Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / To Prove that every Man who is virtuous is also free

To Prove that every Man who is virtuous is also free (16-20)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg027.1st1K-eng1:16-20
Refs {'start': {'reference': '16', 'human_reference': 'Section 16'}, 'end': {'reference': '20', 'human_reference': 'Section 20'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

We must now examine with accuracy that which we have taken as the subject of our investigation, that we may not be led astray through being deceived by the indistinctness of words and expressions; but that, understanding accurately what it is of which we are speaking, we may frame our determinations felicitously. [*]

v.3.p.510

Slavery, then, is of two kinds; slavery of the soul and slavery of the body. Now, of our bodies, men are masters; but over our souls, wickedness and the passions have the dominion. And we may speak of freedom in the same manner. For one kind of freedom gives fearlessness of body in respect of any dangers which can come upon it from men of still more powerful body; while the other produces peace to the mind, by putting a check upon the authority of the passions.

Now, about the former kind, scarcely any one ever raises any question; for the chances of fortune which happen to men are infinite in number, and it often happens that men of the highest virtue have fallen into unexpected misfortunes, and so have lost the freedom which belonged to them through their birth. But there is room for inquiry about those manners which neither desires, nor fears, nor pleasures, nor pains, have ever brought under the yoke, as if they had come forth out of confinement, and as if the chains by which they had been bound were now loosened.

Therefore, discarding all mention of those kinds of freedom which are only a pretence, and of all those names also which are quite unconnected with nature, but which owe their existence only to opinion, such as slaves born in the house, slaves purchased with money, slaves taken in war, let us now investigate the character of the man who is truly free, who is alone possessed of independence, even if ten thousand men set themselves down as his masters; for he will quote that line of Sophocles, which differs in no respect from the doctrines of the Pythagoreans

"God is my ruler, and no mortal man."
[*]

For, in real truth, that man alone is free who has God for his leader; indeed, in my opinion, that man is even the ruler of all others, and has all the affairs of the earth committed to him, being, as it were, the viceroy of a great king, the mortal lieutenant of an immortal sovereign. However, this assertion of the actual authority of the wise man may be postponed to a more suitable opportunity. We must at present examine minutely the question of his perfect freedom.

Tokens

We 1 w 2
must 1 w 6
now 1 w 9
examine 1 w 16
with 1 w 20
accuracy 1 w 28
that 1 w 32
which 1 w 37
we 1 w 39
have 1 w 43
taken 1 w 48
as 1 w 50
the 1 w 53
subject 1 w 60
of 1 w 62
our 1 w 65
investigation 1 w 78
that 2 w 83
we 2 w 85
may 1 w 88
not 1 w 91
be 1 w 93
led 1 w 96
astray 1 w 102
through 1 w 109
being 1 w 114
deceived 1 w 122
by 1 w 124
the 2 w 127
indistinctness 1 w 141
of 2 w 143
words 1 w 148
and 1 w 151
expressions 1 w 162
but 1 w 166
that 3 w 170
understanding 1 w 184
accurately 1 w 194
what 1 w 198
it 2 w 200
is 2 w 202
of 3 w 204
which 2 w 209
we 3 w 211
are 1 w 214
speaking 1 w 222
we 4 w 225
may 2 w 228
frame 1 w 233
our 2 w 236
determinations 1 w 250
felicitously 1 w 262
Compare 1 w 270
Moore 1 w 275
You 1 w 280
may 3 w 283
break 1 w 288
you 1 w 292
may 4 w 295
shatter 1 w 302
the 3 w 305
vase 1 w 309
if 1 w 311
you 2 w 314
will 1 w 318
But 1 w 322
the 4 w 325
scent 1 w 330
of 4 w 332
the 5 w 335
roses 1 w 340
will 2 w 344
hang 1 w 348
round 1 w 353
it 4 w 355
still 1 w 360
Slavery 1 w 369
then 1 w 374
is 3 w 377
of 5 w 379
two 1 w 382
kinds 1 w 387
slavery 1 w 395
of 6 w 397
the 7 w 400
soul 1 w 404
and 3 w 407
slavery 2 w 414
of 7 w 416
the 8 w 419
body 1 w 423
Now 1 w 427
of 8 w 430
our 3 w 433
bodies 1 w 439
men 1 w 443
are 3 w 446
masters 1 w 453
but 2 w 457
over 1 w 461
our 4 w 464
souls 1 w 469
wickedness 1 w 480
and 4 w 483
the 9 w 486
passions 1 w 494
have 2 w 498
the 10 w 501
dominion 1 w 509
And 1 w 513
we 5 w 515
may 5 w 518
speak 2 w 523
of 9 w 525
freedom 1 w 532
in 11 w 534
the 11 w 537
same 1 w 541
manner 1 w 547
For 1 w 551
one 1 w 554
kind 2 w 558
of 10 w 560
freedom 2 w 567
gives 1 w 572
fearlessness 1 w 584
of 11 w 586
body 2 w 590
in 13 w 592
respect 1 w 599
of 12 w 601
any 1 w 604
dangers 1 w 611
which 3 w 616
can 1 w 619
come 1 w 623
upon 1 w 627
it 5 w 629
from 1 w 633
men 2 w 636
of 13 w 638
still 2 w 643
more 1 w 647
powerful 1 w 655
body 3 w 659
while 1 w 665
the 12 w 668
other 1 w 673
produces 1 w 681
peace 1 w 686
to 2 w 688
the 14 w 691
mind 1 w 695
by 2 w 698
putting 1 w 705
a 49 w 706
check 1 w 711
upon 2 w 715
the 15 w 718
authority 1 w 727
of 14 w 729
the 16 w 732
passions 2 w 740
Now 2 w 744
about 1 w 750
the 17 w 753
former 1 w 759
kind 3 w 763
scarcely 1 w 772
any 2 w 775
one 2 w 778
ever 1 w 782
raises 1 w 788
any 3 w 791
question 1 w 799
for 2 w 803
the 18 w 806
chances 1 w 813
of 15 w 815
fortune 1 w 822
which 4 w 827
happen 1 w 833
to 3 w 835
men 3 w 838
are 4 w 841
infinite 1 w 849
in 19 w 851
number 1 w 857
and 5 w 861
it 8 w 863
often 1 w 868
happens 1 w 875
that 4 w 879
men 4 w 882
of 17 w 884
the 19 w 887
highest 1 w 894
virtue 1 w 900
have 3 w 904
fallen 1 w 910
into 1 w 914
unexpected 1 w 924
misfortunes 1 w 935
and 6 w 939
so 3 w 941
have 4 w 945
lost 1 w 949
the 20 w 952
freedom 3 w 959
which 5 w 964
belonged 1 w 972
to 5 w 974
them 1 w 978
through 2 w 985
their 1 w 990
birth 1 w 995
But 2 w 999
there 1 w 1004
is 6 w 1006
room 1 w 1010
for 5 w 1013
inquiry 1 w 1020
about 2 w 1025
those 1 w 1030
manners 1 w 1037
which 6 w 1042
neither 1 w 1049
desires 1 w 1056
nor 1 w 1060
fears 1 w 1065
nor 2 w 1069
pleasures 1 w 1078
nor 3 w 1082
pains 1 w 1087
have 5 w 1092
ever 2 w 1096
brought 1 w 1103
under 2 w 1108
the 25 w 1111
yoke 1 w 1115
as 8 w 1118
if 2 w 1120
they 1 w 1124
had 1 w 1127
come 2 w 1131
forth 1 w 1136
out 3 w 1139
of 18 w 1141
confinement 1 w 1152
and 7 w 1156
as 9 w 1158
if 3 w 1160
the 27 w 1163
chains 1 w 1169
by 3 w 1171
which 7 w 1176
they 2 w 1180
had 2 w 1183
been 1 w 1187
bound 1 w 1192
were 1 w 1196
now 2 w 1199
loosened 1 w 1207
Therefore 1 w 1217
discarding 1 w 1228
all 2 w 1231
mention 1 w 1238
of 19 w 1240
those 2 w 1245
kinds 2 w 1250
of 20 w 1252
freedom 4 w 1259
which 8 w 1264
are 5 w 1267
only 1 w 1271
a 82 w 1272
pretence 1 w 1280
and 8 w 1284
of 21 w 1286
all 3 w 1289
those 3 w 1294
names 1 w 1299
also 1 w 1303
which 9 w 1308
are 6 w 1311
quite 1 w 1316
unconnected 1 w 1327
with 2 w 1331
nature 1 w 1337
but 3 w 1341
which 10 w 1346
owe 2 w 1349
their 2 w 1354
existence 1 w 1363
only 2 w 1367
to 6 w 1369
opinion 1 w 1376
such 1 w 1381
as 10 w 1383
slaves 1 w 1389
born 1 w 1393
in 28 w 1395
the 30 w 1398
house 1 w 1403
slaves 2 w 1410
purchased 1 w 1419
with 3 w 1423
money 1 w 1428
slaves 3 w 1435
taken 2 w 1440
in 29 w 1442
war 1 w 1445
let 1 w 1449
us 4 w 1451
now 3 w 1454
investigate 1 w 1465
the 31 w 1468
character 1 w 1477
of 22 w 1479
the 32 w 1482
man 3 w 1485
who 1 w 1488
is 9 w 1490
truly 1 w 1495
free 5 w 1499
who 2 w 1503
is 10 w 1505
alone 1 w 1510
possessed 1 w 1519
of 23 w 1521
independence 1 w 1533
even 1 w 1538
if 4 w 1540
ten 4 w 1543
thousand 1 w 1551
men 7 w 1554
set 1 w 1557
themselves 1 w 1567
down 1 w 1571
as 12 w 1573
his 1 w 1576
masters 2 w 1583
for 8 w 1587
he 37 w 1589
will 3 w 1593
quote 1 w 1598
that 5 w 1602
line 1 w 1606
of 24 w 1608
Sophocles 1 w 1617
which 11 w 1623
differs 1 w 1630
in 33 w 1632
no 8 w 1634
respect 2 w 1641
from 2 w 1645
the 34 w 1648
doctrines 1 w 1657
of 25 w 1659
the 35 w 1662
Pythagoreans 1 w 1674
God 1 w 1679
is 12 w 1681
my 1 w 1683
ruler 1 w 1688
and 10 w 1692
no 9 w 1694
mortal 1 w 1700
man 4 w 1703
It 1 w 1707
is 13 w 1709
not 2 w 1712
known 1 w 1717
from 3 w 1721
what 2 w 1725
play 1 w 1729
this 1 w 1733
line 2 w 1737
comes 1 w 1742
it 13 w 1745
is 15 w 1747
placed 1 w 1753
among 1 w 1758
the 36 w 1761
Incerta 1 w 1768
Fragmenta 1 w 1777
No 3 w 1780
89 1 w 1782
by 4 w 1785
Brunck 1 w 1791
For 2 w 1795
in 36 w 1798
real 1 w 1802
truth 1 w 1807
that 6 w 1812
man 5 w 1815
alone 2 w 1820
is 16 w 1822
free 6 w 1826
who 3 w 1829
has 2 w 1832
God 2 w 1835
for 9 w 1838
his 3 w 1841
leader 1 w 1847
indeed 1 w 1854
in 38 w 1857
my 2 w 1859
opinion 2 w 1866
that 7 w 1871
man 6 w 1874
is 18 w 1876
even 2 w 1880
the 37 w 1883
ruler 2 w 1888
of 26 w 1890
all 4 w 1893
others 1 w 1899
and 11 w 1903
has 3 w 1906
all 5 w 1909
the 39 w 1912
affairs 1 w 1919
of 27 w 1921
the 40 w 1924
earth 1 w 1929
committed 1 w 1938
to 7 w 1940
him 1 w 1943
being 2 w 1949
as 16 w 1952
it 15 w 1954
were 2 w 1958
the 41 w 1962
viceroy 1 w 1969
of 28 w 1971
a 133 w 1972
great 1 w 1977
king 2 w 1981
the 42 w 1985
mortal 2 w 1991
lieutenant 1 w 2001
of 29 w 2003
an 27 w 2005
immortal 1 w 2013
sovereign 1 w 2022
However 1 w 2030
this 2 w 2035
assertion 1 w 2044
of 30 w 2046
the 43 w 2049
actual 1 w 2055
authority 2 w 2064
of 31 w 2066
the 44 w 2069
wise 1 w 2073
man 7 w 2076
may 6 w 2079
be 7 w 2081
postponed 1 w 2090
to 8 w 2092
a 145 w 2093
more 2 w 2097
suitable 1 w 2105
opportunity 1 w 2116
We 2 w 2119
must 2 w 2123
at 17 w 2125
present 1 w 2132
examine 2 w 2139
minutely 1 w 2147
the 45 w 2150
question 2 w 2158
of 32 w 2160
his 5 w 2163
perfect 1 w 2170
freedom 5 w 2177