Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the question, Who is the Heir of Divine Things

On the question, Who is the Heir of Divine Things (11-15)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg015.1st1K-eng1:11-15
Refs {'start': {'reference': '11', 'human_reference': 'Section 11'}, 'end': {'reference': '15', 'human_reference': 'Section 15'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next

Let no one, however, think that this is all that is signified by those few words, "Be silent and hear;" but that there is also something greater in them which may give a lesson to any one. For these words do not recommend you only to be silent with your tongues, and to hear with your ears, but also to conduct yourself thus in both these respects in your soul;

for many persons when they have come to listen to some one, have nevertheless not come with their minds, but wander outside, [*] [*]

v.2.p.96
and keep on thinking of thousands upon thousands of things within themselves, whether concerning their relations, or strangers, or themselves, which at that moment they ought not to remember at all, but which in short they, re-collecting to themselves in regular order, and thus by reason of the excessive tumult which they keep alive in themselves, they are unable to hear the speaker. For he speaks as if he were not among men, but among inanimate statues who have indeed ears, but no sense of hearing.

If, therefore, the mind chooses to associate neither with things wandering about outside, nor with those which are stored up within it, but, remaining quiet and silent, directs its whole attention to the speaker, keeping silent in accordance with the injunction of Moses, it will be able to listen with all attention, but otherwise it would not be able to do so.

4

Silence, then, is a desirable thing for those who are ignorant, but for those who desire knowledge, and who have at the same time a love for their masters freedom of speech, is a most necessary possession. Accordingly it is said, in the book of Exodus, "The Lord will fight for us, and you will be silent." [*] And, immediately afterwards, there is added a scripture in the following words: "And the Lord said unto Moses, Why dost thou cry unto me?" As it is proper for those persons to be silent who can say nothing worthy of being listened to, and for those to speak who, through love of wisdom, believe in God; and not only to speak quietly but to cry out with exceeding noise, not indeed with the noise of the mouth and tongue, by means of which they say that the air is affected with a rotatory motion, and so is rendered capable of being perceived by the hearing, but by the all-instructed and very loudly speaking organ of that voice of which no mortal man is the hearer, but only the uncreated and immortal God.

For the well-arranged and carefully attuned melody of that harmony which is perceptible by the intellect, the invisible musician, perceptible by the intellect, is alone able to comprehend; but no one of those involved in the entanglements of the outward senses can appreciate it. Accordingly, when the entire organ of the mind sounds according to the symphony of the diapason and of the double diapason, the hearer, as it were, asks (for he does not ask in reality, since everything is known [*]

v.2.p.97
to God), "Why dost thou cry unto me?" Is it in supplication that evils may be averted, or in thankfulness for a participation in good things which have been already enjoyed, or for a combination of both reasons?

Let 1 w 3
no 1 w 5
one 1 w 8
however 1 w 16
think 1 w 22
that 1 w 26
this 1 w 30
is 2 w 32
all 1 w 35
that 2 w 39
is 3 w 41
signified 1 w 50
by 1 w 52
those 1 w 57
few 1 w 60
words 1 w 65
Be 1 w 69
silent 1 w 75
and 1 w 78
hear 1 w 82
but 1 w 87
that 3 w 91
there 1 w 96
is 4 w 98
also 1 w 102
something 1 w 111
greater 1 w 118
in 3 w 120
them 1 w 124
which 1 w 129
may 1 w 132
give 1 w 136
a 10 w 137
lesson 1 w 143
to 1 w 145
any 1 w 148
one 2 w 151
For 1 w 155
these 1 w 160
words 2 w 165
do 1 w 167
not 1 w 170
recommend 1 w 179
you 1 w 182
only 1 w 186
to 2 w 188
be 1 w 190
silent 2 w 196
with 1 w 200
your 1 w 204
tongues 1 w 211
and 2 w 215
to 4 w 217
hear 2 w 221
with 2 w 225
your 2 w 229
ears 1 w 233
but 2 w 237
also 2 w 241
to 5 w 243
conduct 1 w 250
yourself 1 w 258
thus 1 w 262
in 4 w 264
both 1 w 268
these 2 w 273
respects 1 w 281
in 5 w 283
your 4 w 287
soul 1 w 291
for 1 w 295
many 1 w 299
persons 1 w 306
when 1 w 310
they 1 w 314
have 1 w 318
come 1 w 322
to 6 w 324
listen 1 w 330
to 7 w 332
some 2 w 336
one 3 w 339
have 2 w 344
nevertheless 1 w 356
not 2 w 359
come 2 w 363
with 3 w 367
their 1 w 372
minds 1 w 377
but 3 w 381
wander 1 w 387
outside 1 w 394
Genesis 1 w 402
xxvi 1 w 406
3 1 w 408
Deuteronomy 1 w 420
xxvii 1 w 425
9 1 w 427
and 4 w 431
keep 1 w 435
on 10 w 437
thinking 1 w 445
of 1 w 447
thousands 1 w 456
upon 1 w 460
thousands 2 w 469
of 2 w 471
things 1 w 477
within 1 w 483
themselves 1 w 493
whether 1 w 501
concerning 1 w 511
their 2 w 516
relations 1 w 525
or 5 w 528
strangers 1 w 537
or 6 w 540
themselves 2 w 550
which 2 w 556
at 6 w 558
that 4 w 562
moment 1 w 568
they 2 w 572
ought 1 w 577
not 3 w 580
to 8 w 582
remember 1 w 590
at 8 w 592
all 2 w 595
but 4 w 599
which 3 w 604
in 12 w 606
short 1 w 611
they 3 w 615
re-collecting 1 w 629
to 9 w 631
themselves 3 w 641
in 14 w 643
regular 1 w 650
order 1 w 655
and 7 w 659
thus 2 w 663
by 2 w 665
reason 1 w 671
of 3 w 673
the 15 w 676
excessive 1 w 685
tumult 1 w 691
which 4 w 696
they 4 w 700
keep 2 w 704
alive 1 w 709
in 15 w 711
themselves 4 w 721
they 5 w 726
are 1 w 729
unable 1 w 735
to 10 w 737
hear 3 w 741
the 19 w 744
speaker 1 w 751
For 2 w 755
he 25 w 757
speaks 1 w 763
as 2 w 765
if 2 w 767
he 26 w 769
were 1 w 773
not 4 w 776
among 1 w 781
men 3 w 784
but 5 w 788
among 2 w 793
inanimate 1 w 802
statues 1 w 809
who 1 w 812
have 3 w 816
indeed 1 w 822
ears 2 w 826
but 6 w 830
no 7 w 832
sense 1 w 837
of 4 w 839
hearing 1 w 846
If 1 w 849
therefore 1 w 859
the 21 w 863
mind 2 w 867
chooses 1 w 874
to 11 w 876
associate 1 w 885
neither 1 w 892
with 5 w 896
things 2 w 902
wandering 1 w 911
about 1 w 916
outside 2 w 923
nor 1 w 927
with 6 w 931
those 2 w 936
which 5 w 941
are 2 w 944
stored 1 w 950
up 2 w 952
within 2 w 958
it 9 w 960
but 7 w 964
remaining 1 w 974
quiet 1 w 979
and 9 w 982
silent 3 w 988
directs 1 w 996
its 1 w 999
whole 1 w 1004
attention 1 w 1013
to 13 w 1015
the 23 w 1018
speaker 2 w 1025
keeping 1 w 1033
silent 4 w 1039
in 26 w 1041
accordance 1 w 1051
with 8 w 1055
the 24 w 1058
injunction 1 w 1068
of 5 w 1070
Moses 1 w 1075
it 12 w 1078
will 1 w 1082
be 3 w 1084
able 2 w 1088
to 14 w 1090
listen 2 w 1096
with 9 w 1100
all 3 w 1103
attention 2 w 1112
but 8 w 1116
otherwise 1 w 1125
it 14 w 1127
would 1 w 1132
not 5 w 1135
be 4 w 1137
able 3 w 1141
to 15 w 1143
do 2 w 1145
so 10 w 1147
Silence 1 w 1155
then 1 w 1160
is 9 w 1163
a 62 w 1164
desirable 1 w 1173
thing 4 w 1178
for 3 w 1181
those 3 w 1186
who 3 w 1189
are 3 w 1192
ignorant 1 w 1200
but 9 w 1204
for 4 w 1207
those 4 w 1212
who 4 w 1215
desire 1 w 1221
knowledge 1 w 1230
and 10 w 1234
who 5 w 1237
have 4 w 1241
at 14 w 1243
the 27 w 1246
same 1 w 1250
time 1 w 1254
a 70 w 1255
love 1 w 1259
for 5 w 1262
their 3 w 1267
master 1 w 1273
s 90 w 1275
freedom 1 w 1282
of 6 w 1284
speech 1 w 1290
is 10 w 1293
a 72 w 1294
most 1 w 1298
necessary 1 w 1307
possession 1 w 1317
Accordingly 1 w 1329
it 15 w 1331
is 11 w 1333
said 1 w 1337
in 30 w 1340
the 29 w 1343
book 1 w 1347
of 7 w 1349
Exodus 1 w 1355
The 1 w 1360
Lord 1 w 1364
will 2 w 1368
fight 1 w 1373
for 6 w 1376
us 6 w 1378
and 11 w 1382
you 6 w 1385
will 3 w 1389
be 5 w 1391
silent 5 w 1397
Exodus 2 w 1405
xiv 1 w 1408
4 1 w 1410
And 1 w 1414
immediately 1 w 1426
afterwards 1 w 1436
there 3 w 1442
is 12 w 1444
added 1 w 1449
a 80 w 1450
scripture 1 w 1459
in 31 w 1461
the 31 w 1464
following 1 w 1473
words 3 w 1478
And 2 w 1483
the 32 w 1486
Lord 2 w 1490
said 2 w 1494
unto 1 w 1498
Moses 2 w 1503
Why 1 w 1507
dost 1 w 1511
thou 3 w 1515
cry 1 w 1518
unto 2 w 1522
me 12 w 1524
As 1 w 1528
it 16 w 1530
is 13 w 1532
proper 1 w 1538
for 7 w 1541
those 5 w 1546
persons 2 w 1553
to 18 w 1555
be 6 w 1557
silent 6 w 1563
who 6 w 1566
can 1 w 1569
say 1 w 1572
nothing 1 w 1579
worthy 1 w 1585
of 8 w 1587
being 1 w 1592
listened 1 w 1600
to 19 w 1602
and 12 w 1606
for 8 w 1609
those 6 w 1614
to 20 w 1616
speak 4 w 1621
who 7 w 1624
through 1 w 1632
love 2 w 1636
of 9 w 1638
wisdom 1 w 1644
believe 1 w 1652
in 35 w 1654
God 1 w 1657
and 13 w 1661
not 7 w 1664
only 2 w 1668
to 21 w 1670
speak 5 w 1675
quietly 1 w 1682
but 10 w 1685
to 22 w 1687
cry 2 w 1690
out 4 w 1693
with 10 w 1697
exceeding 1 w 1706
noise 1 w 1711
not 8 w 1715
indeed 2 w 1721
with 11 w 1725
the 33 w 1728
noise 2 w 1733
of 10 w 1735
the 34 w 1738
mouth 1 w 1743
and 14 w 1746
tongue 2 w 1752
by 3 w 1755
means 1 w 1760
of 11 w 1762
which 6 w 1767
they 6 w 1771
say 2 w 1774
that 5 w 1778
the 36 w 1781
air 1 w 1784
is 18 w 1786
affected 1 w 1794
with 12 w 1798
a 94 w 1799
rotatory 1 w 1807
motion 1 w 1813
and 15 w 1817
so 12 w 1819
is 19 w 1821
rendered 1 w 1829
capable 1 w 1836
of 12 w 1838
being 2 w 1843
perceived 1 w 1852
by 4 w 1854
the 37 w 1857
hearing 2 w 1864
but 11 w 1868
by 5 w 1870
the 38 w 1873
all-instructed 1 w 1887
and 16 w 1890
very 1 w 1894
loudly 1 w 1900
speaking 1 w 1908
organ 1 w 1913
of 13 w 1915
that 6 w 1919
voice 1 w 1924
of 14 w 1926
which 7 w 1931
no 17 w 1933
mortal 1 w 1939
man 2 w 1942
is 20 w 1944
the 39 w 1947
hearer 1 w 1953
but 12 w 1957
only 3 w 1961
the 40 w 1964
uncreated 1 w 1973
and 17 w 1976
immortal 1 w 1984
God 2 w 1987
For 3 w 1991
the 41 w 1994
well-arranged 1 w 2007
and 18 w 2010
carefully 1 w 2019
attuned 1 w 2026
melody 1 w 2032
of 15 w 2034
that 7 w 2038
harmony 1 w 2045
which 8 w 2050
is 21 w 2052
perceptible 1 w 2063
by 6 w 2065
the 42 w 2068
intellect 1 w 2077
the 43 w 2081
invisible 1 w 2090
musician 1 w 2098
perceptible 2 w 2110
by 7 w 2112
the 44 w 2115
intellect 2 w 2124
is 23 w 2127
alone 1 w 2132
able 6 w 2136
to 25 w 2138
comprehend 1 w 2148
but 13 w 2152
no 18 w 2154
one 5 w 2157
of 16 w 2159
those 7 w 2164
involved 1 w 2172
in 46 w 2174
the 45 w 2177
entanglements 1 w 2190
of 17 w 2192
the 46 w 2195
outward 1 w 2202
senses 1 w 2208
can 2 w 2211
appreciate 1 w 2221
it 20 w 2223
Accordingly 2 w 2235
when 2 w 2240
the 47 w 2243
entire 1 w 2249
organ 2 w 2254
of 18 w 2256
the 48 w 2259
mind 3 w 2263
sounds 1 w 2269
according 1 w 2278
to 26 w 2280
the 49 w 2283
symphony 1 w 2291
of 19 w 2293
the 50 w 2296
diapason 1 w 2304
and 19 w 2307
of 20 w 2309
the 51 w 2312
double 1 w 2318
diapason 2 w 2326
the 52 w 2330
hearer 2 w 2336
as 7 w 2339
it 21 w 2341
were 2 w 2345
asks 1 w 2350
for 9 w 2354
he 67 w 2356
does 1 w 2360
not 9 w 2363
ask 2 w 2366
in 50 w 2368
reality 1 w 2375
since 1 w 2381
everything 1 w 2391
is 24 w 2393
known 1 w 2398
Exodus 3 w 2404
xiv 2 w 2407
4 2 w 2409
to 27 w 2412
God 3 w 2415
Why 2 w 2421
dost 2 w 2425
thou 4 w 2429
cry 3 w 2432
unto 3 w 2436
me 16 w 2438
Is 1 w 2442
it 23 w 2444
in 53 w 2446
supplication 1 w 2458
that 8 w 2462
evils 1 w 2467
may 2 w 2470
be 10 w 2472
averted 1 w 2479
or 35 w 2482
in 54 w 2484
thankfulness 1 w 2496
for 10 w 2499
a 143 w 2500
participation 1 w 2513
in 55 w 2515
good 1 w 2519
things 3 w 2525
which 9 w 2530
have 5 w 2534
been 1 w 2538
already 1 w 2545
enjoyed 1 w 2552
or 37 w 2555
for 11 w 2558
a 149 w 2559
combination 1 w 2570
of 21 w 2572
both 2 w 2576
reasons 1 w 2583