Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Incorruptibility of the World

On the Incorruptibility of the World (131-135)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg029.1st1K-eng1:131-135
Refs {'start': {'reference': '131', 'human_reference': 'Section 131'}, 'end': {'reference': '135', 'human_reference': 'Section 135'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

let us therefore examine the dates of each of these, disregarding the fables invented by the tragedians about the gods; but if man is not eternal then neither is any other animal, so that then neither are the places which receive them, the earth, or the water, or the air; from all which considerations it is plain that this world is liable to destruction.

25

But it is necessary to encounter such quibbling arguments as these, lest some persons of too little experience should yield to and be led away by them; and we must begin our refutation of them from the same point from which the Sophists begin their deceit. They say, "There could no longer be any inequalities existing on the earth, if the world were eternal." Why not, my most excellent friends? For other persons will come up and say that the natures of trees are in no respect different from mountains; but just as they at certain seasons lose their leaves, and again at certain seasons recover their verdure again; on which account there is admirable truth in those lines of the poet:—

"Like leaves on trees the race of man is found,
Now green in youth, now withering on the ground;
Another race the following spring supplies;
They fall successive and successive rise."
[*] And so in like manner some portions of the mountains are broken off, and others grow in their stead:

but after a long lapse of time the additional growth becomes conspicuous because the trees having a more rapid nature, display their increase with great rapidity; but mountains have a slower character, on which account it happens that the additions which take place in their case are not perceptible by the outward senses except after a long time.

And these men appear to be ignorant of the manner in which they are produced, since if they had not been, perhaps they would have been silent out of shame; but still there is no reason why we should not teach them; but there is nothing new in what is now said, neither are they our words but the ancient sayings of wise men, by whom nothing which was necessary for knowledge has been left uninvestigated;

when the fiery principle which is contained beneath, in the earth, is thrust upwards by the natural power of fire, it proceeds to its own appropriate place; and if it meets with any respite or [*]

v.4.p.57
relaxation, though ever so slight, it draws up with it a large portion of the earthy substance, as much as it can; and when it has emerged from the earth it proceeds more slowly; but the earthy substance being compelled to follow it for a long time, being at last raised to an immense height, is contracted at the top, and at last comes to end on a sharp point imitating the general appearance of the flame of fire;

Tokens

let 1 w 3
us 1 w 5
therefore 1 w 14
examine 1 w 21
the 2 w 24
dates 1 w 29
of 1 w 31
each 1 w 35
of 2 w 37
these 1 w 42
disregarding 1 w 55
the 4 w 58
fables 1 w 64
invented 1 w 72
by 1 w 74
the 5 w 77
tragedians 1 w 87
about 1 w 92
the 6 w 95
gods 1 w 99
but 1 w 103
if 1 w 105
man 1 w 108
is 2 w 110
not 1 w 113
eternal 1 w 120
then 1 w 124
neither 1 w 131
is 3 w 133
any 1 w 136
other 1 w 141
animal 1 w 147
so 1 w 150
that 1 w 154
then 2 w 158
neither 2 w 165
are 1 w 168
the 12 w 171
places 1 w 177
which 1 w 182
receive 1 w 189
them 1 w 193
the 14 w 197
earth 1 w 202
or 2 w 205
the 15 w 208
water 1 w 213
or 3 w 216
the 16 w 219
air 1 w 222
from 1 w 227
all 1 w 230
which 2 w 235
considerations 1 w 249
it 3 w 251
is 4 w 253
plain 1 w 258
that 2 w 262
this 1 w 266
world 1 w 271
is 6 w 273
liable 1 w 279
to 1 w 281
destruction 1 w 292
But 1 w 296
it 4 w 298
is 7 w 300
necessary 1 w 309
to 2 w 311
encounter 1 w 320
such 1 w 324
quibbling 1 w 333
arguments 1 w 342
as 1 w 344
these 2 w 349
lest 1 w 354
some 1 w 358
persons 1 w 365
of 3 w 367
too 1 w 370
little 1 w 376
experience 1 w 386
should 1 w 392
yield 1 w 397
to 4 w 399
and 1 w 402
be 1 w 404
led 1 w 407
away 1 w 411
by 2 w 413
them 2 w 417
and 2 w 421
we 1 w 423
must 1 w 427
begin 1 w 432
our 1 w 435
refutation 1 w 445
of 4 w 447
them 3 w 451
from 2 w 455
the 20 w 458
same 1 w 462
point 1 w 467
from 3 w 471
which 3 w 476
the 21 w 479
Sophists 1 w 487
begin 2 w 492
their 1 w 497
deceit 1 w 503
They 1 w 508
say 1 w 511
There 1 w 518
could 1 w 523
no 2 w 525
longer 1 w 531
be 4 w 533
any 2 w 536
inequalities 1 w 548
existing 1 w 556
on 7 w 558
the 23 w 561
earth 2 w 566
if 2 w 569
the 24 w 572
world 2 w 577
were 1 w 581
eternal 2 w 588
Why 1 w 593
not 2 w 596
my 1 w 599
most 1 w 603
excellent 1 w 612
friends 1 w 619
For 1 w 623
other 2 w 628
persons 2 w 635
will 1 w 639
come 1 w 643
up 1 w 645
and 3 w 648
say 2 w 651
that 3 w 655
the 26 w 658
natures 1 w 665
of 5 w 667
trees 1 w 672
are 2 w 675
in 11 w 677
no 4 w 679
respect 1 w 686
different 1 w 695
from 4 w 699
mountains 1 w 708
but 2 w 712
just 1 w 716
as 2 w 718
they 1 w 722
at 9 w 724
certain 1 w 731
seasons 1 w 738
lose 1 w 742
their 2 w 747
leaves 1 w 753
and 4 w 757
again 1 w 762
at 10 w 764
certain 2 w 771
seasons 2 w 778
recover 1 w 785
their 3 w 790
verdure 1 w 797
again 2 w 802
on 11 w 805
which 4 w 810
account 1 w 817
there 2 w 822
is 10 w 824
admirable 1 w 833
truth 1 w 838
in 17 w 840
those 1 w 845
lines 1 w 850
of 6 w 852
the 31 w 855
poet 1 w 859
Like 1 w 866
leaves 2 w 872
on 12 w 874
trees 2 w 879
the 32 w 882
race 1 w 886
of 7 w 888
man 2 w 891
is 11 w 893
found 1 w 898
Now 1 w 902
green 1 w 907
in 19 w 909
youth 1 w 914
now 1 w 918
withering 1 w 927
on 13 w 929
the 34 w 932
ground 1 w 938
Another 1 w 946
race 2 w 950
the 36 w 953
following 1 w 962
spring 1 w 968
supplies 1 w 976
They 2 w 981
fall 1 w 985
successive 1 w 995
and 5 w 998
successive 2 w 1008
rise 1 w 1012
Homer 1 w 1019
II 1 w 1022
vi 1 w 1025
147 1 w 1029
And 1 w 1033
so 7 w 1035
in 23 w 1037
like 1 w 1041
manner 1 w 1047
some 2 w 1051
portions 1 w 1059
of 8 w 1061
the 37 w 1064
mountains 2 w 1073
are 3 w 1076
broken 1 w 1082
off 1 w 1085
and 6 w 1089
others 1 w 1095
grow 1 w 1099
in 25 w 1101
their 4 w 1106
stead 1 w 1111
but 3 w 1115
after 1 w 1120
a 73 w 1121
long 2 w 1125
lapse 1 w 1130
of 10 w 1132
time 1 w 1136
the 40 w 1139
additional 1 w 1149
growth 1 w 1155
becomes 1 w 1162
conspicuous 1 w 1173
because 1 w 1180
the 41 w 1183
trees 3 w 1188
having 1 w 1194
a 79 w 1195
more 1 w 1199
rapid 1 w 1204
nature 2 w 1210
display 1 w 1218
their 5 w 1223
increase 1 w 1231
with 2 w 1235
great 1 w 1240
rapidity 1 w 1248
but 4 w 1252
mountains 3 w 1261
have 1 w 1265
a 88 w 1266
slower 1 w 1272
character 1 w 1281
on 18 w 1284
which 5 w 1289
account 2 w 1296
it 12 w 1298
happens 1 w 1305
that 4 w 1309
the 43 w 1312
additions 1 w 1321
which 6 w 1326
take 1 w 1330
place 2 w 1335
in 29 w 1337
their 6 w 1342
case 1 w 1346
are 4 w 1349
not 4 w 1352
perceptible 1 w 1363
by 3 w 1365
the 45 w 1368
outward 1 w 1375
senses 1 w 1381
except 1 w 1387
after 2 w 1392
a 101 w 1393
long 3 w 1397
time 2 w 1401
And 2 w 1405
these 3 w 1410
men 2 w 1413
appear 1 w 1419
to 5 w 1421
be 7 w 1423
ignorant 1 w 1431
of 11 w 1433
the 47 w 1436
manner 2 w 1442
in 30 w 1444
which 7 w 1449
they 2 w 1453
are 5 w 1456
produced 1 w 1464
since 1 w 1470
if 4 w 1472
they 3 w 1476
had 1 w 1479
not 5 w 1482
been 1 w 1486
perhaps 1 w 1494
they 4 w 1498
would 1 w 1503
have 2 w 1507
been 2 w 1511
silent 1 w 1517
out 4 w 1520
of 12 w 1522
shame 1 w 1527
but 5 w 1531
still 1 w 1536
there 3 w 1541
is 14 w 1543
no 10 w 1545
reason 1 w 1551
why 1 w 1554
we 4 w 1556
should 2 w 1562
not 6 w 1565
teach 1 w 1570
them 4 w 1574
but 6 w 1578
there 4 w 1583
is 15 w 1585
nothing 1 w 1592
new 1 w 1595
in 33 w 1597
what 1 w 1601
is 16 w 1603
now 2 w 1606
said 1 w 1610
neither 3 w 1618
are 6 w 1621
they 5 w 1625
our 2 w 1628
words 1 w 1633
but 7 w 1636
the 56 w 1639
ancient 1 w 1646
sayings 1 w 1653
of 13 w 1655
wise 1 w 1659
men 3 w 1662
by 4 w 1665
whom 1 w 1669
nothing 2 w 1676
which 8 w 1681
was 1 w 1684
necessary 2 w 1693
for 2 w 1696
knowledge 1 w 1705
has 1 w 1708
been 3 w 1712
left 1 w 1716
uninvestigated 1 w 1730
when 1 w 1735
the 57 w 1738
fiery 1 w 1743
principle 1 w 1752
which 9 w 1757
is 18 w 1759
contained 1 w 1768
beneath 1 w 1775
in 39 w 1778
the 58 w 1781
earth 3 w 1786
is 19 w 1789
thrust 1 w 1795
upwards 1 w 1802
by 5 w 1804
the 59 w 1807
natural 1 w 1814
power 1 w 1819
of 14 w 1821
fire 1 w 1825
it 15 w 1828
proceeds 1 w 1836
to 6 w 1838
its 1 w 1841
own 1 w 1844
appropriate 1 w 1855
place 3 w 1860
and 7 w 1864
if 5 w 1866
it 17 w 1868
meets 1 w 1873
with 3 w 1877
any 3 w 1880
respite 1 w 1887
or 12 w 1889
Homer 2 w 1894
II 2 w 1897
vi 3 w 1900
147 2 w 1904
relaxation 1 w 1915
though 1 w 1922
ever 1 w 1926
so 10 w 1928
slight 1 w 1934
it 20 w 1937
draws 1 w 1942
up 4 w 1944
with 4 w 1948
it 22 w 1950
a 136 w 1951
large 1 w 1956
portion 2 w 1963
of 15 w 1965
the 60 w 1968
earthy 1 w 1974
substance 1 w 1983
as 10 w 1986
much 1 w 1990
as 11 w 1992
it 23 w 1994
can 1 w 1997
and 8 w 2001
when 2 w 2005
it 24 w 2007
has 2 w 2010
emerged 1 w 2017
from 5 w 2021
the 61 w 2024
earth 5 w 2029
it 25 w 2031
proceeds 2 w 2039
more 2 w 2043
slowly 1 w 2049
but 8 w 2053
the 62 w 2056
earthy 2 w 2062
substance 2 w 2071
being 1 w 2076
compelled 1 w 2085
to 7 w 2087
follow 2 w 2093
it 26 w 2095
for 3 w 2098
a 148 w 2099
long 4 w 2103
time 3 w 2107
being 2 w 2113
at 20 w 2115
last 1 w 2119
raised 1 w 2125
to 8 w 2127
an 23 w 2129
immense 1 w 2136
height 1 w 2142
is 21 w 2145
contracted 1 w 2155
at 21 w 2157
the 63 w 2160
top 1 w 2163
and 9 w 2167
at 22 w 2169
last 2 w 2173
comes 2 w 2178
to 10 w 2180
end 2 w 2183
on 27 w 2185
a 158 w 2186
sharp 1 w 2191
point 2 w 2196
imitating 1 w 2205
the 64 w 2208
general 1 w 2215
appearance 1 w 2225
of 16 w 2227
the 65 w 2230
flame 1 w 2235
of 17 w 2237
fire 2 w 2241