Scaife ATLAS

Apology (19-20)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0032.tlg005.perseus-eng2:19-20

Refs	`{'start': {'reference': '19', 'human_reference': 'Section 19'}, 'end': {'reference': '20', 'human_reference': 'Section 20'}}`
Ancestors	`[]`
Children	`[]`

plain text • XML

But in spite of all, Meletus, do you maintain that I corrupt the young by such practices? And yet surely we know what kinds of corruption affect the young; so you tell us whether you know of any one who under my influence has fallen from piety into impiety, or from sober into wanton conduct, or from moderation in living into extravagance, or from temperate drinking into sottishness, or from strenuousness into effeminacy, or has been overcome of any other base pleasure.”

But, by Heaven!

said Meletus:

there is one set of men I know,—those whom you have persuaded to obey you rather than their parents.

I admit it,

he reports Socrates as replying,

at least so far as education is concerned; for people know that I have taken an interest in that. But in a question of health, men take the advice of physicians rather than that of their parents; and moreover, in the meetings of the legislative assembly all the people of Athens, without question, follow the advice of those whose words are wisest rather than that of their own relatives. Do you not also elect for your generals, in preference to fathers and brothers,—yes, by Heaven! in preference to your very selves,—those whom you regard as having the greatest wisdom in military affairs?

Yes,

Meletus had said;

for that is both expedient and conventional.

Tokens

But	1	w	3
in	1	w	5
spite	1	w	10
of	1	w	12
all	1	w	15
Meletus	1	w	23
do	1	w	26
you	1	w	29
maintain	1	w	37
that	1	w	41
I	1	w	42
corrupt	1	w	49
the	1	w	52
young	1	w	57
by	1	w	59
such	1	w	63
practices	1	w	72
And	1	w	76
yet	1	w	79
surely	1	w	85
we	1	w	87
know	1	w	91
what	1	w	95
kinds	1	w	100
of	2	w	102
corruption	1	w	112
affect	1	w	118
the	2	w	121
young	2	w	126
so	1	w	129
you	4	w	132
tell	1	w	136
us	2	w	138
whether	1	w	145
you	5	w	148
know	2	w	152
of	3	w	154
any	1	w	157
one	1	w	160
who	1	w	163
under	1	w	168
my	1	w	170
influence	1	w	179
has	1	w	182
fallen	1	w	188
from	1	w	192
piety	1	w	197
into	1	w	201
impiety	1	w	208
or	3	w	211
from	2	w	215
sober	1	w	220
into	2	w	224
wanton	1	w	230
conduct	1	w	237
or	4	w	240
from	3	w	244
moderation	1	w	254
in	8	w	256
living	1	w	262
into	3	w	266
extravagance	1	w	278
or	5	w	281
from	4	w	285
temperate	1	w	294
drinking	1	w	302
into	4	w	306
sottishness	1	w	317
or	6	w	320
from	5	w	324
strenuousness	1	w	337
into	5	w	341
effeminacy	1	w	351
or	7	w	354
has	2	w	357
been	1	w	361
overcome	1	w	369
of	4	w	371
any	2	w	374
other	1	w	379
base	1	w	383
pleasure	1	w	391
But	2	w	396
by	2	w	399
Heaven	1	w	405
said	1	w	410
Meletus	2	w	417
there	1	w	423
is	2	w	425
one	2	w	428
set	1	w	431
of	5	w	433
men	1	w	436
I	2	w	437
know	3	w	441
those	1	w	448
whom	1	w	452
you	6	w	455
have	1	w	459
persuaded	1	w	468
to	7	w	470
obey	1	w	474
you	7	w	477
rather	1	w	483
than	1	w	487
their	1	w	492
parents	1	w	499
I	3	w	501
admit	1	w	506
it	3	w	508
he	9	w	511
reports	1	w	518
Socrates	1	w	526
as	5	w	528
replying	1	w	536
at	7	w	539
least	1	w	544
so	4	w	546
far	1	w	549
as	7	w	551
education	1	w	560
is	3	w	562
concerned	1	w	571
for	1	w	575
people	1	w	581
know	4	w	585
that	2	w	589
I	4	w	590
have	2	w	594
taken	1	w	599
an	6	w	601
interest	1	w	609
in	18	w	611
that	3	w	615
But	3	w	619
in	19	w	621
a	42	w	622
question	1	w	630
of	6	w	632
health	1	w	638
men	2	w	642
take	2	w	646
the	8	w	649
advice	1	w	655
of	7	w	657
physicians	1	w	667
rather	2	w	673
than	2	w	677
that	4	w	681
of	8	w	683
their	2	w	688
parents	2	w	695
and	1	w	699
moreover	1	w	707
in	20	w	710
the	11	w	713
meetings	1	w	721
of	9	w	723
the	12	w	726
legislative	1	w	737
assembly	1	w	745
all	3	w	748
the	13	w	751
people	2	w	757
of	10	w	759
Athens	1	w	765
without	1	w	773
question	2	w	781
follow	1	w	788
the	15	w	791
advice	2	w	797
of	11	w	799
those	2	w	804
whose	1	w	809
words	1	w	814
are	3	w	817
wisest	1	w	823
rather	3	w	829
than	3	w	833
that	5	w	837
of	12	w	839
their	3	w	844
own	1	w	847
relatives	1	w	856
Do	1	w	859
you	8	w	862
not	1	w	865
also	1	w	869
elect	1	w	874
for	2	w	877
your	1	w	881
generals	1	w	889
in	22	w	892
preference	1	w	902
to	8	w	904
fathers	1	w	911
and	2	w	914
brothers	1	w	922
yes	1	w	927
by	3	w	930
Heaven	2	w	936
in	23	w	939
preference	2	w	949
to	9	w	951
your	2	w	955
very	1	w	959
selves	1	w	965
those	3	w	972
whom	2	w	976
you	11	w	979
regard	1	w	985
as	9	w	987
having	1	w	993
the	20	w	996
greatest	1	w	1004
wisdom	1	w	1010
in	25	w	1012
military	1	w	1020
affairs	1	w	1027
Yes	1	w	1031
Meletus	3	w	1039
had	1	w	1042
said	2	w	1046
for	3	w	1050
that	6	w	1054
is	7	w	1056
both	1	w	1060
expedient	1	w	1069
and	3	w	1072
conventional	1	w	1084