Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Incorruptibility of the World

On the Incorruptibility of the World (46-50)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg029.1st1K-eng1:46-50
Refs {'start': {'reference': '46', 'human_reference': 'Section 46'}, 'end': {'reference': '50', 'human_reference': 'Section 50'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Therefore, on the same principle, if the heaven is destroyed, the sun and moon will also be destroyed, and all the other planets likewise will be destroyed, and all the fixed stars, and all that host of gods visible to the outward senses which was formerly considered so happy; and to imagine this is nothing else than to fancy the gods themselves in a process of destruction, for this is equivalent to considering men immortal. And yet in a comparison between different objects devoid of honour, if you were to consider the matter, you would find it more consistent with probability to look on men as immortal than to believe that the gods are perishable, since it might happen through the grace of God, for it is not improbable that a mortal might receive immortality, but it is impossible for gods to lose their immortality even if the sophistries of mankind should run on to ever such a degree of wicked insanity.

And, moreover, those persons who allege conflagrations and regenerations of the world, think and confess that the stars are gods, which nevertheless they are not ashamed to destroy as far as their arguments go; for they are bound to prove them to be either red hot pieces of iron, as some do affirm, who argue about the whole of the heaven as if it were a prison,

v.4.p.40
talking utter nonsense, or else to look upon them as divine and godlike natures, and then to attribute to them that immortality which belongs to gods. But as it is, they have wandered so far from true doctrine, that without being aware of it they have attributed corruptibility and perishableness to providence (and that is the soul of the world) by the inconsistent principles which they advocate.

Therefore Chrysippus, the most celebrated philosopher of that sect, in his treatise about Increase, utters some such prodigious assertions as these, and after he has prefaced his doctrines with the assertion that it is impossible for two makers of a species to exist in the same substance, he proceeds, "Let it be granted for the sake of argument and speculation that there is one person entire and sound, and another wanting one foot from his birth, and that the sound man is called Dion and the cripple Theon, and afterwards that Dion also loses one of his feet, then if the question were asked which had been spoiled, it would be more natural to say this of Theon;" but this is the assertion of one who delights in paradox rather than in truth,

for how could it be said that he who had suffered no mutilation whatever, namely Theon, was taken off, and that Dion, who had lost a foot, was not injured? Very appropriately, he will reply, for Dion, who had had his foot cut off, falls back upon the original imperfection of Theon, and there cannot be two specific differences in the same subject, therefore it follows of necessity that Dion must remain, and that Theon must be taken off

"So are we slain by arrows winged With our own feathers,"
[*] as the tragic poet says. For any one, copying the form of this argument and adapting it to the entire world, may prove in the clearest manner that providence itself is liable to corruption.

Consider the matter thus: let the world be the subject of our argument, as Dion was just now, for it is perfect, and let the soul of the world take the place of Theon, who was [*]

v.4.p.41
imperfect, since a part is less than the whole; and as the foot was cut off from Dion, so also let everything which resembles a body be cut off from the world;

Therefore 1 w 9
on 1 w 12
the 1 w 15
same 1 w 19
principle 1 w 28
if 1 w 31
the 2 w 34
heaven 1 w 40
is 1 w 42
destroyed 1 w 51
the 3 w 55
sun 1 w 58
and 1 w 61
moon 1 w 65
will 1 w 69
also 1 w 73
be 1 w 75
destroyed 2 w 84
and 2 w 88
all 1 w 91
the 4 w 94
other 1 w 99
planets 1 w 106
likewise 1 w 114
will 2 w 118
be 2 w 120
destroyed 3 w 129
and 3 w 133
all 2 w 136
the 6 w 139
fixed 1 w 144
stars 1 w 149
and 4 w 153
all 3 w 156
that 1 w 160
host 1 w 164
of 1 w 166
gods 1 w 170
visible 1 w 177
to 1 w 179
the 7 w 182
outward 1 w 189
senses 1 w 195
which 1 w 200
was 1 w 203
formerly 1 w 211
considered 1 w 221
so 2 w 223
happy 1 w 228
and 5 w 232
to 2 w 234
imagine 1 w 241
this 1 w 245
is 5 w 247
nothing 1 w 254
else 1 w 258
than 1 w 262
to 3 w 264
fancy 1 w 269
the 8 w 272
gods 2 w 276
themselves 1 w 286
in 4 w 288
a 21 w 289
process 1 w 296
of 2 w 298
destruction 1 w 309
for 3 w 313
this 2 w 317
is 7 w 319
equivalent 1 w 329
to 4 w 331
considering 1 w 342
men 1 w 345
immortal 1 w 353
And 1 w 357
yet 1 w 360
in 6 w 362
a 24 w 363
comparison 1 w 373
between 1 w 380
different 1 w 389
objects 1 w 396
devoid 1 w 402
of 3 w 404
honour 1 w 410
if 3 w 413
you 1 w 416
were 1 w 420
to 5 w 422
consider 3 w 430
the 10 w 433
matter 1 w 439
you 2 w 443
would 1 w 448
find 1 w 452
it 1 w 454
more 1 w 458
consistent 1 w 468
with 1 w 472
probability 1 w 483
to 6 w 485
look 1 w 489
on 10 w 491
men 2 w 494
as 2 w 496
immortal 2 w 504
than 2 w 508
to 7 w 510
believe 1 w 517
that 2 w 521
the 11 w 524
gods 3 w 528
are 1 w 531
perishable 1 w 541
since 1 w 547
it 4 w 549
might 1 w 554
happen 1 w 560
through 1 w 567
the 12 w 570
grace 1 w 575
of 4 w 577
God 1 w 580
for 4 w 584
it 5 w 586
is 11 w 588
not 2 w 591
improbable 1 w 601
that 3 w 605
a 38 w 606
mortal 3 w 612
might 2 w 617
receive 1 w 624
immortality 1 w 635
but 1 w 639
it 7 w 641
is 12 w 643
impossible 1 w 653
for 5 w 656
gods 4 w 660
to 8 w 662
lose 1 w 666
their 1 w 671
immortality 2 w 682
even 1 w 686
if 4 w 688
the 14 w 691
sophistries 1 w 702
of 5 w 704
mankind 1 w 711
should 1 w 717
run 1 w 720
on 11 w 722
to 9 w 724
ever 1 w 728
such 1 w 732
a 43 w 733
degree 1 w 739
of 6 w 741
wicked 1 w 747
insanity 1 w 755
And 2 w 759
moreover 1 w 768
those 1 w 774
persons 1 w 781
who 1 w 784
allege 1 w 790
conflagrations 1 w 804
and 6 w 807
regenerations 1 w 820
of 7 w 822
the 15 w 825
world 1 w 830
think 1 w 836
and 7 w 839
confess 1 w 846
that 4 w 850
the 16 w 853
stars 2 w 858
are 2 w 861
gods 5 w 865
which 2 w 871
nevertheless 1 w 883
they 1 w 887
are 3 w 890
not 3 w 893
ashamed 1 w 900
to 10 w 902
destroy 4 w 909
as 4 w 911
far 1 w 914
as 5 w 916
their 2 w 921
arguments 1 w 930
go 6 w 932
for 6 w 936
they 2 w 940
are 4 w 943
bound 1 w 948
to 11 w 950
prove 1 w 955
them 2 w 959
to 12 w 961
be 5 w 963
either 1 w 969
red 2 w 972
hot 1 w 975
pieces 1 w 981
of 8 w 983
iron 1 w 987
as 6 w 990
some 1 w 994
do 1 w 996
affirm 1 w 1002
who 2 w 1006
argue 1 w 1011
about 1 w 1016
the 23 w 1019
whole 1 w 1024
of 9 w 1026
the 24 w 1029
heaven 2 w 1035
as 7 w 1037
if 5 w 1039
it 11 w 1041
were 2 w 1045
a 68 w 1046
prison 1 w 1052
talking 1 w 1060
utter 1 w 1065
nonsense 1 w 1073
or 15 w 1076
else 2 w 1080
to 13 w 1082
look 2 w 1086
upon 1 w 1090
them 3 w 1094
as 8 w 1096
divine 1 w 1102
and 8 w 1105
godlike 1 w 1112
natures 1 w 1119
and 9 w 1123
then 1 w 1127
to 14 w 1129
attribute 1 w 1138
to 15 w 1140
them 4 w 1144
that 5 w 1148
immortality 3 w 1159
which 3 w 1164
belongs 1 w 1171
to 16 w 1173
gods 6 w 1177
But 1 w 1181
as 9 w 1183
it 13 w 1185
is 15 w 1187
they 3 w 1192
have 1 w 1196
wandered 1 w 1204
so 8 w 1206
far 2 w 1209
from 1 w 1213
true 1 w 1217
doctrine 1 w 1225
that 6 w 1230
without 1 w 1237
being 1 w 1242
aware 1 w 1247
of 10 w 1249
it 15 w 1251
they 4 w 1255
have 2 w 1259
attributed 1 w 1269
corruptibility 1 w 1283
and 11 w 1286
perishableness 1 w 1300
to 17 w 1302
providence 1 w 1312
and 12 w 1316
that 7 w 1320
is 17 w 1322
the 30 w 1325
soul 1 w 1329
of 11 w 1331
the 31 w 1334
world 2 w 1339
by 1 w 1342
the 32 w 1345
inconsistent 1 w 1357
principles 1 w 1367
which 4 w 1372
they 5 w 1376
advocate 1 w 1384
Therefore 2 w 1394
Chrysippus 1 w 1404
the 34 w 1408
most 1 w 1412
celebrated 1 w 1422
philosopher 1 w 1433
of 12 w 1435
that 8 w 1439
sect 1 w 1443
in 18 w 1446
his 4 w 1449
treatise 1 w 1457
about 2 w 1462
Increase 1 w 1470
utters 1 w 1477
some 2 w 1481
such 2 w 1485
prodigious 1 w 1495
assertions 1 w 1505
as 12 w 1507
these 1 w 1512
and 13 w 1516
after 1 w 1521
he 41 w 1523
has 1 w 1526
prefaced 1 w 1534
his 5 w 1537
doctrines 1 w 1546
with 3 w 1550
the 36 w 1553
assertion 2 w 1562
that 9 w 1566
it 18 w 1568
is 22 w 1570
impossible 2 w 1580
for 8 w 1583
two 1 w 1586
makers 1 w 1592
of 13 w 1594
a 106 w 1595
species 1 w 1602
to 18 w 1604
exist 1 w 1609
in 20 w 1611
the 37 w 1614
same 2 w 1618
substance 1 w 1627
he 44 w 1630
proceeds 1 w 1638
Let 1 w 1643
it 19 w 1645
be 8 w 1647
granted 1 w 1654
for 9 w 1657
the 38 w 1660
sake 1 w 1664
of 14 w 1666
argument 2 w 1674
and 14 w 1677
speculation 1 w 1688
that 10 w 1692
there 1 w 1697
is 24 w 1699
one 1 w 1702
person 2 w 1708
entire 1 w 1714
and 15 w 1717
sound 1 w 1722
and 16 w 1726
another 1 w 1733
wanting 1 w 1740
one 2 w 1743
foot 1 w 1747
from 2 w 1751
his 6 w 1754
birth 1 w 1759
and 17 w 1763
that 11 w 1767
the 41 w 1770
sound 2 w 1775
man 2 w 1778
is 26 w 1780
called 1 w 1786
Dion 1 w 1790
and 18 w 1793
the 42 w 1796
cripple 1 w 1803
Theon 1 w 1808
and 19 w 1812
afterwards 1 w 1822
that 12 w 1826
Dion 2 w 1830
also 2 w 1834
loses 1 w 1839
one 3 w 1842
of 15 w 1844
his 7 w 1847
feet 1 w 1851
then 2 w 1856
if 6 w 1858
the 44 w 1861
question 1 w 1869
were 3 w 1873
asked 1 w 1878
which 5 w 1883
had 1 w 1886
been 1 w 1890
spoiled 1 w 1897
it 20 w 1900
would 2 w 1905
be 10 w 1907
more 3 w 1911
natural 1 w 1918
to 19 w 1920
say 1 w 1923
this 3 w 1927
of 16 w 1929
Theon 2 w 1934
but 4 w 1939
this 4 w 1943
is 30 w 1945
the 45 w 1948
assertion 3 w 1957
of 17 w 1959
one 4 w 1962
who 4 w 1965
delights 1 w 1973
in 22 w 1975
paradox 1 w 1982
rather 1 w 1988
than 3 w 1992
in 23 w 1994
truth 1 w 1999
for 10 w 2003
how 1 w 2006
could 1 w 2011
it 21 w 2013
be 11 w 2015
said 1 w 2019
that 13 w 2023
he 56 w 2025
who 5 w 2028
had 2 w 2031
suffered 1 w 2039
no 7 w 2041
mutilation 1 w 2051
whatever 1 w 2059
namely 1 w 2066
Theon 3 w 2071
was 2 w 2075
taken 1 w 2080
off 1 w 2083
and 20 w 2087
that 14 w 2091
Dion 3 w 2095
who 6 w 2099
had 3 w 2102
lost 1 w 2106
a 150 w 2107
foot 2 w 2111
was 3 w 2115
not 5 w 2118
injured 1 w 2125
Very 1 w 2130
appropriately 1 w 2143
he 58 w 2146
will 3 w 2150
reply 1 w 2155
for 11 w 2159
Dion 4 w 2163
who 7 w 2167
had 4 w 2170
had 5 w 2173
his 10 w 2176
foot 3 w 2180
cut 1 w 2183
off 2 w 2186
falls 1 w 2192
back 1 w 2196
upon 2 w 2200
the 47 w 2203
original 1 w 2211
imperfection 1 w 2223
of 20 w 2225
Theon 4 w 2230
and 21 w 2234
there 2 w 2239
cannot 1 w 2245
be 12 w 2247
two 2 w 2250
specific 1 w 2258
differences 1 w 2269
in 26 w 2271
the 49 w 2274
same 3 w 2278
subject 1 w 2285
therefore 1 w 2295
it 22 w 2297
follows 1 w 2304
of 21 w 2306
necessity 1 w 2315
that 15 w 2319
Dion 5 w 2323
must 1 w 2327
remain 1 w 2333
and 22 w 2337
that 16 w 2341
Theon 5 w 2346
must 2 w 2350
be 13 w 2352
taken 2 w 2357
off 3 w 2360
So 1 w 2364
are 6 w 2367
we 5 w 2369
slain 1 w 2374
by 2 w 2376
arrows 1 w 2382
winged 1 w 2388
With 1 w 2392
our 2 w 2395
own 1 w 2398
feathers 1 w 2406
From 1 w 2412
the 52 w 2415
Myrmidons 1 w 2424
of 23 w 2426
AEschylus 1 w 2435
The 8 w 2439
passage 1 w 2446
is 32 w 2448
evidently 1 w 2457
the 53 w 2460
original 2 w 2468
of 24 w 2470
the 54 w 2473
stanza 1 w 2479
in 31 w 2481
Waller 1 w 2487
s 176 w 2489
Ode 1 w 2492
to 20 w 2494
a 177 w 2495
Lady 1 w 2499
That 1 w 2504
eagle 1 w 2509
s 177 w 2511
fate 1 w 2515
and 23 w 2518
mine 1 w 2522
are 7 w 2525
one 5 w 2528
Who 1 w 2532
on 48 w 2534
the 55 w 2537
shaft 1 w 2542
that 17 w 2546
made 1 w 2550
him 1 w 2553
die 1 w 2556
Espied 1 w 2563
a 187 w 2564
feather 2 w 2571
of 25 w 2573
his 11 w 2576
own 2 w 2579
Wherewith 1 w 2589
he 73 w 2591
wont 1 w 2595
to 21 w 2597
soar 1 w 2601
so 17 w 2603
high 1 w 2607
as 20 w 2611
the 57 w 2614
tragic 1 w 2620
poet 1 w 2624
says 1 w 2628
For 1 w 2632
any 1 w 2635
one 6 w 2638
copying 1 w 2646
the 58 w 2649
form 2 w 2653
of 26 w 2655
this 5 w 2659
argument 3 w 2667
and 24 w 2670
adapting 1 w 2678
it 26 w 2680
to 22 w 2682
the 59 w 2685
entire 2 w 2691
world 3 w 2696
may 1 w 2700
prove 2 w 2705
in 35 w 2707
the 60 w 2710
clearest 1 w 2718
manner 1 w 2724
that 18 w 2728
providence 2 w 2738
itself 1 w 2744
is 35 w 2746
liable 1 w 2752
to 23 w 2754
corruption 1 w 2764
Consider 1 w 2773
the 61 w 2776
matter 2 w 2782
thus 1 w 2786
let 1 w 2790
the 62 w 2793
world 4 w 2798
be 14 w 2800
the 63 w 2803
subject 2 w 2810
of 27 w 2812
our 3 w 2815
argument 4 w 2823
as 21 w 2826
Dion 6 w 2830
was 4 w 2833
just 1 w 2837
now 1 w 2840
for 14 w 2844
it 28 w 2846
is 36 w 2848
perfect 2 w 2855
and 25 w 2859
let 2 w 2862
the 64 w 2865
soul 2 w 2869
of 28 w 2871
the 65 w 2874
world 5 w 2879
take 3 w 2883
the 66 w 2886
place 1 w 2891
of 29 w 2893
Theon 6 w 2898
who 8 w 2902
was 5 w 2905
From 2 w 2909
the 67 w 2912
Myrmidons 2 w 2921
of 30 w 2923
AEschylus 2 w 2932
The 10 w 2936
passage 2 w 2943
is 37 w 2945
evidently 2 w 2954
the 68 w 2957
original 3 w 2965
of 31 w 2967
the 69 w 2970
stanza 2 w 2976
in 37 w 2978
Waller 2 w 2984
s 206 w 2986
Ode 2 w 2989
to 24 w 2991
a 217 w 2992
Lady 2 w 2996
That 2 w 3001
eagle 2 w 3006
s 207 w 3008
fate 2 w 3012
and 26 w 3015
mine 2 w 3019
are 9 w 3022
one 7 w 3025
Who 2 w 3029
on 57 w 3031
the 70 w 3034
shaft 2 w 3039
that 19 w 3043
made 2 w 3047
him 2 w 3050
die 2 w 3053
Espied 2 w 3060
a 227 w 3061
feather 3 w 3068
of 32 w 3070
his 13 w 3073
own 3 w 3076
Wherewith 2 w 3086
he 92 w 3088
wont 2 w 3092
to 25 w 3094
soar 2 w 3098
so 20 w 3100
high 2 w 3104
imperfect 2 w 3115
since 2 w 3121
a 230 w 3122
part 1 w 3126
is 39 w 3128
less 2 w 3132
than 4 w 3136
the 72 w 3139
whole 2 w 3144
and 27 w 3148
as 25 w 3150
the 73 w 3153
foot 4 w 3157
was 6 w 3160
cut 2 w 3163
off 4 w 3166
from 3 w 3170
Dion 7 w 3174
so 21 w 3177
also 3 w 3181
let 3 w 3184
everything 1 w 3194
which 6 w 3199
resembles 1 w 3208
a 237 w 3209
body 1 w 3213
be 15 w 3215
cut 3 w 3218
off 5 w 3221
from 4 w 3225
the 74 w 3228
world 6 w 3233