Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Apology

Apology (28)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0059.tlg002.perseus-eng2:28
Refs {'start': {'reference': '28', 'human_reference': 'Section 28'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Well then, men of Athens, that I am not a wrongdoer according to Meletuss indictment, seems to me not to need much of a defence, but what has been said is enough. But you may be assured that what I said before is true, that great hatred has arisen against me and in the minds of many persons. And this it is which will cause my condemnation, if it is to cause it, not Meletus or Anytus, but the prejudice and dislike of the many. This has condemned many other good men, and I think will do so;
28b
and there is no danger that it will stop with me. But perhaps someone might say: Are you then not ashamed, Socrates, of having followed such a pursuit, that you are now in danger of being put to death as a result? But I should make to him a just reply: You do not speak well, Sir, if you think a man in whom there is even a little merit ought to consider danger of life or death, and not rather regard this only, when he does things, whether the things he does are right or wrong and the acts of a good or a bad man. For according to your argument all the demigods
28c
would be bad who died at Troy, including the son of Thetis, who so despised danger, in comparison with enduring any disgrace, that when his mother (and she was a goddess) said to him, as he was eager to slay Hector, something like this, I believe,
My son, if you avenge the death of your friend Patroclus and kill Hector, you yourself shall die;
for straightway, after Hector, is death appointed unto you;
[*]he, when he heard this, made light of death and danger,
28d
and feared much more to live as a coward and not to avenge his friends, and said,
Straightway may I die, after doing vengeance upon the wrongdoer, that I may not stay here, jeered at beside the curved ships, a burden of the earth.
. Do you think he considered death and danger?
For thus it is, men of Athens, in truth; wherever a man stations himself, thinking it is best to be there, or is stationed by his commander, there he must, as it seems to me, remain and run his risks, considering neither death nor any other thing more than disgrace.
So I should have done a terrible thing,
28e
if, when the commanders whom you chose to command me stationed me, both at Potidaea and at Amphipolis and at Delium, I remained where they stationed me, like anybody else, and ran the risk of death, but when the god gave me a station, as I believed and understood, with orders to spend my life in philosophy and in examining myself and others,
29
29a
then I were to desert my post through fear of death or anything else whatsoever.

Tokens

Well 1 w 4
then 1 w 8
men 1 w 12
of 1 w 14
Athens 1 w 20
that 1 w 25
I 1 w 26
am 1 w 28
not 1 w 31
a 3 w 32
wrongdoer 1 w 41
according 1 w 50
to 1 w 52
Meletus 1 w 59
s 3 w 61
indictment 1 w 71
seems 1 w 77
to 2 w 79
me 3 w 81
not 2 w 84
to 3 w 86
need 1 w 90
much 1 w 94
of 2 w 96
a 5 w 97
defence 1 w 104
but 1 w 108
what 1 w 112
has 1 w 115
been 1 w 119
said 1 w 123
is 1 w 125
enough 1 w 131
But 1 w 135
you 1 w 138
may 1 w 141
be 2 w 143
assured 1 w 150
that 2 w 154
what 2 w 158
I 2 w 159
said 2 w 163
before 1 w 169
is 2 w 171
true 1 w 175
that 3 w 180
great 1 w 185
hatred 1 w 191
has 2 w 194
arisen 1 w 200
against 1 w 207
me 4 w 209
and 1 w 212
in 4 w 214
the 3 w 217
minds 1 w 222
of 3 w 224
many 1 w 228
persons 1 w 235
And 1 w 239
this 1 w 243
it 1 w 245
is 5 w 247
which 1 w 252
will 1 w 256
cause 1 w 261
my 1 w 263
condemnation 1 w 275
if 1 w 278
it 2 w 280
is 6 w 282
to 4 w 284
cause 2 w 289
it 3 w 291
not 3 w 295
Meletus 2 w 302
or 3 w 304
Anytus 1 w 310
but 2 w 314
the 4 w 317
prejudice 1 w 326
and 2 w 329
dislike 1 w 336
of 4 w 338
the 5 w 341
many 2 w 345
This 1 w 350
has 3 w 353
condemned 1 w 362
many 3 w 366
other 1 w 371
good 1 w 375
men 3 w 378
and 3 w 382
I 3 w 383
think 1 w 388
will 2 w 392
do 2 w 394
so 2 w 396
and 4 w 400
there 1 w 405
is 9 w 407
no 5 w 409
danger 1 w 415
that 4 w 419
it 4 w 421
will 3 w 425
stop 1 w 429
with 1 w 433
me 6 w 435
But 2 w 439
perhaps 1 w 446
someone 1 w 453
might 1 w 458
say 1 w 461
Are 1 w 465
you 2 w 468
then 3 w 472
not 4 w 475
ashamed 1 w 482
Socrates 1 w 491
of 5 w 494
having 1 w 500
followed 1 w 508
such 1 w 512
a 40 w 513
pursuit 1 w 520
that 5 w 525
you 3 w 528
are 1 w 531
now 1 w 534
in 8 w 536
danger 2 w 542
of 6 w 544
being 1 w 549
put 1 w 552
to 6 w 554
death 1 w 559
as 6 w 561
a 46 w 562
result 1 w 568
But 3 w 572
I 4 w 573
should 1 w 579
make 1 w 583
to 7 w 585
him 1 w 588
a 48 w 589
just 1 w 593
reply 1 w 598
You 1 w 602
do 3 w 604
not 5 w 607
speak 1 w 612
well 1 w 616
Sir 1 w 620
if 2 w 623
you 4 w 626
think 2 w 631
a 50 w 632
man 4 w 635
in 11 w 637
whom 1 w 641
there 2 w 646
is 10 w 648
even 1 w 652
a 52 w 653
little 1 w 659
merit 1 w 664
ought 1 w 669
to 8 w 671
consider 1 w 679
danger 3 w 685
of 7 w 687
life 1 w 691
or 4 w 693
death 2 w 698
and 5 w 702
not 6 w 705
rather 1 w 711
regard 1 w 717
this 2 w 721
only 1 w 725
when 1 w 730
he 12 w 732
does 1 w 736
things 1 w 742
whether 1 w 750
the 12 w 753
things 2 w 759
he 16 w 761
does 2 w 765
are 2 w 768
right 1 w 773
or 5 w 775
wrong 2 w 780
and 6 w 783
the 13 w 786
acts 1 w 790
of 8 w 792
a 61 w 793
good 2 w 797
or 6 w 799
a 62 w 800
bad 1 w 803
man 5 w 806
For 1 w 810
according 2 w 819
to 9 w 821
your 1 w 825
argument 1 w 833
all 1 w 836
the 14 w 839
demigods 1 w 847
would 1 w 852
be 5 w 854
bad 2 w 857
who 2 w 860
died 1 w 864
at 15 w 866
Troy 1 w 870
including 1 w 880
the 15 w 883
son 2 w 886
of 9 w 888
Thetis 1 w 894
who 3 w 898
so 5 w 900
despised 1 w 908
danger 4 w 914
in 17 w 917
comparison 1 w 927
with 2 w 931
enduring 1 w 939
any 4 w 942
disgrace 1 w 950
that 6 w 955
when 2 w 959
his 4 w 962
mother 1 w 968
and 7 w 972
she 1 w 975
was 1 w 978
a 77 w 979
goddess 1 w 986
said 3 w 991
to 10 w 993
him 2 w 996
as 8 w 999
he 24 w 1001
was 2 w 1004
eager 1 w 1009
to 11 w 1011
slay 1 w 1015
Hector 1 w 1021
something 1 w 1031
like 2 w 1035
this 3 w 1039
I 5 w 1041
believe 1 w 1048
My 1 w 1051
son 4 w 1054
if 4 w 1057
you 6 w 1060
avenge 1 w 1066
the 17 w 1069
death 3 w 1074
of 10 w 1076
your 2 w 1080
friend 1 w 1086
Patroclus 1 w 1095
and 8 w 1098
kill 1 w 1102
Hector 2 w 1108
you 8 w 1112
yourself 1 w 1120
shall 1 w 1125
die 2 w 1128
for 2 w 1132
straightway 1 w 1143
after 1 w 1149
Hector 3 w 1155
is 18 w 1158
death 4 w 1163
appointed 1 w 1172
unto 1 w 1176
you 10 w 1179
Hom 1 w 1183
Il 1 w 1186
18 1 w 1189
96 1 w 1192
he 26 w 1195
when 3 w 1200
he 28 w 1202
heard 1 w 1207
this 4 w 1211
made 1 w 1216
light 1 w 1221
of 11 w 1223
death 5 w 1228
and 9 w 1231
danger 5 w 1237
and 10 w 1241
feared 1 w 1247
much 2 w 1251
more 1 w 1255
to 16 w 1257
live 1 w 1261
as 10 w 1263
a 101 w 1264
coward 1 w 1270
and 11 w 1273
not 7 w 1276
to 17 w 1278
avenge 2 w 1284
his 7 w 1287
friends 1 w 1294
and 12 w 1298
said 4 w 1302
Straightway 1 w 1314
may 2 w 1317
I 7 w 1318
die 3 w 1321
after 2 w 1327
doing 1 w 1332
vengeance 1 w 1341
upon 1 w 1345
the 18 w 1348
wrongdoer 2 w 1357
that 7 w 1362
I 8 w 1363
may 3 w 1366
not 8 w 1369
stay 1 w 1373
here 3 w 1377
jeered 1 w 1384
at 22 w 1386
beside 1 w 1392
the 19 w 1395
curved 1 w 1401
ships 1 w 1406
a 116 w 1408
burden 1 w 1414
of 12 w 1416
the 20 w 1419
earth 1 w 1424
Do 1 w 1428
you 11 w 1431
think 3 w 1436
he 34 w 1438
considered 1 w 1448
death 6 w 1453
and 13 w 1456
danger 6 w 1462
For 2 w 1466
thus 1 w 1470
it 10 w 1472
is 21 w 1474
men 5 w 1478
of 13 w 1480
Athens 2 w 1486
in 23 w 1489
truth 1 w 1494
wherever 1 w 1503
a 121 w 1504
man 6 w 1507
stations 1 w 1515
himself 1 w 1522
thinking 1 w 1531
it 11 w 1533
is 22 w 1535
best 1 w 1539
to 18 w 1541
be 9 w 1543
there 3 w 1548
or 15 w 1551
is 23 w 1553
stationed 1 w 1562
by 1 w 1564
his 8 w 1567
commander 1 w 1576
there 4 w 1582
he 39 w 1584
must 1 w 1588
as 11 w 1591
it 12 w 1593
seems 2 w 1598
to 19 w 1600
me 13 w 1602
remain 1 w 1609
and 15 w 1612
run 1 w 1615
his 9 w 1618
risks 1 w 1623
considering 1 w 1635
neither 1 w 1642
death 7 w 1647
nor 1 w 1650
any 5 w 1653
other 3 w 1658
thing 4 w 1663
more 2 w 1667
than 1 w 1671
disgrace 2 w 1679
So 2 w 1682
I 9 w 1683
should 2 w 1689
have 1 w 1693
done 1 w 1697
a 134 w 1698
terrible 1 w 1706
thing 5 w 1711
if 5 w 1714
when 4 w 1719
the 26 w 1722
commanders 1 w 1732
whom 2 w 1736
you 12 w 1739
chose 1 w 1744
to 20 w 1746
command 3 w 1753
me 14 w 1755
stationed 2 w 1764
me 15 w 1766
both 1 w 1771
at 28 w 1773
Potidaea 1 w 1781
and 18 w 1784
at 29 w 1786
Amphipolis 1 w 1796
and 19 w 1799
at 30 w 1801
Delium 1 w 1807
I 10 w 1809
remained 1 w 1817
where 2 w 1822
they 1 w 1826
stationed 3 w 1835
me 16 w 1837
like 3 w 1842
anybody 1 w 1849
else 1 w 1853
and 20 w 1857
ran 1 w 1860
the 28 w 1863
risk 2 w 1867
of 14 w 1869
death 8 w 1874
but 3 w 1878
when 5 w 1882
the 29 w 1885
god 3 w 1888
gave 1 w 1892
me 17 w 1894
a 152 w 1895
station 5 w 1902
as 12 w 1905
I 11 w 1906
believed 1 w 1914
and 21 w 1917
understood 1 w 1927
with 3 w 1932
orders 1 w 1938
to 22 w 1940
spend 1 w 1945
my 2 w 1947
life 2 w 1951
in 31 w 1953
philosophy 1 w 1963
and 22 w 1966
in 32 w 1968
examining 1 w 1977
myself 1 w 1983
and 23 w 1986
others 1 w 1992
then 5 w 1997
I 12 w 1998
were 1 w 2002
to 23 w 2004
desert 1 w 2010
my 4 w 2012
post 1 w 2016
through 1 w 2023
fear 2 w 2027
of 15 w 2029
death 9 w 2034
or 19 w 2036
anything 1 w 2044
else 2 w 2048
whatsoever 1 w 2058