Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Incorruptibility of the World

On the Incorruptibility of the World (16-20)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg029.1st1K-eng1:16-20
Refs {'start': {'reference': '16', 'human_reference': 'Section 16'}, 'end': {'reference': '20', 'human_reference': 'Section 20'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

But also because Aristotle bears witness to this fact in the case of Plato, who, from his great reverence for philosophy, would never have spoken falsely, and also because no one can possibly be more to be credited in the case of a teacher than his pupil, especially when the pupil is such a man as this who did not apply himself to instruction lightly with an indifference easily satisfied, but who even endeavoured to surpass all the discoveries of former men, and did actually devise some novelties and enrich every part of philosophy with some most important discoveries.

5

But some persons think that the father of the Platonic theory was the poet Hesiod, as they conceive that the world is spoken of by him as created and indestructible; as created, when he says,

"First did Chaos rule
Then the broad-chested earth was brought to light,
Foundation firm and lasting for whatever
Exists among mankind;"
[*] and as indestructible, because he has given no hint of its dissolution or destruction.

Now Chaos was conceived by Aristotle to be a place, because it is absolutely necessary that a place to receive them must be in existence before bodies. But some of the Stoics think that it is water, imagining that its name has been derived from effusion. [*] But however that may be, it is exceedingly plain that the world is spoken of by Hesiod as having been created:

and a very long time before him Moses, the lawgiver of the Jews, had said in his sacred volumes that the world was both created and indestructible, and the number of the books is five. The first of which he entitled Genesis, in which he begins in the following manner: "in the beginning God created the heaven and the earth; and the earth was invisible and without form." Then proceeding onwards he relates in the following verses, that days and nights, and seasons, and years, and the sun and moon, which showed the nature of the measurement [*] [*] [*]

v.4.p.26
of time, were created, which, having received an immortal portion in common with the whole heaven, continue for ever indestructible.

But we must place those arguments first which make out the world to be uncreated and indestructible, because of our respect for that which is visible, employing an appropriate commencement. To all things which are liable to destruction there are two causes of that destruction, one being internal and the other external; therefore you may find iron, and brass, and all other substances of that kind destroyed by themselves when rust, like a creeping disease, overruns and devours them; and by external causes when, if a house or a city is burnt, they also are consumed in the conflagration, being melted by the violent impetuosity of the fire. A similar end also befalls animals, partly when they are sick of diseases arising internally, and partly when they are destroyed by external causes, being sacrificed, or stoned, or burnt, or when they endure an unclean death by hanging.

But 1 w 3
also 1 w 7
because 1 w 14
Aristotle 1 w 23
bears 1 w 28
witness 1 w 35
to 2 w 37
this 1 w 41
fact 1 w 45
in 1 w 47
the 1 w 50
case 1 w 54
of 1 w 56
Plato 1 w 61
who 1 w 65
from 1 w 70
his 2 w 73
great 1 w 78
reverence 1 w 87
for 1 w 90
philosophy 1 w 100
would 1 w 106
never 1 w 111
have 1 w 115
spoken 1 w 121
falsely 1 w 128
and 1 w 132
also 2 w 136
because 2 w 143
no 1 w 145
one 1 w 148
can 1 w 151
possibly 1 w 159
be 4 w 161
more 1 w 165
to 4 w 167
be 5 w 169
credited 1 w 177
in 2 w 179
the 2 w 182
case 2 w 186
of 2 w 188
a 15 w 189
teacher 1 w 196
than 1 w 200
his 3 w 203
pupil 1 w 208
especially 1 w 219
when 1 w 223
the 3 w 226
pupil 2 w 231
is 5 w 233
such 1 w 237
a 19 w 238
man 1 w 241
as 3 w 243
this 2 w 247
who 2 w 250
did 1 w 253
not 1 w 256
apply 1 w 261
himself 1 w 268
to 5 w 270
instruction 1 w 281
lightly 1 w 288
with 1 w 292
an 5 w 294
indifference 1 w 306
easily 1 w 312
satisfied 1 w 321
but 1 w 325
who 3 w 328
even 1 w 332
endeavoured 1 w 343
to 6 w 345
surpass 1 w 352
all 2 w 355
the 4 w 358
discoveries 1 w 369
of 3 w 371
former 1 w 377
men 1 w 380
and 2 w 384
did 2 w 387
actually 1 w 395
devise 1 w 401
some 1 w 405
novelties 1 w 414
and 3 w 417
enrich 1 w 423
every 1 w 428
part 1 w 432
of 4 w 434
philosophy 2 w 444
with 2 w 448
some 2 w 452
most 1 w 456
important 1 w 465
discoveries 2 w 476
But 2 w 480
some 3 w 484
persons 1 w 491
think 1 w 496
that 1 w 500
the 5 w 503
father 1 w 509
of 5 w 511
the 7 w 514
Platonic 1 w 522
theory 1 w 528
was 1 w 531
the 9 w 534
poet 1 w 538
Hesiod 1 w 544
as 7 w 547
they 1 w 551
conceive 1 w 559
that 2 w 563
the 11 w 566
world 1 w 571
is 11 w 573
spoken 2 w 579
of 6 w 581
by 1 w 583
him 2 w 586
as 8 w 588
created 1 w 595
and 4 w 598
indestructible 1 w 612
as 9 w 615
created 2 w 622
when 2 w 627
he 15 w 629
says 1 w 633
First 1 w 641
did 3 w 644
Chaos 1 w 649
rule 1 w 653
Then 1 w 657
the 12 w 660
broad-chested 1 w 673
earth 1 w 678
was 2 w 681
brought 1 w 688
to 8 w 690
light 2 w 695
Foundation 1 w 706
firm 1 w 710
and 5 w 713
lasting 1 w 720
for 3 w 723
whatever 1 w 731
Exists 1 w 737
among 1 w 742
mankind 1 w 749
Hesiod 2 w 757
Theogon 1 w 765
116 1 w 768
and 6 w 772
as 12 w 774
indestructible 2 w 788
because 3 w 796
he 20 w 798
has 1 w 801
given 1 w 806
no 4 w 808
hint 1 w 812
of 7 w 814
its 1 w 817
dissolution 1 w 828
or 8 w 830
destruction 1 w 841
Now 1 w 845
Chaos 2 w 850
was 3 w 853
conceived 1 w 862
by 2 w 864
Aristotle 2 w 873
to 10 w 875
be 7 w 877
a 63 w 878
place 1 w 883
because 4 w 891
it 6 w 893
is 15 w 895
absolutely 1 w 905
necessary 1 w 914
that 3 w 918
a 69 w 919
place 2 w 924
to 11 w 926
receive 1 w 933
them 1 w 937
must 1 w 941
be 9 w 943
in 11 w 945
existence 1 w 954
before 1 w 960
bodies 1 w 966
But 3 w 970
some 4 w 974
of 8 w 976
the 14 w 979
Stoics 1 w 985
think 2 w 990
that 4 w 994
it 7 w 996
is 17 w 998
water 1 w 1003
imagining 1 w 1013
that 5 w 1017
its 2 w 1020
name 1 w 1024
has 2 w 1027
been 1 w 1031
derived 1 w 1038
from 2 w 1042
effusion 1 w 1050
Χύσις 1 w 1056
as 16 w 1059
if 2 w 1061
chaos 1 w 1066
were 1 w 1070
derived 2 w 1077
from 3 w 1081
Χέω 1 w 1084
to 13 w 1088
pour 1 w 1092
But 4 w 1097
however 1 w 1104
that 6 w 1108
may 1 w 1111
be 12 w 1113
it 9 w 1116
is 18 w 1118
exceedingly 1 w 1129
plain 1 w 1134
that 7 w 1138
the 15 w 1141
world 2 w 1146
is 19 w 1148
spoken 3 w 1154
of 9 w 1156
by 3 w 1158
Hesiod 3 w 1164
as 17 w 1166
having 1 w 1172
been 2 w 1176
created 3 w 1183
and 7 w 1187
a 87 w 1188
very 2 w 1192
long 1 w 1196
time 1 w 1200
before 2 w 1206
him 3 w 1209
Moses 1 w 1214
the 16 w 1218
lawgiver 1 w 1226
of 10 w 1228
the 17 w 1231
Jews 1 w 1235
had 1 w 1239
said 1 w 1243
in 18 w 1245
his 5 w 1248
sacred 1 w 1254
volumes 1 w 1261
that 8 w 1265
the 18 w 1268
world 3 w 1273
was 4 w 1276
both 1 w 1280
created 4 w 1287
and 8 w 1290
indestructible 3 w 1304
and 9 w 1308
the 19 w 1311
number 1 w 1317
of 11 w 1319
the 20 w 1322
books 1 w 1327
is 21 w 1329
five 1 w 1333
The 3 w 1337
first 1 w 1342
of 12 w 1344
which 1 w 1349
he 30 w 1351
entitled 1 w 1359
Genesis 1 w 1366
in 20 w 1369
which 2 w 1374
he 31 w 1376
begins 1 w 1382
in 22 w 1384
the 21 w 1387
following 1 w 1396
manner 1 w 1402
in 24 w 1406
the 22 w 1409
beginning 1 w 1418
God 1 w 1421
created 5 w 1428
the 23 w 1431
heaven 1 w 1437
and 10 w 1440
the 24 w 1443
earth 2 w 1448
and 11 w 1452
the 25 w 1455
earth 3 w 1460
was 5 w 1463
invisible 1 w 1472
and 12 w 1475
without 1 w 1482
form 2 w 1486
Then 2 w 1492
proceeding 1 w 1502
onwards 1 w 1509
he 39 w 1511
relates 1 w 1518
in 29 w 1520
the 26 w 1523
following 2 w 1532
verses 1 w 1538
that 9 w 1543
days 1 w 1547
and 13 w 1550
nights 1 w 1556
and 14 w 1560
seasons 1 w 1567
and 15 w 1571
years 1 w 1576
and 16 w 1580
the 27 w 1583
sun 1 w 1586
and 17 w 1589
moon 1 w 1593
which 3 w 1599
showed 1 w 1605
the 28 w 1608
nature 1 w 1614
of 13 w 1616
the 29 w 1619
measurement 1 w 1630
There 1 w 1635
is 24 w 1637
probably 1 w 1645
some 5 w 1649
corruption 1 w 1659
in 31 w 1661
the 30 w 1664
text 1 w 1668
here 2 w 1672
Hesiod 4 w 1679
Theogon 2 w 1687
116 2 w 1690
Χύσις 2 w 1696
as 22 w 1699
if 3 w 1701
chaos 2 w 1706
were 2 w 1710
derived 3 w 1717
from 4 w 1721
Χέω 2 w 1724
to 14 w 1728
pour 2 w 1732
of 14 w 1736
time 2 w 1740
were 3 w 1745
created 6 w 1752
which 4 w 1758
having 2 w 1765
received 1 w 1773
an 25 w 1775
immortal 1 w 1783
portion 1 w 1790
in 33 w 1792
common 1 w 1798
with 4 w 1802
the 31 w 1805
whole 1 w 1810
heaven 2 w 1816
continue 1 w 1825
for 7 w 1828
ever 6 w 1832
indestructible 4 w 1846
But 5 w 1850
we 6 w 1852
must 2 w 1856
place 3 w 1861
those 1 w 1866
arguments 1 w 1875
first 2 w 1880
which 5 w 1885
make 1 w 1889
out 2 w 1892
the 32 w 1895
world 4 w 1900
to 15 w 1902
be 18 w 1904
uncreated 1 w 1913
and 18 w 1916
indestructible 5 w 1930
because 5 w 1938
of 15 w 1940
our 4 w 1943
respect 1 w 1950
for 8 w 1953
that 10 w 1957
which 6 w 1962
is 25 w 1964
visible 2 w 1971
employing 1 w 1981
an 27 w 1983
appropriate 1 w 1994
commencement 1 w 2006
To 1 w 2009
all 4 w 2012
things 1 w 2018
which 7 w 2023
are 1 w 2026
liable 1 w 2032
to 16 w 2034
destruction 2 w 2045
there 1 w 2050
are 2 w 2053
two 1 w 2056
causes 1 w 2062
of 16 w 2064
that 11 w 2068
destruction 3 w 2079
one 2 w 2083
being 1 w 2088
internal 1 w 2096
and 19 w 2099
the 34 w 2102
other 1 w 2107
external 1 w 2115
therefore 1 w 2125
you 1 w 2128
may 2 w 2131
find 1 w 2135
iron 1 w 2139
and 20 w 2143
brass 1 w 2148
and 21 w 2152
all 5 w 2155
other 2 w 2160
substances 1 w 2170
of 17 w 2172
that 12 w 2176
kind 2 w 2180
destroyed 1 w 2189
by 4 w 2191
themselves 1 w 2201
when 3 w 2205
rust 1 w 2209
like 1 w 2214
a 153 w 2215
creeping 1 w 2223
disease 1 w 2230
overruns 1 w 2239
and 22 w 2242
devours 1 w 2249
them 3 w 2253
and 23 w 2257
by 5 w 2259
external 2 w 2267
causes 2 w 2273
when 4 w 2277
if 4 w 2280
a 159 w 2281
house 1 w 2286
or 21 w 2288
a 160 w 2289
city 1 w 2293
is 28 w 2295
burnt 1 w 2300
they 2 w 2305
also 3 w 2309
are 3 w 2312
consumed 1 w 2320
in 44 w 2322
the 41 w 2325
conflagration 1 w 2338
being 2 w 2344
melted 1 w 2350
by 6 w 2352
the 42 w 2355
violent 1 w 2362
impetuosity 1 w 2373
of 18 w 2375
the 43 w 2378
fire 1 w 2382
A 3 w 2384
similar 1 w 2391
end 2 w 2394
also 4 w 2398
befalls 1 w 2405
animals 1 w 2412
partly 1 w 2419
when 5 w 2423
they 3 w 2427
are 4 w 2430
sick 1 w 2434
of 19 w 2436
diseases 1 w 2444
arising 1 w 2451
internally 1 w 2461
and 24 w 2465
partly 2 w 2471
when 6 w 2475
they 4 w 2479
are 5 w 2482
destroyed 2 w 2491
by 7 w 2493
external 3 w 2501
causes 3 w 2507
being 3 w 2513
sacrificed 1 w 2523
or 22 w 2526
stoned 1 w 2532
or 23 w 2535
burnt 2 w 2540
or 24 w 2543
when 7 w 2547
they 5 w 2551
endure 1 w 2557
an 36 w 2559
unclean 1 w 2566
death 1 w 2571
by 8 w 2573
hanging 1 w 2580