Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Apology

Apology (16-20)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0032.tlg005.perseus-eng2:16-20
Refs {'start': {'reference': '16', 'human_reference': 'Section 16'}, 'end': {'reference': '20', 'human_reference': 'Section 20'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

First, who is there in your knowledge that is less a slave to his bodily appetites than I am? Who in the world more free,—for I accept neither gifts nor pay from any one? Whom would you with reason regard as more just than the one so reconciled to his present possessions as to want nothing beside that belongs to another? And would not a person with good reason call me a wise man, who from the time when I began to understand spoken words have never left off seeking after and learning every good thing that I could?

And that my labour has not been in vain do you not think is attested by this fact, that many of my fellow-citizens who strive for virtue and many from abroad choose to associate with me above all other men? And what shall we say is accountable for this fact, that although everybody knows that it is quite impossible for me to repay with money, many people are eager to make me some gift? Or for this, that no demands are made on me by a single person for the repayment of benefits, while many confess that they owe me a debt of gratitude?

Or for this, that during the siege,[*] while others were commiserating their lot, I got along without feeling the pinch of poverty any worse than when the citys prosperity was at its height? Or for this, that while other men get their delicacies in the markets and pay a high price for them, I devise more pleasurable ones from the resources of my soul, with no expenditure of money? And now, if no one can convict me of misstatement in all that I have said of myself, do I not unquestionably merit praise from both gods and men?

But in spite of all, Meletus, do you maintain that I corrupt the young by such practices? And yet surely we know what kinds of corruption affect the young; so you tell us whether you know of any one who under my influence has fallen from piety into impiety, or from sober into wanton conduct, or from moderation in living into extravagance, or from temperate drinking into sottishness, or from strenuousness into effeminacy, or has been overcome of any other base pleasure.”

But, by Heaven!
said Meletus:
there is one set of men I know,—those whom you have persuaded to obey you rather than their parents.
I admit it,
he reports Socrates as replying,
at least so far as education is concerned; for people know that I have taken an interest in that. But in a question of health, men take the advice of physicians rather than that of their parents; and moreover, in the meetings of the legislative assembly all the people of Athens, without question, follow the advice of those whose words are wisest rather than that of their own relatives. Do you not also elect for your generals, in preference to fathers and brothers,—yes, by Heaven! in preference to your very selves,—those whom you regard as having the greatest wisdom in military affairs?
Yes,
Meletus had said;
for that is both expedient and conventional.

Tokens

First 1 w 5
who 1 w 9
is 1 w 11
there 1 w 16
in 1 w 18
your 1 w 22
knowledge 1 w 31
that 1 w 35
is 2 w 37
less 1 w 41
a 2 w 42
slave 1 w 47
to 1 w 49
his 1 w 52
bodily 1 w 58
appetites 1 w 67
than 1 w 71
I 1 w 72
am 1 w 74
Who 1 w 78
in 2 w 80
the 2 w 83
world 1 w 88
more 1 w 92
free 1 w 96
for 1 w 101
I 2 w 102
accept 1 w 108
neither 1 w 115
gifts 1 w 120
nor 1 w 123
pay 1 w 126
from 1 w 130
any 1 w 133
one 1 w 136
Whom 1 w 141
would 1 w 146
you 2 w 149
with 1 w 153
reason 1 w 159
regard 1 w 165
as 2 w 167
more 2 w 171
just 1 w 175
than 2 w 179
the 4 w 182
one 2 w 185
so 2 w 187
reconciled 1 w 197
to 2 w 199
his 2 w 202
present 1 w 209
possessions 1 w 220
as 3 w 222
to 3 w 224
want 1 w 228
nothing 1 w 235
beside 1 w 241
that 2 w 245
belongs 1 w 252
to 4 w 254
another 1 w 261
And 1 w 265
would 2 w 270
not 3 w 273
a 18 w 274
person 1 w 280
with 2 w 284
good 1 w 288
reason 2 w 294
call 1 w 298
me 1 w 300
a 21 w 301
wise 1 w 305
man 1 w 308
who 2 w 312
from 2 w 316
the 6 w 319
time 1 w 323
when 1 w 327
I 3 w 328
began 1 w 333
to 5 w 335
understand 1 w 345
spoken 1 w 351
words 1 w 356
have 1 w 360
never 1 w 365
left 1 w 369
off 1 w 372
seeking 1 w 379
after 1 w 384
and 2 w 387
learning 1 w 395
every 1 w 400
good 2 w 404
thing 2 w 409
that 3 w 413
I 4 w 414
could 1 w 419
And 2 w 423
that 4 w 427
my 1 w 429
labour 1 w 435
has 1 w 438
not 4 w 441
been 1 w 445
in 7 w 447
vain 1 w 451
do 1 w 453
you 3 w 456
not 5 w 459
think 1 w 464
is 6 w 466
attested 1 w 474
by 1 w 476
this 1 w 480
fact 1 w 484
that 5 w 489
many 1 w 493
of 2 w 495
my 2 w 497
fellow-citizens 1 w 512
who 3 w 515
strive 1 w 521
for 2 w 524
virtue 1 w 530
and 3 w 533
many 2 w 537
from 3 w 541
abroad 1 w 547
choose 1 w 553
to 6 w 555
associate 1 w 564
with 3 w 568
me 3 w 570
above 1 w 575
all 2 w 578
other 2 w 583
men 1 w 586
And 3 w 590
what 1 w 594
shall 1 w 599
we 1 w 601
say 1 w 604
is 8 w 606
accountable 1 w 617
for 3 w 620
this 2 w 624
fact 2 w 628
that 6 w 633
although 1 w 641
everybody 1 w 650
knows 1 w 655
that 7 w 659
it 7 w 661
is 10 w 663
quite 1 w 668
impossible 1 w 678
for 4 w 681
me 5 w 683
to 7 w 685
repay 1 w 690
with 4 w 694
money 1 w 699
many 3 w 704
people 1 w 710
are 1 w 713
eager 1 w 718
to 8 w 720
make 1 w 724
me 6 w 726
some 1 w 730
gift 2 w 734
Or 1 w 737
for 5 w 740
this 3 w 744
that 8 w 749
no 9 w 751
demands 1 w 758
are 2 w 761
made 1 w 765
on 10 w 767
me 8 w 769
by 2 w 771
a 64 w 772
single 1 w 778
person 2 w 784
for 6 w 787
the 8 w 790
repayment 1 w 799
of 3 w 801
benefits 1 w 809
while 1 w 815
many 4 w 819
confess 1 w 826
that 9 w 830
they 1 w 834
owe 1 w 837
me 10 w 839
a 68 w 840
debt 1 w 844
of 4 w 846
gratitude 1 w 855
Or 2 w 858
for 7 w 861
this 4 w 865
that 10 w 870
during 1 w 876
the 10 w 879
siege 1 w 884
The 1 w 888
blockade 1 w 896
of 5 w 898
Athens 1 w 904
by 3 w 906
the 12 w 909
Spartans 1 w 917
in 12 w 919
the 13 w 922
last 1 w 926
year 1 w 930
of 6 w 932
the 14 w 935
Peloponnesian 1 w 948
War 1 w 951
while 2 w 957
others 1 w 963
were 1 w 967
commiserating 1 w 980
their 1 w 985
lot 1 w 988
I 5 w 990
got 1 w 993
along 1 w 998
without 1 w 1005
feeling 1 w 1012
the 17 w 1015
pinch 1 w 1020
of 7 w 1022
poverty 1 w 1029
any 6 w 1032
worse 1 w 1037
than 3 w 1041
when 2 w 1045
the 18 w 1048
city 1 w 1052
s 65 w 1054
prosperity 1 w 1064
was 1 w 1067
at 16 w 1069
its 2 w 1072
height 1 w 1078
Or 3 w 1081
for 8 w 1084
this 5 w 1088
that 11 w 1093
while 3 w 1098
other 4 w 1103
men 3 w 1106
get 1 w 1109
their 2 w 1114
delicacies 1 w 1124
in 16 w 1126
the 21 w 1129
markets 1 w 1136
and 5 w 1139
pay 4 w 1142
a 89 w 1143
high 1 w 1147
price 1 w 1152
for 9 w 1155
them 1 w 1159
I 6 w 1161
devise 1 w 1167
more 3 w 1171
pleasurable 1 w 1182
ones 1 w 1186
from 4 w 1190
the 23 w 1193
resources 1 w 1202
of 8 w 1204
my 3 w 1206
soul 1 w 1210
with 6 w 1215
no 10 w 1217
expenditure 1 w 1228
of 9 w 1230
money 2 w 1235
And 4 w 1239
now 3 w 1242
if 3 w 1245
no 12 w 1247
one 6 w 1250
can 1 w 1253
convict 1 w 1260
me 12 w 1262
of 10 w 1264
misstatement 1 w 1276
in 17 w 1278
all 4 w 1281
that 12 w 1285
I 7 w 1286
have 2 w 1290
said 1 w 1294
of 11 w 1296
myself 1 w 1302
do 2 w 1305
I 8 w 1306
not 6 w 1309
unquestionably 1 w 1323
merit 1 w 1328
praise 1 w 1334
from 5 w 1338
both 1 w 1342
gods 1 w 1346
and 6 w 1349
men 5 w 1352
But 1 w 1356
in 18 w 1358
spite 1 w 1363
of 12 w 1365
all 5 w 1368
Meletus 1 w 1376
do 3 w 1379
you 4 w 1382
maintain 1 w 1390
that 13 w 1394
I 9 w 1395
corrupt 1 w 1402
the 24 w 1405
young 1 w 1410
by 4 w 1412
such 1 w 1416
practices 1 w 1425
And 5 w 1429
yet 1 w 1432
surely 1 w 1438
we 4 w 1440
know 3 w 1444
what 2 w 1448
kinds 1 w 1453
of 13 w 1455
corruption 1 w 1465
affect 1 w 1471
the 25 w 1474
young 2 w 1479
so 10 w 1482
you 7 w 1485
tell 1 w 1489
us 3 w 1491
whether 1 w 1498
you 8 w 1501
know 4 w 1505
of 14 w 1507
any 7 w 1510
one 7 w 1513
who 4 w 1516
under 2 w 1521
my 5 w 1523
influence 1 w 1532
has 2 w 1535
fallen 1 w 1541
from 6 w 1545
piety 1 w 1550
into 1 w 1554
impiety 1 w 1561
or 19 w 1564
from 7 w 1568
sober 1 w 1573
into 2 w 1577
wanton 1 w 1583
conduct 1 w 1590
or 20 w 1593
from 8 w 1597
moderation 1 w 1607
in 25 w 1609
living 1 w 1615
into 3 w 1619
extravagance 1 w 1631
or 21 w 1634
from 9 w 1638
temperate 1 w 1647
drinking 1 w 1655
into 4 w 1659
sottishness 1 w 1670
or 22 w 1673
from 10 w 1677
strenuousness 1 w 1690
into 5 w 1694
effeminacy 1 w 1704
or 23 w 1707
has 3 w 1710
been 2 w 1714
overcome 1 w 1722
of 15 w 1724
any 8 w 1727
other 5 w 1732
base 1 w 1736
pleasure 1 w 1744
But 2 w 1749
by 5 w 1752
Heaven 1 w 1758
said 2 w 1763
Meletus 2 w 1770
there 2 w 1776
is 19 w 1778
one 8 w 1781
set 1 w 1784
of 16 w 1786
men 6 w 1789
I 10 w 1790
know 5 w 1794
those 1 w 1801
whom 1 w 1805
you 9 w 1808
have 3 w 1812
persuaded 1 w 1821
to 15 w 1823
obey 1 w 1827
you 10 w 1830
rather 1 w 1836
than 4 w 1840
their 3 w 1845
parents 1 w 1852
I 11 w 1854
admit 1 w 1859
it 21 w 1861
he 36 w 1864
reports 1 w 1871
Socrates 1 w 1879
as 14 w 1881
replying 1 w 1889
at 26 w 1892
least 1 w 1897
so 13 w 1899
far 1 w 1902
as 16 w 1904
education 1 w 1913
is 20 w 1915
concerned 1 w 1924
for 10 w 1928
people 2 w 1934
know 6 w 1938
that 14 w 1942
I 12 w 1943
have 4 w 1947
taken 1 w 1952
an 28 w 1954
interest 1 w 1962
in 35 w 1964
that 15 w 1968
But 3 w 1972
in 36 w 1974
a 142 w 1975
question 2 w 1983
of 17 w 1985
health 1 w 1991
men 7 w 1995
take 2 w 1999
the 31 w 2002
advice 1 w 2008
of 18 w 2010
physicians 1 w 2020
rather 2 w 2026
than 5 w 2030
that 16 w 2034
of 19 w 2036
their 4 w 2041
parents 2 w 2048
and 7 w 2052
moreover 1 w 2060
in 37 w 2063
the 34 w 2066
meetings 1 w 2074
of 20 w 2076
the 35 w 2079
legislative 1 w 2090
assembly 1 w 2098
all 7 w 2101
the 36 w 2104
people 3 w 2110
of 21 w 2112
Athens 2 w 2118
without 2 w 2126
question 3 w 2134
follow 1 w 2141
the 38 w 2144
advice 2 w 2150
of 22 w 2152
those 2 w 2157
whose 1 w 2162
words 2 w 2167
are 5 w 2170
wisest 1 w 2176
rather 3 w 2182
than 6 w 2186
that 17 w 2190
of 23 w 2192
their 5 w 2197
own 1 w 2200
relatives 1 w 2209
Do 1 w 2212
you 11 w 2215
not 7 w 2218
also 1 w 2222
elect 1 w 2227
for 11 w 2230
your 2 w 2234
generals 1 w 2242
in 39 w 2245
preference 1 w 2255
to 16 w 2257
fathers 1 w 2264
and 8 w 2267
brothers 1 w 2275
yes 1 w 2280
by 6 w 2283
Heaven 2 w 2289
in 40 w 2292
preference 2 w 2302
to 17 w 2304
your 3 w 2308
very 3 w 2312
selves 1 w 2318
those 3 w 2325
whom 2 w 2329
you 14 w 2332
regard 2 w 2338
as 18 w 2340
having 1 w 2346
the 43 w 2349
greatest 1 w 2357
wisdom 1 w 2363
in 42 w 2365
military 1 w 2373
affairs 1 w 2380
Yes 1 w 2384
Meletus 3 w 2392
had 1 w 2395
said 3 w 2399
for 12 w 2403
that 18 w 2407
is 24 w 2409
both 2 w 2413
expedient 1 w 2422
and 9 w 2425
conventional 1 w 2437