Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Anabasis

Anabasis (2.4.3-2.4.7)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0032.tlg006.perseus-eng2:2.4.3-2.4.7
Refs {'start': {'reference': '2.4.3', 'human_reference': 'Book 2 Chapter 4 Section 3'}, 'end': {'reference': '2.4.7', 'human_reference': 'Book 2 Chapter 4 Section 7'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '2'}, {'reference': '2.4'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Why are we lingering? Do we not understand that the King would like above everything else to destroy us, in order that the rest of the Greeks also may be afraid to march against the Great King? For the moment he is scheming to keep us here because his army is scattered, but when he has collected his forces again, there is no question but that he will attack us.

Or perhaps he is digging a trench or building a wall somewhere to cut us off and make our road impassable. For never, if he can help it, will he choose to let us go back to Greece and report that we, few as we are, were victorious over the King at his very gates, and then laughed in his face and came home again.

To those who talked in this way Clearchus replied:

I too have in mind all these things; but I reflect that if we go away now, it will seem that we are going away with hostile intent and are acting in violation of the truce. And then, in the first place, no one will provide us a market or a place from which we can get provisions; secondly, we shall have no one to guide us; again, the moment we take this course Ariaeus will instantly desert us; consequently we shall have not a friend left, for even those who were friends before will be our enemies.

Then remember the riversthere may be others, for aught I know, that we must cross, but we know about the Euphrates at any rate, that it cannot possibly be crossed in the face of an enemy. Furthermore, in case fighting becomes necessary, we have no cavalry to help us, whereas the enemys cavalry are exceedingly numerous and exceedingly efficient; hence if we are victorious, whom could we kill[*]? And if we are defeated, not one of us can be saved.

For my part, therefore, I cannot see why the King, who has so many advantages on his side, should need, in case he is really eager to destroy us, to make oath and give pledge and forswear himself by the gods and make his good faith unfaithful in the eyes of Greeks and barbarians.
Such arguments Clearchus would present in abundance.

Tokens

Why 1 w 3
are 1 w 6
we 1 w 8
lingering 1 w 17
Do 1 w 20
we 2 w 22
not 1 w 25
understand 1 w 35
that 1 w 39
the 1 w 42
King 1 w 46
would 1 w 51
like 1 w 55
above 1 w 60
everything 1 w 70
else 1 w 74
to 1 w 76
destroy 1 w 83
us 1 w 85
in 5 w 88
order 1 w 93
that 2 w 97
the 2 w 100
rest 1 w 104
of 1 w 106
the 3 w 109
Greeks 1 w 115
also 1 w 119
may 1 w 122
be 1 w 124
afraid 1 w 130
to 2 w 132
march 1 w 137
against 1 w 144
the 4 w 147
Great 1 w 152
King 2 w 156
For 1 w 160
the 5 w 163
moment 1 w 169
he 6 w 171
is 1 w 173
scheming 1 w 181
to 3 w 183
keep 1 w 187
us 2 w 189
here 1 w 193
because 1 w 200
his 1 w 203
army 1 w 207
is 3 w 209
scattered 1 w 218
but 1 w 222
when 1 w 226
he 10 w 228
has 1 w 231
collected 1 w 240
his 2 w 243
forces 1 w 249
again 2 w 254
there 1 w 260
is 5 w 262
no 2 w 264
question 1 w 272
but 2 w 275
that 3 w 279
he 12 w 281
will 1 w 285
attack 1 w 291
us 4 w 293
Or 1 w 296
perhaps 1 w 303
he 13 w 305
is 6 w 307
digging 1 w 314
a 24 w 315
trench 1 w 321
or 4 w 323
building 1 w 331
a 25 w 332
wall 1 w 336
somewhere 1 w 345
to 4 w 347
cut 1 w 350
us 5 w 352
off 1 w 355
and 2 w 358
make 1 w 362
our 1 w 365
road 1 w 369
impassable 1 w 379
For 2 w 383
never 1 w 388
if 1 w 391
he 15 w 393
can 1 w 396
help 1 w 400
it 1 w 402
will 2 w 407
he 17 w 409
choose 1 w 415
to 5 w 417
let 1 w 420
us 6 w 422
go 1 w 424
back 1 w 428
to 6 w 430
Greece 1 w 436
and 3 w 439
report 1 w 445
that 4 w 449
we 3 w 451
few 1 w 455
as 3 w 457
we 4 w 459
are 2 w 462
were 1 w 467
victorious 1 w 477
over 1 w 481
the 7 w 484
King 3 w 488
at 8 w 490
his 3 w 493
very 2 w 497
gates 1 w 502
and 4 w 506
then 1 w 510
laughed 1 w 517
in 13 w 519
his 4 w 522
face 1 w 526
and 5 w 529
came 1 w 533
home 1 w 537
again 3 w 542
To 1 w 545
those 1 w 550
who 1 w 553
talked 1 w 559
in 15 w 561
this 1 w 565
way 1 w 568
Clearchus 1 w 577
replied 1 w 584
I 1 w 586
too 1 w 589
have 1 w 593
in 16 w 595
mind 1 w 599
all 2 w 602
these 1 w 607
things 1 w 613
but 3 w 617
I 2 w 618
reflect 1 w 625
that 5 w 629
if 2 w 631
we 6 w 633
go 2 w 635
away 1 w 639
now 1 w 642
it 2 w 645
will 3 w 649
seem 1 w 653
that 6 w 657
we 7 w 659
are 3 w 662
going 1 w 667
away 2 w 671
with 1 w 675
hostile 1 w 682
intent 1 w 688
and 6 w 691
are 4 w 694
acting 1 w 700
in 22 w 702
violation 1 w 711
of 3 w 713
the 10 w 716
truce 1 w 721
And 1 w 725
then 2 w 729
in 23 w 732
the 12 w 735
first 1 w 740
place 1 w 745
no 4 w 748
one 1 w 751
will 4 w 755
provide 1 w 762
us 9 w 764
a 64 w 765
market 1 w 771
or 8 w 773
a 66 w 774
place 2 w 779
from 1 w 783
which 1 w 788
we 8 w 790
can 2 w 793
get 1 w 796
provisions 1 w 806
secondly 1 w 815
we 9 w 818
shall 1 w 823
have 2 w 827
no 5 w 829
one 2 w 832
to 9 w 834
guide 1 w 839
us 10 w 841
again 4 w 847
the 13 w 851
moment 2 w 857
we 10 w 859
take 1 w 863
this 2 w 867
course 1 w 873
Ariaeus 1 w 880
will 5 w 884
instantly 1 w 893
desert 1 w 899
us 12 w 901
consequently 1 w 914
we 11 w 916
shall 2 w 921
have 3 w 925
not 2 w 928
a 78 w 929
friend 1 w 935
left 1 w 939
for 2 w 943
even 1 w 947
those 2 w 952
who 2 w 955
were 2 w 959
friends 1 w 966
before 1 w 972
will 6 w 976
be 4 w 978
our 3 w 981
enemies 1 w 988
Then 1 w 993
remember 1 w 1001
the 14 w 1004
rivers 1 w 1010
there 2 w 1016
may 2 w 1019
be 6 w 1021
others 1 w 1027
for 4 w 1031
aught 1 w 1036
I 3 w 1037
know 1 w 1041
that 7 w 1046
we 13 w 1048
must 1 w 1052
cross 1 w 1057
but 4 w 1061
we 14 w 1063
know 2 w 1067
about 1 w 1072
the 17 w 1075
Euphrates 1 w 1084
at 15 w 1086
any 1 w 1089
rate 2 w 1093
that 8 w 1098
it 4 w 1100
cannot 1 w 1106
possibly 1 w 1114
be 7 w 1116
crossed 1 w 1123
in 26 w 1125
the 18 w 1128
face 2 w 1132
of 4 w 1134
an 12 w 1136
enemy 1 w 1141
Furthermore 1 w 1153
in 27 w 1156
case 1 w 1160
fighting 1 w 1168
becomes 1 w 1175
necessary 1 w 1184
we 15 w 1187
have 4 w 1191
no 10 w 1193
cavalry 1 w 1200
to 10 w 1202
help 2 w 1206
us 14 w 1208
whereas 1 w 1216
the 20 w 1219
enemy 2 w 1224
s 76 w 1226
cavalry 2 w 1233
are 5 w 1236
exceedingly 1 w 1247
numerous 1 w 1255
and 7 w 1258
exceedingly 2 w 1269
efficient 1 w 1278
hence 1 w 1284
if 3 w 1286
we 16 w 1288
are 6 w 1291
victorious 2 w 1301
whom 1 w 1306
could 1 w 1311
we 17 w 1313
kill 1 w 1317
Hoplites 1 w 1325
because 2 w 1333
of 5 w 1335
their 1 w 1340
heavy 1 w 1345
equipment 1 w 1354
were 3 w 1359
ineffective 1 w 1370
in 32 w 1372
a 104 w 1373
pursuit 1 w 1380
especially 1 w 1391
when 2 w 1395
an 14 w 1397
enemy 3 w 1402
fled 1 w 1406
as 6 w 1409
in 33 w 1411
the 22 w 1414
battle 1 w 1420
of 6 w 1422
I 4 w 1423
viii 1 w 1428
long 1 w 1434
before 2 w 1440
they 1 w 1444
were 4 w 1448
within 1 w 1454
striking 1 w 1462
distance 1 w 1470
Horsemen 1 w 1479
of 7 w 1482
course 2 w 1488
were 5 w 1493
at 19 w 1495
their 2 w 1500
best 1 w 1504
in 36 w 1506
following 1 w 1515
up 2 w 1517
a 111 w 1518
routed 1 w 1524
enemy 4 w 1529
And 2 w 1534
if 4 w 1536
we 21 w 1538
are 7 w 1541
defeated 1 w 1549
not 4 w 1553
one 3 w 1556
of 8 w 1558
us 18 w 1560
can 4 w 1563
be 12 w 1565
saved 1 w 1570
For 3 w 1574
my 6 w 1576
part 1 w 1580
therefore 1 w 1590
I 5 w 1592
cannot 2 w 1598
see 2 w 1601
why 1 w 1604
the 26 w 1607
King 4 w 1611
who 4 w 1615
has 2 w 1618
so 3 w 1620
many 1 w 1624
advantages 1 w 1634
on 10 w 1636
his 7 w 1639
side 1 w 1643
should 1 w 1650
need 1 w 1654
in 39 w 1657
case 2 w 1661
he 45 w 1663
is 14 w 1665
really 1 w 1671
eager 1 w 1676
to 12 w 1678
destroy 2 w 1685
us 19 w 1687
to 13 w 1690
make 2 w 1694
oath 1 w 1698
and 8 w 1701
give 1 w 1705
pledge 1 w 1711
and 9 w 1714
forswear 1 w 1722
himself 1 w 1729
by 1 w 1731
the 27 w 1734
gods 1 w 1738
and 10 w 1741
make 3 w 1745
his 8 w 1748
good 1 w 1752
faith 1 w 1757
unfaithful 1 w 1767
in 40 w 1769
the 28 w 1772
eyes 1 w 1776
of 9 w 1778
Greeks 2 w 1784
and 11 w 1787
barbarians 1 w 1797
Such 1 w 1802
arguments 1 w 1811
Clearchus 2 w 1820
would 2 w 1825
present 1 w 1832
in 41 w 1834
abundance 1 w 1843