Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Incorruptibility of the World

On the Incorruptibility of the World (11-15)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg029.1st1K-eng1:11-15
Refs {'start': {'reference': '11', 'human_reference': 'Section 11'}, 'end': {'reference': '15', 'human_reference': 'Section 15'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

and he said in a cavilling and reproachful tone, that formerly he had feared for his house lest it should be overthrown by violent gales, or extraordinary storms, or by lapse of time, or through the want of the proper care requisite to preserve it,

v.4.p.24
but that now he had a much greater fear hanging over him in consequence of those men who by their reasonings went to destroy the whole world.

But some say that it was not Aristotle who invented this doctrine, but some of the Pythagoreans; but I have met with a work of Ocellus, a Lucanian by birth, entitled, "A Treatise on the Nature of the Universe," in which he has not only asserted that the world is indestructible, but he has even endeavoured to prove it so by demonstrative proofs.

4

But some say that the world has been proved by Plato in the Timaeus to be both uncreated and indestructible, in the account of that divine assembly in which the younger gods are addressed by the eldest and the governor of them all in the following terms; [*]"O ye gods of gods, those works of which I am the father and the creator are indissoluble as long as I choose that they shall be so. Now everything which has been bound together is capable of being dissolved, but it is the part of an evil ruler to dissolve that which has been well combined and arranged, and which is in good condition. Wherefore, since you also have been created, you are not of necessity immortal or utterly indissoluble; nevertheless you shall not be dissolved, nor shall you be exposed to the fate of death, inasmuch as you have my will to keep you united, which is a still greater and more powerful bond than those by which you were bound together when you were first created."

But some persons interpret Platos words sophistically, and think that he affirms that the world was created, not inasmuch as it has had a beginning of creation, but inasmuch as if it had been created it could not possibly have existed in any other manner than that in which it actually does exist as has been described, or else because it is in its creation and change that the parts are seen.

But the forementioned opinion is better and truer, not only because throughout the whole treatise he affirms that the Creator of the gods is also the father and creator and maker of everything, and that the world is a most beautiful work of his and his offspring, being an imitation visible to the outward senses of an archetypal model appreciable only by the intellect, comprehending in itself as many objects of the outward senses as the model does objects [*]

v.4.p.25
of the intellect, since it is a most perfect impression of a most perfect model, and is addressed to the outward sense as the other is to the intellect. [*]

and 1 w 3
he 1 w 5
said 1 w 9
in 1 w 11
a 3 w 12
cavilling 1 w 21
and 2 w 24
reproachful 1 w 35
tone 1 w 39
that 1 w 44
formerly 1 w 52
he 2 w 54
had 1 w 57
feared 1 w 63
for 2 w 66
his 1 w 69
house 1 w 74
lest 1 w 78
it 1 w 80
should 1 w 86
be 1 w 88
overthrown 1 w 98
by 1 w 100
violent 1 w 107
gales 1 w 112
or 3 w 115
extraordinary 1 w 128
storms 1 w 134
or 6 w 137
by 2 w 139
lapse 1 w 144
of 1 w 146
time 1 w 150
or 7 w 153
through 1 w 160
the 1 w 163
want 1 w 167
of 2 w 169
the 2 w 172
proper 1 w 178
care 1 w 182
requisite 1 w 191
to 3 w 193
preserve 1 w 201
it 3 w 203
but 1 w 207
that 2 w 211
now 1 w 214
he 5 w 216
had 2 w 219
a 18 w 220
much 1 w 224
greater 1 w 231
fear 2 w 235
hanging 1 w 242
over 2 w 246
him 1 w 249
in 5 w 251
consequence 1 w 262
of 3 w 264
those 1 w 269
men 1 w 272
who 1 w 275
by 3 w 277
their 1 w 282
reasonings 1 w 292
went 1 w 296
to 4 w 298
destroy 1 w 305
the 4 w 308
whole 1 w 313
world 1 w 318
But 1 w 322
some 1 w 326
say 1 w 329
that 3 w 333
it 4 w 335
was 1 w 338
not 1 w 341
Aristotle 1 w 350
who 3 w 353
invented 1 w 361
this 1 w 365
doctrine 1 w 373
but 2 w 377
some 2 w 381
of 4 w 383
the 5 w 386
Pythagoreans 1 w 398
but 3 w 402
I 1 w 403
have 1 w 407
met 1 w 410
with 1 w 414
a 29 w 415
work 1 w 419
of 5 w 421
Ocellus 1 w 428
a 30 w 430
Lucanian 1 w 438
by 4 w 440
birth 1 w 445
entitled 1 w 454
A 2 w 457
Treatise 1 w 465
on 4 w 467
the 6 w 470
Nature 1 w 476
of 6 w 478
the 7 w 481
Universe 1 w 489
in 9 w 493
which 1 w 498
he 11 w 500
has 1 w 503
not 2 w 506
only 1 w 510
asserted 1 w 518
that 4 w 522
the 8 w 525
world 2 w 530
is 6 w 532
indestructible 1 w 546
but 4 w 550
he 13 w 552
has 2 w 555
even 1 w 559
endeavoured 1 w 570
to 6 w 572
prove 1 w 577
it 7 w 579
so 4 w 581
by 5 w 583
demonstrative 1 w 596
proofs 1 w 602
But 2 w 606
some 3 w 610
say 2 w 613
that 5 w 617
the 9 w 620
world 3 w 625
has 3 w 628
been 1 w 632
proved 1 w 638
by 6 w 640
Plato 1 w 645
in 11 w 647
the 10 w 650
Timaeus 1 w 657
to 8 w 659
be 3 w 661
both 1 w 665
uncreated 1 w 674
and 3 w 677
indestructible 2 w 691
in 13 w 694
the 11 w 697
account 1 w 704
of 8 w 706
that 6 w 710
divine 1 w 716
assembly 1 w 724
in 15 w 726
which 2 w 731
the 12 w 734
younger 1 w 741
gods 1 w 745
are 3 w 748
addressed 1 w 757
by 7 w 759
the 13 w 762
eldest 1 w 768
and 4 w 771
the 14 w 774
governor 1 w 782
of 9 w 784
them 1 w 788
all 1 w 791
in 16 w 793
the 16 w 796
following 1 w 805
terms 1 w 810
Timaeus 2 w 818
p 9 w 820
40 1 w 823
O 2 w 826
ye 1 w 828
gods 2 w 832
of 10 w 834
gods 3 w 838
those 2 w 844
works 1 w 849
of 11 w 851
which 3 w 856
I 2 w 857
am 1 w 859
the 17 w 862
father 1 w 868
and 5 w 871
the 19 w 874
creator 1 w 881
are 4 w 884
indissoluble 1 w 896
as 8 w 898
long 1 w 902
as 9 w 904
I 3 w 905
choose 1 w 911
that 7 w 915
they 1 w 919
shall 1 w 924
be 4 w 926
so 7 w 928
Now 1 w 932
everything 1 w 942
which 4 w 947
has 4 w 950
been 2 w 954
bound 1 w 959
together 1 w 967
is 8 w 969
capable 1 w 976
of 12 w 978
being 1 w 983
dissolved 1 w 992
but 5 w 996
it 8 w 998
is 10 w 1000
the 22 w 1003
part 1 w 1007
of 13 w 1009
an 11 w 1011
evil 1 w 1015
ruler 1 w 1020
to 11 w 1022
dissolve 2 w 1030
that 8 w 1034
which 5 w 1039
has 5 w 1042
been 3 w 1046
well 1 w 1050
combined 1 w 1058
and 6 w 1061
arranged 1 w 1069
and 7 w 1073
which 6 w 1078
is 12 w 1080
in 22 w 1082
good 1 w 1086
condition 1 w 1095
Wherefore 1 w 1105
since 1 w 1111
you 2 w 1114
also 1 w 1118
have 2 w 1122
been 4 w 1126
created 2 w 1133
you 3 w 1137
are 5 w 1140
not 3 w 1143
of 14 w 1145
necessity 1 w 1154
immortal 1 w 1162
or 18 w 1164
utterly 1 w 1171
indissoluble 2 w 1183
nevertheless 1 w 1196
you 4 w 1199
shall 2 w 1204
not 4 w 1207
be 9 w 1209
dissolved 2 w 1218
nor 2 w 1222
shall 3 w 1227
you 5 w 1230
be 10 w 1232
exposed 1 w 1239
to 12 w 1241
the 24 w 1244
fate 1 w 1248
of 15 w 1250
death 1 w 1255
inasmuch 1 w 1264
as 13 w 1266
you 6 w 1269
have 3 w 1273
my 1 w 1275
will 1 w 1279
to 13 w 1281
keep 1 w 1285
you 7 w 1288
united 1 w 1294
which 7 w 1300
is 15 w 1302
a 88 w 1303
still 1 w 1308
greater 2 w 1315
and 8 w 1318
more 1 w 1322
powerful 1 w 1330
bond 1 w 1334
than 1 w 1338
those 3 w 1343
by 8 w 1345
which 8 w 1350
you 8 w 1353
were 1 w 1357
bound 2 w 1362
together 2 w 1370
when 1 w 1374
you 9 w 1377
were 2 w 1381
first 1 w 1386
created 3 w 1393
But 3 w 1398
some 4 w 1402
persons 1 w 1409
interpret 1 w 1418
Plato 2 w 1423
s 91 w 1425
words 1 w 1430
sophistically 1 w 1443
and 9 w 1447
think 1 w 1452
that 9 w 1456
he 33 w 1458
affirms 1 w 1465
that 10 w 1469
the 26 w 1472
world 4 w 1477
was 2 w 1480
created 4 w 1487
not 5 w 1491
inasmuch 2 w 1499
as 16 w 1501
it 12 w 1503
has 6 w 1506
had 3 w 1509
a 105 w 1510
beginning 1 w 1519
of 16 w 1521
creation 1 w 1529
but 6 w 1533
inasmuch 3 w 1541
as 19 w 1543
if 1 w 1545
it 13 w 1547
had 4 w 1550
been 5 w 1554
created 5 w 1561
it 14 w 1563
could 1 w 1568
not 6 w 1571
possibly 1 w 1579
have 4 w 1583
existed 1 w 1590
in 32 w 1592
any 1 w 1595
other 1 w 1600
manner 1 w 1606
than 2 w 1610
that 11 w 1614
in 33 w 1616
which 9 w 1621
it 15 w 1623
actually 1 w 1631
does 1 w 1635
exist 2 w 1640
as 20 w 1642
has 7 w 1645
been 6 w 1649
described 1 w 1658
or 23 w 1661
else 1 w 1665
because 1 w 1672
it 16 w 1674
is 19 w 1676
in 34 w 1678
its 1 w 1681
creation 2 w 1689
and 10 w 1692
change 1 w 1698
that 12 w 1702
the 28 w 1705
parts 1 w 1710
are 6 w 1713
seen 1 w 1717
But 4 w 1721
the 29 w 1724
forementioned 1 w 1737
opinion 1 w 1744
is 20 w 1746
better 1 w 1752
and 11 w 1755
truer 1 w 1760
not 7 w 1764
only 2 w 1768
because 2 w 1775
throughout 1 w 1785
the 30 w 1788
whole 2 w 1793
treatise 1 w 1801
he 39 w 1803
affirms 2 w 1810
that 13 w 1814
the 31 w 1817
Creator 1 w 1824
of 17 w 1826
the 32 w 1829
gods 4 w 1833
is 22 w 1835
also 2 w 1839
the 33 w 1842
father 2 w 1848
and 12 w 1851
creator 2 w 1858
and 13 w 1861
maker 1 w 1866
of 18 w 1868
everything 2 w 1878
and 14 w 1882
that 14 w 1886
the 35 w 1889
world 5 w 1894
is 23 w 1896
a 141 w 1897
most 1 w 1901
beautiful 1 w 1910
work 3 w 1914
of 19 w 1916
his 4 w 1919
and 15 w 1922
his 5 w 1925
offspring 1 w 1934
being 2 w 1940
an 28 w 1942
imitation 1 w 1951
visible 1 w 1958
to 18 w 1960
the 36 w 1963
outward 1 w 1970
senses 1 w 1976
of 21 w 1978
an 29 w 1980
archetypal 1 w 1990
model 1 w 1995
appreciable 1 w 2006
only 3 w 2010
by 9 w 2012
the 37 w 2015
intellect 1 w 2024
comprehending 1 w 2038
in 41 w 2040
itself 1 w 2046
as 22 w 2048
many 1 w 2052
objects 1 w 2059
of 22 w 2061
the 38 w 2064
outward 2 w 2071
senses 2 w 2077
as 23 w 2079
the 39 w 2082
model 2 w 2087
does 2 w 2091
objects 2 w 2098
Timaeus 3 w 2105
p 26 w 2107
40 2 w 2110
of 23 w 2113
the 40 w 2116
intellect 2 w 2125
since 2 w 2131
it 20 w 2133
is 27 w 2135
a 157 w 2136
most 2 w 2140
perfect 1 w 2147
impression 1 w 2157
of 24 w 2159
a 158 w 2160
most 3 w 2164
perfect 2 w 2171
model 3 w 2176
and 16 w 2180
is 28 w 2182
addressed 2 w 2191
to 19 w 2193
the 41 w 2196
outward 3 w 2203
sense 3 w 2208
as 24 w 2210
the 42 w 2213
other 2 w 2218
is 29 w 2220
to 20 w 2222
the 44 w 2225
intellect 3 w 2234
There 1 w 2240
is 30 w 2242
probably 1 w 2250
some 5 w 2254
corruption 1 w 2264
in 45 w 2266
the 45 w 2269
text 1 w 2273
here 3 w 2277