Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / Against Alcibiades

Against Alcibiades (28-32)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0027.tlg004.perseus-eng2:28-32
Refs {'start': {'reference': '28', 'human_reference': 'Section 28'}, 'end': {'reference': '32', 'human_reference': 'Section 32'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Indeed, so different is he from the Spartans that whereas the Spartans accept defeat even at the hands of their allies, when they compete against them, Alcibiades will not endure it even at the hands of his fellow-citizens; in fact, he has openly stated that he will brook no rivals. It is inevitable that such behaviour should cause the states within our confederacy to feel sympathy for our enemies and loathing for us.

In order to make it clear, however, that he was insulting Athens as a whole in addition to Diomedes, he asked the leaders of the Athenian deputation to lend him the processional vessels, alleging that he intended to use them for a celebration of his victory on the day before the sacrifice; he then abused the trust placed in him and refused to return them, as he wanted to use the golden basins and censers next day before Athens did so. Naturally, when those strangers who did not know that they belonged to us saw the state-procession taking place after that of Alcibiades, they imagined that we were using his vessels: while those who had either heard the truth from the Athenians present or else knew the ways of Alcibiades, laughed at us when they saw one man showing himself superior to our entire community.

Then again, look at the arrangements which he made for his stay at Olympia as a whole. For Alcibiades the people of Ephesus erected a Persian pavilion twice as large as that of our official deputation: Chios furnished him with beasts for sacrifice and with fodder for his horses: while he requisitioned wine and everything else necessary for his maintenance from Lesbos. And so lucky is he that although the Greek people at large can testify to his lawlessness and corruption, he has gone unpunished. While those who hold office within a single city have to render account of that office,

Alcibiades, whose authority extends over all our allies and who receives monies from them, is not liable to answer for any of his public acts; on the contrary, after behaving as I have described, he was rewarded with free entertainment in the Prytaneum[*]; and not content with that, he is for ever taking credit for his victory, as though he had not so much brought Athens into disgrace as won her a garland of honour. Only reflect, and you will find that men who have given way even temporarily to any single one of the excesses in which Alcibiades has indulged time and again, have brought ruin upon their houses; yet Alcibiades, whose entire life is devoted to extravagance, has doubled his wealth.

You regard as misers those who are niggardly and close-fisted; but you are mistaken. It is the spendthrift, with his endless wants, who stoops lowest to fill his pockets. In fact, it will be a public disgrace, if you show tolerance towards a man who has achieved his success only with the help of your money, when in ostracizing Callias, son of Didymius, who won victories at all the great games by his personal prowess, you took no account whatsoever of his achievement, although it was by his own efforts that he brought glory to Athens.

Tokens

Indeed 1 w 6
so 1 w 9
different 1 w 18
is 1 w 20
he 1 w 22
from 1 w 26
the 1 w 29
Spartans 1 w 37
that 1 w 41
whereas 1 w 48
the 2 w 51
Spartans 2 w 59
accept 1 w 65
defeat 1 w 71
even 1 w 75
at 3 w 77
the 3 w 80
hands 1 w 85
of 1 w 87
their 1 w 92
allies 1 w 98
when 1 w 103
they 1 w 107
compete 1 w 114
against 1 w 121
them 1 w 125
Alcibiades 1 w 136
will 1 w 140
not 1 w 143
endure 1 w 149
it 1 w 151
even 2 w 155
at 4 w 157
the 7 w 160
hands 2 w 165
of 2 w 167
his 1 w 170
fellow-citizens 1 w 185
in 2 w 188
fact 1 w 192
he 11 w 195
has 1 w 198
openly 1 w 204
stated 1 w 210
that 2 w 214
he 12 w 216
will 2 w 220
brook 1 w 225
no 2 w 227
rivals 1 w 233
It 1 w 236
is 3 w 238
inevitable 1 w 248
that 3 w 252
such 1 w 256
behaviour 1 w 265
should 1 w 271
cause 1 w 276
the 8 w 279
states 1 w 285
within 1 w 291
our 2 w 294
confederacy 1 w 305
to 1 w 307
feel 1 w 311
sympathy 1 w 319
for 1 w 322
our 3 w 325
enemies 1 w 332
and 3 w 335
loathing 1 w 343
for 2 w 346
us 2 w 348
In 2 w 351
order 1 w 356
to 2 w 358
make 1 w 362
it 5 w 364
clear 1 w 369
however 1 w 377
that 4 w 382
he 14 w 384
was 1 w 387
insulting 1 w 396
Athens 1 w 402
as 4 w 404
a 36 w 405
whole 1 w 410
in 8 w 412
addition 1 w 420
to 3 w 422
Diomedes 1 w 430
he 16 w 433
asked 1 w 438
the 10 w 441
leaders 1 w 448
of 3 w 450
the 11 w 453
Athenian 1 w 461
deputation 1 w 471
to 4 w 473
lend 1 w 477
him 1 w 480
the 13 w 483
processional 1 w 495
vessels 1 w 502
alleging 1 w 511
that 5 w 515
he 21 w 517
intended 1 w 525
to 5 w 527
use 2 w 530
them 2 w 534
for 3 w 537
a 45 w 538
celebration 1 w 549
of 4 w 551
his 2 w 554
victory 1 w 561
on 6 w 563
the 15 w 566
day 1 w 569
before 1 w 575
the 16 w 578
sacrifice 1 w 587
he 25 w 590
then 3 w 594
abused 1 w 600
the 18 w 603
trust 1 w 608
placed 1 w 614
in 11 w 616
him 2 w 619
and 4 w 622
refused 1 w 629
to 7 w 631
return 1 w 637
them 3 w 641
as 6 w 644
he 29 w 646
wanted 1 w 652
to 8 w 654
use 5 w 657
the 20 w 660
golden 1 w 666
basins 1 w 672
and 5 w 675
censers 1 w 682
next 1 w 686
day 2 w 689
before 2 w 695
Athens 2 w 701
did 1 w 704
so 2 w 706
Naturally 1 w 716
when 2 w 721
those 1 w 726
strangers 1 w 735
who 2 w 738
did 2 w 741
not 2 w 744
know 1 w 748
that 6 w 752
they 2 w 756
belonged 1 w 764
to 9 w 766
us 8 w 768
saw 1 w 771
the 23 w 774
state-procession 1 w 790
taking 1 w 796
place 2 w 801
after 1 w 806
that 7 w 810
of 5 w 812
Alcibiades 2 w 822
they 3 w 827
imagined 1 w 835
that 8 w 839
we 2 w 841
were 1 w 845
using 1 w 850
his 3 w 853
vessels 2 w 860
while 1 w 866
those 2 w 871
who 3 w 874
had 1 w 877
either 1 w 883
heard 1 w 888
the 26 w 891
truth 1 w 896
from 2 w 900
the 27 w 903
Athenians 1 w 912
present 1 w 919
or 8 w 921
else 1 w 925
knew 1 w 929
the 29 w 932
ways 1 w 936
of 6 w 938
Alcibiades 3 w 948
laughed 1 w 956
at 20 w 958
us 10 w 960
when 3 w 964
they 4 w 968
saw 2 w 971
one 1 w 974
man 1 w 977
showing 1 w 984
himself 1 w 991
superior 1 w 999
to 10 w 1001
our 4 w 1004
entire 1 w 1010
community 1 w 1019
Then 1 w 1024
again 2 w 1029
look 1 w 1034
at 21 w 1036
the 31 w 1039
arrangements 1 w 1051
which 1 w 1056
he 47 w 1058
made 1 w 1062
for 6 w 1065
his 4 w 1068
stay 1 w 1072
at 22 w 1074
Olympia 1 w 1081
as 8 w 1083
a 89 w 1084
whole 2 w 1089
For 1 w 1093
Alcibiades 4 w 1103
the 32 w 1106
people 1 w 1112
of 7 w 1114
Ephesus 1 w 1121
erected 1 w 1128
a 91 w 1129
Persian 1 w 1136
pavilion 1 w 1144
twice 1 w 1149
as 9 w 1151
large 1 w 1156
as 10 w 1158
that 9 w 1162
of 8 w 1164
our 5 w 1167
official 1 w 1175
deputation 2 w 1185
Chios 1 w 1191
furnished 1 w 1200
him 4 w 1203
with 2 w 1207
beasts 1 w 1213
for 7 w 1216
sacrifice 2 w 1225
and 6 w 1228
with 3 w 1232
fodder 1 w 1238
for 8 w 1241
his 5 w 1244
horses 1 w 1250
while 2 w 1256
he 51 w 1258
requisitioned 1 w 1271
wine 1 w 1275
and 7 w 1278
everything 1 w 1288
else 2 w 1292
necessary 1 w 1301
for 9 w 1304
his 6 w 1307
maintenance 1 w 1318
from 3 w 1322
Lesbos 1 w 1328
And 1 w 1332
so 3 w 1334
lucky 1 w 1339
is 11 w 1341
he 52 w 1343
that 10 w 1347
although 1 w 1355
the 33 w 1358
Greek 1 w 1363
people 2 w 1369
at 26 w 1371
large 2 w 1376
can 1 w 1379
testify 1 w 1386
to 11 w 1388
his 7 w 1391
lawlessness 1 w 1402
and 8 w 1405
corruption 1 w 1415
he 54 w 1418
has 2 w 1421
gone 1 w 1425
unpunished 1 w 1435
While 1 w 1441
those 3 w 1446
who 5 w 1449
hold 1 w 1453
office 1 w 1459
within 2 w 1465
a 115 w 1466
single 1 w 1472
city 1 w 1476
have 1 w 1480
to 12 w 1482
render 1 w 1488
account 1 w 1495
of 11 w 1497
that 11 w 1501
office 2 w 1507
Alcibiades 5 w 1518
whose 1 w 1524
authority 1 w 1533
extends 1 w 1540
over 1 w 1544
all 4 w 1547
our 6 w 1550
allies 2 w 1556
and 9 w 1559
who 7 w 1562
receives 1 w 1570
monies 1 w 1576
from 4 w 1580
them 4 w 1584
is 14 w 1587
not 3 w 1590
liable 1 w 1596
to 13 w 1598
answer 1 w 1604
for 10 w 1607
any 1 w 1610
of 13 w 1612
his 8 w 1615
public 1 w 1621
acts 1 w 1625
on 16 w 1628
the 35 w 1631
contrary 1 w 1639
after 2 w 1645
behaving 1 w 1653
as 13 w 1655
I 4 w 1656
have 2 w 1660
described 1 w 1669
he 58 w 1672
was 2 w 1675
rewarded 1 w 1683
with 5 w 1687
free 1 w 1691
entertainment 1 w 1704
in 25 w 1706
the 36 w 1709
Prytaneum 1 w 1718
σίτησις 1 w 1725
ἐν 1 w 1727
Πρυτανείῳ 1 w 1736
was 3 w 1739
the 37 w 1742
usual 1 w 1747
reward 2 w 1753
for 11 w 1756
a 140 w 1757
victory 2 w 1764
at 28 w 1766
the 38 w 1769
games 1 w 1774
or 21 w 1776
signal 1 w 1782
service 1 w 1789
to 15 w 1791
the 39 w 1794
state 4 w 1799
The 2 w 1803
same 1 w 1807
privilege 1 w 1816
was 4 w 1819
granted 1 w 1826
Diocleides 1 w 1836
in 26 w 1838
415 1 w 1841
after 3 w 1847
his 9 w 1850
information 1 w 1861
in 28 w 1863
the 40 w 1866
matter 1 w 1872
of 14 w 1874
the 41 w 1877
Hermae 1 w 1883
Cf 1 w 1886
Andoc 1 w 1892
1 2 w 1894
45 1 w 1897
and 10 w 1902
not 4 w 1905
content 1 w 1912
with 6 w 1916
that 12 w 1920
he 66 w 1923
is 17 w 1925
for 13 w 1928
ever 3 w 1932
taking 2 w 1938
credit 1 w 1944
for 14 w 1947
his 10 w 1950
victory 3 w 1957
as 17 w 1960
though 2 w 1966
he 67 w 1968
had 2 w 1971
not 5 w 1974
so 4 w 1976
much 1 w 1980
brought 1 w 1987
Athens 3 w 1993
into 1 w 1997
disgrace 1 w 2005
as 18 w 2007
won 1 w 2010
her 3 w 2013
a 159 w 2014
garland 1 w 2021
of 15 w 2023
honour 1 w 2029
Only 1 w 2034
reflect 1 w 2041
and 12 w 2045
you 1 w 2048
will 3 w 2052
find 1 w 2056
that 13 w 2060
men 3 w 2063
who 8 w 2066
have 3 w 2070
given 1 w 2075
way 2 w 2078
even 3 w 2082
temporarily 1 w 2093
to 18 w 2095
any 2 w 2098
single 2 w 2104
one 4 w 2107
of 16 w 2109
the 43 w 2112
excesses 1 w 2120
in 33 w 2122
which 2 w 2127
Alcibiades 6 w 2137
has 3 w 2140
indulged 1 w 2148
time 1 w 2152
and 13 w 2155
again 3 w 2160
have 4 w 2165
brought 2 w 2172
ruin 1 w 2176
upon 1 w 2180
their 2 w 2185
houses 1 w 2191
yet 1 w 2195
Alcibiades 7 w 2205
whose 2 w 2211
entire 2 w 2217
life 1 w 2221
is 20 w 2223
devoted 1 w 2230
to 19 w 2232
extravagance 1 w 2244
has 4 w 2248
doubled 1 w 2255
his 11 w 2258
wealth 1 w 2264
You 1 w 2268
regard 1 w 2274
as 21 w 2276
misers 1 w 2282
those 4 w 2287
who 10 w 2290
are 1 w 2293
niggardly 1 w 2302
and 14 w 2305
close-fisted 1 w 2317
but 1 w 2321
you 2 w 2324
are 2 w 2327
mistaken 1 w 2335
It 2 w 2338
is 25 w 2340
the 45 w 2343
spendthrift 1 w 2354
with 7 w 2359
his 12 w 2362
endless 1 w 2369
wants 1 w 2374
who 11 w 2378
stoops 1 w 2384
lowest 1 w 2390
to 21 w 2392
fill 1 w 2396
his 13 w 2399
pockets 1 w 2406
In 3 w 2409
fact 2 w 2413
it 19 w 2416
will 4 w 2420
be 8 w 2422
a 189 w 2423
public 2 w 2429
disgrace 2 w 2437
if 7 w 2440
you 3 w 2443
show 2 w 2447
tolerance 1 w 2456
towards 1 w 2463
a 193 w 2464
man 2 w 2467
who 12 w 2470
has 5 w 2473
achieved 1 w 2481
his 14 w 2484
success 1 w 2491
only 1 w 2495
with 8 w 2499
the 46 w 2502
help 1 w 2506
of 17 w 2508
your 1 w 2512
money 1 w 2517
when 4 w 2522
in 37 w 2524
ostracizing 1 w 2535
Callias 1 w 2542
son 1 w 2546
of 18 w 2548
Didymius 1 w 2556
who 13 w 2560
won 2 w 2563
victories 1 w 2572
at 34 w 2574
all 7 w 2577
the 47 w 2580
great 1 w 2585
games 2 w 2590
by 1 w 2592
his 15 w 2595
personal 1 w 2603
prowess 1 w 2610
you 5 w 2614
took 1 w 2618
no 9 w 2620
account 2 w 2627
whatsoever 1 w 2637
of 19 w 2639
his 16 w 2642
achievement 1 w 2653
although 2 w 2662
it 21 w 2664
was 5 w 2667
by 2 w 2669
his 17 w 2672
own 1 w 2675
efforts 1 w 2682
that 14 w 2686
he 77 w 2688
brought 3 w 2695
glory 1 w 2700
to 26 w 2702
Athens 4 w 2708