 w 411
his 3 w 414
famous 1 w 420
chains 1 w 426
Hermogenes 1 w 437
There 1 w 443
seems 1 w 448
to 6 w 450
be 2 w 452
something 1 w 461
in 8 w 463
that 3 w 467
Socrates 2 w 476
Socrates 3 w 485
And 1 w 489
the 16 w 492
name 1 w 496
Hades 1 w 501
is 5 w 503
not 3 w 506
in 9 w 508
the 17 w 511
least 1 w 516
derived 1 w 523
from 1 w 527
the 18 w 530
invisible 1 w 539
ἀειδές 1 w 546
but 3 w 551
far 1 w 554
more 1 w 558
probably 1 w 566
from 2 w 570
knowing 1 w 577
εἰδέναι 1 w 585
all 2 w 589
noble 1 w 594
things 1 w 600
and 5 w 604
for 1 w 607
that 4 w 611
reason 1 w 617
he 26 w 619
was 1 w 622
called 1 w 628
Hades 2 w 633
by 2 w 635
the 19 w 638
lawgiver 1 w 646
Hermogenes 2 w 657
Very 1 w 662
well 1 w 666
what 1 w 671
shall 1 w 676
we 2 w 678
say 1 w 681
of 5 w 683
Demeter 1 w 690
Hera 1 w 695
Apollo 1 w 702
Athena 1 w 709
Hephaestus 1 w 720
Ares 1 w 725
and 6 w 729
the 21 w 732
other 1 w 737
gods 1 w 741
Socrates 4 w 749
Demeter 2 w 757
appears 1 w 764
to 7 w 766
have 2 w 770
been 1 w 774
called 2 w 780
Demeter 3 w 787
because 1 w 795
like 1 w 799
a 48 w 800
mother 1 w 806
μήτηρ 1 w 812
she 1 w 816
gives 1 w 821
the 24 w 824
gift 1 w 828
of 6 w 830
food 1 w 834
and 7 w 838
Hera 2 w 842
is 7 w 844
a 51 w 845
lovely 1 w 851
one 1 w 854
ἐρατή 1 w 860
as 5 w 864
indeed 1 w 870
Zeus 1 w 875
is 8 w 877
said 1 w 881
to 8 w 883
have 3 w 887
married 1 w 894
her 6 w 897
for 2 w 900
love 2 w 904
But 1 w 908
perhaps 1 w 915
the 25 w 918
lawgiver 2 w 926
had 1 w 929
natural 1 w 936
phenomena 1 w 945
in 14 w 947
mind 1 w 951
and 8 w 955
called 3 w 961
her 7 w 964
Hera 3 w 968
Ἥρα 1 w 972
as 6 w 975
a 66 w 976
disguise 1 w 984
for 3 w 987
ἀήρ 1 w 990
air 1 w 994
putting 1 w 1003
the 26 w 1006
beginning 1 w 1015
at 12 w 1017
the 27 w 1020
end 1 w 1023
You 1 w 1027
would 1 w 1032
understand 2 w 1042
if 2 w 1045
you 2 w 1048
were 1 w 1052
to 9 w 1054
repeat 1 w 1060
the 28 w 1063
name 2 w 1067
Hera 4 w 1071
over 1 w 1075
and 10 w 1078
over 2 w 1082
And 2 w 1086
Pherephatta 1 w 1097
How 1 w 1102
many 1 w 1106
people 1 w 1112
fear 1 w 1116
this 2 w 1120
name 3 w 1124
and 11 w 1128
also 1 w 1132
Apollo 2 w 1138
I 1 w 1140
imagine 1 w 1147
it 6 w 1149
is 12 w 1151
because 2 w 1158
they 3 w 1162
do 1 w 1164
not 4 w 1167
know 2 w 1171
about 1 w 1176
correctness 1 w 1187
of 7 w 1189
names 1 w 1194
You 2 w 1198
see 2 w 1201
they 4 w 1205
change 1 w 1211
the 31 w 1214
name 5 w 1218
to 10 w 1220
Phersephone 1 w 1231
and 12 w 1234
its 1 w 1237
aspect 1 w 1243
frightens 1 w 1252
them 5 w 1256
But 2 w 1260
really 1 w 1266
the 33 w 1269
name 6 w 1273
indicates 1 w 1282
that 5 w 1286
the 34 w 1289
goddess 1 w 1296
is 13 w 1298
wise 1 w 1302
for 4 w 1306
since 1 w 1311
things 2 w 1317
are 2 w 1320
in 23 w 1322
motion 1 w 1328
φερόμενα 1 w 1337
that 6 w 1343
which 1 w 1348
grasps 1 w 1354
ἐφαπτόμενον 1 w 1366
and 13 w 1370
touches 1 w 1377
ἐπαφῶν 1 w 1384
and 14 w 1388
is 15 w 1390
able 1 w 1394
to 12 w 1396
follow 1 w 1402
them 6 w 1406
is 16 w 1408
wisdom 1 w 1414
Pherepapha 1 w 1425
or 8 w 1428
something 2 w 1437
of 8 w 1439
that 7 w 1443
sort 2 w 1447
would 2 w 1453
therefore 1 w 1462
be 7 w 1464
the 37 w 1467
correct 2 w 1474
name 7 w 1478
of 9 w 1480
the 38 w 1483
goddess 2 w 1490
because 3 w 1498
she 2 w 1501
is 18 w 1503
wise 2 w 1507
and 15 w 1510
touches 2 w 1517
that 8 w 1521
which 2 w 1526
is 20 w 1528
in 25 w 1530
motion 2 w 1536
ἐπαφὴ 1 w 1542
τοῦ 1 w 1545
φερομένου 1 w 1554
and 16 w 1559
this 3 w 1563
is 22 w 1565
the 39 w 1568
reason 2 w 1574
why 1 w 1577
Hades 3 w 1582
who 1 w 1586
is 23 w 1588
wise 3 w 1592
consorts 1 w 1601
with 5 w 1605
her 12 w 1608
because 4 w 1616
she 3 w 1619
is 25 w 1621
wise 4 w 1625
but 4 w 1629
people 2 w 1635
have 4 w 1639
altered 1 w 1646
her 13 w 1649
name 8 w 1653
attaching 1 w 1663
more 2 w 1667
importance 1 w 1677
to 14 w 1679
euphony 1 w 1686
than 1 w 1690
to 15 w 1692
truth 1 w 1697
and 17 w 1701
they 5 w 1705
call 4 w 1709
her 14 w 1712
Pherephatta 2 w 1723
Likewise 1 w 1732
in 27 w 1734
the 41 w 1737
case 1 w 1741
of 10 w 1743
Apollo 3 w 1749
as 11 w 1752
I 2 w 1753
say 2 w 1756
many 2 w 1761
people 3 w 1767
are 3 w 1770
afraid 1 w 1776
because 5 w 1783
of 11 w 1785
the 42 w 1788
name 9 w 1792
of 12 w 1794
the 43 w 1797
god 4 w 1800
thinking 1 w 1809
that 9 w 1813
it 9 w 1815
has 1 w 1818
some 3 w 1822
terrible 1 w 1830
meaning 1 w 1837
Have 1 w 1842
you 3 w 1845
not 5 w 1848
noticed 1 w 1855
that 10 w 1859
Hermogenes 3 w 1870
Certainly 1 w 1880
what 2 w 1885
you 4 w 1888
say 3 w 1891
is 28 w 1893
true 1 w 1897
Socrates 5 w 1906
But 3 w 1910
really 2 w 1916
the 44 w 1919
name 10 w 1923
is 29 w 1925
admirably 1 w 1934
appropriate 1 w 1945
to 16 w 1947
the 45 w 1950
power 1 w 1955
of 13 w 1957
the 46 w 1960
god 5 w 1963
Hermogenes 4 w 1974
How 2 w 1978
is 30 w 1980
that 11 w 1984