Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the doctrine that Dreams are sent from God, Books 1-2

On the doctrine that Dreams are sent from God, Books 1-2 (1.6-1.10)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg019.1st1K-eng1:1.6-1.10
Refs {'start': {'reference': '1.6', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 6'}, 'end': {'reference': '1.10', 'human_reference': 'Book 1 Section 10'}}
Ancestors [{'reference': '1'}]
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
2

Let us then at once begin and consider the first of these points. To me, then, the well appears to be an emblem of knowledge; for its nature is not superficial, but very deep. Nor does it lie in an open place, but a well is fond of being hidden somewhere in secret. Nor is it found with ease, but only after great labour and with difficulty; and this too is seen to be the case with sciences, not only with such as have great and indescribable subjects of speculation, but even with respect to such as are the most insignificant.

Choose, therefore, whichever art you please; not the most excellent, but even the most obscure of all, which perhaps no one who has been bred a free man in the whole city would ever study of his own accord, and which scarcely any servant in the field would attend to, who, against his will, was a slave to some morose and ill-tempered master who compelled him to do many unpleasant things.

For the matter will be found to be not a simple one, but rather one of great complications and variety, not easy to be seized upon, but difficult to discover, difficult to master, hostile [*] [*]

v.2.p.294
to delay, and indolence and indifference, full of earnestness and contention, and sweat, and care. For which reason "those who dig in this well say that they cannot find even water in it;" because the ends of science are not only hard to discover, but are even altogether undiscoverable;

and it is owing to this that one man is more thoroughly skilled in grammar or in geometry than another, because of its being impossible to circumscribe, increase, and extend one within certain limits; for there is always more that is left behind than what comes to be learnt; and what is left watches for and catches the learner, so that even he who fancies that he has comprehended and mastered the very extremities of knowledge would be considered but half perfect by another person who was his judge, and if he were before the tribunal of truth would appear to be only beginning knowledge;

for life is short, as some one has said, but art is long; of which that man most thoroughly comprehends the magnitude, who sincerely and honestly plunges deeply into it, and who digs it out like a well. And such a man, when he is at the point of death, being now grey-headed and exceedingly old, it is said, wept, not that he feared death as being a coward, but out of a desire for instruction, as feeling that he was now, for the first time, entering upon it when he was finally departing from life.

Let 1 w 3
us 1 w 5
then 1 w 9
at 1 w 11
once 1 w 15
begin 1 w 20
and 1 w 23
consider 1 w 31
the 2 w 34
first 1 w 39
of 1 w 41
these 1 w 46
points 1 w 52
To 1 w 55
me 1 w 57
then 2 w 62
the 5 w 66
well 1 w 70
appears 1 w 77
to 1 w 79
be 2 w 81
an 2 w 83
emblem 1 w 89
of 2 w 91
knowledge 1 w 100
for 1 w 104
its 1 w 107
nature 1 w 113
is 1 w 115
not 1 w 118
superficial 1 w 129
but 1 w 133
very 1 w 137
deep 1 w 141
Nor 1 w 145
does 1 w 149
it 2 w 151
lie 1 w 154
in 3 w 156
an 3 w 158
open 1 w 162
place 1 w 167
but 2 w 171
a 10 w 172
well 2 w 176
is 2 w 178
fond 1 w 182
of 3 w 184
being 1 w 189
hidden 1 w 195
somewhere 1 w 204
in 5 w 206
secret 1 w 212
Nor 2 w 216
is 3 w 218
it 3 w 220
found 1 w 225
with 1 w 229
ease 1 w 233
but 3 w 237
only 1 w 241
after 1 w 246
great 1 w 251
labour 1 w 257
and 2 w 260
with 2 w 264
difficulty 1 w 274
and 3 w 278
this 1 w 282
too 1 w 285
is 5 w 287
seen 1 w 291
to 3 w 293
be 4 w 295
the 6 w 298
case 1 w 302
with 3 w 306
sciences 1 w 314
not 2 w 318
only 2 w 322
with 4 w 326
such 1 w 330
as 3 w 332
have 1 w 336
great 2 w 341
and 4 w 344
indescribable 1 w 357
subjects 1 w 365
of 4 w 367
speculation 1 w 378
but 4 w 382
even 1 w 386
with 5 w 390
respect 1 w 397
to 4 w 399
such 2 w 403
as 4 w 405
are 1 w 408
the 7 w 411
most 1 w 415
insignificant 1 w 428
Choose 1 w 435
therefore 1 w 445
whichever 1 w 455
art 1 w 458
you 1 w 461
please 1 w 467
not 3 w 471
the 9 w 474
most 2 w 478
excellent 1 w 487
but 5 w 491
even 2 w 495
the 10 w 498
most 3 w 502
obscure 1 w 509
of 5 w 511
all 1 w 514
which 2 w 520
perhaps 1 w 527
no 5 w 529
one 1 w 532
who 1 w 535
has 1 w 538
been 1 w 542
bred 1 w 546
a 32 w 547
free 1 w 551
man 1 w 554
in 8 w 556
the 11 w 559
whole 1 w 564
city 1 w 568
would 1 w 573
ever 2 w 577
study 1 w 582
of 6 w 584
his 2 w 587
own 1 w 590
accord 1 w 596
and 5 w 600
which 3 w 605
scarcely 1 w 613
any 1 w 616
servant 1 w 623
in 9 w 625
the 12 w 628
field 1 w 633
would 2 w 638
attend 1 w 644
to 5 w 646
who 3 w 650
against 1 w 658
his 3 w 661
will 1 w 665
was 1 w 669
a 43 w 670
slave 1 w 675
to 6 w 677
some 2 w 681
morose 1 w 687
and 6 w 690
ill-tempered 1 w 702
master 1 w 708
who 4 w 711
compelled 1 w 720
him 1 w 723
to 7 w 725
do 2 w 727
many 1 w 731
unpleasant 1 w 741
things 1 w 747
For 1 w 751
the 13 w 754
matter 1 w 760
will 2 w 764
be 6 w 766
found 2 w 771
to 8 w 773
be 7 w 775
not 4 w 778
a 51 w 779
simple 1 w 785
one 2 w 788
but 6 w 792
rather 1 w 798
one 3 w 801
of 7 w 803
great 3 w 808
complications 1 w 821
and 7 w 824
variety 1 w 831
not 5 w 835
easy 1 w 839
to 9 w 841
be 8 w 843
seized 1 w 849
upon 1 w 853
but 7 w 857
difficult 2 w 866
to 10 w 868
discover 1 w 876
difficult 3 w 886
to 11 w 888
master 2 w 894
hostile 1 w 902
Genesis 1 w 909
xxviii 1 w 915
12 1 w 918
Genesis 2 w 926
xxvi 2 w 930
33 1 w 933
to 12 w 936
delay 1 w 941
and 8 w 945
indolence 1 w 954
and 9 w 957
indifference 1 w 969
full 1 w 974
of 8 w 976
earnestness 1 w 987
and 10 w 990
contention 1 w 1000
and 11 w 1004
sweat 1 w 1009
and 12 w 1013
care 1 w 1017
For 2 w 1021
which 4 w 1026
reason 1 w 1032
those 1 w 1038
who 5 w 1041
dig 1 w 1044
in 14 w 1046
this 2 w 1050
well 3 w 1054
say 1 w 1057
that 1 w 1061
they 1 w 1065
cannot 1 w 1071
find 1 w 1075
even 3 w 1079
water 1 w 1084
in 16 w 1086
it 10 w 1088
because 1 w 1097
the 16 w 1100
ends 1 w 1104
of 9 w 1106
science 2 w 1113
are 3 w 1116
not 7 w 1119
only 3 w 1123
hard 1 w 1127
to 13 w 1129
discover 2 w 1137
but 8 w 1141
are 4 w 1144
even 4 w 1148
altogether 1 w 1158
undiscoverable 1 w 1172
and 13 w 1176
it 11 w 1178
is 14 w 1180
owing 1 w 1185
to 15 w 1187
this 3 w 1191
that 2 w 1195
one 4 w 1198
man 3 w 1201
is 16 w 1203
more 1 w 1207
thoroughly 1 w 1217
skilled 1 w 1224
in 18 w 1226
grammar 1 w 1233
or 11 w 1235
in 19 w 1237
geometry 1 w 1245
than 1 w 1249
another 1 w 1256
because 2 w 1264
of 10 w 1266
its 2 w 1269
being 2 w 1274
impossible 1 w 1284
to 16 w 1286
circumscribe 1 w 1298
increase 1 w 1307
and 14 w 1311
extend 1 w 1317
one 5 w 1320
within 1 w 1326
certain 1 w 1333
limits 1 w 1339
for 3 w 1343
there 2 w 1348
is 17 w 1350
always 1 w 1356
more 2 w 1360
that 3 w 1364
is 18 w 1366
left 1 w 1370
behind 1 w 1376
than 2 w 1380
what 1 w 1384
comes 1 w 1389
to 17 w 1391
be 14 w 1393
learnt 1 w 1399
and 15 w 1403
what 2 w 1407
is 19 w 1409
left 2 w 1413
watches 1 w 1420
for 4 w 1423
and 16 w 1426
catches 1 w 1433
the 20 w 1436
learner 1 w 1443
so 4 w 1446
that 4 w 1450
even 5 w 1454
he 25 w 1456
who 6 w 1459
fancies 1 w 1466
that 5 w 1470
he 26 w 1472
has 2 w 1475
comprehended 1 w 1487
and 17 w 1490
mastered 1 w 1498
the 21 w 1501
very 2 w 1505
extremities 1 w 1516
of 11 w 1518
knowledge 2 w 1527
would 3 w 1532
be 15 w 1534
considered 1 w 1544
but 9 w 1547
half 1 w 1551
perfect 1 w 1558
by 1 w 1560
another 2 w 1567
person 1 w 1573
who 7 w 1576
was 2 w 1579
his 6 w 1582
judge 1 w 1587
and 18 w 1591
if 6 w 1593
he 30 w 1595
were 1 w 1599
before 1 w 1605
the 23 w 1608
tribunal 1 w 1616
of 12 w 1618
truth 1 w 1623
would 4 w 1628
appear 2 w 1634
to 18 w 1636
be 17 w 1638
only 4 w 1642
beginning 1 w 1651
knowledge 3 w 1660
for 6 w 1664
life 1 w 1668
is 21 w 1670
short 1 w 1675
as 17 w 1678
some 3 w 1682
one 6 w 1685
has 3 w 1688
said 1 w 1692
but 10 w 1696
art 2 w 1699
is 22 w 1701
long 1 w 1705
of 13 w 1708
which 5 w 1713
that 6 w 1717
man 4 w 1720
most 4 w 1724
thoroughly 2 w 1734
comprehends 1 w 1745
the 24 w 1748
magnitude 1 w 1757
who 8 w 1761
sincerely 1 w 1770
and 19 w 1773
honestly 1 w 1781
plunges 1 w 1788
deeply 1 w 1794
into 1 w 1798
it 17 w 1800
and 20 w 1804
who 9 w 1807
digs 1 w 1811
it 18 w 1813
out 1 w 1816
like 1 w 1820
a 124 w 1821
well 4 w 1825
And 1 w 1829
such 3 w 1833
a 125 w 1834
man 5 w 1837
when 1 w 1842
he 35 w 1844
is 23 w 1846
at 23 w 1848
the 25 w 1851
point 2 w 1856
of 14 w 1858
death 1 w 1863
being 3 w 1869
now 4 w 1872
grey-headed 1 w 1883
and 21 w 1886
exceedingly 1 w 1897
old 1 w 1900
it 19 w 1903
is 24 w 1905
said 2 w 1909
wept 1 w 1914
not 10 w 1918
that 7 w 1922
he 38 w 1924
feared 1 w 1930
death 2 w 1935
as 19 w 1937
being 4 w 1942
a 136 w 1943
coward 1 w 1949
but 11 w 1953
out 2 w 1956
of 15 w 1958
a 138 w 1959
desire 1 w 1965
for 7 w 1968
instruction 1 w 1979
as 20 w 1982
feeling 1 w 1989
that 8 w 1993
he 39 w 1995
was 3 w 1998
now 5 w 2001
for 8 w 2005
the 26 w 2008
first 2 w 2013
time 1 w 2017
entering 1 w 2026
upon 2 w 2030
it 20 w 2032
when 2 w 2036
he 42 w 2038
was 4 w 2041
finally 1 w 2048
departing 1 w 2057
from 1 w 2061
life 2 w 2065