Scaife ATLAS

CTS Library / On the Confusion of Languages

On the Confusion of Languages (6-10)

urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0018.tlg013.1st1K-eng1:6-10
Refs {'start': {'reference': '6', 'human_reference': 'Section 6'}, 'end': {'reference': '10', 'human_reference': 'Section 10'}}
Ancestors []
Children []
prev
plain textXML
next
3

And there is also another story akin to this, related by the devisers of fables, concerning the sameness of language existing among animals: for they say that formerly, all the animals in the world, whether land animals, or aquatic ones, or winged ones, had but one language, and that, just as among men Greeks speak the same language as Greeks, and the present race of barbarians speak the same language as

v.2.p.3
barbarians, exactly in the same manner every animal was able to converse with every other animal with which it might meet, and with which it did anything, or from which it suffered anything, so that they sympathised with one another at their mutual misfortunes, and rejoiced whenever any of them met with any good fortune;

for they could impart their pleasures and their annoyances to one another by their sameness of language, so that they felt pleasure together and pain together; and this similarity of manners and union of feelings lasted, until being sated with the great abundance of good things which they enjoyed, as often happens, they were at last drawn on to a desire of what was unattainable, and even sent an embassy to treat for immortality, requesting to be released from old age, and to be always endowed with the vigour of youth, saying, that already one animal of their body, and that a reptile, the serpent, had received this gift; for he, having put off old age, was allowed again to grow young; and that it was absurd for the more important animals to be left behind by an inferior one, or for their whole body to be distanced by one.

However, they suffered the punishment suitable to their audacity, for they immediately were separated in their language, so that, from that time forth, they have not been able to understand one another, by reason of the difference in the dialects into which the one common language of them all had been divided.

4

But he who brings his account nearer the truth, has distinguished between the rational and irrational animals, so that he testifies that identity of language belonged to men alone: and this also, as they say, is a fabulous story. And indeed they affirm, that the separation of language into an infinite variety of dialects, which Moses calls the confusion of tongues, was effected as a remedy for sins, in order that men might not be able to co-operate in common for deeds of wickedness through understanding one another; and that they might not, when they were in a manner deprived of all means of communication with one another, be able with united energies to apply themselves to the same actions.

But this precaution does not appear to have turned out of any use; for since that time, though men have been separated into different nations, and have no longer used one language, nevertheless, land and sea have been repeatedly filled with unspeakable evils.

v.2.p.4
For it was not the languages which were the causes of mens uniting for evil objects, but the emulation and rivalry of their souls in wrong-doing.

Tokens

And 1 w 3
there 1 w 8
is 1 w 10
also 1 w 14
another 1 w 21
story 1 w 26
akin 1 w 30
to 2 w 32
this 1 w 36
related 1 w 44
by 1 w 46
the 3 w 49
devisers 1 w 57
of 1 w 59
fables 1 w 65
concerning 1 w 76
the 4 w 79
sameness 1 w 87
of 2 w 89
language 1 w 97
existing 1 w 105
among 1 w 110
animals 1 w 117
for 1 w 121
they 1 w 125
say 1 w 128
that 1 w 132
formerly 1 w 140
all 1 w 144
the 6 w 147
animals 2 w 154
in 4 w 156
the 7 w 159
world 1 w 164
whether 1 w 172
land 1 w 176
animals 3 w 183
or 5 w 186
aquatic 1 w 193
ones 1 w 197
or 6 w 200
winged 1 w 206
ones 2 w 210
had 1 w 214
but 1 w 217
one 3 w 220
language 2 w 228
and 2 w 232
that 2 w 236
just 1 w 241
as 1 w 243
among 2 w 248
men 2 w 251
Greeks 1 w 257
speak 1 w 262
the 9 w 265
same 2 w 269
language 3 w 277
as 2 w 279
Greeks 2 w 285
and 3 w 289
the 10 w 292
present 1 w 299
race 1 w 303
of 3 w 305
barbarians 1 w 315
speak 2 w 320
the 11 w 323
same 3 w 327
language 4 w 335
as 3 w 337
barbarians 2 w 347
exactly 1 w 355
in 6 w 357
the 12 w 360
same 4 w 364
manner 1 w 370
every 1 w 375
animal 4 w 381
was 1 w 384
able 2 w 388
to 3 w 390
converse 1 w 398
with 1 w 402
every 2 w 407
other 2 w 412
animal 5 w 418
with 2 w 422
which 1 w 427
it 3 w 429
might 1 w 434
meet 1 w 438
and 4 w 442
with 3 w 446
which 2 w 451
it 5 w 453
did 1 w 456
anything 1 w 464
or 7 w 467
from 1 w 471
which 3 w 476
it 6 w 478
suffered 1 w 486
anything 2 w 494
so 2 w 497
that 3 w 501
they 2 w 505
sympathised 1 w 516
with 4 w 520
one 4 w 523
another 2 w 530
at 7 w 532
their 1 w 537
mutual 1 w 543
misfortunes 1 w 554
and 5 w 558
rejoiced 1 w 566
whenever 1 w 574
any 3 w 577
of 4 w 579
them 1 w 583
met 1 w 586
with 5 w 590
any 4 w 593
good 1 w 597
fortune 2 w 604
for 5 w 608
they 3 w 612
could 1 w 617
impart 1 w 623
their 2 w 628
pleasures 1 w 637
and 6 w 640
their 3 w 645
annoyances 1 w 655
to 4 w 657
one 5 w 660
another 3 w 667
by 2 w 669
their 4 w 674
sameness 2 w 682
of 5 w 684
language 5 w 692
so 3 w 695
that 4 w 699
they 4 w 703
felt 1 w 707
pleasure 2 w 715
together 1 w 723
and 7 w 726
pain 1 w 730
together 2 w 738
and 8 w 742
this 3 w 746
similarity 1 w 756
of 6 w 758
manners 1 w 765
and 9 w 768
union 1 w 773
of 7 w 775
feelings 1 w 783
lasted 1 w 789
until 1 w 795
being 1 w 800
sated 1 w 805
with 6 w 809
the 26 w 812
great 1 w 817
abundance 1 w 826
of 8 w 828
good 2 w 832
things 1 w 838
which 4 w 843
they 5 w 847
enjoyed 1 w 854
as 8 w 857
often 1 w 862
happens 1 w 869
they 6 w 874
were 1 w 878
at 11 w 880
last 2 w 884
drawn 1 w 889
on 11 w 891
to 7 w 893
a 94 w 894
desire 1 w 900
of 10 w 902
what 1 w 906
was 2 w 909
unattainable 1 w 921
and 10 w 925
even 1 w 929
sent 2 w 933
an 35 w 935
embassy 1 w 942
to 8 w 944
treat 1 w 949
for 6 w 952
immortality 1 w 963
requesting 1 w 974
to 9 w 976
be 2 w 978
released 1 w 986
from 2 w 990
old 1 w 993
age 6 w 996
and 11 w 1000
to 10 w 1002
be 3 w 1004
always 1 w 1010
endowed 1 w 1017
with 7 w 1021
the 29 w 1024
vigour 1 w 1030
of 11 w 1032
youth 1 w 1037
saying 1 w 1044
that 5 w 1049
already 1 w 1056
one 6 w 1059
animal 6 w 1065
of 12 w 1067
their 5 w 1072
body 1 w 1076
and 12 w 1080
that 6 w 1084
a 118 w 1085
reptile 1 w 1092
the 31 w 1096
serpent 1 w 1103
had 2 w 1107
received 1 w 1115
this 4 w 1119
gift 1 w 1123
for 7 w 1127
he 34 w 1129
having 1 w 1136
put 1 w 1139
off 1 w 1142
old 2 w 1145
age 7 w 1148
was 3 w 1152
allowed 1 w 1159
again 1 w 1164
to 11 w 1166
grow 1 w 1170
young 1 w 1175
and 13 w 1179
that 7 w 1183
it 13 w 1185
was 4 w 1188
absurd 1 w 1194
for 8 w 1197
the 32 w 1200
more 1 w 1204
important 1 w 1213
animals 4 w 1220
to 12 w 1222
be 4 w 1224
left 1 w 1228
behind 1 w 1234
by 3 w 1236
an 42 w 1238
inferior 1 w 1246
one 7 w 1249
or 18 w 1252
for 9 w 1255
their 6 w 1260
whole 1 w 1265
body 2 w 1269
to 13 w 1271
be 6 w 1273
distanced 1 w 1282
by 4 w 1284
one 8 w 1287
However 1 w 1295
they 7 w 1300
suffered 2 w 1308
the 35 w 1311
punishment 1 w 1321
suitable 1 w 1329
to 14 w 1331
their 7 w 1336
audacity 1 w 1344
for 10 w 1348
they 8 w 1352
immediately 1 w 1363
were 2 w 1367
separated 1 w 1376
in 20 w 1378
their 8 w 1383
language 6 w 1391
so 4 w 1394
that 8 w 1398
from 3 w 1403
that 9 w 1407
time 1 w 1411
forth 1 w 1416
they 9 w 1421
have 1 w 1425
not 4 w 1428
been 1 w 1432
able 5 w 1436
to 15 w 1438
understand 1 w 1448
one 9 w 1451
another 4 w 1458
by 5 w 1461
reason 1 w 1467
of 14 w 1469
the 41 w 1472
difference 1 w 1482
in 21 w 1484
the 42 w 1487
dialects 1 w 1495
into 1 w 1499
which 5 w 1504
the 43 w 1507
one 10 w 1510
common 1 w 1516
language 7 w 1524
of 15 w 1526
them 2 w 1530
all 3 w 1533
had 3 w 1536
been 2 w 1540
divided 1 w 1547
But 1 w 1551
he 48 w 1553
who 2 w 1556
brings 1 w 1562
his 5 w 1565
account 1 w 1572
nearer 1 w 1578
the 45 w 1581
truth 1 w 1586
has 1 w 1590
distinguished 1 w 1603
between 1 w 1610
the 46 w 1613
rational 1 w 1621
and 15 w 1624
irrational 1 w 1634
animals 5 w 1641
so 6 w 1644
that 10 w 1648
he 52 w 1650
testifies 1 w 1659
that 11 w 1663
identity 1 w 1671
of 16 w 1673
language 8 w 1681
belonged 1 w 1689
to 17 w 1691
men 5 w 1694
alone 1 w 1699
and 16 w 1703
this 5 w 1707
also 2 w 1711
as 17 w 1714
they 10 w 1718
say 3 w 1721
is 15 w 1724
a 174 w 1725
fabulous 1 w 1733
story 2 w 1738
And 2 w 1742
indeed 1 w 1748
they 11 w 1752
affirm 1 w 1758
that 12 w 1763
the 49 w 1766
separation 1 w 1776
of 17 w 1778
language 9 w 1786
into 2 w 1790
an 53 w 1792
infinite 1 w 1800
variety 1 w 1807
of 18 w 1809
dialects 2 w 1817
which 6 w 1823
Moses 1 w 1828
calls 1 w 1833
the 50 w 1836
confusion 1 w 1845
of 19 w 1847
tongues 1 w 1854
was 5 w 1858
effected 1 w 1866
as 19 w 1868
a 188 w 1869
remedy 1 w 1875
for 12 w 1878
sins 1 w 1882
in 30 w 1885
order 1 w 1890
that 13 w 1894
men 6 w 1897
might 2 w 1902
not 6 w 1905
be 11 w 1907
able 6 w 1911
to 21 w 1913
co-operate 1 w 1923
in 31 w 1925
common 2 w 1931
for 13 w 1934
deeds 1 w 1939
of 20 w 1941
wickedness 1 w 1951
through 1 w 1958
understanding 1 w 1971
one 12 w 1974
another 5 w 1981
and 18 w 1985
that 14 w 1989
they 12 w 1993
might 3 w 1998
not 8 w 2001
when 2 w 2006
they 13 w 2010
were 3 w 2014
in 33 w 2016
a 196 w 2017
manner 3 w 2023
deprived 1 w 2031
of 21 w 2033
all 5 w 2036
means 1 w 2041
of 22 w 2043
communication 1 w 2056
with 8 w 2060
one 13 w 2063
another 6 w 2070
be 12 w 2073
able 7 w 2077
with 9 w 2081
united 1 w 2087
energies 1 w 2095
to 22 w 2097
apply 1 w 2102
themselves 1 w 2112
to 23 w 2114
the 56 w 2117
same 6 w 2121
actions 1 w 2128
But 2 w 2132
this 6 w 2136
precaution 1 w 2146
does 1 w 2150
not 10 w 2153
appear 1 w 2159
to 24 w 2161
have 2 w 2165
turned 1 w 2171
out 2 w 2174
of 23 w 2176
any 5 w 2179
use 1 w 2182
for 14 w 2186
since 1 w 2191
that 15 w 2195
time 2 w 2199
though 1 w 2206
men 7 w 2209
have 3 w 2213
been 3 w 2217
separated 2 w 2226
into 3 w 2230
different 1 w 2239
nations 1 w 2246
and 19 w 2250
have 4 w 2254
no 12 w 2256
longer 1 w 2262
used 1 w 2266
one 14 w 2269
language 10 w 2277
nevertheless 1 w 2290
land 2 w 2295
and 21 w 2298
sea 1 w 2301
have 5 w 2305
been 4 w 2309
repeatedly 1 w 2319
filled 1 w 2325
with 10 w 2329
unspeakable 1 w 2340
evils 1 w 2345
For 1 w 2349
it 22 w 2351
was 6 w 2354
not 11 w 2357
the 58 w 2360
languages 1 w 2369
which 7 w 2374
were 4 w 2378
the 59 w 2381
causes 1 w 2387
of 24 w 2389
men 8 w 2392
s 135 w 2394
uniting 1 w 2401
for 15 w 2404
evil 2 w 2408
objects 1 w 2415
but 2 w 2419
the 60 w 2422
emulation 1 w 2431
and 22 w 2434
rivalry 1 w 2441
of 25 w 2443
their 9 w 2448
souls 1 w 2453
in 37 w 2455
wrong-doing 1 w 2466