Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Incorruptibility of the World

On the Incorruptibility of the World (56-60)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg029.1st1K-eng1:56-60
Refs {'start': {'reference': '56', 'human_reference': 'Section 56'}, 'end': {'reference': '60', 'human_reference': 'Section 60'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

But I must now proceed to examine the argument which I postponed just now, if indeed things that are so evident stand in need of any demonstration; but, indeed, proofs are necessary on account of the inventors of fables who, filling all life with their falsehoods, have utterly driven truth out of the land, and have not merely banished it from cities and houses, but have even deprived each separate individual of that most valuable possession, and, for the purpose of alluring his sight, have invented metres and rhythm as a bait and a snare, by which they cajole the ears of fools, just as ugly and shapeless courtesans allure the eyes by necklaces and spurious ornaments in the absence of all genuine beauty,

for they say that the generation of mankind by means of one another is a more recent work of nature, but that the more original and ancient mode of their birth is out of the earth, since she both is and is considered the mother of all men. And they say that those men who are celebrated among the Greeks as having sprung from seed were produced and grew up as trees do now, being perfect and completely armed sons of the earth.

But that this is a mere fiction of fable it is easy to see from many circumstances. For the very moment that the first man was born there was a necessity for his receiving growth in accordance with the previously defined measures and numbers of time, for nature has arranged the different ages as certain steps along which man in a manner ascends and descends; he ascends while he is growing, and he descends at the period when he is lessening; and the boundary of the uppermost steps is the prime of life at which when a man has arrived he no longer makes any further advance; but as runners who run the diaulos turn back again upon the same path which they have already travelled, so too does man retrace his steps, giving back in the weakness of old age what he has received from vigorous youth;

but to fancy that any one has ever been born absolutely perfect is the part of those who are ignorant of the laws of nature, which are unchangeable ordinances. For our minds, being vitiated by the contagion of the mortal body which is united to them, are very naturally liable to changes and alterations, but the works of the nature of the universe are unalterable, since she has dominion over all

v.4.p.29
things, and by means of the stability of whatever desires she has once established she preserves the definitions which have been originally fixed in an unchangeable state.

If then she had originally thought it proper that men should be born perfect, now also man would still be born in a perfect state, without ever being an infant, or a boy, or a youth, but he would at once be a man, and perhaps he would be altogether exempt from old age and from death, for that thing which has no increase must also of necessity be exempt from all diminution, for up to the prime of a mans life all his changes tend towards increase, but from that period up to old age and death they exist with a gradual diminution; and it is natural to suppose that he who has no share in the former must also be free from the subsequent changes.

But 1 w 3
I 1 w 4
must 1 w 8
now 1 w 11
proceed 1 w 18
to 1 w 20
examine 1 w 27
the 1 w 30
argument 1 w 38
which 1 w 43
I 2 w 44
postponed 1 w 53
just 1 w 57
now 2 w 60
if 1 w 63
indeed 1 w 69
things 1 w 75
that 1 w 79
are 1 w 82
so 1 w 84
evident 1 w 91
stand 1 w 96
in 4 w 98
need 1 w 102
of 1 w 104
any 1 w 107
demonstration 1 w 120
but 1 w 124
indeed 2 w 131
proofs 1 w 138
are 2 w 141
necessary 1 w 150
on 4 w 152
account 1 w 159
of 3 w 161
the 2 w 164
inventors 1 w 173
of 4 w 175
fables 1 w 181
who 1 w 184
filling 1 w 192
all 1 w 195
life 1 w 199
with 1 w 203
their 1 w 208
falsehoods 1 w 218
have 1 w 223
utterly 1 w 230
driven 1 w 236
truth 1 w 241
out 1 w 244
of 5 w 246
the 4 w 249
land 1 w 253
and 3 w 257
have 2 w 261
not 1 w 264
merely 1 w 270
banished 1 w 278
it 2 w 280
from 1 w 284
cities 1 w 290
and 4 w 293
houses 1 w 299
but 2 w 303
have 3 w 307
even 1 w 311
deprived 1 w 319
each 1 w 323
separate 1 w 331
individual 1 w 341
of 6 w 343
that 2 w 347
most 1 w 351
valuable 1 w 359
possession 1 w 369
and 5 w 373
for 1 w 377
the 5 w 380
purpose 1 w 387
of 7 w 389
alluring 1 w 397
his 1 w 400
sight 1 w 405
have 4 w 410
invented 1 w 418
metres 1 w 424
and 6 w 427
rhythm 1 w 433
as 1 w 435
a 33 w 436
bait 1 w 440
and 7 w 443
a 36 w 444
snare 1 w 449
by 1 w 452
which 2 w 457
they 1 w 461
cajole 1 w 467
the 7 w 470
ears 1 w 474
of 8 w 476
fools 1 w 481
just 2 w 486
as 2 w 488
ugly 1 w 492
and 8 w 495
shapeless 1 w 504
courtesans 1 w 514
allure 1 w 520
the 8 w 523
eyes 1 w 527
by 2 w 529
necklaces 1 w 538
and 9 w 541
spurious 1 w 549
ornaments 1 w 558
in 11 w 560
the 9 w 563
absence 1 w 570
of 9 w 572
all 4 w 575
genuine 1 w 582
beauty 1 w 588
for 2 w 592
they 2 w 596
say 1 w 599
that 3 w 603
the 11 w 606
generation 1 w 616
of 10 w 618
mankind 1 w 625
by 3 w 627
means 1 w 632
of 11 w 634
one 2 w 637
another 1 w 644
is 3 w 646
a 57 w 647
more 1 w 651
recent 1 w 657
work 1 w 661
of 12 w 663
nature 1 w 669
but 3 w 673
that 4 w 677
the 13 w 680
more 2 w 684
original 1 w 692
and 10 w 695
ancient 1 w 702
mode 1 w 706
of 13 w 708
their 2 w 713
birth 1 w 718
is 4 w 720
out 2 w 723
of 14 w 725
the 15 w 728
earth 1 w 733
since 1 w 739
she 2 w 742
both 1 w 746
is 5 w 748
and 11 w 751
is 6 w 753
considered 1 w 763
the 16 w 766
mother 1 w 772
of 15 w 774
all 5 w 777
men 3 w 780
And 1 w 784
they 3 w 788
say 2 w 791
that 5 w 795
those 1 w 800
men 4 w 803
who 2 w 806
are 4 w 809
celebrated 1 w 819
among 1 w 824
the 19 w 827
Greeks 1 w 833
as 3 w 835
having 1 w 841
sprung 1 w 847
from 2 w 851
seed 1 w 855
were 1 w 859
produced 1 w 867
and 12 w 870
grew 1 w 874
up 1 w 876
as 4 w 878
trees 1 w 883
do 1 w 885
now 3 w 888
being 1 w 894
perfect 1 w 901
and 13 w 904
completely 1 w 914
armed 1 w 919
sons 1 w 923
of 16 w 925
the 20 w 928
earth 2 w 933
But 2 w 937
that 6 w 941
this 1 w 945
is 8 w 947
a 79 w 948
mere 2 w 952
fiction 1 w 959
of 17 w 961
fable 2 w 966
it 5 w 968
is 9 w 970
easy 1 w 974
to 3 w 976
see 2 w 979
from 3 w 983
many 1 w 987
circumstances 1 w 1000
For 1 w 1004
the 21 w 1007
very 1 w 1011
moment 1 w 1017
that 7 w 1021
the 22 w 1024
first 1 w 1029
man 3 w 1032
was 1 w 1035
born 1 w 1039
there 1 w 1044
was 2 w 1047
a 88 w 1048
necessity 1 w 1057
for 3 w 1060
his 3 w 1063
receiving 1 w 1072
growth 1 w 1078
in 19 w 1080
accordance 1 w 1090
with 2 w 1094
the 24 w 1097
previously 1 w 1107
defined 1 w 1114
measures 1 w 1122
and 14 w 1125
numbers 1 w 1132
of 18 w 1134
time 1 w 1138
for 4 w 1142
nature 2 w 1148
has 1 w 1151
arranged 1 w 1159
the 25 w 1162
different 1 w 1171
ages 1 w 1175
as 10 w 1177
certain 1 w 1184
steps 1 w 1189
along 1 w 1194
which 3 w 1199
man 4 w 1202
in 22 w 1204
a 102 w 1205
manner 1 w 1211
ascends 1 w 1218
and 15 w 1221
descends 1 w 1229
he 28 w 1232
ascends 2 w 1239
while 1 w 1244
he 29 w 1246
is 11 w 1248
growing 1 w 1255
and 16 w 1259
he 30 w 1261
descends 2 w 1269
at 14 w 1271
the 26 w 1274
period 1 w 1280
when 1 w 1284
he 33 w 1286
is 12 w 1288
lessening 1 w 1297
and 17 w 1301
the 27 w 1304
boundary 1 w 1312
of 19 w 1314
the 28 w 1317
uppermost 1 w 1326
steps 2 w 1331
is 13 w 1333
the 29 w 1336
prime 1 w 1341
of 20 w 1343
life 2 w 1347
at 15 w 1349
which 4 w 1354
when 2 w 1358
a 112 w 1359
man 6 w 1362
has 2 w 1365
arrived 1 w 1372
he 38 w 1374
no 6 w 1376
longer 1 w 1382
makes 1 w 1387
any 3 w 1390
further 1 w 1397
advance 1 w 1404
but 4 w 1408
as 14 w 1410
runners 1 w 1417
who 3 w 1420
run 3 w 1423
the 31 w 1426
diaulos 1 w 1433
turn 1 w 1437
back 1 w 1441
again 1 w 1446
upon 1 w 1450
the 32 w 1453
same 1 w 1457
path 1 w 1461
which 5 w 1466
they 4 w 1470
have 5 w 1474
already 1 w 1481
travelled 1 w 1490
so 3 w 1493
too 1 w 1496
does 1 w 1500
man 7 w 1503
retrace 1 w 1510
his 4 w 1513
steps 3 w 1518
giving 1 w 1525
back 2 w 1529
in 27 w 1531
the 34 w 1534
weakness 1 w 1542
of 21 w 1544
old 1 w 1547
age 2 w 1550
what 1 w 1554
he 44 w 1556
has 3 w 1559
received 1 w 1567
from 4 w 1571
vigorous 1 w 1579
youth 1 w 1584
but 5 w 1588
to 5 w 1590
fancy 1 w 1595
that 8 w 1599
any 4 w 1602
one 3 w 1605
has 4 w 1608
ever 1 w 1612
been 1 w 1616
born 2 w 1620
absolutely 1 w 1630
perfect 2 w 1637
is 15 w 1639
the 35 w 1642
part 1 w 1646
of 22 w 1648
those 2 w 1653
who 4 w 1656
are 5 w 1659
ignorant 1 w 1667
of 23 w 1669
the 36 w 1672
laws 1 w 1676
of 24 w 1678
nature 3 w 1684
which 6 w 1690
are 6 w 1693
unchangeable 1 w 1705
ordinances 1 w 1715
For 2 w 1719
our 2 w 1722
minds 1 w 1727
being 2 w 1733
vitiated 1 w 1741
by 4 w 1743
the 37 w 1746
contagion 1 w 1755
of 25 w 1757
the 38 w 1760
mortal 1 w 1766
body 1 w 1770
which 7 w 1775
is 16 w 1777
united 1 w 1783
to 6 w 1785
them 1 w 1789
are 7 w 1793
very 2 w 1797
naturally 1 w 1806
liable 1 w 1812
to 7 w 1814
changes 1 w 1821
and 18 w 1824
alterations 1 w 1835
but 6 w 1839
the 40 w 1842
works 1 w 1847
of 26 w 1849
the 41 w 1852
nature 4 w 1858
of 27 w 1860
the 42 w 1863
universe 1 w 1871
are 8 w 1874
unalterable 1 w 1885
since 2 w 1891
she 3 w 1894
has 5 w 1897
dominion 1 w 1905
over 1 w 1909
all 7 w 1912
things 2 w 1918
and 19 w 1922
by 5 w 1924
means 2 w 1929
of 28 w 1931
the 43 w 1934
stability 1 w 1943
of 29 w 1945
whatever 1 w 1953
desires 1 w 1960
she 4 w 1963
has 6 w 1966
once 1 w 1970
established 1 w 1981
she 6 w 1984
preserves 1 w 1993
the 44 w 1996
definitions 1 w 2007
which 8 w 2012
have 6 w 2016
been 2 w 2020
originally 1 w 2030
fixed 1 w 2035
in 36 w 2037
an 45 w 2039
unchangeable 2 w 2051
state 1 w 2056
If 1 w 2059
then 1 w 2063
she 7 w 2066
had 1 w 2069
originally 2 w 2079
thought 1 w 2086
it 12 w 2088
proper 1 w 2094
that 9 w 2098
men 6 w 2101
should 1 w 2107
be 7 w 2109
born 3 w 2113
perfect 3 w 2120
now 4 w 2124
also 1 w 2128
man 8 w 2131
would 1 w 2136
still 1 w 2141
be 8 w 2143
born 4 w 2147
in 38 w 2149
a 186 w 2150
perfect 4 w 2157
state 2 w 2162
without 1 w 2170
ever 3 w 2174
being 3 w 2179
an 48 w 2181
infant 1 w 2187
or 25 w 2190
a 190 w 2191
boy 1 w 2194
or 26 w 2197
a 191 w 2198
youth 2 w 2203
but 7 w 2207
he 61 w 2209
would 2 w 2214
at 28 w 2216
once 2 w 2220
be 10 w 2222
a 193 w 2223
man 9 w 2226
and 20 w 2230
perhaps 1 w 2237
he 62 w 2239
would 3 w 2244
be 11 w 2246
altogether 1 w 2256
exempt 1 w 2262
from 5 w 2266
old 2 w 2269
age 3 w 2272
and 21 w 2275
from 6 w 2279
death 1 w 2284
for 5 w 2288
that 10 w 2292
thing 3 w 2297
which 9 w 2302
has 7 w 2305
no 9 w 2307
increase 1 w 2315
must 2 w 2319
also 2 w 2323
of 30 w 2325
necessity 2 w 2334
be 12 w 2336
exempt 2 w 2342
from 7 w 2346
all 10 w 2349
diminution 1 w 2359
for 6 w 2363
up 4 w 2365
to 9 w 2367
the 47 w 2370
prime 2 w 2375
of 31 w 2377
a 206 w 2378
man 10 w 2381
s 159 w 2383
life 3 w 2387
all 11 w 2390
his 5 w 2393
changes 2 w 2400
tend 1 w 2404
towards 1 w 2411
increase 2 w 2419
but 8 w 2423
from 8 w 2427
that 11 w 2431
period 2 w 2437
up 5 w 2439
to 11 w 2441
old 3 w 2444
age 4 w 2447
and 22 w 2450
death 2 w 2455
they 5 w 2459
exist 1 w 2464
with 4 w 2468
a 216 w 2469
gradual 1 w 2476
diminution 2 w 2486
and 23 w 2490
it 16 w 2492
is 20 w 2494
natural 2 w 2501
to 12 w 2503
suppose 1 w 2510
that 12 w 2514
he 66 w 2516
who 5 w 2519
has 8 w 2522
no 10 w 2524
share 1 w 2529
in 46 w 2531
the 49 w 2534
former 1 w 2540
must 3 w 2544
also 3 w 2548
be 13 w 2550
free 1 w 2554
from 9 w 2558
the 50 w 2561
subsequent 1 w 2571
changes 3 w 2578