Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Apology

Apology (41)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg002.perseus-eng2:41
Refs {'start': {'reference': '41', 'human_reference': 'Section 41'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

For if a man when he reaches the other world,

41
41a
after leaving behind these who claim to be judges, shall find those who are really judges who are said to sit in judgment there, Minos and Rhadamanthus, and Aeacus and Triptolemus, and all the other demigods who were just men in their lives, would the change of habitation be undesirable? Or again, what would any of you give to meet with Orpheus and Musaeus and Hesiod and Homer? I am willing to die many times over, if these things are true; for I personally should find the life there wonderful,
41b
when I met Palamedes or Ajax, the son of Telamon, or any other men of old who lost their lives through an unjust judgement, and compared my experience with theirs. I think that would not be unpleasant. And the greatest pleasure would be to pass my time in examining and investigating the people there, as I do those here, to find out who among them is wise and who thinks he is when he is not. What price would any of you pay, judges, to examine him who led the great army against Troy,
41c
or Odysseus, or Sisyphus, or countless others, both men and women, whom I might mention? To converse and associate with them and examine them would be immeasurable happiness. At any rate, the folk there do not kill people for it; since, if what we are told is true, they are immortal for all future time, besides being happier in other respects than men are here.
But you also, judges, must regard death hopefully and must bear in mind this one truth,
41d
that no evil can come to a good man either in life or after death, and God does not neglect him. So, too, this which had come to me has not come by chance, but I see plainly that it was better for me to die now and be freed from troubles. That is the reason why the sign never interfered with me, and I am not at all angry with those who condemned me or with my accusers. And yet it was not with that in view that they condemned and accused me, but because
41e
they thought to injure me. They deserve blame for that. However, I make this request of them: when my sons grow up, gentlemen, punish them by troubling them as I have troubled you; if they seem to you to care for money or anything else more than for virtue, and if they think they amount to something when they do not, rebuke them as I have rebuked you because they do not care for what they ought, and think they amount to something when they are worth nothing.

Tokens

For 1 w 3
if 1 w 5
a 1 w 6
man 1 w 9
when 1 w 13
he 2 w 15
reaches 1 w 22
the 1 w 25
other 1 w 30
world 1 w 35
after 1 w 41
leaving 1 w 48
behind 1 w 54
these 1 w 59
who 1 w 62
claim 1 w 67
to 1 w 69
be 2 w 71
judges 1 w 77
shall 1 w 83
find 1 w 87
those 1 w 92
who 2 w 95
are 1 w 98
really 1 w 104
judges 2 w 110
who 3 w 113
are 2 w 116
said 1 w 120
to 2 w 122
sit 1 w 125
in 4 w 127
judgment 1 w 135
there 1 w 140
Minos 1 w 146
and 1 w 149
Rhadamanthus 1 w 161
and 2 w 165
Aeacus 1 w 171
and 3 w 174
Triptolemus 1 w 185
and 4 w 189
all 3 w 192
the 5 w 195
other 2 w 200
demigods 1 w 208
who 4 w 211
were 1 w 215
just 1 w 219
men 2 w 222
in 6 w 224
their 1 w 229
lives 1 w 234
would 1 w 240
the 8 w 243
change 1 w 249
of 1 w 251
habitation 1 w 261
be 3 w 263
undesirable 1 w 274
Or 1 w 277
again 1 w 282
what 1 w 287
would 2 w 292
any 1 w 295
of 2 w 297
you 1 w 300
give 1 w 304
to 4 w 306
meet 1 w 310
with 1 w 314
Orpheus 1 w 321
and 5 w 324
Musaeus 1 w 331
and 6 w 334
Hesiod 1 w 340
and 7 w 343
Homer 1 w 348
I 1 w 350
am 2 w 352
willing 1 w 359
to 5 w 361
die 1 w 364
many 1 w 368
times 1 w 373
over 1 w 377
if 2 w 380
these 2 w 385
things 1 w 391
are 3 w 394
true 1 w 398
for 1 w 402
I 2 w 403
personally 1 w 413
should 1 w 419
find 2 w 423
the 10 w 426
life 1 w 430
there 2 w 435
wonderful 1 w 444
when 2 w 449
I 3 w 450
met 1 w 453
Palamedes 1 w 462
or 4 w 464
Ajax 1 w 468
the 12 w 472
son 2 w 475
of 3 w 477
Telamon 1 w 484
or 5 w 487
any 3 w 490
other 3 w 495
men 3 w 498
of 4 w 500
old 1 w 503
who 5 w 506
lost 1 w 510
their 2 w 515
lives 2 w 520
through 1 w 527
an 14 w 529
unjust 1 w 535
judgement 1 w 544
and 8 w 548
compared 1 w 556
my 1 w 558
experience 1 w 568
with 2 w 572
theirs 1 w 578
I 4 w 580
think 1 w 585
that 1 w 589
would 3 w 594
not 1 w 597
be 4 w 599
unpleasant 1 w 609
And 1 w 613
the 16 w 616
greatest 1 w 624
pleasure 1 w 632
would 4 w 637
be 5 w 639
to 6 w 641
pass 1 w 645
my 2 w 647
time 2 w 651
in 12 w 653
examining 1 w 662
and 9 w 665
investigating 1 w 678
the 17 w 681
people 1 w 687
there 3 w 692
as 4 w 695
I 5 w 696
do 1 w 698
those 2 w 703
here 4 w 707
to 7 w 710
find 3 w 714
out 1 w 717
who 6 w 720
among 1 w 725
them 1 w 729
is 1 w 731
wise 1 w 735
and 10 w 738
who 7 w 741
thinks 1 w 747
he 26 w 749
is 3 w 751
when 3 w 755
he 28 w 757
is 4 w 759
not 2 w 762
What 1 w 767
price 1 w 772
would 5 w 777
any 4 w 780
of 5 w 782
you 2 w 785
pay 1 w 788
judges 3 w 795
to 8 w 798
examine 1 w 805
him 1 w 808
who 8 w 811
led 1 w 814
the 20 w 817
great 2 w 822
army 1 w 826
against 1 w 833
Troy 1 w 837
or 6 w 840
Odysseus 1 w 848
or 7 w 851
Sisyphus 1 w 859
or 8 w 862
countless 1 w 871
others 1 w 877
both 1 w 882
men 5 w 885
and 11 w 888
women 1 w 893
whom 1 w 898
I 6 w 899
might 1 w 904
mention 1 w 911
To 1 w 914
converse 1 w 922
and 12 w 925
associate 1 w 934
with 3 w 938
them 2 w 942
and 13 w 945
examine 2 w 952
them 3 w 956
would 6 w 961
be 6 w 963
immeasurable 1 w 975
happiness 1 w 984
At 1 w 987
any 5 w 990
rate 1 w 994
the 24 w 998
folk 1 w 1002
there 4 w 1007
do 2 w 1009
not 3 w 1012
kill 1 w 1016
people 2 w 1022
for 2 w 1025
it 6 w 1027
since 1 w 1033
if 4 w 1036
what 2 w 1040
we 2 w 1042
are 5 w 1045
told 1 w 1049
is 6 w 1051
true 2 w 1055
they 1 w 1060
are 6 w 1063
immortal 1 w 1071
for 3 w 1074
all 5 w 1077
future 1 w 1083
time 3 w 1087
besides 1 w 1095
being 1 w 1100
happier 1 w 1107
in 25 w 1109
other 5 w 1114
respects 1 w 1122
than 1 w 1126
men 8 w 1129
are 7 w 1132
here 6 w 1136
But 1 w 1140
you 3 w 1143
also 1 w 1147
judges 4 w 1154
must 1 w 1159
regard 1 w 1165
death 1 w 1170
hopefully 1 w 1179
and 14 w 1182
must 2 w 1186
bear 1 w 1190
in 26 w 1192
mind 1 w 1196
this 1 w 1200
one 1 w 1203
truth 1 w 1208
that 2 w 1213
no 5 w 1215
evil 1 w 1219
can 1 w 1222
come 1 w 1226
to 10 w 1228
a 91 w 1229
good 1 w 1233
man 4 w 1236
either 1 w 1242
in 28 w 1244
life 2 w 1248
or 12 w 1250
after 2 w 1255
death 2 w 1260
and 15 w 1264
God 1 w 1267
does 1 w 1271
not 4 w 1274
neglect 1 w 1281
him 2 w 1284
So 1 w 1287
too 1 w 1291
this 2 w 1296
which 1 w 1301
had 2 w 1304
come 2 w 1308
to 12 w 1310
me 19 w 1312
has 1 w 1315
not 5 w 1318
come 3 w 1322
by 1 w 1324
chance 1 w 1330
but 1 w 1334
I 7 w 1335
see 1 w 1338
plainly 1 w 1345
that 3 w 1349
it 8 w 1351
was 1 w 1354
better 1 w 1360
for 4 w 1363
me 21 w 1365
to 13 w 1367
die 2 w 1370
now 1 w 1373
and 16 w 1376
be 11 w 1378
freed 1 w 1383
from 1 w 1387
troubles 1 w 1395
That 1 w 1400
is 9 w 1402
the 29 w 1405
reason 1 w 1411
why 1 w 1414
the 30 w 1417
sign 1 w 1421
never 1 w 1426
interfered 1 w 1436
with 4 w 1440
me 22 w 1442
and 17 w 1446
I 8 w 1447
am 9 w 1449
not 6 w 1452
at 16 w 1454
all 6 w 1457
angry 1 w 1462
with 5 w 1466
those 3 w 1471
who 10 w 1474
condemned 1 w 1483
me 23 w 1485
or 14 w 1487
with 6 w 1491
my 4 w 1493
accusers 1 w 1501
And 2 w 1505
yet 1 w 1508
it 12 w 1510
was 2 w 1513
not 7 w 1516
with 7 w 1520
that 4 w 1524
in 31 w 1526
view 1 w 1530
that 5 w 1534
they 2 w 1538
condemned 2 w 1547
and 18 w 1550
accused 1 w 1557
me 24 w 1559
but 2 w 1563
because 1 w 1570
they 3 w 1574
thought 1 w 1581
to 14 w 1583
injure 1 w 1589
me 25 w 1591
They 1 w 1596
deserve 1 w 1603
blame 1 w 1608
for 5 w 1611
that 6 w 1615
However 1 w 1623
I 9 w 1625
make 1 w 1629
this 3 w 1633
request 1 w 1640
of 6 w 1642
them 4 w 1646
when 4 w 1651
my 5 w 1653
sons 1 w 1657
grow 1 w 1661
up 1 w 1663
gentlemen 1 w 1673
punish 1 w 1680
them 5 w 1684
by 2 w 1686
troubling 1 w 1695
them 6 w 1699
as 11 w 1701
I 10 w 1702
have 1 w 1706
troubled 1 w 1714
you 4 w 1717
if 6 w 1720
they 4 w 1724
seem 1 w 1728
to 15 w 1730
you 5 w 1733
to 16 w 1735
care 1 w 1739
for 6 w 1742
money 1 w 1747
or 17 w 1749
anything 1 w 1757
else 1 w 1761
more 1 w 1765
than 2 w 1769
for 7 w 1772
virtue 1 w 1778
and 19 w 1782
if 7 w 1784
they 5 w 1788
think 3 w 1793
they 6 w 1797
amount 1 w 1803
to 17 w 1805
something 1 w 1814
when 5 w 1818
they 7 w 1822
do 4 w 1824
not 8 w 1827
rebuke 1 w 1834
them 7 w 1838
as 12 w 1840
I 11 w 1841
have 2 w 1845
rebuked 1 w 1852
you 6 w 1855
because 2 w 1862
they 8 w 1866
do 5 w 1868
not 9 w 1871
care 2 w 1875
for 8 w 1878
what 3 w 1882
they 9 w 1886
ought 2 w 1891
and 20 w 1895
think 4 w 1900
they 10 w 1904
amount 2 w 1910
to 18 w 1912
something 2 w 1921
when 6 w 1925
they 11 w 1929
are 10 w 1932
worth 1 w 1937
nothing 1 w 1944