Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Incorruptibility of the World

On the Incorruptibility of the World (106-110)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg029.1st1K-eng1:106-110
Refs {'start': {'reference': '106', 'human_reference': 'Section 106'}, 'end': {'reference': '110', 'human_reference': 'Section 110'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Again, there is this assertion made by some of those who diligently employ themselves in investigating truth which appears to me to be a sufficiently felicitous one; if the world is destroyed it will either be destroyed by some other efficient cause, or by God; now there is certainly nothing else whatever from which it can receive its destruction, for there is nothing whatever which it does not surround and contain; but that which is surrounded and confined within something else is manifestly inferior in power to that which surrounds and confines it, by which it is therefore mastered; on the other hand, to say that it is destroyed by God is the most impious of all possible assertions; for God is the cause not of disorder, and irregularity, and destruction, but of order, and beautiful regularity, and life, and of every good thing, as is confessed by all those whose opinions are based on truth.

21

But a person may very likely wonder at those who talk about conflagrations and regenerations, not only on account of the arguments which I have just been adducing, by which they are convicted of maintaining erroneous opinions, but also above all other reasons for this one; for since there are four elements of which the world consists, namely, earth, water, air, and fire, why is it that they are to separate fire from all the others, and to affirm that all the others are dissolved into that one? For some one may say, if it is necessary that they should all be resolved into one, why

v.4.p.50
should they not be resolved into air, or water, or earth? For these elements also contain powers of great magnitude; but yet no one has ever said that the world was to pass away into air, or into water, or into earth; so that it would be equally natural to deny that it is resolved into fire.

Moreover, it would have become them, perceiving the beautiful equality which exists in the world, to fear and to feel too great awe to venture to condemn so divine a thing to death; for there is a most admirable system of compensation existing in the four elements which arrange and dispense their vicissitudes by the rules of equality, and the definitions of justice;

for as the seasons of the year, in their proper alternations of revolutions, go through their regular cycle, completing their periodical changes without any cessation; in the same manner suppose that the elements of the world in the course of their continual interchanges with one another (though it is a most paradoxical assertion), when they appear to be perishing are in reality being made immortal, passing over the same course again and again, so as to have their existence infinitely protracted.

Therefore the steep road begins with the earth; for when it is wasted away it endures a change to water, and the water when it has evaporated is changed into air, and the air when rarefied is changed into fire; but the downward road descends from the head, when the fire in consequence of the conflagration which ensues settles down into air, and again when the air being closely pressed settles down into water, and when the water by its copious effusion is condensed so as to be changed into earth.

Tokens

Again 1 w 5
there 1 w 11
is 1 w 13
this 1 w 17
assertion 1 w 26
made 1 w 30
by 1 w 32
some 1 w 36
of 1 w 38
those 1 w 43
who 1 w 46
diligently 1 w 56
employ 1 w 62
themselves 1 w 72
in 2 w 74
investigating 1 w 87
truth 1 w 92
which 1 w 97
appears 1 w 104
to 1 w 106
me 2 w 108
to 2 w 110
be 1 w 112
a 7 w 113
sufficiently 1 w 125
felicitous 1 w 135
one 1 w 138
if 1 w 141
the 3 w 144
world 1 w 149
is 3 w 151
destroyed 1 w 160
it 2 w 162
will 1 w 166
either 1 w 172
be 2 w 174
destroyed 2 w 183
by 2 w 185
some 2 w 189
other 1 w 194
efficient 1 w 203
cause 1 w 208
or 2 w 211
by 3 w 213
God 1 w 216
now 1 w 220
there 2 w 225
is 4 w 227
certainly 1 w 236
nothing 1 w 243
else 1 w 247
whatever 1 w 255
from 1 w 259
which 2 w 264
it 4 w 266
can 1 w 269
receive 1 w 276
its 1 w 279
destruction 1 w 290
for 1 w 294
there 3 w 299
is 5 w 301
nothing 2 w 308
whatever 2 w 316
which 3 w 321
it 6 w 323
does 1 w 327
not 3 w 330
surround 1 w 338
and 1 w 341
contain 1 w 348
but 1 w 352
that 1 w 356
which 4 w 361
is 6 w 363
surrounded 1 w 373
and 2 w 376
confined 1 w 384
within 1 w 390
something 1 w 399
else 2 w 403
is 7 w 405
manifestly 1 w 415
inferior 1 w 423
in 13 w 425
power 1 w 430
to 4 w 432
that 2 w 436
which 5 w 441
surrounds 1 w 450
and 3 w 453
confines 1 w 461
it 8 w 463
by 4 w 466
which 6 w 471
it 9 w 473
is 8 w 475
therefore 1 w 484
mastered 1 w 492
on 7 w 495
the 9 w 498
other 2 w 503
hand 1 w 507
to 5 w 510
say 1 w 513
that 3 w 517
it 10 w 519
is 9 w 521
destroyed 3 w 530
by 5 w 532
God 2 w 535
is 10 w 537
the 11 w 540
most 1 w 544
impious 1 w 551
of 2 w 553
all 1 w 556
possible 1 w 564
assertions 1 w 574
for 3 w 578
God 3 w 581
is 11 w 583
the 12 w 586
cause 2 w 591
not 4 w 594
of 3 w 596
disorder 1 w 604
and 5 w 608
irregularity 1 w 620
and 6 w 624
destruction 2 w 635
but 2 w 639
of 4 w 641
order 2 w 646
and 7 w 650
beautiful 1 w 659
regularity 2 w 669
and 8 w 673
life 1 w 677
and 9 w 681
of 5 w 683
every 1 w 688
good 1 w 692
thing 4 w 697
as 4 w 700
is 13 w 702
confessed 1 w 711
by 6 w 713
all 2 w 716
those 2 w 721
whose 1 w 726
opinions 1 w 734
are 1 w 737
based 1 w 742
on 12 w 744
truth 2 w 749
But 1 w 753
a 39 w 754
person 1 w 760
may 1 w 763
very 2 w 767
likely 1 w 773
wonder 1 w 779
at 7 w 781
those 3 w 786
who 3 w 789
talk 1 w 793
about 1 w 798
conflagrations 1 w 812
and 10 w 815
regenerations 1 w 828
not 5 w 832
only 1 w 836
on 19 w 838
account 1 w 845
of 6 w 847
the 13 w 850
arguments 1 w 859
which 7 w 864
I 1 w 865
have 1 w 869
just 1 w 873
been 1 w 877
adducing 1 w 885
by 7 w 888
which 8 w 893
they 1 w 897
are 2 w 900
convicted 1 w 909
of 7 w 911
maintaining 1 w 922
erroneous 1 w 931
opinions 2 w 939
but 3 w 943
also 1 w 947
above 1 w 952
all 3 w 955
other 3 w 960
reasons 1 w 967
for 4 w 970
this 2 w 974
one 3 w 977
for 5 w 981
since 1 w 986
there 5 w 991
are 3 w 994
four 1 w 998
elements 1 w 1006
of 8 w 1008
which 9 w 1013
the 17 w 1016
world 2 w 1021
consists 1 w 1029
namely 1 w 1036
earth 1 w 1042
water 1 w 1048
air 1 w 1052
and 11 w 1056
fire 1 w 1060
why 1 w 1064
is 16 w 1066
it 13 w 1068
that 4 w 1072
they 2 w 1076
are 4 w 1079
to 6 w 1081
separate 1 w 1089
fire 2 w 1093
from 2 w 1097
all 4 w 1100
the 19 w 1103
others 1 w 1109
and 12 w 1113
to 7 w 1115
affirm 1 w 1121
that 5 w 1125
all 5 w 1128
the 21 w 1131
others 2 w 1137
are 5 w 1140
dissolved 1 w 1149
into 1 w 1153
that 6 w 1157
one 4 w 1160
For 1 w 1164
some 4 w 1168
one 5 w 1171
may 2 w 1174
say 2 w 1177
if 5 w 1180
it 14 w 1182
is 18 w 1184
necessary 1 w 1193
that 7 w 1197
they 3 w 1201
should 1 w 1207
all 6 w 1210
be 5 w 1212
resolved 1 w 1220
into 2 w 1224
one 6 w 1227
why 2 w 1231
should 2 w 1237
they 4 w 1241
not 6 w 1244
be 6 w 1246
resolved 2 w 1254
into 3 w 1258
air 2 w 1261
or 13 w 1264
water 2 w 1269
or 14 w 1272
earth 2 w 1277
For 2 w 1281
these 1 w 1286
elements 2 w 1294
also 2 w 1298
contain 2 w 1305
powers 1 w 1311
of 9 w 1313
great 1 w 1318
magnitude 1 w 1327
but 4 w 1331
yet 1 w 1334
no 8 w 1336
one 7 w 1339
has 1 w 1342
ever 4 w 1346
said 1 w 1350
that 8 w 1354
the 26 w 1357
world 3 w 1362
was 1 w 1365
to 11 w 1367
pass 1 w 1371
away 1 w 1375
into 4 w 1379
air 3 w 1382
or 17 w 1385
into 5 w 1389
water 3 w 1394
or 18 w 1397
into 6 w 1401
earth 3 w 1406
so 13 w 1409
that 9 w 1413
it 16 w 1415
would 1 w 1420
be 7 w 1422
equally 1 w 1429
natural 1 w 1436
to 15 w 1438
deny 1 w 1442
that 10 w 1446
it 17 w 1448
is 19 w 1450
resolved 3 w 1458
into 7 w 1462
fire 3 w 1466
Moreover 1 w 1475
it 18 w 1478
would 2 w 1483
have 2 w 1487
become 1 w 1493
them 2 w 1497
perceiving 1 w 1508
the 28 w 1511
beautiful 2 w 1520
equality 1 w 1528
which 10 w 1533
exists 1 w 1539
in 32 w 1541
the 29 w 1544
world 4 w 1549
to 17 w 1552
fear 1 w 1556
and 13 w 1559
to 18 w 1561
feel 1 w 1565
too 1 w 1568
great 2 w 1573
awe 1 w 1576
to 20 w 1578
venture 1 w 1585
to 21 w 1587
condemn 1 w 1594
so 15 w 1596
divine 1 w 1602
a 110 w 1603
thing 5 w 1608
to 22 w 1610
death 1 w 1615
for 6 w 1619
there 6 w 1624
is 21 w 1626
a 112 w 1627
most 2 w 1631
admirable 1 w 1640
system 1 w 1646
of 10 w 1648
compensation 1 w 1660
existing 1 w 1668
in 36 w 1670
the 31 w 1673
four 2 w 1677
elements 3 w 1685
which 11 w 1690
arrange 1 w 1697
and 14 w 1700
dispense 1 w 1708
their 1 w 1713
vicissitudes 1 w 1725
by 8 w 1727
the 33 w 1730
rules 1 w 1735
of 11 w 1737
equality 2 w 1745
and 15 w 1749
the 34 w 1752
definitions 1 w 1763
of 12 w 1765
justice 1 w 1772
for 7 w 1776
as 10 w 1778
the 35 w 1781
seasons 1 w 1788
of 13 w 1790
the 36 w 1793
year 1 w 1797
in 38 w 1800
their 2 w 1805
proper 1 w 1811
alternations 1 w 1823
of 14 w 1825
revolutions 1 w 1836
go 2 w 1839
through 1 w 1846
their 3 w 1851
regular 3 w 1858
cycle 1 w 1863
completing 1 w 1874
their 4 w 1879
periodical 1 w 1889
changes 1 w 1896
without 1 w 1903
any 1 w 1906
cessation 1 w 1915
in 40 w 1918
the 40 w 1921
same 1 w 1925
manner 1 w 1931
suppose 1 w 1938
that 11 w 1942
the 41 w 1945
elements 4 w 1953
of 15 w 1955
the 42 w 1958
world 5 w 1963
in 41 w 1965
the 43 w 1968
course 1 w 1974
of 16 w 1976
their 5 w 1981
continual 1 w 1990
interchanges 1 w 2002
with 3 w 2006
one 8 w 2009
another 1 w 2016
though 1 w 2023
it 25 w 2025
is 25 w 2027
a 137 w 2028
most 3 w 2032
paradoxical 1 w 2043
assertion 3 w 2052
when 1 w 2058
they 5 w 2062
appear 2 w 2068
to 23 w 2070
be 10 w 2072
perishing 1 w 2081
are 6 w 2084
in 45 w 2086
reality 1 w 2093
being 1 w 2098
made 2 w 2102
immortal 1 w 2110
passing 1 w 2118
over 2 w 2122
the 47 w 2125
same 2 w 2129
course 2 w 2135
again 1 w 2140
and 16 w 2143
again 2 w 2148
so 17 w 2151
as 14 w 2153
to 24 w 2155
have 3 w 2159
their 6 w 2164
existence 1 w 2173
infinitely 1 w 2183
protracted 1 w 2193
Therefore 1 w 2203
the 49 w 2206
steep 1 w 2211
road 1 w 2215
begins 1 w 2221
with 4 w 2225
the 50 w 2228
earth 4 w 2233
for 9 w 2237
when 2 w 2241
it 29 w 2243
is 28 w 2245
wasted 1 w 2251
away 2 w 2255
it 30 w 2257
endures 1 w 2264
a 163 w 2265
change 3 w 2271
to 25 w 2273
water 4 w 2278
and 17 w 2282
the 51 w 2285
water 5 w 2290
when 3 w 2294
it 31 w 2296
has 2 w 2299
evaporated 1 w 2309
is 29 w 2311
changed 1 w 2318
into 8 w 2322
air 4 w 2325
and 18 w 2329
the 52 w 2332
air 5 w 2335
when 4 w 2339
rarefied 1 w 2347
is 30 w 2349
changed 2 w 2356
into 9 w 2360
fire 4 w 2364
but 5 w 2368
the 53 w 2371
downward 1 w 2379
road 2 w 2383
descends 1 w 2391
from 3 w 2395
the 54 w 2398
head 1 w 2402
when 5 w 2407
the 55 w 2410
fire 5 w 2414
in 55 w 2416
consequence 1 w 2427
of 17 w 2429
the 56 w 2432
conflagration 2 w 2445
which 12 w 2450
ensues 1 w 2456
settles 1 w 2463
down 2 w 2467
into 10 w 2471
air 6 w 2474
and 19 w 2478
again 3 w 2483
when 6 w 2487
the 57 w 2490
air 7 w 2493
being 2 w 2498
closely 1 w 2505
pressed 1 w 2512
settles 2 w 2519
down 3 w 2523
into 11 w 2527
water 6 w 2532
and 20 w 2536
when 7 w 2540
the 58 w 2543
water 7 w 2548
by 9 w 2550
its 2 w 2553
copious 1 w 2560
effusion 1 w 2568
is 31 w 2570
condensed 1 w 2579
so 18 w 2581
as 17 w 2583
to 30 w 2585
be 14 w 2587
changed 3 w 2594
into 12 w 2598
earth 5 w 2603