Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Hellenica

Hellenica (2.3.15-2.3.19)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0032.tlg001.perseus-eng2:2.3.15-2.3.19
Refs {'start': {'reference': '2.3.15', 'human_reference': 'Book 2 Chapter 3 Section 15'}, 'end': {'reference': '2.3.19', 'human_reference': 'Book 2 Chapter 3 Section 19'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '2'}, {'reference': '2.3'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Now in the beginning Critias and Theramenes were agreed in their policy and friendly; but when Critias showed himself eager to put many to death, because, for one thing, he had been banished by the democracy, Theramenes opposed him, saying that it[*] was not reasonable to put a man to death because he was honoured by the commons, provided he was doing no harm to the aristocrats.
For,
said he,
you and I also have said and done many things for the sake of winning the favour of the city.

Then Critias (for he still treated Theramenes as a friend) replied that it was impossible for people who wanted to gain power not to put out of the way those who were best able to thwart them.

But if,
he said,
merely because we are thirty and not one, you imagine that it is any the less necessary for us to keep a close watch over this government, just as one would if it were an absolute monarchy, you are foolish.

But when, on account of the great numbers continuallyand unjustlyput to death, it was evident that many were banding together and wondering what the state was coming to, Theramenes spoke again, saying that unless they admitted an adequate number of citizens into partnership with them in the management of affairs, it would be impossible for the oligarchy to endure.

Accordingly Critias and the rest of the Thirty, who were by this time alarmed and feared above all that the citizens would flock to the support of Theramenes, enrolled a body of three thousand, who were to share, as they said, in the government.

Theramenes, however, objected to this move also, saying that, in the first place, it seemed to him absurd that, when they wanted to make the best of the citizens their associates, they should limit themselves to three thousand, as though this number must somehow be good men and true and there could neither be excellent men outside this body nor rascals within[*] it.

Besides,
he said,
we are undertaking, in my opinion, two absolutely inconsistent things,—to rig up our government on the basis of force and at the same time to make it weaker than its subjects.

Tokens

Now 1 w 3
in 1 w 5
the 1 w 8
beginning 1 w 17
Critias 1 w 24
and 1 w 27
Theramenes 1 w 37
were 1 w 41
agreed 1 w 47
in 4 w 49
their 1 w 54
policy 1 w 60
and 2 w 63
friendly 1 w 71
but 1 w 75
when 1 w 79
Critias 2 w 86
showed 1 w 92
himself 1 w 99
eager 1 w 104
to 1 w 106
put 1 w 109
many 1 w 113
to 2 w 115
death 1 w 120
because 1 w 128
for 1 w 132
one 1 w 135
thing 1 w 140
he 5 w 143
had 1 w 146
been 1 w 150
banished 1 w 158
by 1 w 160
the 3 w 163
democracy 1 w 172
Theramenes 2 w 183
opposed 1 w 190
him 2 w 193
saying 1 w 200
that 1 w 204
it 3 w 206
404 1 w 209
B 1 w 210
C 3 w 212
was 1 w 216
not 1 w 219
reasonable 1 w 229
to 3 w 231
put 2 w 234
a 20 w 235
man 2 w 238
to 4 w 240
death 2 w 245
because 2 w 252
he 9 w 254
was 2 w 257
honoured 1 w 265
by 2 w 267
the 4 w 270
commons 1 w 277
provided 1 w 286
he 11 w 288
was 3 w 291
doing 1 w 296
no 3 w 298
harm 1 w 302
to 5 w 304
the 5 w 307
aristocrats 1 w 318
For 1 w 322
said 1 w 327
he 13 w 329
you 1 w 333
and 3 w 336
I 1 w 337
also 1 w 341
have 1 w 345
said 2 w 349
and 4 w 352
done 1 w 356
many 2 w 360
things 1 w 366
for 2 w 369
the 6 w 372
sake 1 w 376
of 1 w 378
winning 1 w 385
the 7 w 388
favour 1 w 394
of 2 w 396
the 8 w 399
city 1 w 403
Then 1 w 408
Critias 3 w 415
for 3 w 419
he 18 w 421
still 1 w 426
treated 1 w 433
Theramenes 3 w 443
as 8 w 445
a 42 w 446
friend 2 w 452
replied 1 w 460
that 2 w 464
it 6 w 466
was 4 w 469
impossible 1 w 479
for 4 w 482
people 1 w 488
who 1 w 491
wanted 1 w 497
to 7 w 499
gain 1 w 503
power 1 w 508
not 2 w 511
to 8 w 513
put 3 w 516
out 1 w 519
of 3 w 521
the 9 w 524
way 1 w 527
those 1 w 532
who 2 w 535
were 2 w 539
best 1 w 543
able 2 w 547
to 9 w 549
thwart 1 w 555
them 1 w 559
But 1 w 563
if 1 w 565
he 22 w 568
said 3 w 572
merely 1 w 579
because 3 w 586
we 5 w 588
are 1 w 591
thirty 1 w 597
and 5 w 600
not 3 w 603
one 3 w 606
you 2 w 610
imagine 1 w 617
that 3 w 621
it 7 w 623
is 3 w 625
any 3 w 628
the 11 w 631
less 1 w 635
necessary 1 w 644
for 5 w 647
us 4 w 649
to 10 w 651
keep 1 w 655
a 58 w 656
close 1 w 661
watch 1 w 666
over 1 w 670
this 1 w 674
government 1 w 684
just 1 w 689
as 10 w 691
one 4 w 694
would 1 w 699
if 2 w 701
it 8 w 703
were 3 w 707
an 12 w 709
absolute 1 w 717
monarchy 1 w 725
you 3 w 729
are 2 w 732
foolish 1 w 739
But 2 w 743
when 2 w 747
on 9 w 750
account 1 w 757
of 4 w 759
the 12 w 762
great 1 w 767
numbers 1 w 774
continually 1 w 785
and 6 w 789
unjustly 1 w 797
put 4 w 801
to 11 w 803
death 3 w 808
it 9 w 811
was 5 w 814
evident 1 w 821
that 4 w 825
many 3 w 829
were 4 w 833
banding 1 w 840
together 1 w 848
and 8 w 851
wondering 1 w 860
what 1 w 864
the 14 w 867
state 1 w 872
was 6 w 875
coming 1 w 881
to 13 w 883
Theramenes 4 w 894
spoke 1 w 899
again 1 w 904
saying 2 w 911
that 5 w 915
unless 1 w 921
they 1 w 925
admitted 1 w 933
an 17 w 935
adequate 1 w 943
number 2 w 949
of 5 w 951
citizens 1 w 959
into 1 w 963
partnership 1 w 974
with 1 w 978
them 2 w 982
in 20 w 984
the 17 w 987
management 1 w 997
of 6 w 999
affairs 1 w 1006
it 13 w 1009
would 2 w 1014
be 9 w 1016
impossible 2 w 1026
for 6 w 1029
the 18 w 1032
oligarchy 1 w 1041
to 15 w 1043
endure 1 w 1049
Accordingly 1 w 1061
Critias 4 w 1068
and 9 w 1071
the 19 w 1074
rest 1 w 1078
of 7 w 1080
the 20 w 1083
Thirty 1 w 1089
who 3 w 1093
were 5 w 1097
by 3 w 1099
this 2 w 1103
time 1 w 1107
alarmed 1 w 1114
and 10 w 1117
feared 1 w 1123
above 1 w 1128
all 2 w 1131
that 6 w 1135
the 21 w 1138
citizens 2 w 1146
would 3 w 1151
flock 1 w 1156
to 16 w 1158
the 22 w 1161
support 1 w 1168
of 8 w 1170
Theramenes 5 w 1180
enrolled 1 w 1189
a 103 w 1190
body 1 w 1194
of 9 w 1196
three 1 w 1201
thousand 1 w 1209
who 4 w 1213
were 6 w 1217
to 17 w 1219
share 1 w 1224
as 14 w 1227
they 2 w 1231
said 4 w 1235
in 22 w 1238
the 24 w 1241
government 2 w 1251
Theramenes 6 w 1262
however 1 w 1270
objected 1 w 1279
to 18 w 1281
this 3 w 1285
move 1 w 1289
also 2 w 1293
saying 3 w 1300
that 7 w 1304
in 24 w 1307
the 25 w 1310
first 1 w 1315
place 1 w 1320
it 16 w 1323
seemed 1 w 1329
to 19 w 1331
him 3 w 1334
absurd 1 w 1340
that 8 w 1344
when 3 w 1349
they 3 w 1353
wanted 2 w 1359
to 20 w 1361
make 1 w 1365
the 27 w 1368
best 2 w 1372
of 10 w 1374
the 28 w 1377
citizens 3 w 1385
their 2 w 1390
associates 1 w 1400
they 4 w 1405
should 1 w 1411
limit 1 w 1416
themselves 1 w 1426
to 21 w 1428
three 2 w 1433
thousand 2 w 1441
as 16 w 1444
though 1 w 1450
this 4 w 1454
number 3 w 1460
must 1 w 1464
somehow 1 w 1471
be 12 w 1473
good 1 w 1477
men 10 w 1480
and 13 w 1483
true 1 w 1487
and 14 w 1490
there 1 w 1495
could 1 w 1500
neither 1 w 1507
be 13 w 1509
excellent 1 w 1518
men 11 w 1521
outside 1 w 1528
this 5 w 1532
body 2 w 1536
nor 1 w 1539
rascals 1 w 1546
within 1 w 1552
404 2 w 1555
B 4 w 1556
C 6 w 1558
it 21 w 1561
Besides 1 w 1569
he 51 w 1572
said 5 w 1576
we 11 w 1579
are 5 w 1582
undertaking 1 w 1593
in 27 w 1596
my 1 w 1598
opinion 1 w 1605
two 1 w 1609
absolutely 1 w 1619
inconsistent 1 w 1631
things 2 w 1637
to 22 w 1641
rig 1 w 1644
up 2 w 1646
our 3 w 1649
government 3 w 1659
on 14 w 1661
the 34 w 1664
basis 1 w 1669
of 11 w 1671
force 1 w 1676
and 15 w 1679
at 20 w 1681
the 35 w 1684
same 1 w 1688
time 2 w 1692
to 23 w 1694
make 2 w 1698
it 22 w 1700
weaker 1 w 1706
than 1 w 1710
its 1 w 1713
subjects 1 w 1721